|
25th February 1915 Mining Fatality At Ullcoats MineInquest At BeckermetOn Thursday evening Mr. G. A. L. Skerry (coroner for the Lordship of Egremont) and a jury, of whom Mr. J. R. Atkinson was foreman, held an inquest at the Assembly Room, Beckermet, upon the body of Thomas Mawson, iron ore miner, of Rifle-Terrace, Beckermet, who was fatally injured in Ullcoats Mine, Egremont, on Wednesday. Mr. W. Leck, H.M.I., represented the Home Office; Mr. O. F. Ormrod, of the firm of Brockbank, Helder and Ormrod, the Ullcoats Mining Company; and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, agent of the Iron Ore Miners' Association, the deceased's relatives. Mr. R. Hartley, of the firm of Messrs. Walker and Hartley, engineers to the Ullcoats Company and Mr. M. Richardson, manager of the Ullcoats Mine, were also present. Margaret Mawson, widow of the deceased, said he was 37 years of age. She last saw him alive at half-past four on Wednesday morning, when he left for his work. He was in the best of health and spirits. As far as she could tell he was brought home about half-past five on the same day. He was then dead. Thomas Southam said he lived at Watson Hill, Egremont, and was a miner at the Ullcoats Mine. He worked in company with deceased and two labourers, John Corkish and Edward Corkish. Mawson and he tried the roof with a bar before they commence work. They dressed a few pieces of ore off the roof, otherwise it was all right. It was a stone, a very good roof. Mawson and he drilled a hole in the bottom, and Mawson fired it at ten o'clock. Each drilled two more holes, and these were fired at half-past one. After the first shot at ten o'clock they tried the roof with a bar. The one that fired a shot tried the roof. The labourers got away the metal. The two shots at half-past one were fired together. Both shots went off, and everything was right up till then. After the last two shots Mawson said he would go back to the working and witness was to make two more charges while he dressed a little more of the roof down. Corkhill had then gone up the pit for stores and Corkish was at the "bait" seat. Witness had prepared the two charges, and went into the working when he found Mawson dressing the first hole witness had fired. He took the two charges in with him. He wanted to fire them before two o'clock. The ground hadn't to be dressed before he could do this. The holes were already bored and were in the same place as the others. Witness went on charging one of the holes while Mawson continued dressing, with his back to witness. Before he got the hold charged he heard Mawson moan and shout, "Tom." Deceased was standing while dressing the side. He didn't hear anything fall except what he thought Mawson was dressing. They worked by candles and there was plenty of light. When he went to see what was the matter with Mawson, he found a lump of ore and stone of about six or seven cwts. on his leg. With the assistance of Corkish he got the stone off him and steadied him until Corkish, whom he sent for, brought assistance. Mawson couldn't walk and they carried him out. Asked if Mawson said anything to him, witness said, "Yes, he said, I'm done, Tom. What will become of my two children?" Witness recognised Mawson was seriously injured. Deceased was carried out to No. 2 pit shaft. He then said, "I would not have cared if I hadn't looked over it myself. I could have laid my life on it." The Coroner: He meant that the roof was all right? Witness: Yes. The Coroner: Did you notice what had happened. Did you think a fall of roof had injured him. Was there a fall of roof or you could not tell? Witness: I couldn't tell just then. The Coroner: You thought he had dressed something down on himself? Witness: Yes. The Coroner: When he said, "I wouldn't have cared if I hadn't looked over it myself," did that give you the impression that he had sounded the roof after the shot? Witness: Yes. More than me would hear him say that. The Coroner: Did he say anything else to you? Witness: He said he wished that he had fired them all four together and never went back. It was always usual to inspect a roof after firing a shot. Mawson was an experienced man, and he had never known him to neglect to look at the roof after firing a shot. Witness went up the pit with Mawson and remained with him until he died at four o'clock. Asked if Mawson was sensible or conscious up to the last, witness said he was not quite conscious. Mawson did say he could not help shouting owing to the pain. He didn't blame anybody. There was no necessity for props in the place then. There might have been after a while. Asked if they were anxious to get done before two o'clock witness said they were not hurrying. Deceased had plenty of time to inspect the roof before firing the last two shots. This would take five or ten minutes. The place was only worked the one shift and they would have gone back to it the next morning. At the time he could not tell what was the cause of the accident. Deceased was properly attended to. Dr. Jackson attended him at the pit. He had not been in the working again until that morning, when he went in with Mr. Leck. The working was then just as they had left it. He found that the metal that had fallen on the deceased was a piece of stone with a little ore on it. It had come from the side of the roof. He could not say whether Mawson had pressed it down or it had fallen. Witness sounded the stone before firing the last two shots, and it was then all right. He thought the shots must have loosened it. By the Foreman: He found the stone only on Mawson's legs. Mr. T. W. Fell, chief assistant to Messrs. Walker and Hartley, engineers to the Ullcoats Mining Company, produced a plan and sections of the working, and explained them to the jury. Southam, in reply to Mr. Leck, said he couldn't say where the stone hit Mawson. He thought Mawson would have plenty of time to sound the roof after he went in following the last shots. He had that impression. Witness had worked twelve years at Ullcoats, and ten months with Mawson. He couldn't say how long Mawson had worked there — a number of years. It was the practice for one to hold a light while the other was dressing. When the latter was tired the other held the light. They did this that morning before anybody came in. Mr. Satterthwaite, overman, came in about eight o'clock or soon after. Mr. Satterthwaite was particular about the roof, and after he had sounded the place all over he ordered them to come back on the side of the place in question. He was satisfied Mawson dressed it down and made it safe. None of the holes fired in the morning was in the roof. They were in the "stope," at the bottom. Mr. Leck: Do you think it likely that the firing of the holes in the bottom might affect the roof? Witness: It might have. If anything hit it, it might affect it. Mr. Leck: By a piece flying up from the bottom? Witness: Yes. There was no need for any timber, but if there had been there was available as much as they would have required. By standing on a plank Mawson could dress any part of the roof. Asked if there were any ambulance men on the place, witness said there were. Mr. Mandale came in soon after the accident. Witness was not an ambulance man. He had never attended any ambulance classes. Mr. Leck: Don't you think now, after seeing your mate injured by your side you would have felt a good deal happier if by ambulance knowledge you had been able to render first aid. You would have felt happier, knowing exactly what to do? Witness: Well, I would. The place they were working in was a "robbery." Mr. Leck said he thought the method of working a place of that description was a good one. By Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy: The roof was not examined by an official before they started work that morning. Asked if he thought it part and parcel of his responsibility as a miner to see that the roof was all right before starting work, witness replied in the affirmative. There were three or four deputies at the mine, but he could not say whether any of them examined the working that morning before witness's company commenced work. There was no delay in getting the deceased out of the pit. The accident happened at about a quarter to two, but when Mawson was brought up the pit he couldn't really say as he hadn't any knowledge of the time. The ambulance from Cleator Moor was at the pit almost immediately. Pressed upon this point, witness said he didn't think there was any delay. Mr. Gavan Duffy: But it would have been an advantage had there been an ambulance at Egremont? Witness: Well, a few minutes maybe. If he had had any suspicion that the stone was unsafe he would have brought it down. This distance from the working place to the shaft was about 150 yards. Asked if they were not cutting it fine to fire the two shots and get to the shaft by two o'clock witness said they could do it quite easily. Mr. Gavan Duffy: In regard to timber you could get as much as you required for your own safety? Witness: Yes. Mr. Gavan Duffy: As much timer as required, and I think the very best of English larch. Witness: Yes, very good larch. Mawson was a very steady, careful, and good workman. By Mr. Ormrod: The roof sounded all right when they examined it. The deputy stood on the plank when he examined it, and he came to the same conclusion. Witness made no suggestion to the deputy about the roof at all. Edward Corkish, miners' labourer, Cringlethwaite, Egremont, gave evidence. He was in the "bait" shed when the accident happened. He saw Satterthwaite sound the roof with a bar about eight o'clock. Mawson also sounded it after the first shot was fired. William Satterthwaite, Bridge End, said he was an overman at Ullcoats Mine. He went into Mawson's working place every day; sometimes twice. He always examined it with a bar, chiefly. His examination consisted of sounding the roof and the sides. If there was any suspicion of change, he arranged for putting a prop in, or if it was a part that could be taken down they took it down. The cause of the stone falling might be a slip, the result of the blasting or dampness. He examined the stone in question on Wednesday morning. It was ore and stone mixed. There was a slip above it that made it fall. When he sounded it on Wednesday morning it sounded all right. Deceased dressed and bored the ground underneath the stone. During the day the stone got rather tainted and the shot on the left-hand side was directly underneath it — one of the two fired about half-past one. A piece of metal from the shot might have hit it. He gave Mawson particular instructions to always look at the high side and also at the "stope." Mawson was a very careful man. Witness came to the conclusion that the stone fell either owing to dressing the ground underneath, or dampness and then the shot going direct up to it. If Mawson had tired to get the stone down he could have done so safely. He didn't think Mawson had been trying to get it down. He thought it fell of its own accord. He didn't know of anything that could have prevented the accident. He always found Mawson a careful man, and anything witness recommended he would do right away. By Mr. Leck: The stone weighed about three cwts. The front of the slip was visible to him in the morning and that was why he told Mawson to dress it well. There was no timber in the working. It was a kind of working where its character might change in a very short time. It had, in fact, altered since he was in it in the morning. He admitted this pointed to the necessity of particular examinations and that was why he gave Mawson particular instructions to examine the top side and then the "stope" after every shot. They didn't work under any special rules at the mine. They worked under the Metalliferous Mines Act. By Mr. Gavan Duffy: He did not agree that an examination of the roof of the working by an official before the men started work would be a safeguard, because it was a "robbery" and the place was worked on only one shift. Mr. Gavan Duffy: You think the onus for the safety of the roof ought to be thrown on the miner? Witness: Well, you see, in a robbery that we generally have one shift they bore probably five or six holes, and they know the circumstances of the place and everything. Mr. Gavan Duffy: That is really not an answer to the question I put to you. I ask whether you think the onus or responsibility for the safety of the roof should be thrown on the workmen or miners, and not a special official appointed for the job? Probably you don't care to answer that. In answer to further questions, witness said the roof was twelve feel high and he seriously suggested that a piece might fly from a shot and hit the roof. Pieces flew a great way. By Mr. Ormrod: An examination before would not have prevented the accident. Changes took place after he examined it. In his opinion what was done tended to bring the stone down or to loosen it because Mawson had taken a good deal of ground from underneath it. He had undermined it. Witness had had forty-four years experience in iron ore mines. The Foreman said the jury found that deceased had been accidentally killed by a fall of stone from the roof and that no blame was attached to anyone. With regard to official examination of the place, they had it in evidence that the roof of such a working changes in a very short time, and, therefore, they thought the miners themselves were the best capable of examining it. Mr. Ormrod, on behalf of the Company, expressed their deep regret and sympathy with the widow in her trouble. As they all knew deceased was a most reliable workman and most steady, it seemed to him it was generally the best workmen who met with these accidents. He hoped Mr. Gavan Duffy would convey the Company's expression of regret and sympathy to the relatives of the deceased. Mr. Gavan Duffy said he would be pleased to do so, and observed with regard to the accident that all would agree there was no responsibility attached to the management of the Ullcoats Mine, which had been free from serious accidents for many years. The Foreman expressed the sympathy of the jury and himself with the widow in her bereavement.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||