Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

19th June 1913

Shocking Fatality at Lowca

Error of Judgement

At the No. 10 Colliery of the Harrington Collieries, at Lowca, a fatal accident occurred on the afternoon shift last Thursday, when William Martin, a married man, of Lowca, was crushed severely through the fall of a huge stone, six feet in length and weighing about a ton and a quarter. When the body was extricated Martin was quite dead.

Inquest

On Saturday afternoon last Mr. G. A. L. Skerry (coroner), and a jury of which Mr. J. Johnstone was chosen foreman, held an inquest in the Reading Room, Lowca.

Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines, was present, Mr. O. F. Ormrod (Brockbank, Helder and Ormrod) represented the Company, and Mr. J. Bird represented the relatives of the deceased.

James Holloway, Eadie's Terrace, Harrington, coalminer, identified the body as that of his brother-in-law, William Martin, who was a coalminer, living at 2, Concrete Cottages, Lowca. He was a married man 38 years of age, and had a wife and three children. He worked at No. 10 Colliery of the Harrington Collieries, and had been a coalminer all his life. He was a healthy man. As far as witness knew, the deceased knew all about mining to the extent of hagging, and propping, and all that sort of thing.

William Henry Johnston, surveyor of the Lowca Collieries, produced a plan that he had prepared, showing the scene of the accident, which he said took place about one mile from the bottom of the shaft.

The Coroner: Was the man working underneath this stone when it fell on him?

The Surveyor: Not immediately underneath.

The Foreman: Have you seen the stone?

The Surveyor: Yes; I saw the stone after the accident occurred.

The Foreman: Did it show any sign of it having been loosened off the brushing?

The Surveyor: It had a slapped side.

A Juryman: Had the place been brushed up? The Surveyor: Yes, the night before.

A Juryman: It could not have been brushed up if you say it was 2 feet 9 inches.

The Surveyor: It was not at that time.

John Hall, coalminer, Lowca, said he worked on the afternoon shift at No. 10 Colliery on Thursday afternoon last, and went down the pit at two o'clock. He and Joseph Ditchburn and the deceased worked in No. 27 district. Deceased was hagging and witness and Ditchburn were trailing and hagging. Deceased commenced work first, witness about ten minutes after him, and Ditchburn about twenty minutes after witness. They sounded their places. Deceased sounded his place with a pick. The roof was about four feet from the ground and could easily be reached. When Ditchburn came in witness had a full tub, and went out with it so that he did not see Ditchburn examine the place. Witness tested the roof before he started to work.

The Coroner: Why did you do that when you saw Martin do it? To make myself safe before I went in. We always examine the place.

Witness, proceeding, said he thought the working was quite safe. He did not examine the part where deceased worked, but the place he worked himself. They did not both examine the same place. Witness examined the brushing all along where he was trailing. He did not see any deputy come to inspect during their shift. The morning shift deputy (Mr. Wilson) examined the working before they went in. They had to ask Wilson at the bottom of the shaft if he had examined the working, and on this occasion Martin asked the deputy and the latter replied that he had. When he has examined the place he leaves a mark, "W. W.," and the date, and on Thursday afternoon the mark and the date were there on the brushing. They had been working about one hour and a half, and witness was out with a tub, leaving Ditchburn and Martin in the working. The latter two were then working about four yards apart. Witness heard Ditchburn call for help, and he ran to the place and found the stone on the top of the deceased. Deceased said, "Oh, Joe, take it off, I'm done." Ditchburn and witness tried to take the stone off, but could not. The stone was about a ton and a quarter in weight, and it was right on top of the deceased. Deceased was in a doubled position, and part of the stone was his back and part on the "pack." Witness ran for help, and brought more men, who all tried to lift the stone but could not. Ditchburn went for a deputy, and witness was sent outbye to tell a lad to report to the shaft. When he came back the deceased was released. Witness did not see the stone fall, but he knew it came from a "slip" in the roof. There was plenty of timber about for timbering and deceased used to do the timbering. Martin put some props up before he started work on the brushing, and he put a prop under the stone, which had been knocked away by the fall of the stone. Witness did not know whether deceased could have prevented the stone falling by putting another prop in, as witness did not know much about timbering. As far as he knew no one was to blame for the accident.

By the Inspector: When you passed the deputy in the pit did he say anything to you? — He said "Get plenty of wood in."

The Inspector: Did he say anything about a slip being in the right-hand side of the working? — Not that I know of.

The Inspector: Did you examine the place where the brushings were right over? — No, sir.

The Inspector: You did not see it? — No, sir.

In further replying to the Inspector, witness said deceased set one prop under the stone that fell, but witness did not see any other that was set.

Mr. Bird: Did you think Martin would have set one himself if he had required it? You consider him quite capable to have charge of the place?

To both questions witness answered yes.

William Wilson, Howgate, Moresby, coalminer, said he was a deputy at the No. 10 Colliery, Lowca, and was on duty on Thursday last on the first shift. In his duty as deputy he had to look into the places to see that everything was right. If he found anything wrong he would fence it, and prevent the men going into the working. He did this examination at the beginning, and the end of their shift. He examined the No. 28 district on Thursday at nine o'clock in the morning, and twelve o'clock noon, and found everything all right. The men working in that district the previous shift to that on which the deceased worked were called Redman and two Wilsons. In addition to inspecting the places witness took a hammer and examined the roofs. He did not see the stone that fell as it was all as one. It was part of the brushing that came down. He considered the working safe at twelve o'clock. He saw Martin, Ditchburn and Hall when they came in on Thursday, and he told Martin to keep plenty of timbering in his place, but there was no special reason for telling Martin this. The timbering was kept pretty near the working — about 100 yards or so. There was no danger in the place, and no warning that witness could give. It was the men's duty to timber the place, and they were the judges as to where the timbering was required. Witness had seen the stone that fell, and it had a slapped side.

The Coroner: Is there no means by which you could have ascertained that this stone had a slape back? Did you expect this stone had a slape beck? — I thought it could have.

The Coroner: If a stone in the place is expected to have a slape back, do you give them any warning? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Why did you tell them to timber it?

In reply to this, witness said he thought the place might become dangerous if it was not timbered. Martin would be quite aware of that, and would know the quality of the brushing. Martin had taken the coal out without timbering the stone, and it had come away. When witness saw the stone at twelve o'clock the coal had not been taken out from underneath it, so that Martin had taken it out.

The Coroner: What ought Martin to have done? Can you suggest anything? — Before he took the coal out he should have timbered.

The Coroner: Do you think he ought to have put in more props? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Was he an experienced miner? — Yes, sir. As far as I know, sir.

The Coroner: Do you think this stone would have come down if he had timbered? — I think it could not, sir.

The Coroner: If you had been in the working would you have worked the coal as far as Martin had without putting in a prop? — No, sir.

The Coroner: How long as he worked at this sort of thing? — Four years to my knowledge.

The Coroner: Do you suggest that he neglected to put in the prop? — From want of thought, I think.

The Coroner: Could you put any blame on anyone but Martin himself? — No, sir.

The Coroner: Is Ditchburn an experienced man? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Would he have been able to see as much of the roof as Martin? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Could Ditchburn have suggested a prop to be put in? — I should think so.

A Juryman: Is it the usual thing for you to tell the men as you go down? — Yes, I make a practice of it.

A Juryman: I understand you told these men in particular? — Yes.

The Inspector: When you examined the place at twelve o'clock did you see the slip in the right hand side? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: Did you tell Martin that the slip was there? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: Did you warn him about the stone? — No, sir, I did not think it was necessary.

The Inspector: Did they say anything about lack of timbering? — No, sir.

The Inspector: There was plenty of timber? — Far too much.

The Inspector: You cannot have too much.

Witness: No; but sometimes you cannot move about for timber.

By Mr. Ormrod: Witness had worked in the mine 19 years, and had been a deputy and shot-firer on and off for three or four years in this colliery.

Mr. Bird: When you saw Martin and told him to put the wood in there was no special reason, but just a general warning? — Yes, I quite expected that Martin would do what was necessary, as he was quite competent to do what, in his judgement, was necessary.

Mr. Bird: If you had thought that he was not a competent man, or that he would not have observed your instructions, what would you have done? — I would have refused to let him go into the place. In my opinion everything would have been all right if the prop had been put in, in time. Martin was competent enough to judge for himself, and probably in Martin's judgement the time had not arrived for the prop to be put in. In witness's judgement it had arrived.

Mr. Bird: And you say he was a competent workman? — Yes, sir.

Joseph Ditchburn, coalminer, Lowca, said he was working on Thursday last, on the afternoon shift, with Hall and the deceased. He should not have been in the same company as Martin, but witness's place was not right, and they were prevented from going into their own working by the deputy. Witness was trailing and hewing with Hall. They were trailing "tub about." Witness was working about five yards from Hall, and he heard the stone fall and heard Martin shout "Oh." The stone gave no warning. His light was knocked out, and he turned round, but could not see anything. There was no explosion. Witness shouted to Martin, and asked him where he was, and Martin just replied "Oh." He afterwards said "Oh, Joe, I'm done." Witness then thought that the stone was on deceased, and he shouted to Hall to come with a light, and they then saw what was wrong. Deceased was in a stooping position, the stone was on his back, and it had doubled him up. Being unable to take the stone off deceased, they called assistance. Witness was not there when deceased was released. When witness went away the deceased was dead. He died before the stone could be got off him — in fact a few minutes after the stone fell on him. Witness himself had worked as a miner about eight years. He examined his own place, and not Martin's. He did not see the stone before it came down, as he was on the other side.

The Coroner: Wilson says that the accident was caused by want of props and from want of thought by Martin, and he suggests that you might have seen that props were wanted, but you were not in? — No, sir. I was not in that part. Witness knew no one who should be blamed. There was no one there but he and deceased, and he was filling a tub at the time of the accident. There had been no shot-firing during that shift, and no deputy had examined the place while witness was in.

A Juryman: If you had worked in the same side as Martin would you have had more timber in? — That just depends. I was not in that side.

The Juryman: Do you think that Martin had enough in then? — I could not say.

The Inspector: Do you know what the timber rule is? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: Do you know the distance? — Three feet, sir.

The Inspector: It is quite evident that you don't know the timber rule. It is not three feet. The distance is four feet. Do you know whether Martin had the timber in four feet from the fall where he was working? — I was not in where Martin was.

The Inspector: Did you see where the timber was and where the coal facing was? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: What distance was there? — About a yard.

The Coroner: Do you mean four feet from the face. There ought to be props in there? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: When I examined the place this morning I found the stone was six feet long, and the prop was right at the end. That exceeds the distance. How long would the deceased work after he put the first prop in? — Maybe half an hour.

A Juryman: Wasn't the place sunk in, and wasn't he siding over? — Yes, the place was sumped up.

The Inspector: The man has exceeded the distance.

Mr. Bird: You don't know the distance the prop was from where deceased was working? — Probably about four feet.

Mr. Bird: Do you think he would have put another prop in if he thought it was necessary? — Yes.

Mr. Bird: He would not want to put one in before it was really necessary for fear it would hamper his work in siding over? — No.

Mr. Bird: You don't think he would have risked the danger of being in there and killed, rather than put a prop in? — No, sir.

By the Coroner: Witness knew nothing about the timbering rule, as he had been trailing.

Hugh Rogers, Copperas Hill, Harrington, said he was a deputy at the No. 10 Colliery. On Thursday last he was on the second shift. He was on his round of examination, and would have been in Martin's working in another ten minutes had not the accident happened. He was called to the accident, and with the men already present tried to lift the stone off Martin. This could not be done, so they tried to lever it up. One end of the stone was jambed in a "canch," so it had to be broken off, and the stone was levered up. Deceased had been in a sitting position, and the stone had pressed his chest on to his knee, doubling him up. One leg was doubled and the other straight out; a very awkward position. Martin was dead when extricated. He never spoke or moaned in witness's presence, and had no sign of life when witness went into the place. Witness said there was a slip running about a yard from the fast side of the place, and by taking coal out of this slip deceased would have released this stone, and therefore caused the accident to happen. That was witness's opinion. If more timbering had been done the stone would not have fallen, but perhaps deceased did not think he was so near the place. There should have been another prop put in further on. If witness had seen the prop in the position that it was, and had seen Martin working where he was, he would have made him put more props in, and would not have allowed him to go on working in the position in which he was.

The Inspector: Martin will be quite a capable man? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: You think in this case he has made an error of judgement. Do you think he has exceeded the distance? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: Just an error of judging the distance? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: Do you think he knew the timbering rule? — Yes, sir.

The Inspector: The last witness did not. He is always trailing. Still the timbering rule is on the pit top.

The Inspector: Well, that is the first thing they ought to know.

By the Coroner: When witness asked the men if they knew the rule they all answered "Yes."

Mr. Bird: Are you satisfied that Martin would have done what you told him? — Yes, sir. He always did.

Mr. Bird: You think it has been an error of judgement? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner, summing up, said the evidence had been given quite satisfactorily and in a way that they would not have any difficulty in coming to a verdict. There was no doubt the man was killed by the fall of stone from the roof of the working, and the last witness seemed to be a very intelligent man, and he thought they would not be far wrong if they accepted his opinion, on the cause of the accident, namely, that the deceased had committed an error of judgement in not timbering far enough up. There was communication, and the man should have been more careful than usual in regard to timbering. There is the old saying "Familiarity breeds contempt," and a man, working in the place every day, it was quite possible for him to make a mistake.

The jury returned a verdict that the deceased met his death accidentally from the fall of this stone from the roof of his working, and they attached no blame to anyone, and had no recommendations to make in this case.

Mr. Ormrod expressed the regret of the Company, and their great sympathy with the relatives of the deceased.

Mr. Johnston asked that the jury be coupled with the remarks.

Mr. Bird replied on behalf of the relatives.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bird, J.      
Brockbank, —    Solicitor  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Ditchburn, Joseph    Miner  
Hall, John    Miner  
Helder, —    Solicitor  
Holloway, James    Miner  
Johnston, William Henry    Surveyor  
Johnstone, J.    Jury Foreman  
Martin, William   38 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ormrod, O. F.    Solicitor  
Rogers, Hugh    Deputy  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Wilson, William    Deputy  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Harrington Colliery  Harrington Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print