|
3rd April 1913 Shot-Firing Fatality At Mawbray, FrizingtonOn Monday afternoon last an accident occurred at the Mawbray Mines, Frizington (owned by the Workington Iron & Steel Co.), in which three men were injured. It appears that Isaac Birkett, Primitive Villa, William Campbell and Peter Connor, Frizington Road, all of Frizington, were engaged in boring holes, when an accident occurred and Birkett's injuries were so serious that he died on Tuesday. The Inquest The inquest was held by the coroner (Mr. E. Atter) and a jury, of which Councillor R. Wilson was chosen foreman, in the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, yesterday afternoon. Mr. W. Leck, HM Inspector of Metalliferous Mines; Mr. J. H. Brown, of the firm of Messrs Brown, Auld & Brown (representing the owners of the mines); and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy (for the relations), were also present William Hodgson, carter, Crosthwaite, Frizington, said he identified the body as that of Isaac Birkett, his cousin. Deceased was a married man, 43 years of age. He had been living with his wife at Primitive Villa, Frizington, and had been engaged by the Workington Iron & Steel Co. at their Mawbray Mines, Frizington, where he had worked for 14 years. Witness last saw him alive three weeks ago. He was a man who enjoyed good health, and he was a teetotaller. By Mr. Duffy: Birkett could read and write and was a fairly intelligent man. Mr. Gill, mining engineer, presented a plan of the working, showing the boreholes. He had not had time to make a plan of the accident. William Campbell, 74, Frizington Road, Frizington, said he worked at the Mawbray Mines belonging to the Workington Iron and Steel Co., and had worked there for about 13 years. He knew the deceased, and had known him four or five years. He was one of their company. The companies went by numbers, and theirs was No. 16. There were ten men in each company, and there were five on each shift. On Monday last they were on the afternoon shift and commenced at two o'clock, and their company included William Morley, himself, Peter Higgins, John Elliott, and Peter Connor. They were engaged in boring holes at the bottom. They had worked in this place about 12 months or more, and were working for a company. Mr. Thomas Richardson was the deputy, and Mr. Walker was the overman. They saw the latter at two o'clock before they went down the pit. They saw no one when they started work. They continued to work until twenty minutes past five, but no officials came to them during that time. They were boring the holes and the company supplied the cartridges, which consist of dynamite, but he did not know the material out of which they were made. They got their charges that day from Morley, who went to the store-keeper, John Elliott for them. They got two packets of dynamite. Every man does his own stemming, and five holes had been bored. The stemming is done by putting a stiff piece of clay on the top of the hole, and then the use of a ramrod or swab stick. Witness finished his hole about twenty past five and went up to bring some swab sticks. He brought two for fear they wanted them. When he got to the working he noticed Birkett; using an iron pump. Witness went to him and asked if he was charging with the pump, and he replied, "Yes." Witness said, "Don't charge with that; here is a swab stick for thee." Just as deceased was reaching for the stick the hole exploded. Witness was away for the sticks about five minutes, and deceased was using the pump all the times he was boring the hole. It was not necessary to draw the deceased's attention to the pump when he was boring the hole. The pump is used when the hole is wet to get the sludge clear from the bottom of the hole. The pump ought not to be used to charge the hole. From the time witness spoke to him until the explosion occurred, witness could hardly say how long would have elapsed. Witness was blown back onto the road. He was thrown on his back a distance of fifteen or twenty feet. When he recovered he had an injury on his left leg, and his ear was partly damaged. Connor was injured slightly, but was further away from the hole. The other man (Higgins) escaped injury. Witness was stunned, but not rendered unconscious. The lights were all blown out, and all was in darkness. A man called Thomas Curwen came down to them shortly after the accident. Witness could not explain why Birkett should have used the iron pump, as there are rules provided warning men that iron is dangerous to use to dynamite. Witness had never known deceased before infringe on the rules. He would get the pump from the blacksmith. It would be no advantage to deceased to get the hole done quicker. Witness realized the danger of an explosion, and that was why he spoke to the deceased. By Mr. Leck: He had been seven years in full employment as a miner. There were ten in the company and five on a shift. Each man bores his own hole, and they have no recognised man as borer or shot-firer. As regards the pump, it is used when they have bored the hole, to clean the sludge and water out. It was quite a proper instrument to use. They did not pay for the swab sticks, but got them from the joiner's shop. Witness had a copy of the special rules and was familiar with them. The rule was "any miner using a drill or any implement of iron or steel for the purpose of tamping a charge shall be instantly dismissed." If there were no special rules in the mine he would still be forbidden to use iron. Witness did not know the chemical contents of the dynamite, but he did know that it was dangerous to use iron in respect to it. The instrument (produced) was a swab stick used for pushing in the cartridges. The pump (produced) was used to pump sludge out of the hole when bored. They were not on shift work, and it would be an advantage to get done quickly, but not to use the pump. They had enough swab sticks. There are officials who visit during each shift, but there had been no official visit in that shift. Before the shift is finished there is an official visit to the working. The Coroner: What sort of official? Witness: A deputy or overman. By the Foreman: They generally come round some time after bait time, and sometimes before or after six o'clock. The Saturday before that the official was in about 8.30 in the morning. Mr. Brown: You speak of going up for a swab stick. I thought you might convey to the jury that you went up the shaft. Did you go up the shaft? Witness: No. sir, about 20 or 30 feet away from the working. The sticks are lying all round, but they are put back to save them for the last round of the shift, so that they should not be buried in the falling metal. They had never any trouble in getting sticks. By Mr. Duffy: It is a practice to have a visit from the overman some time during the shift. Witness was sure he saw deceased put a dynamite cartridge in the hole. There was a good light in the place. He had never seen him do anything of the kind before. He knew him outside of the mine, and he was a steady chap and fairly intelligent. Before this hole was fired it would be about five or six hours since the previous holes were fired. When witness went for the swab sticks there was already one in the working, which was being used by Connor, but there was none for Birkett. By the Foreman: It does not take much time to put a dynamite cartridge in, and they make the holes different depths. If one of the deputies had come down and seen him using the pump he would have been instantly dismissed. By Mr. Leck: When witness went away Connor was charging a hole with a swab stick. The Coroner: Is this the first injury you have had? Witness: Yes, sir. The Coroner: You have been very lucky to escape, and I am sure you will feel your good fortune. I hope it will be the worst you will have. Peter Connor, 72, Frizington Road, said he worked at the Mawbray Mines and had worked there for over 20 years. He had known the deceased, and was a fellow workman of his for five or six months, and he seemed a steady reliable man. Witness had all confidence in him as a workman. On Monday last witness was on the afternoon shift with deceased and started work about two o'clock. He worked with deceased, Higgins, and Campbell, and they were boring holes. All went right until about five o'clock, Morley said he was going to make a charge, and then went up to get a fuse. Shortly witness struck a lough, and it carried his hole on. It took some time to charge the lough. Witness got a swab and dynamite and started to charge his hole. He put his charge in, but did not know what it was composed of. It was the same sort they had used all the years he had been there. He had never had an accident with them. Witness was away about five minutes, and when he returned Campbell had just come back with some swabs. When he came back witness was charging a hole, and was putting in his last cartridge. He charged it with twenty-three. He heard Campbell say, "Don't charge with the pump, Ike, here's a swab," and with that the hole exploded. This was about six or seven feet from witness, and it came from Birkett's hole. It blew the lights out and threw witness against the side, and a lamp struck him on the forehead. He was stunned, and when he came to himself someone had come into the working with a light. Witness heard a groan, which came from Birkett. Witness had worked with Birkett about six months, and had never seen him use the iron before, and had never seen anyone else use it. Witness knew it was against the rules, and it was a dangerous thing to do. He could give no reason why deceased should have used the pump, and he would not have done it himself. If he had seen deceased using it, he would have spoken to him, and smart too, because it was dangerous, not only to himself, but to all the workmen near. By Mr. Leck: Witness put about 23 cartridges in his hole. He brought about 40 in a tin. He did not know how many had got in Birkett's hole. Witness had not been back to the place since the accident. There were plenty of swab sticks lying about. Andy Morton, who went to the deceased, was one of the ambulance men at the mine, and he rendered first aid. Witness helped Birkett out of the pit. Mr. Leck: Notwithstanding your injuries, well, you have had a very narrow escape yourself. On further questions by Mr. Leck, witness said they had no recognised man for firing. They consulted one another about the holes, and agreed. Witness did not know Birkett was charging his hole with the pump. He thought he was cleaning it out, and he had his back to him. By Mr. Duffy: He saw deceased put the dynamite in the hole. The pump was in the hole when the explosion took place, and it (the pump) was slit down the middle. The Foreman: Don't you think there should be a man in charge of the shift, to stop men using these things. Witness: If I had known he was doing it, I would have stopped him all right. The Coroner: How is it no one comes down to see the shift between two and ten o'clock? Why should there be an official visit in the morning, and not in the afternoon? Mr. Duffy: Is there not an afternoon deputy? Mr. Gill said there was no occasion for a deputy in the afternoon shift. They had one in the morning because there was the whole of the pit working, and they got metal out, but in the afternoon they were just boring. There is a man in charge for fear anything happened. After hearing other evidence, The jury returned a verdict that the deceased died from shock from fracture of the skull, which was occasioned by an explosion of dynamite. Mr. Brown asked for permission, on behalf of the owners to express regret they felt at the sad death of the deceased. He was a man of whom they had never had any complaints, and they wished him (Mr. Brown) to express their regret. The Coroner (to the cousin of the deceased): You hear what Mr. Brown has said on the part of the employers at their regret of the death of your cousin? Will you convey that to the relations? The Foreman said he was sure the jury also wished to be associated with the remark.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||