Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th May 1914

A Collier's Death Follows An Accident

Last Monday evening Mr. E. Atter and a jury, of which Councillor R. Wilson was the chosen foreman, held an inquiry in the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary into the death of William James Young, collier, aged 29 years, of 2, Torrentine's Place, Tangier Street, Whitehaven, which, preceded by a fit, occurred at his residence on Saturday, 2nd May, as the result of a blow in the right eye with a piece of coal, whilst following his employment in the Main Band at Wellington Pit, on the 25th April.

Messrs George Cook (H.M. Inspector of Mines), R. R. Blair (for the Colliery Company), J. Hanlon, miner's agent (for the relatives of the deceased, and Steele (manager at Wellington Pit), were also present at the inquest.

Mary Ann Young, widow of the deceased, said he was 29 years of age at his death. He had worked at Wellington Pit since they returned from Liverpool (he having worked there), which was about two years ago. They had been married eight years in June, and he had never ailed anything in that time until he had this accident neither had he been previously medically attended. He was always very constant in his work, and she had never known him to have a fit until a day or two before he died. In his family he was the youngest of thirteen, and his parents and all his brothers and sisters were dead.

The Coroner: Did you ever hear of any of his brothers and sisters having had fits? — Never, sir, they were a strong family.

The Coroner: That's the way you put it — all are dead out of a family of thirteen.

Continuing her evidence, Mrs. Young said that deceased left home about 4.30 a.m., when on the first shift, and returned about a quarter to two. When he left home on the 24th April he was all right, but when he returned on the 25th, he said "I have got a bat in the eye, and I doubt it's going to be a bad job." It was the right eye, and it was quite bloodshot; he could not open it, and it was black and blue. He bathed it with tea leaves, and then went to bed. He never went out that day, and at night he could not sleep. "I doubt I am going to have a bad eye" he said, he could not eat his meals as he should have done, and had not done since the accident. He was a temperate man — (with emphasis) — and a good man. "I have never seen him drunk since we were married. He was down on it, gentlemen." He went to his work on the Saturday, but said to her "I'm going, Mary Ann, and I am not fit. What are we going to do?" He returned about one o'clock on the Saturday afternoon with his week's wages. His eyes were bad, and he never went out of the house all day. She had never known him to stay in on a Saturday before. He bathed his eye, and said he would try and work it off, but it got worse. He kept it shut for fear he would get more dirt into it. He could not look at the gas, and he did not wear a shade over his eye.

The Coroner: Why? (a pause) Don't you think it would have been better?

After pausing for some time, witness said deceased did not bother with a shade, and did not have one on.

On the Saturday night she went to the "play," the last house, returning home about eleven o'clock, when she saw her husband laying over the table with his head on his arms. He had been bathing his eye and it was paining him.

The Coroner: You went to the play, eh? If it wanted this care should there not have been someone in the house to look after him?

Witness said he was in by himself. On the Sunday he was in the house all day.

The Coroner: Did you send for a doctor? — No, sir.

The Coroner: Why not? It would have cost him nothing.

Witness did not directly answer this question, but said the doctor was not called in until deceased had the fit. He said he would bathe it to see if it would come right, as he thought it would. She could not say why she did not suggest having a doctor. He was at his work on the Monday and each day until Thursday. He kept his hat over his eye all the time. He had grand eyesight before the accident, and she never knew him previously to say anything about his eye. On Thursday night he had his supper at home, and said he thought he would give in and see the doctor. She left him at his supper at about quarter to twelve, and she went to bed. (She generally went first.) He came upstairs, got undressed, and shut the room door after him. He then said, "Oh, my eyes are going mad. I feel dizzy. Do be sharp and bring some water and a flannel." She went for these, and on her return she found deceased lying on the floor. She called to him and he did not answer so she called in neighbours. There was nothing tight about his back as he took his clothing off downstairs, and he was a lad that always had his shirt loose." He just had a tea cake and a mug of tea for his supper, and had an egg and bacon when he came from work. When she called in the neighbours he was lying helpless, and was struggling, and was crying with his hand on his head, "Oh, my head." He could not have been conscious the way he was going on. She got an awful fright, and (here, witness broke down) — "I thought I was going to die myself, gentlemen." Someone went for the doctor, who came in about a quarter of an hour. Previous to his accident her husband had had no worry; he was a strong able-bodied man, and did not know his own strength. He never told her of any trouble that he might have.

The Coroner: Might he have had any mental trouble?

Witness: He never had anything, sir.

The Foreman: Did no one ever look into your husband's eye to see if there was anything in it?

Witness: No, sir, nothing was done.

The Foreman expressed his disapproval that this had not been done, as the eye might have been very badly cut, and there might have been something wrong with the pupil of the eye.

Witness: The doctor said it was very bad.

By the Coroner: There was no cut about the eye.

Mr. Brownrigg (a juror): Did he tell you what caused this bat in the eye?

Witness: He got a bat with a lump of coal.

Samuel Ball, collier, 15, Back Ginns, Whitehaven, said he worked at Wellington Pit, and had known deceased about two years. During that time he had been all right in health as far as witness knew. He did not work with deceased as a rule and only worked with him on the date of the accident, because his own place had got gassed. He was all right when he commenced work, but whilst working a piece of coal from the face hit him on the right eye. He put his head down, and wiping his eye, told witness that he had got a "smack in the eye." He stopped working about five or ten minutes, and then started again. It happened just about bait time — around nine o'clock in the morning. Deceased did not eat his bait that morning, as he said he had his teeth out, and his gums were sore. Witness thought he had them taken out the day before, but did not know why.

The Coroner: Was it by illness or by accident?

Witness: No, I think it was by him in Tangier Street.

Witness, continuing, said deceased's eye seemed to pain him throughout the shift, and on and off he stopped work, but never said anything. Witness could see the eye was troubling him, as he kept rubbing it. He did not work with witness after that day. He did not hear deceased report the accident to anyone. As a rule they reported accidents, but when the deputy joiner was in their working about eleven o'clock, witness did not hear deceased report his accident. Witness did not mention it to anyone; it was not his place.

The Coroner: But without it being your place, did you not mention it to anyone that Young had got a piece of coal in his eye? — No, sir.

Mr. Blair: Why did he not report the accident? — I don't know, sir.

Mr. Blair: Don't you generally report any accident you have? — Yes, sir. — You know that if you don't report it you get no compensation? — Yes, sir.

By Mr. Hanlon: It was true that deceased had the opportunity of reporting the accident to the deputy joiner when he came in, but he did not. A good many men go home without reporting what they think is a slight accident, and if they think it is going to keep them off work they go sick and report.

By Mr. Hogg (a juror): Witness and deceased were in the working the whole time the deputy was in, and witness did not hear deceased report to the deputy.

Mrs. Young was recalled, and asked as to the reason of her husband having his teeth out, and she said he got four teeth taken out before the accident, and intended to get four out at a time until the whole lot were out, so that he could get new ones. They were both going to have the set together, and he should have had another four out this week. He was not gassed, but "went in quietly and sat and got then pulled out." She had hers out the same. His gums blew awfully, and he could not take his food because it was choking him. Asked why the deceased had his teeth taken out, she said, "So that he could get new ones." There was nothing the matter with them.

The Coroner: People don't have their teeth taken out if they don't ail anything, do they?

Witness: Plenty does.

The Coroner: What?

Witness: There's a few does.

Richard Denwood, collier, Rudd's Court, Roper Street, said that deceased, a man named Singleton and himself, had worked together about four months at Wellington Pit. During the time witness had known deceased he was always a strong healthy man, and he had never known him to ail anything. On the 24th April witness saw him coming outbye, and he told witness that he had got a bat in the eye with a piece of coal whilst working that day with Ball. He had to keep his cap over his eye on account of the lights. On the following day he was working with witness, and his eye was bloodshot. He was able to do his work, but he complained terribly about his eye. Witness heard him tell William Graham, a deputy, he had a bat in the eye on the day before. He complained the witness, all the week after, and witness had never heard him complain before, neither of his eyes nor anything about his health.

By Mr. Blair: Witness did not know deceased had had his teeth out, but one day while getting his bait he told witness he could not eat as his teeth were aching.

By Mr. Hanlon: He was there when deceased told Graham about the accident. He knew deceased when he lived at Parton and when he worked at William Pit, and he was always a constant worker that never ailed anything.

John Henry Singleton, collier, 92, Queen Street, Whitehaven, who had worked with deceased, and Denwood also testified as to deceased always being in good health and a constant worker up to the time of the accident. Witness did not hear him report to the deputy, as witness was on the roads, but he heard deceased complain throughout the week about having pains in his head caused by the injury to the eye.

William Graham, deputy joiner at Wellington Pit, said he had known deceased about two years. (missing line in original) ... joiner, on the Saturday that he had got a nasty (missing line in original) and he seemed to be a strong healthy man, and was a constant worker. No complaint was made by deceased to witness the day after the accident.

The Coroner: Denwood has told us that he heard deceased on the Saturday say to you that he had got a nasty bat in the eye the day before.

Witness: No, sir. It was not that day; it was on the Thursday morning, the 23rd, the day before the accident. That was just in the ordinary way of speaking, and he did not say he got a bat in the eye; he just said his eye was painful. He did not say which eye, and I did not ask him. It was about eight o'clock when he told me that, and it was in his own working. Denwood and Singleton were present, but they were not getting their bait. Witness did not think anything about the complaint, as it was just in the ordinary way of talking. Witness was in their working doing a particular job, and deceased just said his eye was painful. It was quite an ordinary thing for a man to have a bad eye.

The Coroner: Yes, but here's a man that you have known for a long time, a constant worker, and a man that never ailed anything; that man complains to you that he had a painful eye, and you took not notice of it?

Witness answered that deceased did not say what caused it.

The Coroner then reminded him that they had Denwood's evidence, which stated that he heard deceased report to witness on the Saturday, the day following the accident, that he had got a nasty bat in the eye. Witness denied this, and said that he was working in deceased's working about eleven o'clock or half-past on the Saturday — (The Coroner: Yes, that's the time Denwood gives us) — but deceased did not report his accident to him. It was not that day he complained to witness, it was the day before the accident.

The Coroner: How is it that you are so certain it was not that day, and that it was on the Thursday when he told you?

Witness: Well, it was on the Thursday morning that I was in the working doing a particular job, and he just said he had a painful eye, and I took no notice of it.

The Coroner: You say you took no notice of it, and thought nothing about it. How is it you come now and say you took no notice, yet you are certain of the day?

Witness: Because I took particular notice.

The Coroner: How did you, when you say you took no notice?

Witness: Because I was doing a particular job that day.

He further said it was a common occurrence for fellows in the pit to complain of painful eyes.

The Coroner: If it is, the less reason for you to remember it. What makes you put it on your oath to the jury that this was before the accident happened that he made the statement to you?

Witness: I knew by the day I was in the working doing a particular job.

The Coroner: Just think now. First when you gave your evidence you were going to say that he made the complaint on Wednesday.

Witness: Oh, yes; but I made a mistake, sir. I'll own up to that.

The Coroner: Have you any note of it?

Witness: No, sir; but I could prove it.

The Coroner: How?

Witness: That very day his working was stopped on account of gas.

The Coroner: Yes, and how can you prove that he told you about his eye on the Thursday?

Witness: Because I was doing this job in his working that day, and that is how I can think on.

The Coroner: You can think on about stopping the working, but how can you prove that he made the statement to you on the Thursday?

Witness: I was doing this job, and he happened to say "My eye's been painful." That's the very words he used. I never asked him what caused it.

The Coroner: Will you swear that he did not tell you on the Saturday, about eleven o'clock, that he got a nasty bat in the eye the day before?

Witness: Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Do you swear it?

Witness: Yes, sir. Not to my knowledge.

The Coroner: Do you swear it?

Witness: I will swear it.

The Coroner: Do you swear that it was on the Thursday, the 23rd April, that he made the complaint?

Witness: I swear it was.

Mr. Hanlon: You didn't think you got mixed between the 23rd and the 30th?

Witness: Not whatever. He did not report it, but just said his eye was painful. They were just having a conversation, and thought no more about it until Denwood reminded him of it. He never remembered deceased saying anything on the Saturday morning. He generally took reports down when they were given.

The Foreman: If he had spoken to you about his eye, would you not have made a written statement?

Witness: Yes, sir. I would have reported it to the overman and he would have taken it down. I never reported anything.

Mr. Hogg (a juror): On the Saturday morning did you go in the deceased's place as a workman or as an official?

Witness: As a workman.

Mr. Hogg: Did you notice that deceased was working under some difficulty?

Witness: No, sir.

Mr. Hogg: The evidence we have is that he was working under some difficulty, and if he was it might have brought it to mind?

Witness: Yes, sir; it might.

Mr. Hogg: And did you not notice it?

Witness: No, sir.

Mr. Hogg: How long were you in the working?

Witness: About five minutes.

Mr. Hogg: You would not have much chance of noticing deceased?

Witness: No, sir.

The Coroner: You said to Mr. Hanlon that Denwood reminded you of what deceased had said to you about his eye.

Witness: That was on Friday, 1st May.

The Coroner: Did Denwood and you have some talk?

Witness: No, sir; only I asked him why his mate was not at work, and he said it was through a bat he had on his eye, and Denwood asked me if I could not mind deceased telling me that he got the bat on the eye, and I said "No."

The Coroner: Did you tell Denwood that he had not told you? What did you say to him?

Witness: I said I never heard him say anything about it to me, and Denwood said deceased might have said something and I had not heard it with them talking.

The Coroner: He never said he heard deceased tell you that he had got a bat in the eye?

Witness: No, sir.

The Coroner: Denwood, come in, please.

Denwood was re-called, and the Coroner asked him: Is this the William Graham that you spoke of who came to your working when the deceased was there on the Saturday? Is he the person you heard deceased speak to that he had got a bat in the eye?

To these questions Denwood answered "Yes, sir."

The Coroner: Have you spoken to Graham about it since?

Witness: Yes, sir; on Friday.

The Coroner: What took place between you?

Witness: I told him Young was knocked off with his eye.

The Coroner: Yes. What else? Graham says he was only told on the Saturday of Young, that he had met with this injury. What do you say?

Witness: When he (Denwood) came in Young was joking with him, and told him he got a bat in the eye. He told him on the Saturday.

The Coroner: Are you certain?

Witness: Yes, sir.

Dr. Bevis, assistant to Dr. Harris, said that he was called to the deceased's house on Friday morning last about three o'clock in the morning. He found the deceased lying on the floor, unconscious, and suffering from symptoms of compression of the brain. He had never attended him before. Deceased died on the Saturday about 3.45am, he never having recovered consciousness. On Monday witness and Dr. Harper, of Workington (for the Colliery Company) performed a post-mortem on the deceased, and they found an extensive haemorrhage on the brain and more on the right side. The haemorrhage had been there a day or two, and was sufficient to cause death.

The Coroner: Would the injury to the eye on the 24th April be sufficient to account for what you saw?

Witness: It may do.

He further stated that the heart was healthy, and the kidneys were apparently healthy, but they were having the kidneys sent away to be microscopically examined.

The Coroner: Must there have been some act of violence to have caused the haemorrhage?

Witness: It could have been caused without violence.

The Coroner: On a healthy man?

Witness: Yes.

In replying further he said teeth extraction could not have produced it, although pretty severe violence might have caused it.

The Coroner: Presuming a strong healthy man, who never misses any work, and never had any signs of fits, and is healthy except having teeth out, receives an injury to his eye, goes home and complains constantly about it during the week after. That is quite consistent to set up what you found?

Witness: Oh, yes, It could have been caused otherwise, but is very rare in such a young man. They generally find it in healthy people. It is apoplexy you know. The fit would be caused by the haemorrhage.

The Coroner: How long would you expect for it to come on?

Witness: It may come on almost immediately, and it may take days.

The Coroner: Can you say Dr. Harper endorses your views?

Witness: Yes, he does. It is possible that the haemorrhage might have been caused by the injuries to the eye.

Mr. Blair: Would not injury that caused haemorrhage have shown some outward and visible sign on the eye?

Witness: It was a week before, and it may possibly have passed off. There was no sign of injury to the eye when he took the post-mortem.

Mr. Blair: Would a fall of coal that had caused this not have made a mark that would have lasted longer than a week?

Witness: I would have thought so, but there was no mark.

Mr. Hanlon: You were told that he had had a bat in the eye. Suppose it was what you call a strong blind bat, and he had bathed it for a week, would it be possible for that to take the discolouring away?

Witness: That is possible.

By the Coroner: They went behind the eye and found no discolouration there at all.

The Foreman: We hear that his eye was very much bloodshot. That is evident that he must have got a good bat in the eye?

Witness: In these sort of people you get bloodshot eyes from anything in their work.

The Foreman asked would it not have more effect on the pupil of the eye, but the doctor answered that it would not.

The Coroner: That would not be the more painful part of the eye?

Witness: Oh, no sir.

The Coroner, summing up the evidence, said he did not think there was any question that death was not caused by cerebral haemorrhage, and he asked the jury could they come to any other conclusion, but say that what happened on the Thursday night was the result of this accident. He did think that Graham was mistaken as to the day he received the complaint. He had nothing to fix it in his memory, and the Coroner thought their opinion must be the same as his when he said there was no complaint made to Graham on Thursday, and that, having heard the evidence of Denwood, they would think it was an honest mistake made by Graham, and be of the opinion that the statement was made to him on the Saturday.

The jury retired, and found a verdict that deceased died from cerebral haemorrhage from a blow in the eye sustained whilst following his employment.

The Coroner: If you allow me to say so, I thoroughly agree with you. The evidence is quite conclusive upon that.

Mr. Blair: I would like to say we are very sorry indeed that a man like this should die, because he was an excellent worker, and one that will be very difficult to replace.

The Coroner: (to Mrs. Young): You have heard the remarks Mr. Blair has expressed on the part of the Company of the appreciation of the work he did for them, and also their sorrow and regret at his death.

Mrs. Young: Thank you, sir.

The Foreman also voiced the sentiments of the jury.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Ball, Samuel    Miner  
Bevis, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Blair, R. R.      
Brownrigg, —    Juror  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Denwood, Richard    Miner  
Graham, William    Deputy  
Hanlon, J.    Miners' Agent  
Harper, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Harris, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Hogg, —    Juror  
Singleton, John Henry    Miner  
Steel, Robert    Manager  Whos Who Page
Wilson, R., Councillor    Jury Foreman  
Young, Mary Ann      Widow
Young, William James   29 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Wellington Colliery  Wellington Colliery
Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print