Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th September 1912

The Flooding Of Dean Moor Pit

The adjourned inquest with reference to the death of Peter Hutchinson (30), miner, of Asby, who was drowned by an inrush of water in Dean Moor Colliery on June 8th, was held on Tuesday afternoon, in the Primitive Methodist Church, Asby, by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont. There had been three adjournments to enable the management to get the pit clear of water in order that the Government Inspector might make a thorough inspection of the place, where the inrush occurred. Mr. Jonathon Watson was foreman of the jury. There were also present: Mr. J. B. Atkinson, chief inspector of mines for the Newcastle district, and Mr. J. Hope Brown, representing the Dean Moor Colliery Company.

Mr. William Watkyn Thomas, mining engineer, Egremont, submitted plan of workings which he had prepared from information supplied by the management. This he explained to the jury.

Wilkinson Serginson, Cross Gates, Lamplugh, drifter, employed by the Dean Moor Colliery Company, stated that on June 5th he was working with Hutchinson, and commenced work at six o'clock in the morning. The blacksmith and manager's son were also down the pit and the blacksmith helped to put a pump in, while the manager's son brought a key down for the pump. They were drifting, and they were two men on each shift. When they first went down they cleared out some metal left from a shot on a previous shift. They afterwards hewed a bit of coal out of a hole so that they could get a machine set for boring. It was used either for shots or boring for water. Hutchinson was standing at the bottom, and witness by the side of the tub, about three feet higher up. They had previously bored into the coal. Practically at the close of the shift Hutchinson was throwing coal into the tub, and witness was levelling them in the tub. It was nearly one o'clock, and time for stopping the shift, when an outburst of water occurred and seemed to come from under Hutchinson's feet. It put the lights out at the face and a tub was washed up the "dip" by the force of water. The place filled very quickly with water - it seemed to fill in an instant. Witness held on to the tub, and went up with it, but it got going too fast, and after holding on for some twenty yards he let go, as he was afraid he might get his hands jammed against the roof. He then tried to stand the force of the water, but it knocked him off his feet, and carried him to the shaft. He then got fast between the cage and the lip of the drift. He was fast for some seconds, and began to strike out, as he was not sure where he was. He then got hold of the bell-wire, and also shouted, after which someone lowered a rope and pulled him up - it would be about 16 fathoms to the top of the shaft. This all took place inside two minutes during which time witness held his breath. There was a very big force of water behind him. He didn't see Hutchinson after the inrush but he remembered touching him while he was being swept along the drift. Hutchinson was floating motionless, and if he was not dead he must have been unconscious.

By the Coroner: There was not he least indication that they were in any danger while they were working in the drift. They had bored shot holes down into the solid coal on the previous Wednesday, and there were no signs of water then. They could only see that the coal was damp, but in any case they would have expected that considering the position of the coal. If they had anticipated any danger they would have at once come out and reported, in accordance with instructions. He had been working in the Dean Moor Colliery four months, and previously was at Lowca. Before the accident he was shown a plan of the colliery by Mr. Thomas, the manager. He knew there were some old workings near the place where they were drifting. Their intention was to bore a ring of holes in the place referred to for fear of any danger. They would not have worked the coal there until they had proved it solid. He considered it was a pure accident.

By the Inspector: When he started the shaft was put down really for the drift. The first bore-hole was put down 11ft. 6in., in hard shale and did not get the coal. It was put down to prove the dip of the coal. The next bore-hole was put down about forty feet further away, about eleven feet down and into three feet of coal. The third hole was put down twenty feet further on 5ft. 6in., into coal. The holes were put down also with a view to guard against any danger from the old workings. They took it for granted that the old workings would be filled with water. He had worked in the old working drift, and had seen the level of water, but he did not anticipate the head of water there proved to be. He thought it might have been ten or twelve feet, but it proved to be over thirty feet. The water which came away before the accident was quite clear. It seemed like surface water, but then which came away at the time of the accident was cankered. From the plan he thought they would pass over the old workings. They thought where the hole was sunk in the seam they were right in a pillar of twenty or thirty feet of coal. The object of the drifting was he fancied to drain the old workings and work the coal. Asked why they had not according to the rule of the Act put flank holes, witness said he did not think the rule applied to a stone drift, and that the plan they adopted was the best and safest.

The Inspector said that was the rule, however, and it had not been complied with.

Witness repeated that he did not think the rule applied to a stone drift.

By Mr. Brown: The coal during boring was so dry that they had to water it, and they naturally came to the conclusion that they were not in the neighbourhood of water at all. They felt quite confident they were not in fact, the water they did get was quite fresh. They would not had worked the coal without putting in advance bore-holes, because they would have felt that they would have been breaking the rule. It was an old working that did not appear on the plan, or they should not have done what they did. It had been omitted from the plan altogether.

Replying further to Mr. Atkinson, witness said that if they had put flank holes in they might have struck the old working - "or we might not" - added witness. If they had known the old working was so near they would, with the manager's approval, have bored a hole a certain distance; and then shot it, but he would have taken care to have been out of the drift when it was fired.

Jackson Hellon, miner, Asby, said he was working in the mine until six o'clock on the Saturday morning. He was with a young man named Clements, and during the night they fired two shots at the face of the coal. They hewed three-parts of a tub of coal, and they shot it down. They bored a hole, 2ft. 3in. There was no more water than usual. Water was coming in from the bottom at about three tubs an hour. They could not see any coming from the top or the sides. There had been water in ever since they started the dip. Asked if he reported it to anybody, witness said they would all know. He did not know anything at all about the old working. The water coming in was quite fresh. He never saw any plans showing old workings. When witness went back by the pit on the Saturday morning Mr. Thomas told then they would have to be boring in front and at the sides for fear of the "goaf".

By the Inspector: He had no fear of working in the place referred to.

By Mr. Brown: He found the coal practically dry, so that the water could not be coming from the coal.

John Frears, miner, 35, Asby Road, said he was employed at the Dean Moor Colliery, and was last working there the Wednesday before the accident. He was working with Hutchinson and Serginson in the drift within about two yards of where the accident happened. They went about two yards past the fourth bore-hole, and then shot down, the intention being to sink down through the coal and then try for water. They had stopped the drift. The place was sunk down simply to bore for water. They would have got coal afterwards. They thought they were forty yards away from the water, according to the plan, which he saw the same week as the accident happened. Witness knew there were some old workings about, and knowing there would be danger from water, they were always on the look out for it. The old plans were not incorrect because the old working was not marked.

By the Inspector: He was told by the manager that the old workings were forty yards away. Asked if they could not have put a hole out of the drift, and caught the old working, witness said it was possible.

By Mr. Brown: Mr. Thomas might have said the old working was forty feet and not forty yards away.

John Little, pit headman at Dean Moor Colliery, said he looked after the pumps and engines. He put the hand-pump in at the place where the accident occurred. The water which came up was clear. After the accident witness attempted to lift the cage, but could not do so owing to one of the slides being broken by the rush of water, he supposed.

Witness, in reply to Mr. Brown, said that shortly before the accident the cage was running perfectly, as he brought up the manager's son.

Wm. Thomas, manager of the pit, stated that the water which burst in upon the men and drowned Hutchinson must have come from an old working.

The Coroner: Where had it broken through, because apparently the workmen did not see any indication of where the water came from? Witness: It came right from the face, on the left-hand side, and scooped out a hole about two feet square.

How thick is the coal between the face and where the water came through? I should say between 18 inches and 2ft., perhaps.

You mean the water must have broken through that thickness of coal? Yes.

Continuing, witness said they had been pumping water out of the pit ever since the accident and cleared the place sufficiently to get down about a fortnight ago. Water was still coming through, and they could only keep it clear by continually pumping. This was practically a new drift, but there were a lot of old workings about. These had been worked from other shafts. They were worked by the Moorside Colliery Company, which was managed by the late Mr. Johnson. Witness made a tracing of the old working from a plan in the possession of Mr. Johnson, and that was all he had to guide him as to the position of the old workings. He had found the plan accurate in every way practically since he commenced to use it. When the men got into the hole in question witness calculated that they were about 35 feet from the old working, according to the plan. It was their intention to bore into this place, and then commence working the coal. He had instructed the men that as soon as they got sufficient coal out they were to put bore holes in to find water. The proprietors of the Colliery had promised to supply the necessary apparatus for boring as soon as he sent for it. They had practically finished the work previous to boring when the accident occurred, and he was going to send for the boring appliance probably at the week-end.

By the Inspector: He knew where the tail of the water was at several points. The deputy used to go and measure it. It indicated a head of water of between 30 and 40 feet, he calculated. The old workings were stopped in 1900. Witness set off the pit himself, and it was correctly shown on the plan. They drove a drift so as to get into a solid pillar of coal.

Don't you think it would have been prudent also, in accordance with rule, if before you had sunk that hole down into the coal you had satisfied yourself by boring? — I sunk practically from the last bore hole that I put down.

Putting it in another way, don't you think it was quite practicable to have bored from the drift so as to have proved there were no old workings near where you were going to sink this hole? — Witness replied that he did not think it was practicable, because if he had put the hole in the centre of the drift he would have gone much further beyond the distance, and then he would have proved nothing.

What about flank holes? — If I had put them in I consider I should have done the same.

The Inspector afterwards referred to the rule with regard to the distance of a working from a place likely to contain water to a dangerous extent, and said that was meant as a protection, in addition to following plans.

By Mr. Brown: He repeated that he did not think flank holes would have answered in this case. He put the holes in the bottom of the drift to ascertain the extent of the coal and also to prove the water. If that was not in the strict letter of law he considered he was doing the thing in a much safer way. He put them in the direction of where he thought the water was. He arranged with Serginson to obtain bore rods from Oughterside, and he was going to get some from the owners. Nothing further was to be done until they got the rods. Considering the dry condition of the coal he considered there was no danger in sinking down from the last bore hole. He had been manager of the pit 19 years, and knew the seam very well. His experience and also that of the workmen, was that water passed very freely along the sole of the seam, and all his bore holes went down through the seam to the sole. If they had put in a fifteen feet borehole in the centre of the face it would have not touched water.

The Coroner said they had had a long inquiry, and he thought the various witnesses had put before the jury very plainly exactly what had happened. The duty of the jury was simply to ascertain the cause of Hutchinson's death. His Majesty's Inspector had drawn attention to a rule, which said "Where a place is likely to contain a dangerous accumulation the working approaching that place shall not at any point within 40 yards of that place exceed 8ft in width, and there shall be constantly kept as a sufficient distance, not being less than five yards in advance, and keep one bore hole near the centres of the working, and sufficient flank bore holes on each side." That pointed out the Coroner, was in order to ascertain where the water was, and if they got a bore hole five yards long the force of water could not break down that seam of coal, and the men could escape. Mr. Thomas probably had been relying upon the plan of the old workings, but at all events he told them that although he had not put any bore holes down, he was going to do so as soon as he got into the coal and had sufficient room. Of course there might have been an error of judgement or something like that, but in any event the jury had simply to find by what means the man meet his death, and whether there was any criminal responsibility.

The jury, after deliberating by themselves for a few minutes found that Hutchinson was accidentally drowned, through an inrush of water in the Dean Moor Colliery.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, John Boland    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Brown, J. Hope    Solicitor  
Clements, —    Miner  
Frears, John    Miner  
Hellon, Jackson    Miner  
Hutchinson, Peter   30 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Johnson, —    Manager  
Little, John    Miner  
Serginson, Wilkinson    Drifter  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Thomas, William    Manager  Whos Who Page
Thomas, William Watkyn    Mining Engineer  
Watsom, Jonathan    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Dean Moor Colliery  Dean Moor Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
13 Jun 1912  Sad Occurrence At Dean Moor Colliery (Whitehaven News)
12 Sep 1912  The Flooding Of Dean Moor Pit (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Dean Moor
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print