|
3rd April 1913 The Townhead Mine DisasterThe InquestCairns' Heroic Conduct PraisedOn Tuesday afternoon, Mr. G. A. L. Skerry; coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, with a jury of whom Mr. T Ewart was foreman, held the adjourned inquest in regard to the death of James Bewley, of Cleator Moor, who was drowned in the flooding of the Townhead Mine, Woodend, on March 13th. Mr. W. Leck, Cleator Moor, H.M. Inspector of Metalliferous Mines, represented the Home Office; Dr. T. Eastham, Manchester (instructed by Mr. E. Atter, Whitehaven) represented the relatives of the deceased. Mr. L. T. Helder, Whitehaven, was present on behalf of the Townhead Mining Company; Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy, miners' agent, with Professor Galloway, mining expert, Cardiff, appeared on behalf of the workmen. There were also present: Mr. Cook, Whitehaven, H.M Inspector of Mines, Mr. W. W. Casson, general manager and engineer of the Townhead Mine; and Mr. J. B. Kitchin, a director of the Townhead Mining Company. The jury, before the Inquiry began, had driven over to the Townhead Mine, and there inspected a model of a dam, which had been erected in the mine. The Coroner having intimated that the only evidence given at the last sitting of the jury was that of Thomas Burns, Duke Street, Cleator Moor, who identified the body of the deceased. Dr. Eastham inquired in view of the fact that this was an important inquiry; it would meet with the Coroner's approval if they had all the witnesses out of Court, except of course, the managing director, who would want to instruct his solicitor. The Coroner said that all the witnesses were already out of Court. John Marsh, Egremont, overman at Townhead Mine, the first witness called, deposed that on Thursday, the 13th March, an inrush of water occurred at the mine soon after six a.m. On the following Tuesday he went down the pit and found the body of Bewley at the foot of the shaft. The body was floating in about three and a half feet of water. By Dr. Eastham: The body was lying close to the short ladder, but was not clinging to it. It was possible to get from the short ladder to the surface ladder. The ladders did not actually join, there being a staging between. Four men escaped by the surface ladder. He would not say whether Bewley mistook the short ladder for the surface ladder. Bewley had worked at the mine about a week. Witness had worked in other mines, but had not seen shafts with ladderways. By Mr. Duffy: He did not say that the Townhead shafts were the only ones in the district provided with ladders. Henry Casson, Seascale, mine surveyor at Townhead, produced and put in plans showing the scene of the accident. He explained that there were old workings adjacent to the Townhead mine, at No. 10 Bain's, which had been abandoned. He did not know whether the old workings contained water, never having been into them. The only guide they had as to the position of the old workings was a plan obtained from the Home Office. They had tried to locate the old workings, and had touched one in driving a drift. They were beneath the old workings, and they tested with boreholes, but no water came through these, all being quite solid. There were no levels shown on the Home Office plans. They put in a dam, which they thought would be sufficient protection in case of water being present. It was not possible from the Home office plans to mark correctly the position of the old workings, because there were no surface marks to go upon. By Dr. Eastham: They took 16ft of water out of an old working previous to the accident. The dam was 39ft 5in below the place where they found water. Dr. Eastham asked the witness as to the building of the dam and its purpose. Mr Helder objected to this question being put to this witness. They courted, the fullest inquiry, but -Dr. Eastham: It doesn't look so. Mr. Helder said such questions should not be put to this witness, who was merely a surveyor. This information should be obtained from persons responsible for the management of the mine. Witness said he was not present when the dam was built. Joseph Maddern, 65, Leconfield Street, Cleator Moor, deposed that he was deputy overman at Townhead Mine. He was on duty on March 13th, and was on the first shift. He went down at 4.40 a.m. He went to examine the workings before anybody else went down. He found everything in safe working order. Witness was up the ladder and examined the rise. He also examined underneath the dam, but could not see any signs of water. The stays of the dam were pitched into the limestone. He sounded the walls and discovered nothing wrong. He considered the dam was sufficient protection against any water that might come in. He knew there was some water in the eye above, but not at this place. Witness examined the neighbourhood of the dam about ten minutes to five. The night shift was then in No. 11 dip. Bewley would arrive about six o'clock, but witness did not see him. The morning shift was due in at six o'clock. By Mr. Leck: He did not help to build the dam, but had to go every morning to see that no more water was coming. There was a little water coming. It came through a 2-inch pipe. The water was about the same as had been coming for weeks. By Dr. Eastham: He used to go into the working before the dam was put in. Water came down the cheek before the dam was put in. He could not say whether that was coming from an old working. It might come out of solid rock. There was a 2-inch pipe in before the dam was made, just to keep the metal dry. Such a pipe would be put in if there was only a little bit of dampness. Asked to show the entry in his book for the 13th March, witness produced his book. There had been water in No. 2 eye before March 13th. Some water broke through some time before the accident. There was an entry about water having been tapped on the 6th February. That was in No. 2 eye. That break-in would be over 30ft above the break-in on the day of the disaster. (Dr. Eastham: It was 39ft above). The deputy on every shift had special instructions to inspect the dam, and to see if there was any more water coming through. By Mr. Helder: The dam was still standing. There was a good deal of water going about in these mines. An old miner would say that if there was plenty of water there was plenty of metal. Mr. Duffy asked witness if the examination he made occupied only 35 minutes? Witness said it did not take long to get through the workings. Joseph Rooney, Cleator, iron ore miner, deposed that he was on the first shift on the day of the accident. On reaching the first brake, where he worked, he noticed there was a change in the air, there being more current. He thought water had broken in, and he and another man named Green made for the shaft and gave warning. They could hear a rush of water. He knew there was water in the pit as they had been siphoning it out. He had seen water coming by No. 14 working, but he had no knowledge of its source. They had been warned about water by Mr. Marsh. He did not see anything of Bewley when he got to the shaft bottom. He warned Cairns as he passed, and Cairns went into another working to warn Ward. There were 13 men in the pit altogether. He and four others went up in the first cage, and he saw four men on the ladders. On reaching the top the cage went down again, and brought up one man named McShane by himself. The cage did not go down again. By Mr. Leck: There was a bit of a rush for the cage, which ordinarily carried four men. By Dr. Eastham: When witness met Cairns the latter's candle went out owing to the draught. Witness was not warned by Mr. Marsh, but witness had heard them saying that there was water about. That was three or four months ago. Nothing was done at that time to deal with the water danger. James McShane, Hagget End, miner, deposed that he had been working at Townhead Mine about three weeks. He went down to his work in No. 10 working on the day of the accident, but he had not commenced work when Rooney came and warned him about the water. Witness made for the shaft, on reaching which he found eight or nine men at the cage. The cage was filled, and some of the men went up the ladders. He was left alone at the bottom of the shaft, and when the cage came down again he got in and was taken up. Rooney told him that Cairns and Ward were in-bye. Before he went up in the cage he shouted to see if there was anybody else about. The water was rising fast, and it was not safe to remain. He was up to his middle in water. Had Bewley been on the short ladder he might have heard witness shout, though the commotion might have prevented him doing so. He could not say whether Bewley was one of those who made for the ladder way, as their lights went out. By Mr. Leck: There was a light at the shaft in addition to the lights which the men had, but that was blown out when the water came. By Dr. Eastham: Had Bewley got to the top of the short ladder witness did not think he would be able to see the surface ladder, with the lights out. Robert Skelton, Bowthorn Cottage, Cleator Moor, miner, deposed that he was on the first shift on March 13th, and went down in the third cage. Bewley went down with him. The witness did not see much of him afterwards. They lit their candles at the bottom, and some men then came running back, and said the water had broken in. Witness had worked in the pit three years. When the men came back they shouted for the cage. Witness argued the point with the men, because there was no water that he could see or hear. When four men got on the cage witness heard a noise, and said, "If that's water she'll take more than four up the pit," and he also got on the cage. (Laughter.) He left Bewley, Burns, Green, Graham, McNulty, and McShane, standing at the shaft bottom. He told the men if they had not time to wait for the cage they must make for the ladders. He saw two or three of them making for the ladders. If a man got in the pump shaft he could not mistake a short ladder for a long ladder, because there was only one ladder in it. He did not know whether Bewley knew the difference between the long and the short ladders. Burns, Green, Graham, and McNulty, went up the ladder. When Bewley did not make his appearance, two or three men went down again to look for him. By Mr. Leck: There was no scuffling for the cage which witness came up on. He had several times travelled up the ladders. All the lights were burning when witness went up the pit. By Dr. Eastham: He did not know whether the short or long ladder would be the nearer to Bewley. By Mr. Helder: The little ladder was not in the shaft at all. It was really in a drift. By the Coroner: He thought Bewley would have plenty of time to find the ladder even if he had no light. He could give no explanation why Bewley went up the short ladder. Edward Green, 76, Duke Street, Cleator Moor, miner at Townhead Mine, deposed that he knew they had been trying to find water, but he did not know whether they found any. Witness went up the ladder first and the others followed. They went through a canvas doorway to reach the ladder. They lost their lights when they opened the canvas door, the draught blowing them out. The short ladder was through the canvas door. He got on that first and crossed over to the other ladder. Witness could not have got across had it not been for the "blink of a match," which was struck by someone. He knew the ladder should be there, but which side he did not know. There was a lot of excitement and witness ran up the first ladder he came to. He had been working in the pit "backwards and forwards for two or three years." He was never in the ladder shaft before. The Coroner: You suggested to the jury that you might have been drowned if you had not seen this light? Witness: Yes, very possibly. The Coroner: If Bewley went up this ladder after you, and no one showed a light across, he might be unable to get any further? — Yes, it was the match that helped me. By Mr. Leck: He had not time to say anything to anybody. It was a case of everyone for himself. (Laughter.) By Dr. Eastham: If the short ladder had been outside the canvas he would have known it was not the surface ladder. By Mr. Helder: If the ladder had not been where it was he supposed they could not have reached the wheel to oil it. The wheel could not have been outside that place. John Cairns, Birks Road, Cleator Moor, one of the two men who were imprisoned in the flooded mine for five and a half days, was next examined. In reply to the Coroner he deposed that he went down the mine with the first shift. He saw Bewley on the top, but he did not see him in the mine. When Rooney gave warning about the water they all made for the shaft. Witness turned back to warn Ward. The water was then coming down the drift and had cut them off from the shaft. Seeing it was no use trying to get to the shaft they went up the rise. He knew that water had been siphoned out of this eye for five or six weeks. Went they went up the rise he did not think the water would fill the pit as it did. By Dr. Eastham: He did not know where the water came from. It might have come from Ennerdale Lake for all he knew. By Mr. Helder; He knew that the management were taking precautions against possible water. Mr. Helder said he did not know that he had anything else to say to the witness, except to congratulate him upon his escape. Everyone must feel that this witness did a very worthy act in going back to warn Ward at the risk of his own life. William Walter Casson, St Bees, general manager and engineer of Townhead Mines, deposed that his Company had occupied their royalty between 13 and 14 years, but had leased the royalty in the vicinity of the place where the accident occurred within the last few years. He did not know that there were any abandoned workings there originally. The owner of the royalty was Lord Leconfield. They ascertained there were some old workings after they took the new area. They had not worked the new area very much before they wrote to the Home Office for copies of the old plans. After they got the plans they immediately tried to locate the old workings on their own plans. It was found that there was only 5ft difference between the two plans with regard to these two workings. In the plans they got from the Home Office there were no levels shown with respect to the particular vicinity with which they were dealing. They came to the conclusion by the ground that the old workings were above them. Those workings were abandoned twenty-three years ago, but they would not necessarily assume that the workings were full of water. They would naturally expect to find some water. From where they were working they could not expect to get the drainage from the whole of the workings. They knew they were getting to the neighbourhood of water, and that was the reason they drove No. 5 rise — with the initial object of holing the water from the old workings. They made no borings up to that particular point because of the information they had got from the Home Office. They put four boreholes in the roof of the drift as they went along. At first it was perfectly dry, but in 2 hours there was a change, and a dampness showed itself. That was one reason they stopped the drift. Mr. Leck made an inspection of the pit, and witness mentioned the altered conditions to him. It was then decided, as a precaution, to stop the working. It was in consequence of the drift getting a bit damp that they put in the dam as an extra precaution to prevent the flooding of the mine. The dam was designed by witness and his joiner. Witness had ascertained how the water had come through the roof. From what he had seen since the breaking in of the water he considered it was most unlikely that they could have found the water. He thought the water had gradually cracked the roof and then burst through. The Coroner asked witness how he accounted for the water getting into the mine after the dam was there? Witness said the dam was intact with the exception of one portion of the side. It was difficult to say how that portion had been washed away, they found several inches of a shale bed. When the ring was made there was very little, if any shale to be seen. There might have been a mark, but nothing to show there was any shale. The water had evidently got into the shale bed, at first eaten itself in, and after getting a start had eventually got behind and washed the whole thing out. The Coroner: What do you tell the jury shortly, as being the reason why this dam was not effective? Witness: Weakness on the solid side of the rise. And could you have discovered that that side was weak when you were putting in the dam? — No, I don't think so. Witness explained that during the whole time they had been taking water from another point, and as a result of these operations there was at least 16 feet head of water taken off old workings of somebody else. By Mr. Leck: He explained the breaking in of the water through ten feet of ground by the presence of the fault and the slape face, which caused the interved wedge-shaped piece of ground to give way. Is it not a sensible mining rule that you should take precautions as if old workings were full of water? — That is so. I rather understood from your answers to the Coroner that you did not look at it quite that way? — If I did convey that impression it is an impression that I did not mean to convey. By Dr. Eastham: He had no notice from the inspector with reference to water. They abandoned working No. 5 after the visit of the inspector, when it was found that the side was wet. He was not trained as a mining engineer. He had held his present position for thirteen or fourteen years, and previous to that he did surveying for an iron ore company. They did use precautions against the old workings being full of water. The quantity of water, which broke into, the mine was about a million and a quarter gallons. He thought the dam, which they put in, was of sufficient strength for its purpose. The method adopted of draining the water from the new eye was the best method. He had never given their workmen warnings about water. They had not taken any precautions to prevent a repetition of the flooding. He did not consider pumps necessary for the safe working of this mine. It was not an engineering impossibility to connect the short ladder with the surface ladder. He did not consider that the present position of the ladders caused a trap. Pressed upon this point, witness adhered to his statement, and pointed out the short ladder was not in the shaft at all, but in the drift. He would now consider the position of these ladders, but he could not say what he could do in the matter. By Mr. Helder: Knowing of the old workings he was now taking the necessary precautions for dealing with the water. This concluded the evidence. The Coroner, addressing the jury, said that in addition to finding by what means Bewley met his death, it was for them to say whether there had been any negligence on the part of the management. If they thought the management had not done all that could have been done, or if they had any recommendation to make, he hoped they would say so, because no doubt the Company. Would take notice of anything the jury thought should be done. He did not see how they could suggest any criminal negligence, as there seemed to be nothing whatever in the Metalliferous Mines Act which compelled the Company to do anything more than they had done. The jury, after deliberating about fifteen minutes, returned a verdict that Bewley was accidentally drowned by a sudden inrush of water. They made no recommendation. Mr. Helder, on behalf of the Company and of Mr. Casson, expressed their sincere regret that the accident should have caused the death of Bewley, and they tendered their sincere sympathy to the relatives. The Coroner said he was sure the relatives would be very glad to hear that. He thought some notice should be taken of the heroic conduct of Cairns. (Applause) He could easily have got to the shaft and gone up with the other men, but he knew the man Ward was in the working, and he went back to acquaint him of what had happened. Although Cairns had saved his own life and also that of Ward, there was a possibility that by going back Cairns might have lost his life. He thought such conduct was deserving of the Edward medal; it was one of the finest pieces of heroism in connection with mines he had heard of for a long time. (Applause) The foreman said the jury unanimously concurred in the Coroner's remarks, and recommended Cairns for the Edward medal. The Coroner said he would be pleased to forward the recommendation to the proper quarter.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||