11th March 1914
Colliery Engineering and Hygiene
Dilemmas Of The Pit
The five Milroy lectures which Dr. F. Shufflebotham has just delivered before the Royal College of Physicians were avowedly devoted to the hygienic aspects of the coalmining industry, but incidentally they illustrate the responsibilities that
devolve upon the colliery engineer in regard to safeguarding the welfare and safety of those engaged in the mines. It must be remembered that the records of British coalmining go back to the 13th century, and the conditions now existing may be regarded
as representing an accumulation of the unsolved or partially solved problems left by previous developments. The history of the industry is one of continually increasing complication, each change in method and each advance in technique bringing in its
train new dangers to life and limb and new difficulties for the attention of the mining engineer.
So long as the progress of coal-getting consisted of digging or quarrying out the mineral at the outcrop the operations were of a very simple nature, but whenever it becomes necessary to drive tunnels and sink shafts the circumstances were completely
altered, and sources of danger were introduced from which the miner had to be safeguarded. As soon as he leaves the surface the coal-getter has to reckon with falls of roof and side, the influx of water, want of the air required for respiration, absence
of light, underground fires, poisonous gases, and the various risks arising from failure of the mechanical appliances necessarily employed in working the mine. Explosions due to inflammable gas were the consequence of the introduction of artificial light
into collieries, and the safety lamp introduced by the genius of Davy and Stephenson soon had to be modified in order to meet the more exacting conditions caused by the employment of more rapid ventilating currents which, as the workings became more
extensive, were needed to supply air for respiration and for scouring out the noxious gases. With the increase in the ventilating current came the evil of coal-dust, the explosive character of which when mixed with air has only recently been fully
realized. Again, the substitution of the safety lamp for the naked light meant a serious diminution in the amount of illumination available, and this diminution in its turn is generally admitted to be the principal cause of miners' nystagmus, the
commonest of all occupational diseases, which it has been calculated causes an annual loss to the community of about £100,000.
Temperature And Humidity.
The increased depth at which coalmines are being worked has affected the atmospheric conditions under which the miners are employed, and the effect upon the health and working capacity of the men of the high temperatures reached in deep mines has
demanded serious consideration. Dry bulb temperatures ranging up to 97.8deg. have been recorded, and at Pendleton in Lancashire, where the workings have reached a depth of about 3,700ft., the air-current attains a maximum temperature of 94.3deg. at the
working face. Yet though the pits naturally are hot this temperature, owing to the extreme dryness of the air, is said not to interfere with the work, the output being equal to that of shallower mines in the neighbourhood.
The influence of humidity, in relation to the temperature of the atmosphere, upon labour capacity and health has long been appreciated, especially in tunnel construction and deep metalliferous mining, but its recognition in legislation is of recent date.
The Coal Mines Act 1911, and the general regulations there-under require that a hygrometer shall be placed below ground in a conspicuous position near a shaft or outlet in both the main intake airway and the main return airway, and prescribe that these
instruments shall be read by a responsible official at stated intervals ; but no indication is given of any action that should be taken in consequence of such reading. On the Continent, however, definite rules are in force. In France, for instance, work
is forbidden, except in cases of absolute necessity, in any working place where the temperature exceeds 95deg. F. on the dry bulb thermometer or 86deg. F. on the wet bulb thermometer. Further, according to the French mining laws, any temperature
exceeding 77deg. F. on the wet bulb thermometer must be considered high. Another reason in favour of keeping down the degree of humidity in the atmosphere of a mine having a relatively high temperature is that the combination of moisture, warmth, and
darkness favours the development of a disease, ankylostomiasis, which has caused considerable trouble in German coalmines, though British coalmines have so far escaped from it. In order to keep down the temperature and humidity of the underground
atmosphere the colliery engineer may increase the volume and speed of the ventilating current, but the irony of the situation is that the adoption of such a course tends to produce conditions especially favourable to the production and dissemination of
coal-dust.
Use Of Electricity.
The relation between the poor illumination in coalmines — especially at the working face — and the prevalence of miners' nystagmus has already been mentioned. Dr. Shufflebotham in the course of his lectures alluded to the
practicability of getting a better light by replacing the ordinary flame lamp by electric lamps, were it not for the fact that the flame lamp fulfils two separate functions, not only providing light but also affording a means for detecting the presence
of small quantities of inflammable gas. It is true that so far the great drawback to the electric lamp has been that it serves for illumination only, and that therefore it could not be used universally without the concurrent use of the ordinary flame
lamp for examining the condition of the mine atmosphere as regards gas ; but efforts are being made to overcome this difficulty, and there is reason for thinking that electric safety lamps capable of performing both these essential functions will shortly
be available.
Apart from its use for illumination in portable safety lamps which can be made absolutely safe, electricity is employed underground for a large variety of purposes in which its safety at all times is not entirely beyond suspicion. The circumstances
attending the disaster which happened at Senghenydd last year have drawn attention to the danger of explosions and fires which may arise from the sparking of low potential circuits in connexion with underground signalling. No doubt this, and similar
dangers, can be overcome without taking the strenuous course of excluding altogether the use of electricity underground — a course which has recently been under consideration by the coalminers of South Wales. But in order that this result may be
obtained the dangers must first be recognized, and unfortunately experience sometimes demands a heavy toll.
Coal-dust And Stone-dust.
The close relation that exists between engineering and hygienic questions in coal-mining is clearly brought out by the attempts which are being made to solve the problem of coal-dust. Illustrations of this relationship have already been mentioned in
connexion with safety in illumination and miners' nystagmus and with ankylostomiasis and coal-dust. The method of combating the danger arising from the explosive character of coal-dust, which is at present receiving favourable consideration, is by the
dissemination of finely-divided stone-dust or other incombustible dust throughout the workings of the mine. The continued inhalation of coal-dust does not appear to cause any ill-effects, though the lungs become loaded with it and deeply pigmented.
Dr. Shufflebotham states that he has been present at many autopsies on miners where such conditions have been exhibited, and the history of the cases had shown that the lungs throughout life had fulfilled their functions most satisfactorily, and
there was no record of any lung trouble. Pulmonary tuberculosis is not so commonly found among coalminers as among those engaged in many other occupations. It would appear that this relative immunity is not due to any germicidal property of the coaldust,
although it probably exerts a protective influence against the tubercle bacillus, but is rather to be attributed to the stimulating effect of the coal-dust on the lung tissue, with an increased growth of connective tissue. The effect upon the lungs of
the continual inhalation of stone-dust not containing free silica or any hard material is not yet thoroughly understood, and time alone can show whether such dusts may be inhaled regularly and continuously with impunity. Experiments have been carried out
by Dr. Beattie for the Home Office with the object of discovering if fibrosis of the lung is produced in guinea-pigs by inhalation of stone-dust, but these experiments cannot be taken as conclusive because they were not of sufficient duration to
make the conditions of the guinea-pig and the miner comparable.
Poisonous Gases.
It is now universally admitted that coal-dust plays a principal part in all large colliery explosions, and that the death-roll is due less to the violence of the concussion or to the direct effects of flame than to poisoning by carbon monoxide gas, or
after-damp, resulting from the incomplete combustion of the coal-dust. This knowledge has led to a more thorough medical examination, when possible, of those who have been rescued as well as of the bodies of those who have been killed. With that object
in view Dr. Shufflebotham visited Senghenydd and examined many men who were rescued on the day following the explosion. A large proportion of the cases which had been badly "gassed" showed large, well-defined patches of an erythematous
rash, which may be described as a superficial blush or redness of the skin. The rash was of a bright cherry-coloured hue, the characteristic colour of carbon-monoxide poisoning. The patches varied in size from 6in. by 4in. to 5in., to 1½in. by
½in., and were principally located upon the buttocks, and occasionally upon the legs and the upper portion of the body. The peculiar interest of these cases lies in the fact that they were reported to Dr. Shufflebotham as "superficial
burns." He was sure, however, that they were not burns, one reason being that some patches developed for days after the explosion, and there had been no superficial marks on the areas of skin which were so affected. Dr. Shufflebotham says
that he is not aware of any previous description of this condition, and this fact suggests the possibility that erroneous conclusions may have been drawn regarding the circumstances of previous disasters through mistaking the evidences of carbon monoxide
poisoning for those of fire or the blast of the explosion. The effects of carbon monoxide poisoning appear to be multifarious, and in their study modern coalmining has provided science with a prolific source of new problems.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Beattie, —, Dr. | | | |
| Shufflebotham, F., Dr. | | | |