|
5th February 1915 Law ReportCourt Of AppealCompensation : Delay In Making A Claim. Coulson v. South Moor Colliery Company. (Before the Master of the Rolls, Lord Justice Swinfen Eady, and Lord Justice Phillimore.) This appeal from an award of the Judge of the Consett County Court, sitting as arbitrator under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, raised a new and interesting point under the Act. The applicant was a coal hewer in the employment of the respondents, and on November 21, 1911, he slipped while at work and strained himself. He had to stop work and a swelling appeared on his groin. He rested for an hour and then the overman came along, and the applicant told him of the accident and showed him the swelling. The overman said that he had better go home, but the applicant said that he could finish the shift and he did so. By the next time he was due to come to work the swelling had gone down, and he continued working as usual. Four months later, and again nine months after that, the swelling returned while he was at work, but passed off without his having to absent himself from work. Finally, on February 27, 1914, the swelling came on again but remained, and he had for the first time to see a doctor and was incapacitated by hernia from February 27, 1914, to May 30, 1914. No claim for compensation was made until March 13, 1914, and the question therefore arose whether the failure to make a claim within six months was a bar to the proceedings under section 2, subsection 1, of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, or whether the failure to make a claim was caused by mistake or was due to other reasonable causes within proviso (b) of section 3, subsection 1. The County Court Judge held that the failure to make a claim within six months was not shown to have been occasioned by mistake or other reasonable cause. He therefore dismissed the application. The workman appealed. Mr. Lowenthal appeared for the appellant ; and Mr. Schwabe, K.C., and Mr. Meynell for the respondents. At the conclusion of the arguments their Lordships took time to consider their decision. The judgement of the Court was delivered to-day by Lord Swinfen Eady allowing the appeal. Judgement. Lord Justice Swinfen Eady said :— The County Court Judge held upon the facts that the applicant's failure to make a claim within six months from the occurrence of the accident causing the injury was not shown to have been occasioned by any reasonable cause, within the meaning of section 2, subsection 1 (b) of the Act. It was urged that he could not have made a claim for compensation before he did, as, although the accident happened in 1911, it was not until 1914 that he suffered any loss ; until then he was not disabled for a period of one week or any period from earning full wages at his work. However this may be, we are satisfied that upon the facts of the present case the applicant has shown reasonable cause for his failure to make a claim within the period specified by the statute. He treated the accident from the first as a very slight one, and the doctor says that it was a small hernia ; he thought he had completely recovered, and for six months and more after the accident he never lost a single day's work, and only experienced slight discomfort on one occasion and then only for a very brief period. The circumstances are very special, and not likely to afford a precedent for any other case, as the employers not only waive the question of notice, but do not in any way dispute the genuineness of the claim, or call any evidence. Ordinarily a claim in respect of a hernia caused by an accident which occurred more than two years previously, and of which accident no proper notice had been given to the employer, would probably be viewed with grave suspicion ; but all the circumstances point to the bona fides of this claim, and in this connexion we have not failed to notice that the workman concedes that the results of the injury are now entirely at an end, and he does not ask for a suspensory award. In our judgement the appeal should be allowed, with costs. Solicitors. — Messrs. Hyman Isaacs, Lewis, and Mills, agents for Messrs. Isaacs and Heath, Sunderland ; Messrs. Rawle, Johnstone, and Co., agents for Messrs. Cooper and Goodger, Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||