Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

17th October 1912

Mining Fatality At Bigrigg

Opening Of The Inquest

A fatal accident happened on Thursday to a married man named J. H. Nevinson, 40 years of age, residing at Ennerdale Bridge, and employed at Parkside No. 2 Mine, Bigrigg, belonging to the Workington Iron and Steel Co. The deceased was a pit sinker, and was working in the shaft of the mine, along with J. Miller, Main-street, Hensingham, J. Wild, Trumpet-terrace, Cleator; M. Leech, Parkgate, Frizington, and J. King, Bowthorn-road, Cleator Moor. The men had lowered some timber down the pit for use in the shaft, and having removed the timber from the shackles they were in the act of putting the timber into position whilst the shackles, which were suspended to the rope, were being drawn-up the shaft, when one of the shackles became disconnected with the rope by some means, and fell down the shaft, striking Nevinson on the head. The men heard the "thud," and saw their unfortunate comrade fall off the platform, which was erected at the bottom of the shaft for the use of the men. He fell into the sump. They at once took the man out of the sump, and brought him to the surface, where it was found that a portion of the shackle had penetrated the skull and proved fatal.

An inquest was opened at the Schoolroom, Bigrigg, in the evening, before Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, and a jury of whom Mr. G. Veitch, Bigrigg, was foreman.

Evidence of identification was given by Mr. W. Kitchin, Cain-street, Bigrigg, and the inquest was adjourned until the following night.

Mr. J. Hope Brown, solicitor, Whitehaven, who represented the Company expressed their deep regret that they felt at the loss of such a highly esteemed and useful workman, and said he would like the Company's regret to be conveyed to the deceased's widow.

The Adjourned Inquest

The adjourned inquest was held in the schoolroom, Bigrigg, last (Friday) night. There were present: Mr. G. A. L. Skerry (the coroner), Mr. Leck (H.M. Inspector of Mines), Mr. J. H. Brown (representing the Company), Mr. G. T. Duffy (representing the relatives), and Mr. Wm. Dixon (engineer for the Company); with the jury, of whom Mr. G. Veitch, Bigrigg, was foreman.

John Wild, 10, Trumpet-terrace, Cleator, joiner said he worked at the Parkhouse Mine, and knew deceased very well. Deceased was an iron-ore miner, and was engaged in sinking a shaft. He (witness) was on the same shift with deceased, who was in charge, J. Miller, who was second in charge, J. King, a sinker, and Mr. Leech, a labourer. Witness was in charge of the wooding. They commenced work at six o'clock. Deceased was an experienced man and very careful. They were putting in timber that they had sunk. All went right until about 11.50, when the accident happened. At the time of the accident they were bringing timber down with a sling chain, shackles, and split pin. The pit sides came down with one shackle and the pit ends with two, one to each end. There had come down two ends, seven feet long, four inches thick, and seven and a half inches wide. They are brought down by a clivace on the rope end of the timber. There are holes in the timber, seven feet from one end, for the rope, and these are put in before the timber comes down. The bolt on the shackle is put through the holes in the shackle when the timber is taken off, fastened with a pin, and sent up the shaft. The pin is not liable to come out itself, as they have to pull them out, and they work like a spring.

A shackle was produced, and the witness explained how they worked. The shackle produced was the one that killed the deceased.

Witness went on to say that when these shackles fastened to timber come down, deceased had to look after one, and Leech after the other, and see they were sent up all safe. After the timber is released the pin is replaced and knocked away. They always put in the split pin. The shackle and pin fell down on deceased's head after it had gone so far up the shaft. Witness had put his end in all right and was waiting for Nevinson putting his end in. Deceased was standing on the platform when the shackle fell down. He fell off the platform into the water, and witness and the other men went to his aid. They lifted him on to the platform out of the water, and he was then unconscious and bleeding. Witness had hardly time to see where the blow was. They got him to the top with a kibble. Deceased never regained consciousness, and in about quarter of an hour he was quite dead. His skull was fractured. The shackles weigh about 4lbs. After the accident happened the manager got the shackle. Witness never saw the shackle until the next morning. He believed the split pin was found in once place and the shackle in another.

When asked as to what he would attribute as to the cause of the accident, he said he thought the pin could hardly have been in. The bolt just shot through the holes, and with the swing of the rope it might work out. The cause of the accident was a pure mistake. He had never seen the shackle sent up with the pin out, and he has nothing to do with seeing that they were put right. The only thing he could say was that the pin had not been put in, and the bolt had been left out. Witness had been working in this shaft ever since it started, which was just about twelve months ago, and he had never known a shackle to fall before. There is plenty of light at the bottom, and there is no difficulty in seeing how the pin is put in. The pin could only be put in one way.

By Mr. Leck: He was in charge of the wooding, and it was not his business to see that the shackles were in proper condition before being sent up; it was deceased's. During the time he had worked at the shaft he had never known a pin be put in with one side only, as described by Mr. Leck, but that was one way the mistake could be made. On further questioning by Mr. Leck, witness said the shaft was 16 feet long and seven feet wide, there was a compartment seven feet square, where the accident happened, and another part is 4ft 2in. They have 9ft. remaining under cover, and when there nothing falling from the surface could strike anybody. The other shafts are used for ore. The depth of the sinking pit is 731 feet. The bottom of the shaft is oblong, and he was in the east corner, and deceased was opposite him. Witness heard a thud. He was looking at deceased, waiting for him, and he saw him fall over. He saw nothing strike him, as it happened so quickly. Deceased would fall about two or three feet, and there might be two feet of water. He would fall in.

By Mr. Brown: After the pin is put in the bolt the shackle is quite safe, and if the deceased had stepped back under cover, this would not have happened.

By Mr. Duffy: This is an exceptional kind of accident. His suggestion about the pin was simply a theory. There was nothing in the shaft to pull the pin out by the string attached. He would not say definitely that the pin was not put in. The pin would be more stable than screw.

By the Coroner: The shackle could not come off the chain unless the bolts were not sent through both holes or else the pin had not been put in right.

Mark Leech, 95, Parkgate, Frizington, said he was a labourer at the Parkhouse mine. His duty was when timber came down he helped the deceased to take it off the shackles. They loosed the pin, took the bolt out, and took off the timber. They put the bolt and pin in again, and sent the shackle up the shaft. They never made any mistake about the putting in of the bolt. He always put the pins in right, and they had plenty of light, to see how they had done it. The accident he thought might have been caused by either the pin being shaken out, and he thought it had not been put in. He put his pin in all right, he was certain, and he was not in a hurry. The deceased steadied the chain and witness knocked off. When the shackles were right for sending up, deceased used to shout, "Knock it away, I'm right." He had never knocked away until deceased shouted. Witness never saw the shackle after the accident, and he never knew anything like this happen before. He never saw the pin put in, in an improper way, but it was possible to miss getting both ends of the bolt through the holes in the shackle. Witness never made a mistake in this case in his life, and the pin could not have been put in right. He had before realised the danger of not sending the shackle up in proper condition. After the accident he saw the manager come down the pit, and no one else. That would be before two o'clock.

By a Juryman: Both the shackles had pieces of wood in when covered. When they had sent them up could step under the covering.

By Mr. Leck: He had been working down the pit about a week, and had been a miner about two years. He knew it was divided into several compartments, and it was customary for them to go under cover when they had sent the shackles up. He thought the deceased never stepped under the cover. When deceased told him he was right he had his own pin in. He never saw only one side of the pin put in. This was the first sinking pit he had worked in, and he was acting under the instructions of Nevinson.

By Mr. Duffy: During the week he was there he always put the pin in one shackle.

Isaac Walker, manager of the pit, said he went down the shaft about two hours after the accident. There was no one else down with him, or before him. He went down to investigate, and see what he could find. He found no trace or mark on the side of the shaft, and when he got to the bottom he found the shackle immediately where deceased was found. The cotter was attached to the shackle, and the bolt was five feet from that. He thought the cause of the accident would be that the bolt had not been put in or else he had not got his cotter in secure. This was the only way, in his opinion, the thing could have happened. There is no possibility of the cotter falling out when the shackle was going up, if the pin and bolt had been put in properly. It could catch nothing in the shaft to pull it out as they have a kibble, which would have to catch on anything in the shaft before the shackle could, and there is no possibility of the pin coming out if it is put in correctly. He never noticed any carelessness about the men in his work, and he had never known the shackle to fall before.

By Mr. Leck: None of the bankers had reported to him about the shackles not being in order until yesterday, when one said a shackle had come up a time ago with the bolt and pin hanging loose. Deceased had worked at the mine between two and three years, and he had been in the sinking pit about 15 months. He was a careful, steady chap, and well liked by all his mates. He was of a kind disposition. He had been in charge of the shift about five months. He had previously been second in charge, but on the death of another, he was promoted as they had not another man like him.

By the Coroner: The bankers are supposed to report matters about loose shackles, and he had told them to do this. If this had been done they would have warned the men.

By Mr. Brown: He considered this system of fastening shackles by the bolt and pin the best and better than having a screw, as a man who was not used to screws would get on the wrong threads, then with a little shake the screw would loosen. The same shackles were used in the sinking of the No. 2 pit a considerable time ago.

By Mr. Duffy: They were all good men in the shaft, and they were all asked to make any complaints necessary, and they would get what they required. If a screw was put in, and then a pin behind that, it might be safer.

By the Coroner: There were no instructions given about men getting under cover; they did it on their own accord for their own safety. Deceased had no timidity about him.

John Fitzgerald, 21, Springfield Road, Bigrigg, a banker, at the Parkhouse mine, said he had worked at the sinking pit since it started. He had never seen a shackle come up with the pin out.

The Coroner said he did not think they needed any further evidence. They had investigated this case so far as possible, and he thought it was proved that the accident would not have happened if the pin had been put in properly. There was no evidence as to who made the mistake, and they must take Leech's word that he put his pin in all right. The only conclusion was that deceased had forgotten to do it himself. Yet, he did not know how he could have done this, when he was careful and experienced in his work, and altogether a practical man. He thought there was only one verdict. If they thought investigation had been useful, they were quite at liberty to make any recommendation. These inquiries are useful for getting to know if everything is in perfect order at the workings, and if not, remedies can be suggested, and the things put right. It was a pity that a man, with a wife and three children should come to such a lamentable death in so simple a manner.

The jury returned a verdict of "Deceased met his death accidentally by a shackle falling down the shaft on his head."

Funeral At Ennerdale.

The sad news of the sudden and tragic death of Mr. Henry Nevinson, of Ennerdale Bridge, which occurred on Thursday last at Parkhouse Mine, Bigrigg, was received in Ennerdale and the surrounding districts with feelings of profound regret. The deceased who was 40 years of age, has spent the whole of his life in this neighbourhood. He was the oldest son of Mr. and Mrs W. Nevinson, of Salter, and by his quiet unassuming manner and industrious habits he has earned the highest esteem of all. He was ever an active member of the Ennerdale Mechanics Club, and during late years he has carried out the secretarial duties in a manner pleasing to all. He was a man of temperate habits, and was looked upon by employers and fellow workmen alike as a thrifty and industrious workman. Some years ago he married Hannah, second daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Gainford, of Ennerdale, and she with three children are left to mourn the loss of one who was ever an affectionate husband and a loving and indulgent father.

The funeral was held at St. Mary's Church, Ennerdale, on Saturday last, and despite unfavourable climatic conditions was attended by an unusually large concourse of people, many of whom were unable to gain admittance to the church. The members of the Mechanics attended in regalia, and marched to the funeral. The choir also attended and sang at the residence. "Thy Will Be Done," and in church the hymn "Brief life is here our portion." The burial service was read in an impressive manner by the Vicar (the Rev. A. H. Cooper). The deceased was borne to his last resting place by his fellow workmen from Parkhouse Mine. The attendance at the funeral which was large and representative, included several of the officials and workmen from the mine and friends and relatives from all over West Cumberland. Amongst the many beautiful and costly floral tributes placed on the coffin were the following :— "As a token of remembrance and esteem" from the officials and miners at Parkhouse Mine; Mrs. Higgins and family, Sarah and Jack, 33 Hugh-street, Bransty; Mr. and Mrs. Kitchin, Bigrigg; Mary and Jack, from W. and M. Sewell, Bird Dyke; Amie and Ada, from J. W. Walker, Mr. and Mrs. Noble, from Mr. and Mrs. Joe Sewell. It ought to be stated that the funeral arrangements were carried out by Mr. J. Tolson, The Lund, Lamplugh.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brown, J. Hope    Solicitor  
Cooper, A. H., Rev.      
Dixon, William    Engineer  
Fitzgerald, John    Banker  
Gainford, Hannah      Wife
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas      Whos Who Page
King, J.    Pit Sinker  
Kitchin, W.      
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Leech, Mark    Labourer  
Miller, J.    Pit Sinker  
Nevinson, Joseph Henry   40 Pit Sinker  Deceased, Individual Page
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Tolson, J.    Undertaker  
Veitch, G.    Jury Foreman  
Walker, Isaac    Manager  Whos Who Page
Wild, John    Pit Sinker  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Parkside (Iron Ore)  Parkside (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print