Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

2nd April 1912

High Court Of Justice

Kings Bench Division

A Colliery Explosion

Coroner's Claim.

Rex v. Durham County Council.

(Before Mr. Justice Ridley, Mr. Justice A. T. Lawrence, and Mr. Justice Pickford.)

This was the argument on a rule which had been obtained directed to the Durham County Council to show cause why a writ of mandamus should not issue commanding them to pay to the applicant, John Graham, Coroner for the Chester ward of Durham, the sum of £138 15s. 6d. and interest, being the balance claimed as due to him of the disbursements made by him in connexion with the inquests held by him between February 18, 1909, and April 1, 1909, on the bodies of 166 persons who were killed in the West Stanley Colliery explosion on February 16, 1909.

Mr. Danckwerts, K.C., and Mr. Simey appeared for the County Council to show cause ; Mr. Macmorran, K.C., and Mr. Kenneth Macmorran, for the Coroner, appeared in support of the rule.

Argument For The County Council.

Mr. Danckwerts said that the claim made by the Coroner was in respect of payments to constables, £8 15s. 6d., and to the jury, £171. Of those sums the county council had allowed £1 in respect of the payments to the constables and £40 in respect of payments to the jury, leaving therefore £7 15s. 6d. claimed for the constables and £131 claimed for the jury. The explosion out of which the claim arose having occurred on February 16, 1909, the Coroner was informed, and he issued his warrant for a jury to be summoned. On February 18 the inquest was opened on 51 bodies ; the jury were sworn 51 times, and 51 bodies were viewed. On February 19 the same jury were sworn 46 times, and 46 bodies were viewed. The same jury were sworn on subsequent days and they viewed other bodies. There were in all 166 bodies, and the same jury were sworn 166 times. Adjournments were held, and on April 1 the inquest was concluded.

Correspondence took place between the Coroner and the county council as to what payments should be allowed in respect of the inquests, the result being that certain repayments to the Coroner were directed to be allowed ; but the county council finally refused in May, 1910, to authorize the payments now claimed. On December 31, 1910, the Coroner, however, made the payments in question, although he knew the attitude taken up by the county council. Before this, and while the correspondence above referred to was proceeding, one of the jurymen raised a test action in the County Court against the Coroner and the county council claiming his fees, but the County Court Judge decided that there was no cause of action.

He (counsel) submitted that the Coroner was not entitled to claim the amounts in question, inasmuch as it was unlawful to hold separate inquests on 166 bodies by a jury summoned by warrant for one inquest only. He referred to Sewell on Coroners, p. 156 ; Jervis on Coroners (1829 edition), p. 408 ; Reg. V. West (5 Jun., 485) ; and In re Mitchelstown (22 L.R., lr., 279, at p. 209). Further, the Coroner was precluded from recovering, as by s. 26 of the Coroners Act, 1887, the Coroner was required to pay the fees allowed by the scale made under the Act immediately after the termination of the inquest ; and by s. 27 it was provided that the Coroner should, within four months after the holding of the inquest, cause a full and true account of all sums paid by him to be laid before the local authority, by whom the sums should be reimbursed.

In this case the payments were not made in time and no account was sent in by the Coroner till long after the expiration of the four months. In these circumstances the county council had no power to pay the sums claimed. Moreover, the Police Act, 1890, repealed the scale under the Coroners Act so far as it applied to payments to police-constables ; the payments to the police-constables were not therefore permissible.

Mr. Simey, following on the same side, submitted that, apart from the points raised by Mr. Danckwerts, it was a case where two or more inquests had been held concurrently within the meaning of the note to the schedule to the scale made under the Coroners Act by the local authority.

Argument For The Coroner.

Mr. Macmorran, in support of the rule, said it was necessary to consider what actually happened. On news of the accident reaching him the Coroner instructed the constable to summon a jury at once ; 51 bodies were brought up from the pit ; the jury were separately sworn with reference to each body, separate evidence was given as to each, and a separate verdict was returned as to each ; and each inquest was therefore separate and distinct. Inquests could never be concurrent at the beginning ; evidence as to identity and other matters must always differ as to each body, and inquests could only become concurrent at a point where evidence began to be given, such as scientific evidence as to the cause of an explosion, which was common to all the bodies concerned. The word concurrent did not only mean contemporaneous, but implied proceedings which were common to all.

As to the constable, Mr. Danckwerts had submitted that under the statute of 1890 a constable in such a case was not entitled to a fee at all, but the county council had authorized the Coroner to pay it. As to the time within which claims had to be sent in, it was true that under section 27 (1) of the Coroners act, 1887, the Coroner was ordered to send in his accounts within four months ; but where there was a reasonable explanation for the delay a mandamus must still issue even if the time had been exceeded — Reg. V. Leigh Rural District Council (1898, 1 Q.B., 836) ; Croydon Corporation v. Croydon Rural District Council (1908, 2 Ch., 321). No one could say that on the particular facts there was not a reasonable explanation of the delay in this case. The Coroner was not asking for fees for himself, but was only asking to be repaid sums which he had already paid.

Judgement.

Mr. Justice Ridley said in his opinion the rule must be discharged.

After stating the facts his Lordship said that, as to the fees paid to the members of the jury, there were in his opinion concurrent inquests being held and the note to the schedule applied. An inquest was being held on each body ; it was not one inquest only, because there were different causes of death and the inquests did not begin at the same time ; they were concurrent inquests, because one was not completed before the next was begun. That being so, the Coroner was wrong in allowing £171 as the fees to which the jury were entitled as within the maximum fixed, and he could not now have a mandamus to make the county council repay that sum to him. The county council contended, rightly, that the jury were only entitled to 1s. for each day, but as a matter of grace they allowed fees to an amount of £40.

As to the fees paid by the Coroner to the constable, in his Lordship's opinion the combined effect of sections 26 and 27 of the Coroners Act, 1887, and section 23 of the Police Act, 1890, was to make the Coroner wrong in that respect also.

Mr. Justice Lawrence agreed, and said that in his opinion there were concurrent inquests whenever there was a cause of death affecting more than one body. He regretted the result for the Coroner ; but the Coroner had taken his own course throughout and had acted with his eyes open.

Mr. Justice Pickford concurred.

Solicitors — Sharpe, Pritchard, and Co., for Harold Jevons, Durham ; Haslam and Sanders, for Graham, Shepherd, and Sons, Sunderland.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Danckwerts, —      
Graham, John      
Macmorran, —      
Macmorran, Kenneth      
Simey, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

West Stanley Colliery  West Stanley Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print