Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd July 1913

The Colliery Accident At Walkmill, Moresby

The inquest on the body of John Donnelly, who was killed at Walkmill Pit, Moresby, on Tuesday week, was held in the Court Room, Cleator Moor, on Tuesday afternoon last by the Coroner (Mr. G. A. L. Skerry) and a jury, of which Mr. C. Gowan was chosen Foreman. Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Whitehaven, was present, and Mr. A. Thom, jnr., represented the Company.

Catherine Donnelly, 2, Railway Terrace, Moor Row, identified the body as that of John Donnelly, aged 44 years, and a married man, who lived at 93, Bowthorn Road, Cleator Moor. He had a wife and nine children, and was a coalminer. He was the brother of witness.

William Graham, surveyor at Walkmill Colliery, submitted a plan of the working, showing the scene of the accident.

William Smitham, 51, Moresby Parks, an overman at the Walkmill Colliery, belonging to the Moresby Coal Company, said he was on duty on the first shift that started about 6.30 on Tuesday morning last. Deceased was working on the same shift, and was a repairer. About twelve o'clock witness noticed the engine plane road standing, and on making enquiries he was informed that there had been a breakaway on the brow. On proceeding up the brow he came across eight tubs, all scattered across the road. There was also a lot of timber and a certain quantity of metal on top of them. He immediately made inquiries of a clipper, named Frank Bray, as to what had occurred, and Bray said that there were twelve tubs coming down the brow when eight uncoupled themselves and broke away. The other four tubs were further up the brow and had come to a standstill owing to the first two tubs having left the line. Witness disconnected the wires, so as to work the engine. The first head (or wooden part of the end of the first tub) was not safe, so he got a prop and put it in the centre of the head, and directed Bray to bring Donnelly, Mahone, Reed, and Tremble. They got a prop up, and it wanted the end leg in, so witness told Donnelly and Reed to set it. He then sent Bray to bring the four tubs down. It was customary work for Bray, who had been at the job nearly twelve months, and was 17 years old. They afterwards heard a rumbling noise, and witness knew it was the tubs coming. He gave the warning that the set was amain. The tubs were then about 100 yards away. Tremble shouted, "Get in somewhere," and he and witness jumped in beside the broken tubs, and Reed and Mahone ran up on the full side. They had not got far when they heard a crash. After the crash witness shouted "Is all right, chaps?" One of the men said, "I think we are," but when they came further down they saw Donnelly crushed between two tubs. He was quite dead and practically smashed up. He had been killed instantaneously. Donnelly was not deaf. They had not much time to get away. They had to jump for it. Witness could not say whether Donnelly attempted to get away. They were all standing together, and deceased would hear the shout. He had the same chance to get away, and was the nearest man to the vacant place to get into. There was plenty of light from five good lamps. They were given sufficient warning, and witness could not account for deceased not getting away. He had been attempting to cross the road, as his legs were on the full side, and his head on the empty side. If he had stood still he might have had a better chance of escaping the tubs. He might have been crossing towards a manhole on the opposite side of the rails. If the tubs had just struck him they would have killed him, owing to the speed they were travelling. Witness sent Bray to the tubs, so that they could pick up the debris about the place. The tubs are brought down by a screw clip fixed on to a haulage rope, and the engine pulls them along. When Bray went for the tubs he would have to put scotches in the wheels, put the clip on, and when he gets the clip on tight enough he lets the scotches out. (This was explained with the produced articles.) Bray told witness the clip had not held, as it had slipped. That would be the only way that the accident could have happened. Bray was quite competent and a good lad, in fact one of the best lads that witness had on the road. The clip had not been quite tight enough.

By the foreman: They were empty tubs, weighing about 4½cwt each.

By a juryman: The rope was not greasy. Scutches were found near the place.

By a juryman: If the clip is put on correctly there is no chance of it being knocked off.

By the Inspector: After the warning was given witness and the rest got about twelve yards away and deceased had plenty of time. Deceased might have slipped over the rope on the empty side. His injuries were on the upper part of the body.

Frank Bray, 74, Moresby Parks, a clipper in the Moresby Colliery, said he started work on the six o'clock shift on Tuesday last. It was witness's work to take the tubs from the shaft to the bottom of the dib. Witness was on the way from the shaft with the twelve tubs when one of the lifting rails knocked the first tub of the road. The rope was stopped, and he took the clip off so that he could get the tub lifted on the road easier. He shouted for William Higgins to give him a hand. As soon as they got them on they knocked the rope away. They took the scutches out, and he took his back end clip off. The tubs started to skid on the road, and eight of them loosed off, and left the other four on the brow, with the first of the four on the road. Witness followed the eight and found that they had drew their legs and let the spot in. They had got 100 yards away and were off the rails and smashed. Witness shouted for help, and Mr. Smitham came. Two other clippers were on behind. Mr. Smitham sent witness for four shiftsmen, and deceased was one of them. They began putting a leg in, to hold the head up of the four tubs. Witness was sent for the four tubs. He lifted the first tub on the rails and scotched it up. He stopped the rope and tightened his clip on the rope. He pulled his scotches out and knocked the rope away. When he had got about twelve yards down the brow he found the tubs were going fast and skidding. He tried to tighten his clip, and he could not do it. They were going that fast that he was forced to leave go. Witness followed down after the tubs, and saw Donnelly lying right before the front tub. He had been killed at once. Witness had tightened the clip well on, and when the brow got steeper the clip felt the weight of the tubs. The clip witness used was rather stiff. He did not knock the rope away until he had got the clip tight enough. If he had got the clip sufficiently tight the rope would not have slipped, but he tightened it as much as he could. With the tubs getting amain, and the clip dragging behind the tubs, it might have been knocked about a bit. Witness had never known that to happen before. The rope was not greasy. Witness did not know what made it go wrong this time. Witness could tighten it without help.

A juryman: When the tubs were going a little faster than he expected, could he not have screwed the clip the wrong way?

The Inspector: If it was the same clip as took the twelve down it should have taken the four down. You thought it had been tight, but it must not have been.

Witness: I tightened it.

The Inspector: You thought you had, but you might not have had it tight enough.

The Coroner: I hear that that is the identical clip? — Yes, sir.

Joseph Tremble, 57, Moresby Parks, a shiftsman, said he was on the first shift on Tuesday last. Bray sent word in to another clipper that some tubs had broken away. Witness went to the place, and while he was working there he heard some tubs coming, and heard Smitham shout "Look out." Witness looked for a place of safety, and shouted "get through the hole." Witness got into the open place with Smitham. Reed and Mahone ran up the other way. Donnelly was standing nearest the space that witness and Smitham got into. Witness passed Donnelly. Deceased would realise that the tubs were coming. There was no reason for him crossing the road. Witness would not have done that. Donnelly was on the full road first, and he seemed to have gone in the opposite direction. There was a manhole on the other side that he might have been making for. Witness got into the engine plane. Deceased would not have to get to the manhole. There was not much time to think. When they found the deceased he was lying right across the empty road quite dead. He might have tripped himself over the rope when crossing. Witness did not know much about the clips as he had never worked them himself. Witness knew Bray, who was quite a steady and reliable lad, and one that could be depended upon.

By a Juryman: They could not hear whether the clip gave any warning when it slipped.

By the Inspector: The side that deceased was making to, was quite wide, and if he had not slipped down he might not have reached the place of safety. He might have had time. He was standing at the place when witness passed him, but he might have attempted to get away after that.

Witness did not know that a clipper had gone up for tubs and that was why they did not at first know what was coming. Smitham knew a clipper had gone up.

George Reed said he loosed the clip off the rope. The clip was tight, but the rope was running through it. It might have been possible that some dirt had got in and made the clip stiff, and when the rope started it would move away the dirt, and the rope would slip. The clip itself was in good condition and quite in order. Witness did not find it stiff. Witness had done a good bit with the clips. He used to see if there was any dirt in the clip, but sometimes they might not notice dirt. It was a very uncommon thing for the clip to slip. Donnelly and witness were standing together. Witness ran towards the shaft, but could not say which way deceased ran. He must have tried to get over the empty side, and thought that the tubs were full tubs. He had slipped and fell over the road. Full tubs go up the brow and empties go down.

The Inspector: The tubs would go down the brow whether they were full or not when there was a clip.

In answer to the Foreman, Bray said he had plenty of time to get the rope on, as he was not hurrying to get away. He was not told to hurry up, but was rather excited at the tubs running away.

The Coroner, in summing up the evidence, said they had investigated the accident as well as possible, and, although the witness Bray denied that he had not the clip too slack, the Coroner thought this was the only conclusion they could come to, and the only way in which the accident could have happened. There was no blame attached to anyone, unless it was Bray. The probability was that he thought he had the thing tight and it may just have been a pure accident. Certainly they could not say there was any negligence attributed to him, as he thought he had it quite tight. The Coroner thought it had been a pure accident.

The jury returned a verdict that the deceased was accidentally killed by a set of runaway tubs.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bray, Frank    Clipper  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Donelly, John   44 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Donnelly, Catherine      Sister
Gowan, C.    Jury Foreman  
Graham, William    Surveyor  
Higgins, William    Miner  
Mahone, —      
Reed, George    Miner  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Smitham, William    Overman  
Thom, Archibald, jnr.    Manager  Whos Who Page
Tremble, Joseph    Shiftsman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Walkmill Colliery  Walkmill Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print