Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th February 1915

Three Hodbarrow Miners Entombed By Fall Of Rock

One Man Crushed To Death

On Thursday evening a very sad accident took place at the Hodbarrow Mines, resulting in the death of a miner named Henry Coward, and serious injuries to his two mates, Voisey and Osborne. It appears that about five o'clock in the evening the men had, according to their experience, made everything in their working safe, and were about to prepare to bore holes, when, without any warning, there was a fall of some tons of rock from the roof, which crushed through the wood and fell on top of Coward, crushing him dreadfully, every bone in his body being broken. Voisey was also caught by the fall, but was soon released, and taken home, his injuries consisting of some cuts about the head. Osborne was held fast by one hand and foot, and it took his mates nearly three hours to release him. He was in a very precarious position, as there was a second fall from the roof before he was got safely away. It was not till midnight that Coward was removed, being then, of course, quite dead. Osborne was detained at the Hodbarrow hospital, suffering from bruised shoulder and leg, and injured foot. He also suffered from shock.

An inquest was held before Dr. Stoney, at the Hodbarrow hospital on Saturday last. The jury had to visit the sick ward to get the evidence from Osborne, who gave a very clear account of the whole accident.

Mr. W. B. Miles was appointed foreman, the other jurymen being Messrs T. Mandall, Edward James Dixon, Henry Chappels, Alfred Hoyle, Joseph Robshaw, Henry Breakwell, W. B. Jones, Henry Edmondson, George Henry Burgess, William Crump, Samuel Sheldon, and John Dowbiggin.

Frank Sykes, fellow miner, identified the body viewed by the jury as that of Henry Coward, aged 57, who resided at 24, Devonshire Street. He was a miner, working at the Hodbarrow Mines. Witness last saw him alive at two o'clock on Thursday. He was then going to work. Witness did not see him alive after that.

John Osborne, 32, Concrete Square, Haverigg, miner, working at Hodbarrow, said he went to work on Thursday afternoon at two o'clock. He was working as usual until about five o'clock. They had just been making their timber safe, according to the rules of the mines, and the captain's orders. All three were then making ready to bore three stouping holes. Witness and deceased were on the stoup, and Voisey was making ready. All at once they heard a big crash, and before they could do anything the wood was on top of them. There was also a fall of rock. A big lump of rock knocked witness against the wood before he was able to get up. He was on the point of getting up when he was knocked down, and he was pinned against the standing timber. His leg was caught between the roof spoils and the floor. Witness did not know what happened to Coward. He could hear Voisey shout out, but could not hear Coward. Witness did not know that deceased was buried up until an hour after the accident. He came to the conclusion that he must be buried because he could not be found, and witness informed the rescuers that the deceased must be close to witness's feet. He was under the rock at the feet of witness.

Examined by Mr. Leck (H.M. Inspector of Mines): How long have you worked with the late Mr. Coward? — Three years.

You did not work as a regular mate with him? — No, he had just come on that shift.

He would have a good knowledge of the workmanship of the mine? — Yes, he was a very careful workman.

How long had he worked at Hodbarrow? — 30 years.

He would then be well acquainted with the character of the ground? — Yes.

How long have you worked at the mines? — About 38 years.

So you would be well acquainted with the character of the work at Hodbarrow? — Yes. There was some timber to put right, which we did according to the captain's orders, and the rules of the mines. We had finished securing the timber about five minutes before the accident happened.

You had just finished making the timber safe. Tell us what you did? — We put a fork in place of one which had a list. We put it in upright, and put the one that had a list back. We put one plumb and took one out.

Having done that, was there anything else in your judgement which could have been done? — There was nothing else. We were just going to bore our holes. We thought that everything was all right according to mine rules, and the captain's orders.

This was in the afternoon. Had there been a captain in for that shift? — Yes, Captain Towers.

How long was this before the accident? — He had not got very far away.

Just immediately before? Just immediately before it happened. We were just going to bore a hole, having got the tools and the water.

Did he give you any particular instructions? — He said you are all right here, and we replied, "Yes, we are all right."

How many headtrees had you in? — Three.

Another company was working behind you? — Yes.

How many headtrees had they put in? — One side by side.

Is that a usual thing for two companies to work together? — Yes.

You did not think that there was any extra risk? — Everything was safe enough. I could have gone to sleep there. I never dreamed that such a thing would have occurred.

You had three headtrees in; how many were forked? — Two, and we were boring a hole to fork the third one.

You could not put the fork in until you got the floor out? — No.

Was the last headtree close up? — It was close to the roof above. There was not room to drive a wedge between the timber and the top of the roof.

What was on the top? — There was wood, nine inch poles, ten or eleven feet long.

Was the wood put in tight against that? — Yes.

In your judgement was there anything else that could be done? — Nothing else could be done; we could not do any more.

You did not attach or consider any extra risk by taking the second lift at the same time? Nothing whatever; it was done the same way always.

You never knew an accident in the working before? — No, never.

Did you consider how the accident happened? — By some heavy pressure caused by something giving way on the top suddenly. I think the other place will be standing.

Mr. Leck: As a matter of fact it is not.

Is it regular for an official to come in every shift? — Yes, sometimes twice.

After the fall occurred you would be in the dark? — Yes.

Was it long before anyone came? I should say about three minutes.

How many men were working behind you? — Two.

Did they get out without injury? Yes; they ran to the ladder when they heard the crash.

It was not long before someone came? — About three minutes, I think. They had Voisey out in about five minutes after the accident happened.

What method have you of getting timber to the working? — We pull it in to the rise.

Who brings it to the bottom of the rise? — George Bell.

He is one of the company? — Yes.

George Bell's duty is to see you well supplied with timber — Yes.

You have always a plentiful supply of timber? Yes, plentiful.

Had you a plentiful supply on this occasion? We had all the timber we could get in.

If you wanted more there was plenty? Yes; there were about 100 stacks there. I have worked 38 years at these mines, and have never been short of wood. We have always been allowed whatever was wanted. I have never known any complaint about using too much timber. There is never any fault found. We have to use whatever is necessary. Those are the Captain's orders. As a miner I am quite satisfied that nothing more could be done.

James Henry Towers, Hodbarrow House, Captain at the Hodbarrow Mines, stated that he was down the mines on Thursday afternoon, and was in this working between 4.30 and 4.45 p.m. He found the place working all right, timbered quite satisfactorily. Witness was satisfied that nothing more could be done so far as he could judge. In his opinion what took place was a fall of rock. Above, there was an old roof of timber and rock, where the ore was extracted before. There was always a risk of the old roof coming in, and so far as he could judge nothing could prevent it. Witness saw Osborne taken out, but he did not see Coward at all.

Captain Towers examined by Mr. Leck.

Mr. Leck: How long have you been Captain here? — 16 years.

Prior to that what was your mining experience? — I have been in the mines altogether 34 years.

Where was your previous experience? — In Park mines.

You are 16 years here and were 18 years at Park? — That is so.

16 years of good experience, Captain Towers. It would give you a chance of knowing the circumstances of working the Hodbarrow Mines. Mr. Leck then produced the plan of the workings where the accident happened, which was fully explained to the jury.

Continuing, Captain Towers explained that there was one stoup left behind. There was just one height taken out above the place, and it was timbered close to the roof. There had not been previously any fatal accidents similar to the last one in their system of working the mine. Had they any doubt they would have taken extra precautions by lining the drift with wood. He had seen the place just before the accident happened, and it seemed perfectly satisfactory. All the wood was properly set one against the other, as the plan shows. When the accident happened the wood was torn down bodily. The timber after the accident had to be cut out. It seemed that the weight had crushed the wood to the open side. He had no suspicion of any collapse on the other side. He had known the deceased for 30 years at least. He had worked for his father at Park Mines prior to coming to Hodbarrow. He was a very reliable workman, a man in whose judgement he had every confidence. He had never known a fall of roof taking place under similar circumstances.

Mr. Leck: Do you think that the working of the second drift had anything to do with the cause of the fall? — I could not say that exactly.

It would have a tendency to weaken it? — Yes, on one side.

So far as your judgement went you were satisfied at your visit that the place was in satisfactory order? — Yes.

Thomas Mitchell, 11, Crown Street, timberman engaged at the Hodbarrow Mines, said he was working on Thursday afternoon. About five o'clock he was going his ordinary round, and would be about 400 or 500 yards from the accident. A young man came to him and said some men were buried, and he went as quickly as possible, and sent to Captain Towers. Just then, Osborne said, "Tom, come in, and get me out." He went in and found Osborne pinned in under some of the roof. He was fast by one arm and his leg. Voisey was got out before that. Witness remained for over three hours until Osborne got out, and he then came up the shaft with him, and then returned until Coward was got out. After witness got back, Captain Towers left witness in charge, and they worked away under the rock, and ultimately found him beneath it, and they had to work away at the rock and wood to get him out. It would be an hour, or an hour and a half before they found him. The accident happened about five o'clock, and they did not get Coward out until five past twelve. He was quite dead, and looked as though he had been killed at once. He was awfully mashed up, almost every bone in his body being broken.

Mr. Mitchell, examined by Mr. Leck, said he was a timber man, but it was not his duty to put timber in, only to give orders. He had a regular course of workings to go through in each shift, and he had to give orders to have timber put in wherever he thought it was needed. He saw all the workings of his section on every shift. His instructions would be in addition to those of the mine captain.

Mr. Leck: So there would be at least two inspections on each shift, one by the mine captain and one by the timberman? — Yes, sir. Continuing, he said the place where the accident happened was not in his section.

The Coroner, in summing up, said he did not think that there would be any difficulty in coming to a decision. They had the evidence of Osborne, who so far as he knew the place was quite safe. In fact, he was unable to suggest, with his 38 years experience that anything more could be done than what they did. Captain Towers said so far as he could judge the place was safe, and they had the evidence that so far as could be seen nothing more could be done. Mr. Leck raised the question about the method of working, but Captain Towers said that in his judgement it was quite safe, and that a great deal depended on the roof. Mr. Leck, he understood, agreed that everything was done that could be done. It was a sad accident. It was a terrible thing for a man to be so suddenly cut off, for he was apparently killed without ever being aware of what happened. The rock fell on him and he was crushed to death. He thought they would have no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that death was the result of an accident.

The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bell, George    Miner  
Breakwell, Henry    Juror  
Burgess, George Henry    Juror  
Chappels, Henry    Juror  
Coward, Henry   57 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Crump, William    Juror  
Dixon, Edward James    Juror  
Dowbiggin, John    Juror  
Edmondson, Henry    Juror  
Hoyle, Alfred    Juror  
Jones, W. B.    Juror  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Mandall, T.    Juror  
Miles, W. B.    Jury Foreman  
Mitchell, Thomas    Timberman  
Osborne, John    Miner  Injured, Individual Page
Robshaw, Joseph    Juror  
Sheldon, Samuel    Juror  
Stoney, —, Dr.    Coroner  
Sykes, Frank    Miner  
Towers, James Henry    Mine Captain  
Voisey, —    Miner  Injured, Individual Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print