|
20th May 1915 Workmen's CompensationQuestion Of Suitable EmploymentWhitehaven County Court. Friday, May 14. (Before His Honour Judge Gawan Taylor.) Isaac Boyes Patterson, miner, Moor Row, applied under the Workmen's Compensation Act against the Bigrigg Mining Co., Limited. Dr. Eastham, instructed by Messrs. Wood and Lord, solicitors, Manchester, appeared for the applicant; and Mr. W. Procter, instructed by Messrs. Brown, Auld, and Brown, for the respondents. The question involved was whether employment as assistant shiftsman, underground, in an iron ore mine is suitable employment for a man having the use of only one eye. The applicant had been receiving compensation from the respondents in respect to the loss of an eye. His application was that that compensation should be continued. The respondents said they had offered him suitable employment as shiftsman and that the compensation should cease. Dr. Eastham said this was an important case and a serious case, because the workman is only 22 years of age, and as the result of this unfortunate accident he will be unable to work as an iron ore miner, and as a consequence has lost a very large amount of his earnings capacity. He was employed at the respondent's Sir John Walsh mine, and was struck in his right eye with a piece of metal, which penetrated his eye-ball. He had to be sent to Liverpool, where he became an in-patient at the Eye Infirmary. The piece of metal had to be removed, and as a result this man had practically lost the sight of his right eye. The accident occurred in May, 1914. The employers paid compensation at the rate of 18s 3d a week, and payments were made at that rate down to the 20th March. 1915. On that date payment was stopped. The respondents then alleged that this man was able to do the work of an assistant to a shiftsman, and they offered such work, at 5s a day, making 30s a week, and they offered in addition 4s compensation, which made 34s, his average weekly earnings before the accident having been 36s 6d. There is some vision left in the applicant's left eye, but he has a squint, cataract, and a capsule, and in the dark he has confused vision; in fact, he is worse because of the capsule than if he had no sight in the eye at all. It is impossible for him to judge distances in such a way as would make it safe for him to work in a mine. The other eye was practically right. In the report sight was said to be diminished, but it was so slight that they surrendered that point. Mr. Procter: The other eye has sight beyond the normal. Dr. Eastham said they could not have better than natural sight. Mr. Procter: No; but the sight above the normal. Dr. Eastham said this man would not have the same opportunity of foreseeing danger; and he would have great difficulity in timbering. He said nothing about the risk of being knocked down by a bogie or anything of that, sort. This man was not a slacker by any means. Surface work was offered first, and he went and showed his readiness to do it but the manager said he was sorry he had no such work to give him. Mr. Proctor: That letter came from the indemnity society, and when the man went there was no such work. That did not affect the merits of the question. Dr. Eastham went on to read the correspondence as to the offer of an assistant shiftsman underground, how it was objected to as unsuitable, and stated that if surface work was found for him he was ready to take it. Mr. Procter: Can he not look for other work elsewhere? His Honour said the applicant had some earning capacity with his sound eye. Dr. Eastham said he asked His Honour first to say that the work offered was unsuitable. What the compensation should be might be determined afterwards. Since the accident wages had gone up he was told from 36s to 50s., and that fact should be taken into consideration. If wages were going up generally that was a circumstance that His Honour might consider in favour of the applicant. On the other hand a fall in wages might be considered in review of the applicant. His Honour said he took it that he could not order payment of more than the average compensation to the disadvantage, of the average weekly earnings before the accident. Dr. Eastham said that was so; but in considering what the actual order should be he could take into consideration the rise of wages. Mr. Proctor: Had we not better get at the facts? You are auguring law and we don't know what the facts are. Isaac Boyes Patterson said the accident happened on the 19th May 1914. A piece of metal struck his right eye. He went to the Liverpool Eye Hospital and a piece of iron was removed from the eye. He was under the care of Dr. Stevenson. Since the accident he had had trouble with shooting pains in his head. If he shut his left eye he could not see anything with his right eye, except just to distinguish between light and darkness. At night if he looked at a carriage coming along the road, instead of seeing two lights he would see four lights. He could not judge distances very well, and he could not tell which was the right hand light or the left hand light until the carriage was very near. In January he went to do the surface work that was offered. He would try and do surface work if he could get it. Picking metal was part of surface work there was no recognized word to describe surface work. He was told there was surface work. He was offered an assistant shiftsman's work. A shiftsman's work was to timber roofs; remove falls, which involves the use of dynamite if it is a big fall. Mr. Proctor said it was stated that the applicant would not be put to any work where he would have any responsibility whatever. Continuing, Patterson said his work would be to repair roads or do practically anything. The timbering of roofs was dangerous work, being done by candle light. Suppose there was any danger on the right side of him, he could not see it. If a bogie was coming along, he would not be able to see it if it was on the right hand side. Men were sometimes knocked down by bogies. Sometimes the bogie had a candle on and sometimes not. To work in candle light would be far to dangerous for him, because of his cross vision and inability to judge distances in the dark. In timbering they had to dress the roof down with a bar or a pick, in doing which bits fall, and the shiftsman and his assistant, the assistant holding the light, have to get out of the way of the failing pieces. The fall is not always from where the pick is used. Witness showed; by means of matches how propping, was done. Mr. Procter: Does your Honour notice how easily he adjusts those matches? Dr. Eastham: Oh yes, in daylight. If you want a demonstration, you will have to take him down the pit to set him to work in candle-light. Witness said miners' wages to-day were £3 10s. They had gone up generally. Supposing he used his eyes very much they were affected. Cross-examined by Mr. Procter, witness asked whether he had at any time since the accident been fit to do any work, said he had been, fit to work on the top. He could not say how long he had been fit to do some work on the top. He had been since January. He had not tried to get work elsewhere, since January; because his eye would be a greet drawback. There was no work that be was fit to do down below. That had been his opinion ever since the accident. In his opinion no one-eyed man ought to work below, because it was far too dangerous, so that it would not be possible to get any work for him below that he would accept. When Mr. Wilson, the mine manager, on the 1st February told him he had no surface work at that time for him, but that he could give him a job below when he was ready for it, Mr. Duffy had told him to ask for a job at the top, and he told Mr. Wilson that. He could not remember saying to Mr. Wilson, "but I would rather be at the bottom." When he was offered the work of an assistant shiftsman, he knew that Mr. Duffy was taking up the attitude that a one-eyed men should not work below, and witness approved of that. A miner's work was less dangerous than that of a shiftsman. He would not come back as a miner, because a miner had to use explosives. He would not try either one of the other. On the 9th November he was asked to submit to an examination by Dr. Bickerton, of Liverpool. On the 3rd of March he was examined by Dr. Bickerton. He told Dr. Bickerton that he did not wish to go into the mine again, as he would have to handle explosives, charge holes, and fit caps and firing fuses. If he was offered a job in the mine without these dangers, he replied that no man with one eye ought to go down a mine. If one-eyed men were employed in the mine without accident, he would say they were lucky, that was all that did not change his opinion with regard to himself, because he was worse that if he was all together blind of one eye. If he were to put a shield over his injured eye, that would strain his left eye, which would water. His Honour Not more than if you had lost your right eye entirely. Witness said he had tried shading his right eye when he was reading and he could not, read for more than five minutes when the left eye watered. He had done that often. Substantially his reason for refusing to take work in the mine was that he was nervous about going below. Mr. Procter asked witness whether these proceedings were commenced by his authority and immediately objected that the witness had looked to Mr. Duffy and that Mr. Duffy had nodded. He asked His Honour that Mr. Duffy should be asked to leave the Court. Mr. Duffy said that he had not consciously nodded or otherwise tried to influence the witness. On his honour he assured His Honour of that. To do any such thing would be highly improper. Mr. Procter: And I distinctly saw you do it. Mr. Duffy protested that he did not and Mr. Procter as positively reiterated that he did, but the incident passed. Questioned as to different kind of work below ground, witness replied that he could not do such work. Mr. Procter: You seem determined not to do anything? Witness: Not below ground. Re-examined by Dr. Eastham, witness said he was ready to try any surface work. Thomas Gavin Duffy, secretary of the Iron Ore Miners' Union, said there was no analogy at all between working in a coal mine and an iron ore mine. He received a letter from Mr. Martin suggesting that Patterson go and, and he did so and returned to say that there was no surface work. Then the work of an assistant shiftsman was offered. That was not suitable for Patterson at all: it was practically maid of all work in the mine. The assistant would have to work every where, the same as the shiftsman. If the shiftsman wanted a tool, his labourer would have to go and bring it for him. It was the work of the shiftsman and his labourer to work in dangerous parts of the mine and remove the dangers. Wherever the shiftsman goes, the labourer necessarily has to go. We hold the opinion that a man with one eye has no right down a mine at all. Dr. Eastham: Well, we don't raise that question. Mr. Proctor. But he has raised it, and he is your witness. Witness said the work in an iron mine was far more dangerous than the work in a coal mime. This work was not at all suitable for Patterson. Of the one-eyed men who it had been said were already working in the mines, one was not a miner at all. Another, Young, was responsible for a very serious accident. Cross-examined: Witness did not see the accident. Young was retained in his employment after the accident. Witness did not know what the Union would have done if all one-eyed men were discharged. It was not the opinion of the Union that no one-eyed men should not be employed in the mine but witness's personal opinion. Even with an eye-shade it would not be safe for Patterson to work below. It was owing to blurred vision that there would be danger. If that were removed by a shade on the other eye, it would still be unsuitable because when the eye was shaded the other eye watered. Is there any job in a man that a one-eyed man can do? — I don't think so. Then may we take it that four one-eyed men employed in one mine should not be employed. Has your Union taken any action to bring these men out? — No. Witness said he did not come here as an authority on underground conditions in an iron ore mine. He had been down a mine four times, only. He was entitled to speak of underground conditions because he was living and conversing with these men every day. He was not a tailor before he became a union secretary. He had denied that before. He declined to say what he was. The question of wages did not arise on the offer to Patterson of underground work, but he thought that 5s a day for a shiftsman contemptible. He did not suggest to Patterson that he should go and try the work. He did not think a man who could not undertake responsibility ought to go underground. If he was told he had no responsibility then he said the man had no right there. He did not reply to that effect to the offer of underground work: he wrote that he would have to have an examination of Patterson by a specialist before deciding. Re-examined: He had been trade union secretary for nearly eight years and during that time had given evidence before a Royal Commission. He had no interest in the matter. Dr. Stephenson, of the Liverpool Eye Infirmary, eye specialist, said he saw Patterson the day after his accident. Patterson was admitted to the Infirmary, and two days after witness removed the metal from his eye. The effect of the accident was to produce cataract. The left eye had perfect vision, but the injury to the other eye caused dazzling, with in the dark the multiplication of the light of a single flame. The squint alone caused double vision with both eyes open. If he put his hand over his left eye he would see very badly and in a bad light he would very likely get multiplication of lights. If he covered his injured eye, there would be no double vision, but it would intensify the pain in his temple. If he covered the injured eye that would not stop the squint. Supposing he were working in the dim light of the mine, he would still have strain. It was the unconscious effect of the eyes to keep straight that caused the pain Patterson complained of. Having heard what had been said in evidence about the work in the mine of a shiftsman's assistant, he had no doubt in his mind that, Patterson could not do that work. He would be more handicapped in the dim light of a mine. If he had to work in the dim light of a mine witness thought the pain Patterson complained of would be likely to get worse. The piece of metal removed was very far back and disturbed the contents of the eye a good deal. This was not the simple case of the loss of an eye. The condition of the injured eye complicated the case. Witness did not advise Patterson to do the work that was offered to him. Cross-examined: If this man had his good eye only could he do the work? That was rather a difficult question to answer. Witness thought he might be able to do the work if he tried; but he did not think it was safe. That would apply to all one-eyed men. He had known cases of men who had returned to work with only one eye. A great many rivetters had gone back to work with only one eye. He did not think the conditions with them were as bad as they were in the mine. There were not so many moving objects as in the mine. Assuming that the man has one eye only was there anything to prevent Patterson working underground? No, he was physically fit, but he seemed to be frightened. If it were true that Patterson had stated that he would rather have a job below, but that he had been told to ask for one on the top, then witness's objection would be removed. Witness could not recall the case of a miner who after an operation for cataract, had returned to work. The whole of the difficulty would not be got over by the use of a shade. He knew that one-eyed men did work in the mines, but he thought they ought not to be allowed to do so. From the evidence he had heard to-day he thought one of these men would probably one day have another accident. It was a case of going once too often with the pitcher to the well: he had dangerous work. This was the case for the applicant, and Mr. Procter said he would call his witnesses before replying. Robert Wilkinson, manager of the mine, said he asked Patterson if he would not have a job in the pit, and he said he would much rather, but he had been told to ask for a job on the top. There was no responsibility in the work of an assistant shiftsman — he just acts as a labourer. Witness did not think Patterson would be in any danger in undertaking that work. The offer of that work was still open to him. In addition to 5s a day, the Company would pay him 4s a week compensation, making 34s-a week. Cross-examined: Most certainly he thought that Patterson might use dynamite safely. He thought that in time Patterson would be ready for his own job. He was as certain as that he was standings there that Patterson told him he would rather have an underground job. Thomas Thompson, manager of the Margaret Pit, Frizington, said he had two assistant shiftsmen in his mine at the present time: they had had as far as six or eight. It was not a dangerous job: he was really a labourer for the shiftsman. There were three or four one-eyed men working in the Margaret Pit. Atkinson had an accident and lost an eye. He went on as a trailer before his settlement. Another man, McGannon. Dr. Eastham objected to this evidence. The question was whether this particular man could do certain work, not what other men could do. His Honour said surely it was material to know what other one-eyed men were doing. Dr. Eastham said their eyes might not be in the same condition as Patterson's. Mr. Procter said two of the witnesses had said that one-eyed men should not work underground, and he was showing that one-eyed man did work underground and that the inference was that this one-eyed man could do the work. Witness continued to say McGannon was a hanger-on of bogies: That was a more dangerous job than shift work, and he had been working at it for about eight years. They had two other one-eyed men who were working as miners, handling dynamite and charging holes: and they had done a lot of shift work and had done it satisfactorily. They had been working for about five years. Dr. Eastham said he would not cross-examine. George McGannon said he lost his eye when a child and had worked as a hanger-on of bogies. Matthew Thomlinson said he lost an eye by accident and worked afterwards as a shiftman and now worked as a miner. He had had no trouble in doing that. He never considered the shiftsman's work was dangerous. Walter Atkinson said he was a trailer. He had lost his sight of one eye entirely. Alexander Young, miner at Margaret Pit, said he lost one eye, since then he had worked as a shiftsman and then as a miner. By His Honour: After his accident he did not work for two years. That was before there was any compensation. For another two years he worked as a labourer above ground. Then he worked as a shiftsman. Dr. Bickerton, Liverpool, surgeon at the Royal Infirmary, said he examined Patterson on the 3rd March. He did not complain of any pain. His left eye was a perfect eye. Patterson said he did not think he was fit for work where they used explosives, that he was not fit to charge holes at present. He said he had been offered shift work. The double vision which he experienced was common in all eases of cataract, and would pass away. There was nothing to be afraid of in working in the dim light of the mine. If a shade was put upon the injured the difficulty would be completely removed: he would then become a one-eyed man. The squint was nature's method of getting rid of the duplication, and would do so in time. With a shade on the injured eye there would be no strain, he saw no objection to Patterson undertaking work in the mine as a shiftsman, and no possible danger. Instead of straining the other eye by wearing a shade, it would relieve the other eye from strain. Cross-examined: He only examined Patterson once. He knew that Patterson had been in charge of Dr. Stephenson. Dr. Stephenson was an eminent eye specialist. Witness saw Patterson for about an hour. Witness had never been down an iron ore mine, as Dr. Stephenson had been. He had no reason to doubt that Patterson was truthful in complaining of pain. If he had pain witness did not know what it would be due to. He had never heard of squint causing pain. The squint would be due to the accident, and it would probably get worse. The attempt to pull the eyes into parallel would cause eye-strain, if he could make the attempt. With the injured eye shaded he could not. There would be no strain from working in candle-light in a mine. The covering up of the injured eye would entirely prevent the dazzling that Patterson complained of. Witness declined to say what impression he had of Patterson's story and whether he was a malingerer. Re-examined: Patterson did not complain of pain. If he had complained witness would have told him that a shade would remove it. Dr. Eldon Pratt, Whitehaven, said he had examined Patterson and he agreed with Dr. Bickerton that Patterson was fit to do the work that had been offered to him. With shade on there would be no disability in the other eye. Certainly no harm would be done by the man trying. Cross-examined: He only examined Patterson once and that was on May 5th. This concluded the evidence for the respondents. Mr. Procter then addressed His Honour on their behalf, and pointed out that this man had made no attempt elsewhere to get work. There was not the least doubt that if he had applied for work many people would have been glad to have had him, but since January he had made no effort, content with his compensation money. In February, when this shift work was offered him he did not say that he could not do the work. It was only when the Union came on the scene that he said he could not do it. It was unreasonable for the man to say that he would not go into the mine and try the work, putting a shade over his eye. Why should not he have done that? It was only when ho got to Mr. Duffy that he said a one-eyed man ought not to go down the mine. The reason he gave to Dr. Bickerton why he did not wish to work in the pit was that he was expecting he would have to do his ordinary work, handling explosives, and not simply doing shift work. If the man had tried the work and then said he could not do it that would have been natural. But here he said he would not try, and there was no reason at all why this man should not do some work, and yet he never made any attempt to get any. He was standing out to get a lump sum settlement, and it would probably be found that a week afterwards he would be back at his old work. Dr. Eastham: You have no right to say that. Mr. Proctor: It is what has happened in other cases. His Honour said he had not to decide whether a one-eyed man could do this work, because this was not simply a one-eyed man. He preferred the evidence of Dr. Stephenson on the squint, and that he would not have his difficulty removed by wearing a shade. Therefore he came to the conclusion that this man could not do the work that was offered to him. He awarded the man compensation of 8s 3d per week. Dr. Eastham asked for Dr. Stephenson's fee. His Honour said he thought the man might have made some trial of the work. Dr. Eastham said Patterson followed Dr. Stephenson's advice. His Honour decided that each party should bear their own costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||