|
16th October 1913 Miners Wages In The Egremont District[To The Editor Of The Whitehaven News] Sir, I do not a bit mind your correspondent "Interested's" meandering through a quarter of a column of obtuse verbosity in order to prove that his first letter was exactly what I described it "undiluted nonsense." With obvious contempt for the intelligence of your readers he now denies having said that the miners had a "minimum of 6s 8d" at the time of the recent inquiry, and he now tries to rewrite his first letter and stick it in to the sentence: "The average wage of all men in the Egremont district, miner, labourers (above and below ground) should have been given instead of miners only when the average would have been more like 5s 3d or 5s 6d per day." I don't know if your correspondent is aware of the fact that inverted commas are used to denote a literal quotation, and he may not even know that no such statement as the quotes was contained in his first letter. To deliberately invent a statement, put it in between inverted commas, and attempt to foist it upon your readers as a quotation is surely a insult to their intelligence, because it would seem that in the stilted mind of "Interested" they did not know the difference between a pot egg and a hen egg. Here is the opening sentence of his first letter: "Permit me to correct a mistake made by a local gentleman at the recent Housing Inquiry in the Town Hall, Egremont, some weeks ago respecting the average wages of the miners of the district." The italics are mine. There is no question here as to what "Interested" thought or did not think "The local gentleman" should have said or done. "The local gentleman" had made a mistake. Interested," in the fullness of his completed ignorance rushed into print to "correct" the "mistake" and the said mistake was made "respecting the average wages of the miners of the district." These words are not very difficult to understand, and even "Interested" may understand the meaning of his own words. My point was and is that Mr. Nelson's only mistake was in quoting 6s 3d as the miners minimum instead of 6s 6d as it then was. My second point is that if any mistake was made "Interested" should have corrected it, or have made a attempt to do so at the inquiry where his statement could have been met by those with first hand knowledge of the facts; and my third point is that "Interested's" letter was no bona-fide correction of Mr. Nelson's figures which were allowed to stand for "some few weeks" until we were organising the Millom iron ore workers and issued official figures to them to show that their wages were less than those paid to the Egremont miners, and it is under a guise of a correction of Mr. Nelson's figures made "some few weeks ago" that "Interested's" attempt to discredit our statements and undermine our movement in the Millom district. In this, however, he has ignominiously failed. Every figure I gave stands absolutely unchallenged and unchallengeable, and that being so I need waste no more time or attention upon your anonymous will o' t' wisp. — Yours, &c., T. Gavan-Duffy Alva House, Moor Row, October 13th, 1913
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||