|
16th April 1914 Inquiry Into The Ladysmith FatalityOn Thursday afternoon Mr. Atter held the inquiry into the death of Jas. Rook, 16 years of age, of 53, Mount Pleasant, Whitehaven, who died at the Whitehaven Infirmary at three a.m. on the 5th inst., as the result of injuries received whilst following his employment at Ladysmith Pit, on the 30th March. At the opening of the inquest on Monday last, Councillor R. Wilson was chosen foreman, and Mrs. Violet Rook, widow, gave evidence stating that deceased was born on the 27th April, 1897, so that he was 17 years of age this month. Mr. Geo. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Collieries. Mr. R. R. Blair, general manager of the Whitehaven Collieries; Mr. Fryer, manager at Ladysmith Pit; and Mr. St. George Curwen, Workington (representing the deceased's relatives) were present at the inquest on Thursday. Mr. Frank Gibson, mining engineer, submitted and explained plan showing the scene of the accident. William McMean, labourer, Hutbank, said that on the 30th March he, with deceased, Jas. Kerr, and Hy. Hirst, were working in the pit yard, and at about 11-30 a.m. an engine was shoving some empty trucks and three wagons of metal up the line when one of the wagons caught some empty tubs that witness and the others were engaged in filling, and the tubs jammed Kerr and deceased against the wall. The Coroner: Where were you? Did you get caught? Witness: No, sir, or I would not have been here. The Coroner: Oh, yes. They were not both killed. By Mr. Crerar: He heard Hy. Hirst shout "Hauld," as there were two men fast. He did not hear anything before that. By Mr. Curwen: The engineman had heard from his man that all was clear, and he was moving on. The engine whistle blew before the engine moved. By the Foreman: Wm. Pickering was in charge of the men in the yard, and they knew well enough that the wagons were coming. Henry Hirst, Chapel-street, Whitehaven, said he was a boiler fireman. On the 30th March he was working along with Kerr, deceased, and McMean, loading some tubs with cement. At about twenty minutes to twelve the locomotive engineman was shunting two trucks of gravel, two empty wagons, and three wagons of metal up the line. The latter wagons were next to the engine, and the two trucks and two empty wagons were coming first. The engineman blew the whistle before he got to the points, and they all heard the whistle. Witness and the rest of the men sided off to let the wagons past. The wagons were just travelling at a walking pace, and the trucks had passed many times when witness and the others were working there. Deceased had worked at the place about twelve months. Witness was nearer the engine than deceased. The fore end of the first truck passed them, but the brake guard at the back end must have caught the tubs and shoved them over. Witness was about two yards from Rook, and Kerr was between them. Both Rook and Kerr shouted, and witness ran round and told the engineman to stop. There was some blood about the place, and deceased's right leg and left leg were bleeding. By the Inspector: The three wagons of metal had previously passed the tubs all right. He was sure it was the first truck that caught the tubs. By Mr. Blair: The deceased and Kerr shouted when the tubs went against them, and witness ran and told engineman to stop the engine. Wm. Pickering told them that the trucks were coming. Mr. Curwen asked if these tubs had lines of their own to run on, and Mr. Gibson explained it to him by the plan. Mr. Curwen: Were these wagons that caught the tubs coupled or were they loose? Witness: I could not see. The engine was pushing them. The Foreman: I suppose if the young men had been standing where you were standing they would have been out of danger? Witness: If they had they would have been out of danger altogether. The Chairman: Have you been told how to escape the danger? — Have you any directions? Witness: No, sir. Walker Dockeray, 17, South Row, Kells, said he had been an engine-driver for the Company for about six years, and had worked at Ladysmith Pit top about thirteen years. On the 30th March Isaac Pitblade was his fireman. At about a quarter past eleven in the morning he coupled two Furness Railway trucks of gravel to some other wagons to take them up to the Ladysmith pit-top. At about half-past eleven Pitblade was off the engine and was keeping watch when the wagons were being shunted at the slow pace. He said all was clear, and witness blew the whistle twice. Anyone fifty yards away would be sure to hear it distinctly. He got the signal from Pitblade, and his engine was travelling at not more than four miles an hour. When he got to about the end of the points he felt a bump. He heard no shout, but pulled up at once. He got orders to draw back as there was two men fast, and he drew about six yards back. Rook and Kerr were extricated, and they were both injured on the legs. First aid was rendered, and both young fellows were brought to the infirmary in the ambulance. By the Inspector: Kerr and Rook knew the engine was coming, and had stopped work to get out of the way. By Mr. Curwen: They were quite safe where they were if the wagons had not caught the tubs. Isaac Pitblade, fireman on the last witness's engine, said he gave the last witness the signal to come on, and he heard the engine whistle blow. Everything seemed clear, and when he gave the signal the men were close to him. He gave his account of the accident. By the Inspector: He knew the men were working there. The Inspector: Would it not have been better if you had got them on the other side of the railway where they would have been clear, and where there are no walls at all? Witness's reply was not audible to the press, but was to the effect that the men had often worked there when the wagons were passing. Mr. Curwen: Did you notice the tubs before you signalled the driver to start the train? — Yes sir. Mr. Curwen: You thought there was room to get clear? —Yes, sir. The Foreman: How far would you be from the young fellows when the accident occurred? — About four yards, sir. Dr. Morrison, house surgeon at the Infirmary, said the deceased was brought in on Monday, the 30th March, about twelve o'clock when he was suffering from injuries to his right leg. He was conscious, but his injuries were serious and he suffered from shock. About seven o'clock that night Dr. Muriel stitched the wound and operated on the fracture. Deceased got over that all right, and two days later the limb was amputated. He recovered from this operation. He lost a fair amount of blood, and was bleeding when admitted to the infirmary. He died on the 5th April. The primary cause of death was due to toxaemia and secondary to acute traumatic gangrene-septic absorptions. Kerr was improving. Mr. Atter said he did not think they need trouble to take the evidence of Kerr, as he did not think the doctor thought he was well enough. The jury agreed that the evidence already given was quite sufficient. Mr. Atter suggested to the jury that the evidence had been given very satisfactorily and to enable them to understand how the accident happened. There seemed to be no neglect on the part of anyone. The jury found a verdict that deceased died from the effects of having been accidentally crushed by a tub whilst following his employment at Ladysmith Pit-top, and at the same time they suggested that more room be made so that the men could keep clear of the wagons. Mr. Blair said there was any amount of room on the right hand side of the rails, but they could not shift the wall on the side where the accident happened. They would be glad to do anything that would stop an accident like this.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||