|
18th July 1912 Death Of A Cleator Moor MinerThe death took place on Sunday, of Mr. John Rowe, at 39, Birks-road, Cleator Moor. Deceased met with an accident on the 18th June, while engaged as a miner at the Berrier Pit, adjoining the Cleator Moor Goods Station, worked by the Berrier Mining Co. It appears on that date he was standing on the jack roll road, when one of the loaded bogies of metal ran down the incline, striking deceased on the side, knocking him down, and thereby causing injuries to his spine. He was removed to the surface, and a message was sent to Dr. Katon. After examination he was ordered to the Whitehaven Infirmary, where it was found that the spinal column of deceased was so severely injured that there was no hope of recovery. He was in the Institution seventeen days, and after wards removed to home, and was under the care of Dr. Byers until his death on Saturday last. The Inquest The inquiry into the death of Mr. John Rowe took place on Monday evening, in the Court House, Cleator Moor, before Mr. G. L. Skerry (Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont), and there were present: Mr. W. H. Chapman (representing the Berrier Mining Co), Mr. Gavan Duffy (for the deceased's relatives), Mr. Wm. Leck (Inspector of Mines), Mr. Richard Hartley (of Messrs. Walker & Hartley), and Sergt. Lindsay, Mr. Chas Gowan was chosen foreman over the jury. The first witness called was James Drake, 27, Wyndham-street, Cleator Moor, brother-in-law of deceased, who gave evidence of identification. Deceased was 44 years of age, and was engaged as an iron ore miner at the Berrier Pit. He last saw him alive on Saturday night at his home in Birks road. He died as a result of the accident he received on the 18th June. Mr. Sidney Kitchin, Woodend, Bigrigg, articled engineer with Messrs. Walker & Hartley, who are mining engineers to the Berrier Mining Co., said he was taking a survey for Messrs. Walker & Hartley in the pit on the 18th June. He had been in the No. 1 company before the accident occurred, and then proceeded to No. 5 Company for the purpose of setting lines. He saw the accident which happened to Rowe. At the time he was situated at the bottom of the dib for the purpose of taking his sight with the instruments, when he noticed a bogie getting filled in the forebreast. He asked the workmen in the forebreast if they wanted to get the bogie out first, so that he did not interfere with the work, to which they replied they would like the bogie out. He then shifted the instruments and legs, and stepped into the side. The bogie was then pushed to the bottom of the incline by the labourer Graham and there attached to the rope. It would be about 36 feet from the forebreast to the bottom of the incline. The labourer then lifted the bogie to the bottom of the incline and went to the top, and with the assistance of his brother commenced to draw the tub up with the jack roll. Witness was then standing in the side with the dial in his right hand and the legs in his left. He called to the man at the jack roll by the name of Jack, and Rowe, who was in the forebreast, answered the call. The reason he shouted was because he thought there was something which prevented the tub from going to the top. Rowe asked if he was wanted, and witness said he could do with him. He then came forward, proceeding up the centre of the railroad. Witness talked to him about where the back line should be put. The bogie was then being hauled up, and as near as he could tell near to the top. The distance from the bottom to the top would be about 30 feet. Witness noticed nothing, but heard deceased shout. At that time he would be about 26 feet from the bogie. Deceased made a jump to try and get to where witness was. His foot caught on the rail, and he stumbled backwards. In attempting to check the fall witness got hold of him, and in so doing deceased pulled him over on to the top of him, in the centre of the railroad. Witness was lying outside over him, and deceased straight along the lines with his feet up the hill. Witness had his right leg between the legs of deceased. The bogie then came down and struck witness on the knee. Deceased had his feet up, with the intention apparently of stopping the bogie. The bogie struck him on the feet, and he turned a complete somersault into the side. When the tub hit witness it slided him off deceased, and he went longways across the metals. The tub proceeding again, struck him on the calf and just under the arm. He had the dial legs in his right hand, which prevented him getting a second blow. Witness got up and proceeded to where Rowe was. He complained of his back, and said, "Oh my back." Witness tried to get up, but stumbled backwards, not knowing until then that he himself had received injuries. Assistance was obtained, and Rowe was conveyed up the pits. In the meantime assistance was at hand for witness, and he also was taken up the pit. Subsequently deceased was taken to the Whitehaven Infirmary. At the time witness thought it might have been the rope that was broken, and he inspected the rope, however, at the bogie and found it still fastened. The labourer Graham, and his brother were pulling the bogie up. The man named Graham attached the bogie to the rope. He knew how to do it. The incline of the dib would be about one in six and a half or one in seven. The bogie was full with about 11 cwts., of ore in. The weight of the empty bogie would be about 2½ cwt. Witness at the time was standing at the side, and there was plenty of room in both sides for deceased to stand. There would be about 5ft. on the left and perhaps 2½ft. on the right. Witness was standing about four or five feet from the bottom of the incline. By the Inspector: The two men would be practically the same distance away, the one at the top and the one at the forebreast. Plans were produced at this point showing the plan and section of the working where the accident happened and also that of the jack roll. Thomas William Fell, mining engineer's assistant, Beckermet, said the plans produced were prepared by him. Mr. Kitchin, on being examined further, said he had not commenced to set up his instrument. The labourer came out towards the bogie on the rope at the bottom, and walked up the incline to assist the other labourer. He found the rope afterwards was fastened to the bogie. The Inspector: Did it occur to you that you were in a dangerous position, especially when a bogie was being drawn up? Witness: It did, and I kept into the side. The Inspector: Is there a place of refuge in case anything goes amiss? Witness: There is plenty of room at the side - about 12ft. Mr. Duffy: Did you examine the whole of the rope? Witness: No, sir. Mr. Duffy: How long did you remain in the pit after the accident? Witness: I can't say. Rowe was taken up to the surface first and I myself afterwards. Mr. Duffy: How long have you been apprenticed to the Company. Witness: About two years and a half. I have been in most of the mines of the district. Mr. Duffy: Do you find the work of the mine go on the same when surveying is taking place? Witness: As a rule the men have their "pipe." Mr. Duffy: Is there a chain on the bogie? Witness: That I cannot say. Joseph Graham, iron ore labourer, 126, Ennerdale-road, said he worked at the Berrier Pit. He was working with Campbell and Rowe on the date of the accident 18th June. Witness was in No. 5 company, and his brother in No. 1 company. He saw Mr. Kitchin come along with dial. Mr. Kitchin wanted the bogie out from the forebreast so witness took it out and pushed it out about 36 feet on the level. He pushed it all that distance to get to the rope. He put the chain on to fasten the bogie. He put the hooks on to the two eye bolts. The bogie was full, and after witness attached the chain he went to the top of the incline for assistance. There was no one at the top when witness got there, but he got his brother, who was in No. 4 company. Witness and his brother got hold of the handle, and commenced to wind. The bogie came up right from the bottom, and got to about 4ft. from the top. They did not let go of the handles. If they had done so the bogie would certainly have gone back. They have no sprags in case anything goes wrong. The little cog wheel on the spindle of the jack roll got out of its place, with the result there was no hold on the drum, and the bogie ran back. They shouted as soon as it happened, because they knew Mr. Kitchin was at the bottom of the dib when witness left. He did not know where Rowe might be. Previously he heard Mr. Kitchin shout what was up with the bogie. The cog wheel was attached to the spindle, but there was no cotter pin to keep the cog wheel in its place. There had been none on since it was put up. There ought to have been one on, but he never suggested this. Witness was in charge of the jack roll, and had been for about four months, the time when it was put up. Witness did not see any likelihood of danger through there being no cotter pins to keep to keep the cogwheel in position. It was a new jack roll, but there was a place under for the cotter. There was never any signs of the cog shifting, and it never occurred to witness that it might do so. He had been in charge of jack rolls at Messrs. Ainsworth's Mines, Cleator. They were the same kind of jack rolls, and had cotter pins to keep the cogwheel in place. By the Inspector: It was a single rope, consequently the full bogie was pulled up before the empty was brought down. At first he thought the rope had broken away when it jerked his handle. He had been working with the jack roll since it came into the pit, and had never noticed there was any play on it. He could not account why it should have happened. By Mr. Duffy: I have worked seven years at the mines, and I have worked eight months at the Berrier and four months on the jack roll. The jack roll was inspected by Mr. Barnes, the manager, perhaps twice or three times a week. He would examine the gear in connection with it, the ropes and the cogwheels. Witness: I did not point out that the cotter pin was necessary. There was a place for the cotter pin but no groove. Mr. Barnes, manager of the Berrier Mine, 17, Lamb-lane, Egremont, said he was present when the accident happened. He was familiar with the jack roll, and was in the habit of inspecting it. They got it from Messrs. Heathcote's Foundry, Cleator Moor, on the 11th April. It was a common type of jack roll, was strong and suitable for its work, as far as witness knew. The cogwheel was put on a square shafting and driven on tight. There never was a key way made. He had often inspected the jack roll, but never saw it out of its place. He never thought of looking particularly at this wheel. It always seemed all right when witness examined it. A keyway and key on the shafting would be a good suggestion. They had made up their minds to key all the other jack rolls. The Foreman: Don't you think it singular it should slip its full length on the day and never been seen before? — It does. The empty bogies, witness stated, were let down by hand. There was only about 30 feet of a fall. Inspector: Is it not possible this cog might have been almost off before coming up? — Yes. The cogwheel is on the driving shaft so that once the cog actually shifted out there would be no control. — Yes. There was plenty of places to get out of the road in case of danger. At this point the Inspector pointed out that there was no statutory obligation to provide places of refuge in dib places under 20 yards long. When you got this man up the pit what provision did you make for him? I sent for Dr. Katon. He came in fifteen minutes, and while he was examining him I telephoned for the ambulance. I got him examined and then sent him to the Infirmary. We have ambulance equipment at the pit and ambulance men. The men did what they could. Our instructions from the doctor were that we had to move him as little as possible. By Mr. Duffy: I have had eight years' experience in the pits. I was at the pit at the time of the accident on the surface. I went down afterwards and inspected the gear. There was no teeth broken on either the large or small cogwheels. Witness examined the rope from one end to the other, also the chains, and they were quite perfect. He attributed the accident to the cogwheel slipping out of its place. He did not examine the cogwheel that morning. It might have prevented an accident if they had had a clutch on the roll. Mr. Bellman, Earl-street, Cleator Moor, manager for Messrs. Heathcote's Foundry, Cleator Moor, stated that the firm he represented made the jack roll in question for the Berrier Co. They had been in the habit of making them without cotter pins. They had supplied them elsewhere. It is a very common form of jack roll. The shaft was slightly tapered toward the short end and driven on tight. There was the possibility of making the shaft straight. He could not account for the cog slipping. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death," with a recommendation that the cogwheels for jack rolls in future be fitted with cotter pins to prevent them shifting out of place. The Foreman expressed the sympathy of the jury for the relatives of the deceased. Mr. Rowe had been brought up in Cleator Moor, and was amongst the best respected and esteemed citizen they had. Mr. W. H. Chapman, on behalf of the Berrier Mining Co., expressed their regret at the accident, and also wished to give this assurance of regret to the relatives of deceased.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||