|
(Unknown)Article from the (Unknown), April 1915 Tragic CoincidenceSherburn Miner's Terrible DeathThe melancholy circumstances of the death of a young miner named Joseph Smith, a coal cutter man, who was killed while following his employment at Sherburn Hill Colliery on Friday, were inquired into in the Wesleyan Methodist Church, Sherburn Village, on Monday afternoon by Mr. C. E. Cadle, Coroner. Mr. G. H. Hornsby represented the owners of the colliery, Mr. Joseph Ryans was for the Durham Miners' Association, Mr. R. Local represented the local lodge, and Messrs. John Kyle and Wm. Harper were the men's inspectors. Mr. J. R. R. Wilson, H.M. Inspector, also attended. Evidence of identification was given by the father, William Smith of 5, East Street, Sherburn. Thomas Akenhead, of Lambton Terrace, Sherburn Hill, said he was engaged at the mine as a stoneman, and on Friday morning soon after one o'clock he was acting as canch man in the place where Robert Carroll was shotfiring. When the shot had been prepared witness went in-bye for safety, and he had not been long there when he heard another shot fired to his left. He waited about a minute before the out-bye shot fired, and then went to see the result. When within a short distance of the place he saw a part of a lamp and knew something was wrong. Proceeding four feet further he found the body of Smith lying upon the ground face downwards, and being satisfied he was dead he called for assistance. Witness could not say how it was that Smith had been killed, though he was of the opinion that deceased had left his shelter before the out-bye shot had been fired. In answer to a juror, Mr. Hornsby explained that Smith was passing from one part of the mine to another at the time, and he had taken shelter on account of shot firing. When a report was heard he started away to resume his journey along the way, but it happened that it was not the shot for which he was waiting and consequently when the powder nearest to him exploded shortly afterwards he sustained fatal injuries. Robert Stead, an overman, of East View, Sherburn, said he was acting as overman in the second east district of the mine. Shortly after the accident he was called to the place and found Smith's body face downwards lying near to the spot where a shot had been fired. Witness, who has had training in first-aid, examined the man, and found severe injuries to the back of the head, which appeared to have been blown in. In answer to the Coroner, witness explained that Smith had mistaken the in-bye shot when fired for the out-bye shot, and having heard the first one discharge he started away on his journey, and had just got to the place of the second shot when it fired and killed him. Later, witness saw the shot firer, Carroll, and he asked him if he made a practice of going back to see the result of shots when fired, and he said he did, but in that case he did not as the shot was only an eight ounce shot. The Coroner: Do you think the shot firer had not done his duty? Witness: I think he made a mistake. He ought to have gone first to have seen the result of his shot. Further replying to questions, witness said he was not aware that two shots had to be fired in that district. Such a thing as two shots being prepared at the same time might never happen again in twenty years. Mr. Wilson: In your opinion, as a practical man, would it not be wise for it to be known when two shots are to fired on the same road at the same time? — I daresay it would. Can you promise that that will be seen to in the future? — Yes. And will you see it carried out? — Yes. Mr. Hornsby: It will be a question of making arrangements among the shot firers. Robert Carroll, shot firer, was then called into the room, and the Coroner informed him that he was not bound to give evidence unless he chose to do so. He could not say as to whether or not there would be any allegation against him, but he would warn him before he decided to speak. Carroll: If it is required I will give it. The Coroner: We should prefer you to give evidence. Carroll: Then I have no hesitation whatever. Witness, who is aged 72 years, and residing at 23, South Street, Sherburn, said he had been a shot firer for over eight years at Littletown and at Sherburn Hill. On the date in question he laid an eight ounce shot, which consisted of Viking powder, and then proceeded to the shelter outbye, the canchmen entering the in-bye shelter. While witness was waiting the discharge Smith came along, and he warned him as to the shot, and he came alongside him. After waiting about two minutes they heard a report, and Smith remarked "She's gone," picked up his bag, and hurried away. He was eager to reach his work. They thought it was witness' shot that had discharged. The Coroner: You did not make any attempt to prevent him? Witness: No. Where did you go? — I went to another flat. You didn't wait to see the result of the shot? — No. Why? — I cannot explain it. I can give no reason. You didn't call after the young man? — No. You can't give any explanation? — No. You know you ought to have gone to see the result of the shot? — Yes. And if you had gone you would have been blown up? — Yes. There would have been two instead of one. Do you know anything about the other shot being fired? — No. I did not know one had been lighted. How many shot firers are there in the district? — Two. Do you communicate with each other? — No. I suppose you will each take a certain part of the district? — Yes. In answer to the Coroner, witness said he had always been in the habit of following up a shot and that was the first time he had failed to do so. He did not mean when he said the shot was only a light one, that that was a reason why he did not go to see the result. Witness admitted hearing the second shot, but thought it was in another part of the mine. The Coroner said it was clear what had taken place. It was a most unfortunate accident, and had evidently arisen from a mistake that had been made in regard to the two shots. Neither of the firers appeared to be in touch with each other, and it would be better if some means were adopted whereby they could communicate with each other before a shot was discharged. However, that matter on the undertaking of Mr. Hornsby would receive attention in the future. Carroll had admitted the fault and he thought he was clearly to blame, but what the jury had to consider was whether he had committed an error of judgment in not going to see the result or whether it was such an act as would amount to criminal or culpable negligence. There could be no doubt that he committed a serious error of judgment. However, Carroll was an old man. Mr. Hornsby: He says he is not going down the pit anymore. The Coroner: I am glad to hear that, because the man does not seem quite up to his work, and is unable to give any real excuse for what he did. Proceeding, the Coroner said they could attribute the accident to an error of judgment, though he must say it was going very near the line. There was an excuse that Carroll did not know of the other shot and thought it was his which discharged first, but that did not excuse him from going to see the result. The jury deliberated in private, and afterwards announced the following verdict. "That the accident was due to an error of judgment. We recommend that there be direct communication when shots are being fired in the same headway or about the same time."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 25 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||