Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th June 1915

The Disastrous Pit Explosion At Aspatria

Inquest On The Seven Victims

The inquest (which has been adjourned several times) into the deaths of seven of the eight miners injured in the explosion in Brayton Domain No. 4 on 26th April, was resumed on Friday in the Market Hall, Aspatria, by Mr. Atter, coroner for West Cumberland.

Thomas Harris, 23, single, Harriston, is the sole survivor of the injured men. Those who succumbed to their injuries were :—

Joseph Rumney, 60, married, Springkell;

James Wilkinson, 59, married, 71, Lawson Street

Henry Wilkinson, 32, single, 71, Lawson Street

Thomas Rumney, 64, married, 16, Harriston

Thomas Herbert Little, 29, single, 8, Springkell

Robert Lightfoot, 20, single, 36, Harriston

Paul Rayson, 25, single, 36, Harriston

Mr. Joseph Simm was foreman of the jury. There were present: Mr. J. R. Wilson, chief inspector of mines, Newcastle; Mr. G. Cook, Inspector of Mines, Whitehaven; Mr. G. Poole, inspector of mines, Newcastle. Mr. G. A. Lightfoot appeared for the Colliery Company; Mr. A. Sharp, miners' agent, for the relatives, and Mr. T. Cape, miners' agent, for the workmen. Mr. Askew, manager of the Brayton Domain Pits, was also present.

The first witness called was Thomas Eadie, assistant manager, who produced a plan and explained to the jury where the shot was fired and the explosion occurred.

Dr. Briggs, who had attended all the patients, gave evidence as to the causes of the death. Most of these were secondary causes following burns and shock.

Thomas Harris, 23 years of age, 16, Harriston, who was congratulated by the Coroner on being fully recovered and able to give evidence, said he was on the morning shift. It was about eleven o'clock when he the explosion occurred. He did not think he saw any deputy. He could just recollect the explosion and then he fell down. A stone hit him on the head and shoulder. He heard someone shout, and he shouted back. Witness crept out of the place. He was not unconscious.

The witness pointed out on the plan the place of the explosion and the direction taken by the flame. Witness drilled the hole for the shot.

By Mr. Sharp: The hole for the shot was bored by a shot jumper and would be about eighteen or twenty inches long. He did not know there was any gas in the place, nor did he know there was any road round. The explosive they were using was stowite. The explosive was purchased from the Colliery Company. Prior to the 26th April he never heard of any gas in this locality.

By Mr. Cape: He knew nothing about the district when it was going solid, nor did he know of any gas being there. His uncle always went to the store for the explosive. Witness did not know of any falls behind where the shot was fired.

William Brown Dand, deputy, said he had been deputy in No. 4 Pit for three years. He went on duty at four o'clock in the morning. He tested for gas in Jackson's Drift and found no trace. He saw all the deceased workmen during the shift. He was about 500 yards away when the accident happened. The accident happened about half an hour after he had inspected the place. The first he saw when he got on the scene was Wilkinson. He could not say how many men were down the pit. There were twenty-four men in his district.

By the Chief Inspector: He was there before the men went in and after the men went in he tested for gas. They were preparing for firing a shot. They said they were ready for firing a shot. He met Rumney, the shot-firer, 250 yards away and told him. The working was undercut.

The Inspector: If it was undercut why did they want a shot? — Perhaps it was too hard to hew.

Witness further stated that he satisfied himself it was safe to fire the shot from his examination. He did not go into the "goaf" because it would not be safe.

The Inspector: It would not be safe to go up, and yet it was safe enough to risk firing a shot that might blow through? — I came to the conclusion that the place was quite clear of gas when I made my examination. Witness stated that he examined the roof.

The Inspector said the "goaf" was quite safe enough for him to go up? — Witness said that provided someone was with him he would have gone up.

The Inspector: You are here for the purpose of anticipating everything that occurs. Here is a place that is absolutely unknown on the right side. You say you could not go into it for danger, but you allow a shot to be fired? — I did not anticipate it blowing through.

The Inspector: I don't suppose you did.

Witness said he had seen gas in the lamp. There was no question about there being no gas.

The Inspector: We have a shot-firer going round doing nothing but fire shots. You are the responsible official, and you cannot divest yourself of your responsibility. You actually sent the shot-firer into that place knowing the whole of the conditions. You consider you made a thorough examination? — Yes.

And you considered it safe? — Yes.

You did not anticipate danger where the shot was fired? — No.

Witness said he had not found gas in that district previous to the explosion. He had found it since. He thought it came down from other workings. He thought it came down through stoppings. He would not call it a gassy seam. It was his first day in the district, but he had been in the district before. It did not occur to him to go up to the other side. He would have wanted someone to go up it with him. He could see one and a half per cent of gas and if he found it he would report it if men were working, but he would not report it if no one was working there.

By Mr. Sharp: He approved at the time of the shot being fired, but he did not now. Mr. Sharp proceeded to examine as to it being a question of saving a shilling by firing a shot instead of hewing the coal.

Mr. Cape also asked if it was not one of the standing rules that expense must be kept down.

The Inspector: Is it a question of payment or a question of safety?

Witness: We do not consider payment if it is a question of safety.

By Mr. Lightfoot: It was a shot-firer's duty to make an examination before a shot was fired.

Mr. Lightfoot: Mr. Sharp has suggested that you ordered the shot-firer to fire a shot. I suggest that you knew he was going to fire a shot, and that you did not object as you did not anticipate and danger? — Yes.

Witness further stated that Rumney was a very good responsible man. A shot was fired 60 or 100 yards away probably a quarter of an hour before and nothing happened.

A question regarding the ventilation was answered by Mr. Askew, the manager, who said they never slowed down even on Sunday.

By the Coroner: He had not gone into the "goaf" because of the risk. He did not think there was any gas or he would have gone. The risk was from the roof.

By the Inspector: Although he was not compelled to go into the "goaf."

An adjournment was now made for luncheon, and after the interval the first witness was Joseph Hillary, overman for nine years at the colliery. On the day of the accident he became aware of the accident through a change of air. Dand came up and said he thought there had been a fall somewhere. Witness went in and learned of the accident, so he telephoned to the under-manager what had happened and also telephoned throughout the pit for all the workmen to go home as there had been an explosion. There would be 150 or 160 men in the pit.

By Mr. Wilson: He had been in the working that morning before the explosion and had examined it thoroughly. He had been round behind the timber on the Friday before the explosion carrying a Davy lamp but found no signs of gas.

Mr. Wilson: Why did you go in there? — It's my custom. It's my duty to look for gas, and this is a likely place to find it is it not?

Mr. Wilson: Very likely. But you found none? — No.

Witness, in answer to further questions, said he thought the gas had come down over the week-end.

Hudson Yeowart, 35, Lawson Street, said he had been deputy for three years. He went to the pit on the 26th April at four o'clock in the morning. He had had the place under his supervision ten weeks before. When the explosion occurred he felt a sudden blast. The first injured man he met after the accident was James Wilkinson.

By the Inspector: He never found any gas in the district when the district was under him.

By Mr. Sharp: When he was over that district he examined the "goaf" for gas.

George Fisher, Harriston, pumpman, said he had been there a number of years. He was an ambulance man and rendered assistance to all the injured. Three or four others assisted.

George Henry Askew, manager and agent, said he was there before nine o'clock on the 26th April. He did not make an examination of the place until the evening. He thought the explosion was caused by an accumulation of gas in the Little Yard seam above.

The Coroner: Do you think it was due to misjudgement or mismanagement? — I could not say that.

The Coroner: Do you think it was due to misjudgement — not wilful or culpable? — Undoubtedly so, or the explosion would not have occurred.

The Coroner: To what do you attribute it? — The only conclusion I can come to is that the shot-firer did not make an examination immediately beforehand. He was an experienced conscientious good man whom I had known ever since he came to the pit over twenty-five years ago.

By the Inspector: His instructions were that no shot was to be fired unless the "goaf" was properly examined.

You admit that unless someone goes to the other side of the place no shot should be fired? — I do. My instructions are that any gas found in examinations has to be reported even if removed after a short time.

The Inspector: Do you think they looked for gas? — Undoubtedly.

Do you think they know it when they see it? — I hope so. They have passed examinations.

Witness, in answer to further questions, said that from the distance the gas travelled there must have been an accumulation, but he did not think it accumulated over the week-end.

By Mr. Sharp: He would not approve of firing into the "goaf" without he went round to examine it.

By Mr. Cape: It was not a pit that made a lot of gas. There were big districts where they never saw signs of gas. Compressed powder was not used up to the time of the accident.

By the Coroner: They were trying to get a satisfactory explosive. He had made inquiry and found that in that pit they had only had two explosions that had caused injury. The men liked nitro-glycerine explosives. The explosive used on this occasion was gelignite.

Robert Bell, delegate and representative of the workmen, said he visited the scene on 29th April. In Birney's place they found no gas. In a place leading to Wilkinson's place they found gas. They could not get into Wilkinson's working. There was a large quantity of gas. They examined the "goaf," and found the hole had blown through. They found no gas there.

By Mr. Sharp: A very weak charge of powder would break through.

By the Inspector: It would be a bit easier work to get it down with a shot than with a pick? — Yes.

And nobody likes hard work? — Yes.

By Mr. Lightfoot: There would have been no harm in firing a shot there if the place behind had been examined and found free from gas. There were breaks apparently, from behind, but not from the roof. It was the shot-firer's duty to examine for breaks. Breaks might be there, and not apparent on examination.

The Inspector, asked for his observations by the Coroner, said Mr. Askew had agreed the shot ought not to have been fired under the circumstances. The man practically responsible was the unfortunate man who had lost his life. But apart from that, that did not exonerate the deputy because he was a higher official than the shot-firer. He thought he should have taken more precaution with regard to the safety of the place. He made an examination according to his lights, but he thought a man in his position when he discerns the evidence of danger, should take the responsibility of seeing that no shot was fired into the unknown, which might be a dangerous zone as in this case.

Dealing with the question of the explosives used, the Inspector said the management had interpreted the Order so that they could use what explosives they chose. He was not prepared to confirm that opinion, but in the future, there could be no question but that they would only have to use permitted explosives.

The Coroner, in summing up, said it was a most sad occurrence to investigate — the death of seven men. As far as the evidence was concerned, it had been given by reliable men. As regards any question of responsibility he suggested they approach it from the point of view of — put yourself in his place. Did they think that Dand at any time was careless, negligent, or acted improperly? The demeanour of Dand was in his favour. When a person admitted an error of judgement, great allowance had to be made for it. It was different when a man was obstinate and stood out to the last. Dand had told them he did not anticipate the explosion or he would not have given the order. Another unpleasant thing they must do was to consider the act of a man not there to answer for himself. Rumney, who fired the shot, they were told, was an experienced man, and a high character was given him, and especially by Mr. Askew, who spoke of him as a reliable intelligent man. They had to ask themselves was it likely that Rumney would endanger his own life as well as those of the people with him, by acting improperly, negligently.

The jury retired for a short time, and on their return the Foreman said they found a verdict that the deaths were due to burns caused by the explosion of gas. They also recommended :— "That no shot shall be fired in a rib next to any "goaf" unless an examination can be made of the rib and the "goaf" side."

On behalf of Mr. Harris and the officials of the colliery Mr. Lightfoot expressed sympathy with the relatives of the deceased, as did the Foreman, on behalf of the Jury.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Askew, George Henry    Manager  Whos Who Page
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Bell, Robert    Miners' Delegate  
Birney, Thomas   64 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Briggs, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Cape, Tom    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Dand, William Brown    Deputy  
Eadie, Thomas    Assistant Manager  Whos Who Page
Fisher, George    Pumpman  
Harris, Thomas   25 Miner  Injured, Individual Page
Hillary, Joseph    Overman  
Lightfoot, G. A.    Solciitor  
Lightfoot, Robert   20 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Little, Thomas Herbert   29 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Poole, Granville    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Rayson, Paul   25 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Rumney, Joseph   51 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Sharp, Andrew    Miners' Agent  
Simm, Joseph    Jury Foreman  
Wilkinson, Henry   32 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilkinson, James   59 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Wilson, John Robert Robinson    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Yeowart, Hudson    Deputy  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Brayton Domain Colliery  Brayton Domain Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
30 Apr 1915  The Brayton Pit Explosion, Death Of Two Injured Men, Critical State Of Others (Carlisle Journal)
04 May 1915  The Brayton Pit Explosion, Two More Men Succumb, Funeral Of Victims (Carlisle Journal)
06 May 1915  Explosion At No. 4 Brayton Domain Pit, Two Men Killed And Six Injured (Whitehaven News)
07 May 1915  Brayton Explosion, A Fifth Death (Carlisle Journal)
25 May 1915  The Brayton Pit Explosion, Death Of Another Injured Man (Carlisle Journal)
27 May 1915  Brayton Pit Explosion, Death Of Another Injured Man (Whitehaven News)
24 Jun 1915  The Disastrous Pit Explosion At Aspatria, Inquest On The Seven Victims (Whitehaven News)
25 Jun 1915  Colliery Accidents, Brayton Domain Colliery (The Colliery Guardian)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Brayton Domain
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print