11th September 1913
£20,000 Housing Scheme For Egremont
Local Government Board Inquiry
On Tuesday evening last a public inquiry was held in the Market Hall, Egremont, by Mr. W. H. Collin, an Inspector of the Local Government Board, into the application of the Egremont Urban District Council to the Local Government Board "for sanction
to borrow the sum of £20,000 for the purpose of a scheme under part 3 of the Housing of the Working Classes Act, 1890, for the purchase of land and the erection of working class dwellings." Amongst those present were :— Messrs. J. J.
Wilson, W. Garnett, P. Kelly, C. Thompson, S. James, T. Bewlay, and M. Daniels, members of the Urban District Council; Mr. John Nelson, Clerk to the Council; Dr. E. A. Braithwaite, medical officer of health; Dr. George Calderwood, late medical officer of
health; Mr. James Cowan, the surveyor to the Council; Mr. J. Stout, architect, Whitehaven; Mr. Harold Adair, J.P., C.C., Mr. L. Cook, Mr. J. Henderson, Mr. T. Quayle, Mr. E. Bromley, Mr. G. Bainbridge, Mr. J. Hannah, Mr. W. Cook, Mr. J. Newby, Mr. J. A.
Thompson, Mr. J. Nelson, Mr. R. Dalton, Mr. J. Kenney, & c.
Mr. Nelson, Clerk to the Urban District Council, in presenting the case for the application, said, he had in the first place to apologise on behalf of the Chairman of the Council who was unable to be present with them that evening. Proceeding, he
pointed out that at a meeting of the Egremont Urban District Council, on the 8th July last, a formal resolution, of which due notice was given, was passed authorising the application, and on the 14th of the same month a formal application was made to the
Local Government Board for their sanction to the scheme and the borrowing of the necessary money to carry out the same. In accordance with the instructions of the Local Government Board, the printed notice of the Inquiry had been exhibited at all the
churches and chapels in the parish, and also at the usual places where parish notices where exhibited, and it had, in addition, been advertised in the local papers. The Council had entered into a provisional agreement for the purchase of two closes of
land, containing 7.367 acres, situated at Brisco Road, Egremont, and they proposed to erect thereon 76 houses suitable to the requirements of the working class population of that district. The land would, of course, accommodate a greater number of
houses, but, for the present, the Council proposed to build the number he had specified. The site selected was one admirably suited for building purposes, standing some 215 feet above sea level, with a dry gravely sub-soil, and it was practically
situated in the centre of the principal industry of that neighbourhood, namely, the iron ore mines. The whole of the mines in the Urban District, and those in the adjoining parishes of St. John's, Beckermet, were situated within a radius of two miles of
the site. The number of workmen who were employed at the mines in the Urban District of Egremont alone was 1,447, and of these men no fewer than 817 resided outside of the district and many of them at considerable distances from the mine at which they
were employed. In the adjoining parish of St. John's, Beckermet, they had three large mining companies, employing some 624 men, 379 of whom resided in Egremont and 245 out of the district. He might say all these mines were in very close proximity to
Egremont. In fact, two of them are within half a mile of Egremont. The Winscales Mine was rather farther away — probably a mile and three — quarters or two miles. The housing accommodation in the parish of St. John was of very limited
description. In fact, it might reasonably be held and argued that the major part of houses in St. John's parish were in reality part and parcel of the town of Egremont, because they were just over the borders and really got all the benefit of the
Egremont parish in respect of lighting, schooling, and so on. The question of housing the working classes was not only acute in the Egremont Council's area, but in the adjoining parish of Cleator the Urban District Council were confronted with a similar
situation and at the present time were, he believed, formulating a scheme for building the necessary houses to accommodate the working class residents in their district. The Whitehaven Corporation, which was not very far away — about five miles
— were, he was informed, also considering a similar scheme. The large influx of working men into that district, and the lack of housing accommodation and consequent overcrowding in the town, had for some years been a very serious problem. Dr.
Calderwood, the late Medical Officer of Health to the Council, a gentleman with an experience of some forty years as a medical practitioner in the town, and of thirty years, or almost thirty years, as Medical Officer of Health to the Council, had
continuously referred to recent years to overcrowding in the town. In his report of 1910 he found that Dr. Calderwood drew special attention to the shortage of housing accommodation and reporting on the Housing of the Working Classes Act he said
:— "In regard to this Act I have to point out, as I have previously done in my monthly reports, that we are short of a number of houses required to accommodate people properly. In consequence there is a degree of overcrowding not conductive
to the general health of the district. It has also led to the smaller and poorer houses being occupied with working men with families although they are not in any way suitable for such occupation. There are also a considerable number of men working in
the district who are compelled to live out of it because of their inability to procure house accommodation. The only remedy for such a state of things is to build a number of new houses sufficient to meet the needs of the working classes. If this were
done workmen with families would have a chance at proper accommodation and the smaller and poorer houses left for those for whom they were suitable." The present Medical Officer of Health to the Council (Dr. E. A. Braithwaite), who had an
experience of something like ten years in the town as a medical practitioner, confirmed Dr. Calderwood's report as to the overcrowding and the necessity for housing accommodation. The estimated number of inhabitants in the town of Egremont alone was
4,000 and the number of houses 774, or an average of 5.35 persons to each house. In many cases two, and sometimes three, separate families were living in one house. Many of the houses in the lanes and courts were very small and certainly not suited to
the accommodation of a family. Some, indeed, had been found consisting one room downstairs and one bedroom, in which the whole members of the family, male and female, slept. In order to meet to some extent the pressing demand for houses, the Council
prepared the proposed scheme of 76 houses. Fifty-two of these would contain sitting room, kitchen, scullery (with bath), coalhouse, pantry, and w.c. on the ground floor, and on the first floor three bedrooms and a linen closet. These houses were
estimated to cost £230 each to build. The remaining 24 houses were slightly smaller. They would contain a living room, scullery (with bath), pantry, coalhouse, and w.c. on the ground floor, and three bedrooms with linen closet, on the first
floor. The estimated cost of these was £160 each. The total cost of building was £16,768 8s: land, £1,535: streets, £1,030: sewers, £235 18s: fences, &c., £51 10s: making a total of £19,621 16s, or,
allowing £378 4s for contingencies, a total of £20,000. In order to meet the necessary repayments and other outgoings the rent of the 52 larger houses must be at the rate of 7s per week, and that of the smaller houses 5s 9d per week. At the
rents the annual income from the houses, after allowing the usual percentage for empties, would be, — from houses, £1,239 19s: from allotments, &c, £36 4s 3d: making total estimated receipts, £1,276 3s 3d. The estimated
expenditure was: Repayments of loans, £819 8s 6d; rates, taxes, insurance, repairs, maintenance, &c., £443 3s 6d, or a total of £1,262 12s 2d; leaving a credit balance of £13 11s 1d. The rent at which it was estimated the
council would be able to let the houses would seem to be probably rather more than the average working man would be able to afford, but it was undoubtedly a fact well known in the district, at any rate, that the rents for houses in the town, of similar
constriction to those proposed to be built, but without any bath or any other conveniences provided in the proposed scheme, were 6s to 7s a week. The wages in the district were high, so that although the rents might appear somewhat excessive, in reality
this was not so when all the circumstances were considered. There could be no two opinions that there was a very serious lack of houses not only in that town, but also in other parts of the urban district; nor could it be denied that building by private
persons had been at a standstill for many years. The reason for this lack of enterprise on the part of the private builder he was in no position to state, but there could be no doubt it could not be attributed to the difficulty obtaining suitable land
for building purposes. The Council had had no difficulty in obtaining offers of several large areas of excellent building sites, which had been open to purchasers for several years, and might be obtained at very reasonable prices. He was not aware of
any process by which private owners could be compelled to erect dwellings to accommodate the surplus population of the district in which they worked, but undoubtedly there was an obligation on the part of local authorities to see overcrowding did not
occur in the area over which they had jurisdiction, so as to be a menace to the health of the inhabitants who might reside there. That was the position of his council. They were convinced from the reports of their officers that overcrowding did exist
in the town and was detrimental to health. The were further convinced that there was no immediate prospect of the private builder coming forward to supply the necessary accommodation. They recognised that the duty of providing healthy and sanitary
dwelling for the present surplus population was theirs and they put forward the present scheme as calculated to in some measure relieve the present situation. The population of Egremont was something like 4,000 — 3,929 to be correct, and that at
Bigrigg, Moor Row and Scalegill 2,323 or a total population of 6,305. That was the last census return. He dared say the present population was considerably more, but they could now get at the exact figures. The rates amounted to 4s. 4d in the £.
the Poor Rates being 2s. 6d and the District Rates 1s. 10d. This was for the last twelve months. The rateable value was £72, 712 10s and the assessable value £66, 323 17s 6d. He would ask Mr. Stout to produce the plans of the scheme and to
offer any explanation needed.
Mr. Jacob Stout, architect, explained the plan of the district and of the proposed housed to the Inspector, and in reply to him said that the price of the land was reasonable. He could get on the site besides the 76 houses now proposed, 28 larger size
and 36 of the smaller. He placed before the Inspector a statement showing how and what material it was proposed to build the houses — rough bricks. He thought they could get tenders for the work at the figures estimated. He thought — he
had made sufficient allowance. The streets and footpaths proposed were in accordance with the bye-laws. He had not consulted the Surveyor as to the prices for the drainage and sewerage works, nor did he think the Surveyor had seen them. The garden
allotments would be let off to the occupiers of the houses: otherwise the houses had not gardens. These plans and estimates had not been seen by the general public.
The Inspector: So that they don't know what you are letting them in for, do they? — No.
Mr. W. Garnett, a member of the Council, said he was satisfied that there was a demand for houses and he was convinced that there had been a certain degree of overcrowding and that these houses were necessary.
The Inspector: Do you think you will get people to take housed at 7s a week? Yes.
The Inspector asked what wages were earned by the miners.
The Clerk said 6s 3d and 6s 6d were the minimum and the average actually earned was 7s 3d.
The Inspector (to witness): You don't think 76 houses is too many? — I don't think so.
You have seen the plans before? — Yes.
And you think this is the sort of house they want? — Yes.
You have seen the site? — Yes.
Is it a good one? Yes, very.
Dr. Calderwood, formerly medical officer for the District Council, said that during the course of his experience he had found a considerable amount of overcrowding and regularly reported it to the Council year after year, even prior to 1910. It was his
opinion that at the present time there was a great deal of overcrowding.
The Inspector: What is the remedy for overcrowding? — Well, if there was any overcrowding, we could remove those that were causing the overcrowding; but we found the greatest difficulty in doing so, because the people have no place else to go. And
what I have been urging to overcome the overcrowding was to build new houses to accommodate the people. Not only was there overcrowding, but the people working in the place could not live in it; they had two or three miles to go to get accommodation.
The Inspector: How ling has this been going on, then? — It had been going of for four or five years.
And for four or five years you have been urging the Council to build houses? — I am not the medical officer now, but while I was I was urging the Council to build houses.
Do you think you can do with 76? — Oh yes, twice that. There is an average of 5.4 to the house. That is quite sufficient. We want to accommodate a thousand people in order to relieve the pressure: 76 will remove it considerably, but we could do
with more than that.
Mr. J. J. Wilson asked if they would be able to sell these houses after they had built them?
The Inspector shook his head.
The Clerk mentioned the Small Dwellings Act.
The Inspector: You can buy houses under the Small Dwellings Act, but you cannot build them. Any other questions?
Mr. H. Adair: After a while will the rent of these houses be reduced, or will they always have to be at the present figure?
The Inspector: When the debt had been repaid. Do you mean after 60 years?
Mr. Adair: I see, there will be no reduction until after 60 years?
The Inspector: Well, in this estimate there is a fairly good estimate for empties. If you don't get any empties you will have a fairly substantial balance. If they are very careful with the houses also, that will add to the balance and might effect a
reduction in the rent. At the present time there is £65 a year allowed for empties. Well, there very probably won't be any empties for years: there ought not to be. Otherwise I don't see how the rents can be reduced. Because probably the rates
will go up: they won't go down, will they?
The Clerk: I don't think so, except by the falling in of loans.
The Inspector (looking at the list of loans): There are some repayments in 20 years and some in 30 years.
Dr. E. A. Braithwaite, medical officer, said he had made a systematic inspection of the town and found considerable overcrowding.
The Clerk: Is it your opinion that that overcrowding must be injurious to health? — Certainly: Yes.
And is it also your opinion that it is absolutely necessary that houses should be built or provided in some way? — Yes.
The Inspector: How many cases of overcrowding are there?
Witness: Well, I have about 20 down here, sir, specific cases I have taken note of: but I have now doubt there are considerable more than that.
The Inspector: I suppose a large number of the houses have only two bedrooms? — Yes.
It is probable that a larger number of houses are overcrowded? — Yes.
You have no doubt, personally, as to the need for the houses? — Not any doubt at all.
Have you seen the scheme prepared by the Council? — No.
So you can't say whether it is a good one or not? — I have not seen it: I cannot say.
Will you take it from me that it is a good one? — Yes, if you provide houses at all.
The Inspector: Is there any opposition?
Mr. J. J. Wilson: I would just like to ask is it the duty of the Urban Council to provide houses for people working in another area, where the authority in the other area does not make any attempt to provide houses for itself? Are we called upon to
build houses for them?
The Inspector: I should say that all local authorities ought to take their share.
Mr. Wilson: That is my meaning, sir — that the Rural Council should take their share.
The Inspector: Do you think the Urban Council is doing more than their share?
Mr. Wilson: Yes.
The Clerk: I gave the figures of the number of workmen working in the district who are living out of the district. I suppose Mr. Wilson would admit that it is the duty of the Urban Council to supply them with housing accommodation in the district?
There are 817 working in district that are living out of the district.
Mr. Wilson: At this end of the parish?
The Clerk: Yes, in the parish.
Mr. Wilson: Yes, but this end, where the houses are being built.
The Clerk: Well of course I can give you figures for every mine if you care to have them.
The Inspector: It is all one parish — all under one authority?
The Clerk: Yes.
The Inspector: Anybody else? I am going to close the inquiry if there is nobody else.
That closes the inquiry.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Adair, Harold | | | |
| Bainbridge, G. | | | |
| Bewlay, T. | | Councillor | |
| Braithwaite, E. A., Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Bromley, E. | | | |
| Calderwood, George, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Collin, W. H. | | Inspector | |
| Cook, L. | | | |
| Cook, W. | | | |
| Cowan, James | | Surveyor | |
| Dalton, R. | | | |
| Daniels, M. | | Councillor | |
| Garnett, W. | | Councillor | |
| Hannah, J. | | | |
| Henderson, J. | | | |
| James, S. | | Councillor | |
| Kelly, P. | | Councillor | |
| Kenney, J. | | | |
| Nelson, J. | | | |
| Nelson, John | | Clerk | |
| Newby, J. | | | |
| Quayle, T. | | | |
| Stout, Jacob | | Architect | |
| Thompson, C. | | Councillor | |
| Thompson, J. A. | | | |
| Wilson, J. J. | | Councillor | |