Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

7th August 1913

Fatal Accident At Hodbarrow Mines

On Tuesday, an inquest was held before Mr. W. T. Lawrence, deputy coroner, at the Hodbarrow Hospital, touching the death of William Robinson, a labourer, engaged at the Hodbarrow Mines, who met with a serious accident, in consequence of which he expired on Sunday last.

Mr. W. Leck, Inspector of Mines, was present.

The following jury was empanelled :— Messrs Edward Lamb (foreman), Stephen Murphy, Christopher Retallick, William Crank, Henry Breakwell, Joseph Olds, Thomas H. Richards, Alfred Barson, Joseph Hicks, Edmund Crayston, William J. Rodgers, and the Rev. W. R. A. Budd.

John Gibson, labourer, working at Hodbarrow Pier, residing at 1, Victoria Street, stated that the deceased, William Robinson, was his father-in-law, and lived next door. He was a labourer at Hodbarrow Mines, and was 63 years of age. A week ago he met with an accident at Hodbarrow Mines, from which he died on Sunday morning between four and five o'clock.

William Morris, labourer at Hodbarrow Mines, stated that he was working with the deceased on Tuesday, 29th July. They were taking down some timber, along with John Hughes and Sam Knowles, at No. 6 bank, at the mines. They were taking down two big uprights which the Norway goes across. Whilst engaged with their work the three upright timbers had two guide lines on the middle to steady it. The deceased got up the ladder and sawed the stay across which was steadying the timber. That was the way he was doing his work all the morning. It was the first day witness worked with deceased. The two outside timbers were sawn across at the bottom, and Steele, the foreman, shouted, "Look out, boys, it's coming down." They all then ran out of the road, but Robinson got caught. They did not see the accident, as they had their back to deceased. Witness ran back and picked the timber off him. Steele called out, "Robinson has been caught," and witness went back and picked the timber off deceased's head. Deceased was lying flat with the fallen timbers at the back of his head. It was heavy timber, and was 26 or 28ft long and 10 inches across. Witness and others loosed the deceased's shirt, and the policeman ran to the stores for a stretcher. The deceased was not unconscious, and when they got him up the road to the hospital he commenced to talk and wanted to be laid down.

In reply to Mr. Leck, witness said he had not been doing this kind of work before. He was supposed to be under Robinson. Robinson had a good deal of experience and witness had worked with him before, but not in taking timber down. It was Robinson that selected where the guide ropes should be. There was no conversation respecting how many should be used. Witness was merely sent as a casual labourer to help take the timber down.

In reply to Mr. Budd, witness stated that only Hughes was accustomed to work with the deceased. He had the same chance of running away as witness had. He ran five or six yards.

In reply to Mr. Rodgers, witness stated that it was the heavier timber at the top that brought down the props.

Dr. Stoney stated that on Tuesday morning, 29th July, he was called to the Hodbarrow Hospital about four o'clock to attend deceased, who was very severely injured.

He evidently had been struck on the head, both collar bones were broken in more than one place, showing that he had had a very severe blow. It is very unusual to see two collar bones broken at the same time. The injuries were caused by a severe blow, such as timber would cause. He was black and blue from head to foot, and his lungs were injured. He was delirious. Witness had no hope of his recovery till Friday morning, when he seemed a trifle better, but in the afternoon he was much worse, and showed signs of lung trouble, bringing up blood. He brought very large quantities of blood until he died on Sunday morning. Everything possible was done for him, two trained nurses being in attendance on him.

In reply to Mr. Leck witness said he was not surprised when he heard of his death.

In reply to the foreman, witness stated that deceased was struck between the shoulders and on the back of the head with the wood, and was knocked down.

John Steele, foreman of the Hodbarrow labourers employed by the Hodbarrow Mining Company, said the deceased was one of the labourers and had been working for the Company 34 years. He was an experienced man, and witness placed a good deal of trust in him. For above 20 years he was trustworthy man at the job he was engaged on. On the 29th July he saw him while he was at work. He was taking down the gantries from the metal roads. He was doing this kind of work between 20 and 30 years. Three other men were working with him on the job. Knowles and Morris were labourers sent to assist Robinson and Hughes, who had worked together for the last 20 years. The two former only helped when more strength was required, but the deceased and Hughes were experienced men, this being the particular work they had to do. Witness happened to go up on the floor where the men were working, and saw the standing post, which the men were cutting, moving, and he shouted, "Look out." He saw all the four men run. Witness did not see the timber fall on deceased, as they all ran to get out of danger. The next thing he saw was deceased lying on the ground where the timber had knocked him over. He never spoke, and he got him sent to the hospital right away.

In reply to Mr. Leck, witness stated that he was foreman at the mines for 30 years. Taking down gantries was not unusual at the Hodbarrow Mines. The work, however, was done at considerable intervals. Mr. Barrett had ordered the work to be done, and John Hughes and deceased on account of their experience were directed to do the work. He did not give the men any particular instruction as to how they had to do their work, beyond advising them to take care of themselves. He did not explain how the work had to be done, as the men were accustomed to do it, and he considered that it was quite sufficient to tell them to take the gantry down. He did not give any instructions as to how the guide ropes had to be placed. He left the work entirely in deceased's and Hughes's hands, as they knew quite well what they had to do. They could have all the rope that they wanted. They had nothing to do but go to the shed for them. He did not know that deceased had cut through the stays until it came down. He had only just gone up to them. He trusted the two men entirely to carry out the work in their own way. Since the accident the woodwork was cut down in the same way as previously, only they used more ropes. He considered that the accident would not have happened if a guide rope had been fastened to the stay.

In reply to Mr. Budd, witness said he considered that the two men he sent to assist were quite enough.

John Hughes, labourer in the employ of the Hodbarrow Company, said he had worked at the mines between 20 and thirty years. The deceased worked with witness over 20 years. On the 29th July he was working with the deceased sawing down posts belonging to the gantries, in order to take them down. The poles were 7 to 8 inches thick, and were about 20 feet high, with 7-inch caps about 20ft long. Witness was used to this work for over 20 years, — all the time he was at Hodbarrow. The deceased was also used to it, having worked with witness on the same job. John Steele was foreman of the job. They commenced taking down the gantries some days before the accident, instructions being given by John Steele. Witness did not consider the work particularly dangerous. Steele told witness to be careful when they were taking down the wood, but did not give any instruction beyond telling them to use guide ropes. When the posts were cut the woodwork swerved round in the wrong way, and came down. He did not see the accident as he was running away in front. He heard John Steele call out, "Look out, it's coming down," and he then ran away. Witness turned round to look for Robinson, but he could not see him, but John Steele said he was knocked down, and they went to lift him up. Witness did not think that he was conscious at the time.

In reply to Mr. Leck, witness said the woodwork in falling went the wrong way. The props did not usually fall until the stay was cut, which should not be done till they were ready to pull them over. He considered the only mistake that was made was the cutting of the stay. He could not tell them the reason for deceased cutting the stay. He did not see him do it. He could not say if there were any ambulance men about. They were so accustomed to putting up and pulling down gantries that they never looked for any instructions as to how the work had to be done.

In reply to the Foreman, witness said there would be no danger of the timber falling, as the stay was held by spikes. It would be held by the stays. Had he known that Robinson had cut the stay, witness would have immediately put a line to the wood. There was no risk in cutting the stays. He, however, did not know the stay was cut.

Mr. Leck: The cutting of the stay is the last operation; as soon as it is cut you draw the wood away.

Witness: Yes, sir.

The Coroner briefly summed up, after which the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death."

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Barrett, —      
Barson, Alfred    Juror  
Breakwell, Henry    Juror  
Budd, W. R. A., Rev.    Juror  
Crank, William    Juror  
Crayston, Edmund    Juror  
Gibson, John    Labourer  
Hicks, Joseph    Juror  
Hughes, John    Labourer  
Knowles, Sam    Miner  
Lamb, Edward    Jury Foreman  
Lawrence, W. T.    Deputy Coroner  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Morris, William    Labourer  
Murphy, Stephen    Juror  
Olds, Joseph    Juror  
Retallick, Christopher    Juror  
Richards, Thomas H.    Juror  
Robinson, William   63 Labourer  Deceased, Individual Page
Rodgers, William J.    Juror  
Steele, John    Foreman  
Stoney, —, Dr.    Doctor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print