|
13th February 1913 Fatal Accident At The Lonsdale Mines, FrizingtonOn Friday afternoon last, a fatal accident occurred at the Lonsdale Iron ore Mines, whereby two men were killed, and one man injured. So far as can be ascertained, the three men, James Robinson, Frizington Road, James Lightfoot, Harris Villa, Frizington; and John Clegg, Cleator, all of whom act as labourers, were at the bottom of a rise about three p.m., when there was a fall of roof. James Robinson, who was cut about the head and otherwise injured, was, after being attended by the doctor, able to walk home. The others were not so fortunate. James Lightfoot was liberated and taken to the surface about five p.m., and was at once medically attended, and was found in a serious condition. John Clegg was killed, and it was some time later before his body was brought to the surface. They are all married men, Mr. Clegg having three children. Messrs. Walker and Hartley, engineers, Mr. Williams, manager, and other officials, were all at the mine, along with willing workmen, all doing their utmost for the poor fellows. Arrangement were made to convey Lightfoot to the Whitehaven Infirmary, but he expired before he could be removed. The body of John Clegg was shortly afterwards recovered, and conveyed home in the ambulance van. The sad accident cast quite a gloom over the whole district, and the men, as is customary, left work. On Saturday evening Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship and Manor of Egremont, opened an inquest in the Council Chamber, Frizington, to inquire into the cause of death. Mr. Henry Murphy, Yeathouse Hotel, was chosen foreman of the jury. Mr. T. Williams, manager of Lonsdale Mines, was also present. After proceeding by wagonette to Cleator to view the body of Clegg, and then proceeding to Harris Villa to see Lightfoot, Peter Lightfoot, 34, Mill Street, Frizington, identified the body of James Lightfoot as that of his brother. He was 28 years of age, and was married. He resided at 8, Peter Street, Harris Villa. He was a miners' labourer, and he thought had worked at Lonsdale Mines for eighteen months or two years. He last saw him alive on Tuesday. He was then in good health. He was killed on Friday, but he did not know what his injuries were. Previous to being employed at Lonsdale he was working in the quarries. Adam Huddart, 3, Jane Street, Frizington, identified the body of Clegg as that of his nephew, who was also 28 years of age, and resided at 10, Brookside, Cleator. He was married, and had three children. He was killed on Friday at Lonsdale Mines, where he had been employed for a good many years. He was unable to say what his injuries were, and knew nothing about the accident. The Coroner said he did not propose to call any more evidence that day. He had been in communication with Mr. W. Leck, HMI, who said he would like to acquaint Mr. Atkinson, the chief inspector of mines, Newcastle; consequently an adjournment was necessary. It was decided to adjourn until Wednesday, at 5.15pm, in the same place. The Adjourned Inquest The adjourned inquest to inquire into the death of James Lightfoot, and John Clegg, at Lonsdale Mines, on Friday last, was held in the Council Chamber, Frizington, yesterday (Wednesday) evening, before Mr. G. A. L. Skerry,. Mr. Henry Murphy was foreman of the jury, and there were also present; Mr. W. Leck, HMIM, Mr. R. Hartley CE, Mr. Nelson solicitor, Egremont, representing Lonsdale Mining Co; Mr. Fell, surveyor, Mr. T. Williams, manager, Lonsdale Mines; Mr. J. C. Jenkins; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, representing the relatives of deceased men. Mr. Nelson said the Company tendered their sincere sympathy to the relatives of the men, and the Company and men wished to convey their most sincere sympathy to Dr. Morris, who was anxious to do all he could both above and underground to be of any assistance, and they felt this opinion should be publicly expressed. The Coroner said he felt the relatives would appreciate this expression of good feeling, and he was sure Dr. Morris was both kindly and sympathetic and only too anxious to do all he could. Mr. Fell submitted a plan of the working, which he explained very fully. Mr. Leck said he had made two inspections, and the plans were very clear and accurate. James Robinson stated he lived at 25, Frizington Road. He was a miners' labourer at Lonsdale Mines for about two years. He'd been in the mines for twelve years. He was working on the afternoon shift on Friday, working with No. 18 company, Robert Huddart, Thomas Sandwith, Thomas Dixon, and himself. Clegg was in No. 15 company, and Lightfoot was trailing the brake from No. 18 company. As soon as they got into the working they were going to fill a bogey. Huddart and Sandwith were marking a hole out to commence boring. Thomas Dixon was with him. Lightfoot and Clegg were at the bottom of the break, three yards away, waiting for the full bogie going down the brake. J ust as he was starting to fill the bogie a big fall of metal came down, and smashed the wood, and as he looked round was just coming on to the top of Lightfoot and Clegg, and he got a knock on the head. He got out of the way into the forebreast. Huddart was about three or four yards away and asked if all were right, and he replied Lightfoot and Clegg were buried. Sandwith was the first to find where the men were. He commenced to take the old wood away, and neither of the men spoke. He came away then, being injured. By the Coroner: The timbering was very good and had been put in about three weeks or a month before. The timber would be about 13 feet from the ground. It occurred just after they got in. He thought about 2.30 p.m. There was no one there when they arrived in the working. The men on the morning shift had only just left. They marked the holes with a pick, but that would have no effect on the fall. It was metal which fell. There was no noise or warning of the fall at all. By Mr. Leck: He had not seen the place since the accident. He had been in the lead mines and coal mines. There was no second rush while he was there. If it was only timbered recently, it was because there had been a fall previously, and it was timbered with new wood by the miners. He was not connected with the timbering party. His work was to take the metal away. He had never been above the timber. He had heard slight falls, which he had mentioned to Jonathan Park, a deputy. By Mr. Nelson: The timber was put in by practical miners, and was both good and strong. He had heard of slape. By Mr. Gavan Duffy: The last fall was about three weeks ago. He was there at the time, and there was a quantity came down. He did not examine the roof himself, but the deputy did so. The new roof was larch props. Falls were not much that he heard. By the Coroner: Park went in over the wood to examine the roof every time he visited the working. Thomas Dixon, 7, Dyke Street, said he was on the afternoon shift, and went with Lightfoot from the brake bottom. He was working in the same place as Robinson. He put his stores away. He then went on the flat sheet, got the bogie, pushed it up and braked it. He and Robinson started to fill. Huddart and Sandwith were working. Clegg and Lightfoot were standing back on the flat sheet an as they got a start, the fall occurred behind them. Robinson looked back and was caught, and he jumped forward. Robinson was about two yards behind him. He was not struck. Huddart asked Robinson where Lightfoot and Clegg were, and he said they were under the fall. When he and Huddart got to the fall, Sandwith was already there. Robinson went away as he was injured. They pulled the broken wood and rubbish away, but as there was more than they could manage, they ran and shouted to the other companies. He worked with them until they extricated Lightfoot, who was not then dead. They had to use screw jacks. Both Lightfoot and Clegg were close together. They gave Lightfoot some hot tea and he spoke to them. The fall came through the timbering and would weigh several tons. No one was doing anything to disturb the roof, and the fall appeared to be directly overhead. He thought it was inspected a week before and new wood was put in. There was a big fall about the New Year. Jonathan Park, deputy, came in every afternoon and told them what they had to do. He went up to the roof about the timbering. He got up by a hole near where they were filling. He had been up once or twice with men to get some metal from a fall. They had heard it falling several times. They went up to get pieces which had fallen on the timbering, and they got about twenty bogies. He did not know of anyone having sent to dislodge metal from the roof. The deputy stopped them from getting metal. The deputy did not go up every afternoon while he was there. By The Coroner: He thought the fall occurred from the centre. By Mr. Leck: He escaped by jumping forward. Help was immediately obtained. He had nothing to do with the timbering. He had seen the place since the accident, but had not been working in it. The lumps they were sent to take from the timber were blocking the hole, which enabled the men to get on the timber. He was not an ambulance man, and could not say if men any ambulance were near. By Mr. Nelson: Mr. Williams had not ordered them to take any ore down since the new timber was put in, and did not think falls of any consequence had taken place since. When they were stopped taking metal it was before the new timber was put in. By Mr. Gavan Duffy: The lumps came down some time since. It was about eight feet from the timbering, and was consequently possible to be tested or tapped. When the deputy stopped them getting metal it was not because it was not safe, but because he was unaware of their orders from Mr. Williams. William Hocking, Fourmart Hill, stated he worked at Lonsdale Mines and was working on the afternoon shift in No. 12 company. He did not see the accident. He had seen the place since. The fall came from the side above the timber. He had seen the pieces of metal which came down previously, about a month or five weeks before. When he put in timber, there was a fall during the night and no one was then in the mine. He assisted in putting up the new timber. The ore seemed fairly good. He did not expect it to fall. There was an examination then made of the roof; there were six or seven of them, and they all examined the roof. They were nearly three weeks. It was quite possible to test or tap the roof. They always treated the roof as they proceeded from the top of the timbering. It would be about eight feet high at the place where the fall took place. The timber which they used was very strong. He thought the timber they put in was strong enough to hold anything likely to fall, and in their opinion what had fallen was all likely to come. He had seen the pieces which had fallen, and they came from a slape back. Shot firing would cause a certain amount of vibration. They cleared down all that could be got when timbering and he considered it quite safe to work under. He had seen the pieces tapped. He did not work there, but had seen the deputy coming down. By Mr. Williamson (a juryman): The working was a dry place. By Mr. Leck: He had worked at Lonsdale Mines for about 14 years. They examined the roof when timbering. It was also examined by the officials. He then described the method of timbering. The head trees were the thickest and strongest they could get and some of them took nine or ten men to put them in. They were of peeled larch. About the covering they put on the last 18 inches to two foot of old wood and rubbish. If it had been suggested to put a pillar in at that point, he would have considered it necessary. He had seen the place, and he saw there were indications of the slip. He was an ambulance man, and others rendered assistance with ambulance training. Dr. Morris descended the mine, and was there when Lightfoot was extricated. By Mr. Gavan Duffy: If the pieces had been tapped before the men started work he thought they ought to have been discovered. The cover wood was of peeled larch. J. J. Crellin, Winder Gate, deputy at Lonsdale Mines, said he was on morning shift on Friday, from 5 a.m., to 2 p.m. He was through the brake twice that day. He examined the timber, but he did not go over the timber that morning. He was up the place in question on Thursday morning, and examined the roof with a ladder, which was there for the purpose. He used an acetylene lamp, which he considered sufficient to indicate of there was anything unsound. It would show if having been tapped with a hammer the previous day, he might have been able to detect. On the Tuesday he tested it with a bar. Since the new timber was put in he went up three or four times a week and used the bar probably once a week. He considered the lamp a good means of ascertaining if there were any cuts, which was a sure sign of any bad roof. By Mr. Leck: He was with the men all the time on the morning shift when the timber was put in. He thought at the time the new timber was sufficient to meet all requirements. He considered it perfectly safe. He knew of no shots having been fired in the vicinity. The pieces came from a slope side which were not quite visible, but could not be detected previously. By Mr. Nelson: It was possible to tap piece against a slape face and find it all right and yet come away in a few minutes. By Mr. Gavan Duffy: He turned out early in the morning for the purposes of examining the roofs before the men started work. The afternoon deputy started at two p.m. He considered if there was any defect he could distinguish it with his lamp. Mr T. Williams, manager, Winder House, said after the new timbering was put in it was not compulsory for the deputy to go about to examine the roof. The new timber, in his opinion, was sufficient to stand anything with regard to slape backs. They might be tested and yet come away without any warning. The timbering was put as high as they could possibly get it. He saw that the strongest wood possible was used. He had no suspicion of slape backs. He did not expect the deputies to go up. By Mr. Leck: No one suggested to him to put in a pillar, and he considered it quite unnecessary. If he had been going to put in a pillar he would not have put it in at that point. When a place of that kind was timbered in the way that did not require further inspection. By Mr. T Gavan Duffy: He did not expect his deputies to inspect the roof when timbered in this manner, which could not be done unless there was cavity to allow them to do so. He was aware many accidents occurred by fallen roof, but not where timbered. The Coroner summed up, dwelling on the various aspects of the accident. It appeared as far as they saw at the time everything they know. He had it in his mind at one time there might have been some neglect, but that had been cleared up. He left it to the jury - A verdict of "Accidental death by fall of roof" was returned. The Funerals The funeral of James Lightfoot took place at St. Paul's Church, Frizington, on Monday afternoon. The weather was extremely unfavourable, rain falling heavily, but an exceedingly large number attended, including the Lonsdale Mine employees, and the head officials (Mr. C. N. Jenkins and Mr. Thomas Williams). The coffin was borne to its last resting place by the deceased's fellow workmen. The burial service was most impressively conducted by the Vicar (the Rev. R. S. E. Oliver), and the hymn "Jesus, Lover of My Soul," was sung in church. Mr. W. H. Massey was the undertaker. A beautiful wreath of natural flowers, bearing a suitable inscription, was contributed by the Miners' Association, of which the deceased was a member, and other tributes were sent by his sorrowing wife and mother, Sister Mary and Charlie (Cartmel), Mr. and Mrs. Steele, Bessie and Edna, Mrs. Laidlaw, Mrs D Kane, F. Jackson (Ullock), Mrs. Rogerson, and others. The deceased, who was only 28 years of age, was married, and leaves a widow, but no family. He was a native of Frizington. The funeral of John Clegg took place at St. Paul's Church, Frizington, on Tuesday afternoon, and like that of his comrade the previous day, was very largely attended. In addition to the mine officials a large number of workmen were present. The deceased, who was only 28 years of age, was a son of Mrs. and the late John Clegg, Frizington Road, Frizington. He spent some time in South Africa. He leaves a wife and three children.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||