Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

1st July 1915

Mining Fatality At Parkhouse, Bigrigg

The Adjourned Inquiry

The adjourned inquest into the death of Wm. and Jos. Scott, of Wath Brow, the brothers who were killed at Parkhouse Mines on Thursday week, was resumed in the Public Offices, Cleator Moor, on Thursday afternoon, by the Coroner (Mr. G. A. L. Skerry), and a jury of which Mr. John James Miller was foreman.

There were also present, Mr. W. Leck, HM Inspector of Mines, Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, representing the relatives of the deceased, Mr. J. H. Auld representing the Workington Iron & Steel Co., and Mr. W. Dixon representing the management.

Abraham Fisher, 11, Church Street, Moor Row, said he was a miner's labourer at Park House Mine. On the day the two Scott's were killed, he worked with them on the afternoon shift from two p.m. to ten p.m. Daniel Darragen, Joseph Haile, and another labourer were on the morning shift that day. Witness went down the pit about half past two before the deceased, and he went to the bait place to wait for them. They came down together about three o'clock, which was about half an hour late. He did not know the reason why they were late. They all three went back to the shaft for some timber; they wanted timber slabs to cover the working. When they started to get metal out, Wm. Scott was putting the metal into the bogey. Joseph was breaking lumps of metal; and witness was "picking" it. Witness also took the bogies out. About six o'clock Jos. Scott made a hole and fired a shot in the forebreast, and this brought more metal. They went for their bait immediately after the shot was fired. They were away about half an hour, and on their return there was a slight fall, so they went outside for five minutes. Chas. Smith and his labourer, Jos. Garnett of the next company to theirs came out to see if they were any worse. They told him they were all right. Smith advised them to come out, and said headtrees were bent. Jos. Scott said, "We want our metal, Charles." That fall was about seven o'clock and it was from the far end where they were working. Smith walked away then and witness and the Scott's went on working. About an hour afterward there was another slight fall and they ran out. No one came to them this time, and they were out about five minutes. The falls were caused by the shot that was fired. About half past eight there was a big fall. Witness was standing behind a bogey. William Scott was filling in the front, and Jos. Scott was breaking up lumps. The fall came from the side above the timbers, and buried both the Scott's. Witness ran out for help, and Smith and his labourer went back to the working, along with a good many other men. Witness did not go back again, as he was nervous. He expected the deceased would be killed, when he saw the fall. They did not use the timber that they took into the working at three o'clock because they had not time, as they were busy getting the metal out. He meant that they were neglecting their own safety to get the metal out. Of course, the timber work rested with the deceased. There was some timbering above them and it was quite safe. All the headtrees were bent with the first fall. No one visited them during the shift, except Smith and his labourer. The working was safe when they went in, and there was nothing wrong until after the shot was fired. There was no dressing down immediately after the shot was fired. When they came from bait Jos. Scott barred down some ore that was loose, and he was supposed to have got it all down. Witness had worked as a labourer about seven years, and had been underground all the time, but he did not know as much as a miner. He could not have a reason as to the cause of the fall. All the candles and lamps were extinguished when the fall occurred, and he could not see what had happened. There was no timbering in the side of the working, and he guessed the fall was a slip from the side. Neither of the Scott's shouted and there was no warning. He and the Scott's had worked in this working about two months, and had never had any falls before.

By Mr. Leck: There was no night shift worked in that morning, but there was a morning shift. It was customary for a deputy to come into the shift, and one of them, John Pattinson, was in before bait. Witness and the Scott's were there at the time. Pattinson had a look round, and said all was right, and went out again. That was before the shot was fired. The Scott's brought some timber in, and that would account for their being late. He did not remember hearing the Scott's saying anything before starting work. He had not seen the working since the accident. They heard the two slight falls give warning, there was a "creaking," but not so when the big fall came. The headtrees were not broken, but just a bit bent. He did not remember whether it was after the second fall that Smith came in and advised them to leave the working, and it was about half an hour later that the big fall came. When Smith advised them to come out Jas. Scott said "We're nice and comfortable." Witness could not give an opinion whether the place was safe, as his own experience had been with the bogies only.

By Mr. Duffy: He thought Mr. Pattinson came into the working about half past five, and the hole was fired at six o'clock. There was no one about to whom they could report the slight falls, and did not seriously mean that they were deliberately neglecting their own safety to get ore. Witness did not see the headtrees were bent, and they might have been bent before they started their shift.

Wm. Sherwen, surveyor at the mine, produced a plan of the working, prepared by him.

Charles Smith, 46, Bedford Street, Rose Bank, Hensingham, said he was an iron ore miner at Park House. On Thursday last he was on the afternoon shift. Before going down the pit he saw the Scott's, who told him they were going to get some timber. He went down before them, and went on working. He saw them at the bait place about half past three; they had just come down, and later about six o'clock. Witness's working was about twenty or thirty yards from deceased's working. They always told one another when they were going to fire a shot. Just before bait time witness told the Scott's he was going to shot a fire, but any shot in witness's working was too far away to affect the Scott's working. When witness was talking to them they did not tell him they had fired a shot, and it was witness's opinion that Fisher must have heard witness's shot going off, and mistook it for Scott's. Shortly after six o'clock they fired a heavy charge of dynamite in a cut between the metal and the side. The metal was under a large lump of rock, and taking the footing away would disturb the lump of rock. There was a heavy fire about twenty minutes after witness heard a fall in the Scott's working. He went to see if they were all right. They had a look at the working, and saw that the fall had come on top of the timber and had bent it. He told them that if he was them he would keep out of the working for a while as the coming away of the footing had disturbed the rock above. He would have stopped back half an hour if he had been them, to see if the place was settled. Wm. Scott said, "Well, Charlie, we want some metal out," and witness told them to take care of themselves. He also told them that if they disturbed the big lump it would come and squeeze all before it. They went on with their work. The big lump was rock and it did eventually come down. Witness only heard two falls. After the big fall he ran out and met Fisher who shouted "Oh Charlie, come on." He went into the working, and saw that the place was all in together. "The big rock has come down." He shouted "Joe, William Scott," and when he got no answer he knew what had happened. He told Fisher to get the overman. The night shift men got the bodies out, and both were dead. John Pattinson was in witness's working before bait time, and he generally visited every working twice in a shift.

By Mr. Leck: The firing in a cut would not need any boring. He did not know what charge they put in it, but it was heavy. The headtrees were fixed in a "hitch" on both sides, with a log under one of them.

By the Coroner: The Scott's were experienced men.

John Pattinson, Ingwell Cottage, Moor Row, a deputy overman at Park House, said he was in the Scott's working about five o'clock, and no shots had been fired then. He had his lamp with him, and he examined the working. It was all right. The Scott's never told him they were going to fire a shot. The headtrees were not bent. He told them the place was fairly comfortable now. After a shot was fired the working should be dressed down, to get away anything loose. He had been in the working since the accident. A large piece of rock slipped away, and brought the wood down with all the loose stone that the men had put upon it. If there had been a shot fired the footing would be liberated, and the lump would come away. He thought that was what had happened. He thought it was possible that the Scott's would think the headtrees sufficient to hold the rock up, but he himself would have inspected the rock first.

By Mr. Leck: The working did not require any timbering as it was timbered up when he saw it. He did not see the cut referred to by Smith. He always visited the working once in a shift, and sometimes twice.

The Coroner said this had been a most unfortunate accident and the evidence seemed to be pretty clear. The first witness perhaps was not so clear as one would like, but probably he had got a little shock. After reviewing the evidence the Coroner said there might have been an error of judgement; the deceased may have inspected the stone after the shot was fired, and had come to the conclusion that it was all right, especially if they were of the opinion that the headtrees were quite sufficient to keep it up. But whether they inspected or not it was perhaps either carelessness or lack of judgement. He did not think there could be any blame attached to anyone. A good deal of the iron ore mining work had to be left to individual judgement. Mistakes and accidents occurred, which could not be foreseen, and probably this was one of them. The jury would therefore find that deceased were accidentally killed by the slipping of a stone from the side of a working of Park House Mine.

The jury agreed to the verdict.

Mr. Auld said he had been requested by the Workington Iron and Steel Co., the proprietors of the mine, to express their great regret that this accident had occurred. The men were experienced workmen, as Mr. Smith, who was well qualified to judge, had told them, and the Company wished their sympathy to be extended to the widow of Jos. Jackson Scott, and the other relatives of both deceased.

Mr. Duffy said he would have the pleasure of conveying the condolence to the relatives and at the same time he had been asked to mention a matter which might not directly come before the Coroner, but still was a matter for the district, — that was, in the future where a fatal accident had occurred at a mine, that the deceased's body should be washed, and the clothes changed before being sent home. There was distress, agony, and suffering enough in a case like this, and where a man is carried home battered, bruised, and broken up, and in his red clothes, it was all the more revolting. He was sure this only needed mentioning to prevent any recurrence in the future.

The Coroner agreed with the suggestion as he had held inquests where men had been killed at pits. The bodies had not been washed, and were covered with coal dust, thus presenting a horrible sight. If washed they would be a little more presentable.

Mr. Duffy said there was plenty of hot water and accommodation at the mines, more so than in a cottage home.

Mr. Isaac Walker, jnr., manager at Park House, said they would be only too pleased to do as Mr. Duffy suggested, but some people might object. He did not think it had been the custom in the district.

The Coroner: You mean some people would rather have them to be as they were found.

Mr. Walker: Yes.

Mr. Leck said he would rather Mr. Duffy's suggestion was carried out, and he thought that Mr. Walker meant that those who would object would be the jury.

Mr. Walker said that two experienced ambulance men were sent home with the deceased in this case.

Mr. Duffy said he did not suggest any lack of consideration at all on the part of Mr. Walker.

The Foreman of jury on behalf of his colleagues, accorded to the relatives of the deceased their sympathy, and also thought that the recommendation of Mr. Duffy was worthy of the consideration of the mineowners. He lived in the neighbourhood of the two deceased men, and he thought it would have been much better if the suggestion had been carried out.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Auld, J. H.    Solicitor  
Darragen, Daniel    Miner  
Dixon, W.    Solicitor  
Fisher, Abraham    Miners' Labourer  
Garnett, Joseph    Miners' Labourer  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Haile, Joseph    Miner  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Miller, John James    Jury Foreman  
Pattinson, John    Deputy  
Scott, Joseph Jackson   34 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Scott, William    Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Sherwen, William    Surveyor  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Smith, Charles    Miner  
Walker, Isaac    Manager  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Park House (Iron Ore)  Park House (Iron Ore)



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
24 Jun 1915  A Shocking Accident At Bigrigg, Two Brothers Killed (Whitehaven News)
01 Jul 1915  Mining Fatality At Parkhouse, Bigrigg, The Adjourned Inquiry (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Park House (Metalliferous)
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print