|
8th January 1914 Mining Fatality At WoodendOn Tuesday morning a fatal accident occurred at the Moss Bay Mine, Woodend, when a young man named James Murnien lost his life by a fall of roof. Deceased was single man, 24 years of age, and resided with his parents at 26, Prospect Row, Cleator. On the morning of the accident he commenced work at No. 11 pit, Moss Bay Mine (the proprietors of which are the Workington Iron and Steel Co., Ltd), and at 9.45 while drilling a hole a large piece of stone fell from the roof, and caught deceased on the back. His comrades Robert Mulholland and John Howard, attended to him and had him removed to the surface. Medical assistance was speedily requisitioned, and afterwards he was taken home in the ambulance van, but life was extinct when they arrived at the residence of deceased. The Inquest. Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, held an inquiry respecting the death of James Murnien, in the Jubilee Room, Cleator, on Wednesday evening. Mr. J. Hope Brown (of Messrs. Brown, Auld, and Brown, Whitehaven, solicitors for the Workington Iron and Steel Co) was present, also Mr. W. Leck, H. M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, miners agent (on behalf of the relatives); Mr. D. Gill, of Messrs. Dixon and Gill, mining engineers to the Workington Iron and Steel Co., and Inspector Sheffield. Mr. W. Gaythwaite was chosen foreman. Michael Murnien, father of deceased, 26, Prospect Row, Cleator, identified the body. Deceased was 24 years of age and lived with him. He had been an iron ore miner for six years. By the Inspector: Had your son done anything else than work in the mines? Witness: When he was younger he was engaged by Mr. Shanks. Mr. Wm. Sherwen, 36, Lowther-street, Whitehaven, mining engineer for Messrs. Dixon and Gill, produced a plan of the working where the accident occurred, also sectional plan showing the position of the roof, staging, &c. The different sections were thoroughly explained. Mr. Sherwen estimated that the stone would fall about 13 feet from the roof. He had never seen any likelihood of the roof falling. The width of the working where the stone fell would be 21½ feet. It was 18 feet from the roof to the ledge, and 5 feet more to the bottom. Robert Mulholland, 28, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, miner, said he was working on the first shift from six o'clock until two o'clock. He was in company with James Murnien and a labourer named Jno. Howard. He started work at 6.30. He examined the place yesterday morning with Murnien. They used a bar for testing the roof, with the result that they found it all right and safe to work. After sounding they commenced work. Witness started to bore, and Murnien did as well in separate holes. They were boring with the object of firing a shot to loosen the ore. He got his hole done about 9.20 and fired it, and it came off all right. In his opinion his hole was not near enough to shake the roof where Murnien was. He waited until the smoke cleared away, and witness started to dress his hole out. Witness heard a fall of stone while Murnien was boring about eight or nine yards away. Witness called out "Jimmy" and he answered back for him to come and lift him up. Witness went, and found him lying down among two or three small pieces of stone. There was nothing on him. They took him to a "bait" seat to set him down. The labourer Howard assisted him. Witness asked if he could do with a drink, so he gave Murnien a drink of tea out of his bottle. He thought he was hurt round about his body. Witness could tell he was hurt in the back, because he shouted when witness got hold of him. He could see some stone had fallen. The stone seemed to have broken up when it fell. Witness would think there would be two or three cwts. of stone had fallen. They wrapped Murnien up. Deceased loosed his own belt, and complained about his back. Witness sent for Mr. Hillon, the manager. A man named John Calvert also gave assistance. They sent for a stretcher, and got him up the pit. He was alive and did not seem to be seriously injured. He talked to them, but said nothing about how it had happened. Deceased was attended at the pit head by Dr. Jackson, of Egremont, shortly after eleven o'clock. He was alive when he left the pit, but died before he reached home. The ambulance van took him home. The doctor did not think he was seriously injured. Witness said he did not know of anything that might have been done to prevent the accident. Mr. Leck: Had any official been in the working that morning before the accident occurred? Witness: Yes, the overman, Mr. Robinson. He would be in shortly before seven o'clock. Mr. Leck: Do you remember if he said anything to you or not? Witness: He inquired if the top was right, and Jimmy said yes. By Mr. Leck: Murnien was a careful workman. They had no suspicion of the roof; if they had they could have left the stages in. The fall gave no warning in the least. They just heard the crash. Mr. Leck: Is it not usual to have a slate at the mine on which the deputy records that he has been in t he working? Witness: Yes, but there was no slate at our place. I acted on the principle that there being no word, everything was all right. If there was anything wrong the deputy would come up the pit in the morning and report it to Mr. Robinson. He would also mark the place with chalk or stick a bar in the ground. Mr. Gavan Duffy: Are you quite sure the deputy inspected the working that morning before you went in? Witness: I am not in a position to say the place was examined that morning. Mr. Duffy: Do you consider it your duty to examine your own spot before commencing work? Witness: Yes. Mr. Duffy: I am going to suggest to you that you could not reach that part of the working from the staging. Witness: Yes we could with a spiked bar. By Mr. Brown: We have four ladders in our working. We are able to clamp two together and reach the roof. This we did on Monday. I made a thorough examination and found it quite safe. As a miner I always examine the roof before I go in. We are provided with implements to examine the roof. The Coroner: Is it possible that the shot you fired could affect the roof which fell? — Yes. Mr. Sherwen, 22, Trumpet Terrace, Cleator, deputy at the pit, said he was on duty on Tuesday morning on the first shift. He went into the place which was being worked by Murnien and Mulholland and, about 5.30, and examined the place with a long stick with a steel end on it. In witness's opinion it was all right otherwise he would have reported it. The roof did not give any indication of it being unsound. At this stage the deputy's recording book was produced for inspection. Witness added that he had been watching the roof for a long time, and it seemed a good solid stone roof. Witness did not deem it necessary to timber the roof. By Mr. Leck: I have had 32 years' experience in the mine, and been in the Woodend Mines about 26 or 27 years. He was able to reach the roof by getting on a slope about seven or eight feet from the bottom, and using a pole with a spiked end. It was not a roof that needed special care, as there was no indication of this slip or parting. By Mr. Duffy: There are 12 workings in the No.2 section. By standing on the slope I could touch the main roof. The slope runs all round the working. He did not think there was any need for the roof to be examined every hour. By the Coroner: The men generally examine the working themselves. Mr. Thomas Robinson, 9, Trumpet Terrace, overman at the pit, stated in reply to Mr. Leck that he went to any place reported. He was in the working on Monday. The man asked him if they could rake the metal down. On Tuesday morning he went in and said to Murnien "Are you confident it is all right?" He said "Yes," I am." Mulholland also returned the same answer. The Coroner, in summing up, said all the witnesses had given their evidence very well, and there was no trouble in ascertaining the cause of death. The jury found a verdict of "Accidental death." The Foreman, in giving the verdict of the jury, thought it would be an advantage if the slate could be used systematically in the workings so that the men could tell that the workings had been examined, and found in order, or if dangerous to be thus recorded. The jury desired to express their deep sympathy with the relatives of the young man, who had met his death in such a sad way. He was a young man much respected by everyone in the village. Mr. J. H. Brown, on behalf of the employers said they associated themselves with the expression of sympathy which had fallen from the Foreman of the jury. He was sure it must be some consolation to the relatives to find such an expression of sympathy. Large Funeral. The remains of deceased was laid to rest on New Year's Day at St. Mary's R.C. Church, Cleator, amid great manifestations of public grief and respect. Deceased was a young man of great promise and held in the highest esteem, by everyone with whom he came in contact. He had been elected by his fellow workmen as secretary of the Holiday Club, which had recently been formed. He also held the position of secretary to the Cleator Reading Room. He was a member of the C.Y.M.S., attached to the Catholic Church, and at the recent bazaar he was an active worker and held a position in the Christy Minstrel troupe, which had been specially organised for the bazaar. His funeral was one of the largest that has taken place in the village. Messrs. Martindale and Son supplied the coffin, which was borne from the home in Prospect Row to the church, by members of the C.Y.M.S., many of whom walked in procession. The impressive funeral service was conducted by the Rev. F. Clayton, who addressed a few words to the large congregation, nearly every seat was occupied. Mr. J. B. Senior played the Dead March in Saul as the cortege was leaving the church. The coffin was covered with beautiful wreaths sent by friends and relations, and also from the various societies to which deceased belonged.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 25 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||