|
14th December 1911 Shocking Accident At Fletcher PitBogie Falls Down ShaftAn unusual accident occurred on Wednesday at the Postlethwaite Mining Company's Fletcher Pit, Moor Row, which unfortunately resulted in the death of a fine young man, Edward Telfer, 28 years of age, married, who lived at 83, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, and was a pit sinker engaged at Fletcher Pit. Telfer had commenced work that morning at half-past ten, along with three other men named Thompson, Boland and Stewart. They had prepared a blasting shot and were about to be raised up out of the shaft in the "kibble," about half-past eleven. At that time it was blowing a gale. Thomas Kinnett, sinker at the pit top, had left the tram boggie standing on the rails on the top raised platform while he went down for the purpose of assisting the men out of the kibble; when the bogie, which it is supposed was started during the gale, came down and knocked up a wooden guard that was intended to prevent anything falling down the shaft, and fell down the pit on to the kibble, striking the deceased and inflicting fearful injuries on him. An alarm was at once raised and assistance given and the deceased was brought to the surface. Dr. Eaton's assistant, who had been sent for, attended to the unfortunate man until the arrival of the Cleator Moor ambulance, when the patient was carried to the Whitehaven Infirmary. The case was hopeless, and Telfer died about ten o'clock on Thursday morning. Deceased, who formerly belonged to Whitehaven, being a son of the late Mr. William Telfer, of Senhouse-street, and had been living at Cleator Moor for about twelve months, was a member of the Whitehaven Section of the 4th East Lancashire (Howitzer) Brigade of Royal Field Artillery, and was well known and held in esteem. Mr. Atter opened the inquest at the Infirmary on Thursday evening, and stated that it would have to be adjourned for the attendance of a Government Inspector. Charles Telfer, 23, Egremont-road, Hensingham, brother of the deceased, stated that the deceased was a coal-hewer, but latterly had been following pit sinking. Mr. R. Wilson, the foreman of the jury, stated that on behalf of the jury and himself he wished to express their deep sympathy with the widow and child of the deceased. He said he knew deceased personally, and he was a very finely build young man. The inquest was adjourned till Wednesday. The Adjourned Inquest. Yesterday (Wednesday) afternoon, Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland, held the adjourned inquest at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary touching upon death of Edward Telfer, 28 years of age, married, 83, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, who died on Thursday 7th inst, through injuries caused by a bogie falling upon him at Postlethwaite Mining Co's Fletcher Pit, Moor Row, on Wednesday, the 6th. Mr. R. Wilson was the chosen foreman. Mr. J. B. Atkinson, His Majesty's Chief Inspector, and Mr. W. Leck, His Majesty's Inspector of Mines, were present, while Mr. J. Hope Brown, solicitor, Whitehaven, appeared on behalf of the Company; and Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy represented the relatives of the deceased. Mr. John McKellar Main, jun., submitted plans of the pit shaft, and also a small model which showed the action of the tram and the guard on the top of the shaft. The Coroner: Was that model made for this inquest? Mr. Main: Yes. The Coroner: I commend you for it. It has been very helpful. Ralph Boland, 61, Penzance-street, Moor Row, said he was a sinker. He had worked in the pit for about six months, and his mate was the deceased. J. Thompson and a man named Stewart were in their gang. On Wednesday night, at about 10.30 they were working together filling muck from the shaft bottom. When they finished that they were going to come up the pit. Deceased and himself were in the "kibble," coming up, at about eleven o'clock. Something was making a rumbling noise in the shaft. It was an unusual noise, and he had never heard it before. It did not continue long, perhaps two or three minutes. Something struck the "kibble," but he was not hurt. He was face to face with Telfer. The "kibble" started to sway, and it was then that he missed his friend. One of his mates shouted that deceased was laying in the kibble. It was a very rough night. By Mr. J. B. Atkinson: They were standing in the kibble with both legs inside. They were not rigging or standing on the edges. When they were struck they would be about ten or twelve feet from the bottom. The engineman stopped the kibble, and it was lowered to the bottom. Deceased was got into the kibble and taken to the top, he (the witness) and Mr. Stewart also going with the body. When they got to the bank they got off at the first level. He did not know exactly what it was that struck him, although he thought at first it was a piece of iron. He had never known anything all down the shaft before. When witness got to the top he did not examine anything about the pit. He was very seldom on the upper level, and he knew how the shaft was fenced. Following the accident the wind was blowing very strongly, but he could not tell which way. By Mr. Duffy: When he and the deceased got to the top it would be about 11-30 p.m. When they got to the surface they were assisted by the engineman and the banker. The latter came down from the surface to help them. When the deceased was in the engineroom, the master and the doctor were sent for. The latter was not very long in coming to the engine-room. They telephoned away for the ambulance, but he could not say where time it arrived. It might be after three o'clock before it did so. He could not say whether the wind was a "top wind." There was a fence at the top of the mine. By the Jury: He thought the thing was quite safe when he went down the pit. William Stewart, 98, Ennerdale-road, Wath Brow, said he was a sinker at the Fletcher Pit. On Wednesday he was working with the deceased. He saw Bolan and Telfer get into the kibble. He and another man named Thompson heard a rumbling sound. The banker shouted, and the engine-man stopped the kibble and then followed a crash. He did not see anyone fall out of the kibble. Witness went to the bottom with three others, where they saw the deceased lying on the ground. One of his arms was bleeding and bulged up. There was a mark on his brow. They then took him up to the surface in the kibble. When they got to the top they were helped by the banker and the engineman. They took the deceased to the engine-room, and then sent for the doctor. It was the carrier of the kibble that had fallen, and it was a heavy structure. By the Inspector: Witness was very seldom on the upper level. He knew what the arrangements were in regard to the landing of the kibbles. The arm about the winding face could not be raised unless the pit was covered. He could not account for how the carrier got down the pit. He did not examine the pit top after the accident. By the Coroner: He could not say whether the kibble was going at its ordinary speed, because it was only then or twelve feet up. By the Inspector: When witness asked Bolan where the deceased was, Bolan was standing with both feet in the kibble. When they got into the kibble they stood with both feet inside, and never rode on the edge. Three kibbles of stones had gone up previous to the accident. The last kibble had gone up about ten minutes previously. He could not say how he and the witness escaped. They were in the end of the pit. It was 19 feet long and seven or eight feet broad. There were four compartments, and only one was used for winding. He had no theory as to how the carrier came down the pit. When they landed at the surface, a lorry was shoved under the kibble. By Mr. Duffy: One of the compartments in the shaft was a ladder way. He did not know anything about the working of the machinery at the surface, except that a lorry came under the kibble. The carrier would weigh approximately four or five cwt. in weight, but he could not say how the injuries to the deceased were caused. By Mr. Brown: He did not know where the tipper fell from. By the foreman: He could not give a reason how it was that the other men were not struck. By the Coroner: He could not blame anyone for the accident. John Thompson, Trumpet-terrace, Cleator, said he was in charge of the gang at the bottom of the pit. Deceased had worked most of his time with him. At about eleven o'clock or 11.30, the tram came down the shaft, and he saw the deceased at the bottom of the pit. He heard a rumbling sound. He saw the tram fall on the kibble, but he did not know who was in the kibble. When they asked Bolan if deceased was in the kibble, and he said "No," they were bound to know that he would be at the pit bottom. Every assistance was given to the deceased at the pit top. He had never known anything else fall down the pit. It was an exceptionally wild night; one of the wildest he had ever known since he had worked at the pit. He had no complaint about the place not being safe, and he did not feel insecure now about going to his work again. By the Inspector: The banksman was not in his charge. Witness had occasionally been on the pit top, but he had not been there that night. When the pit top was open the bar couldn't be raised, and when it was closed it could be raised. Mr. Duffy objected to the banker's presence in the room, saying that he was a very material witness. The banksman then left the room. Continuing, the witness, in reply to Mr. Atkinson, said on Monday he was at the pit top, and men were present "doing it up." He imagined that the wind blew the carrier forward. He could not account for the carrier getting past the arm. He was aware that the stand had been damaged, and it was possible that that had been done by the tram getting blown against it. Both men, when they were going up in the kibble, had both their legs inside. By Mr. Duffy: He had worked at the pit since January last. He did not know how many times he had been at the top. He had nothing to do with the workings at the top. He thought the wind had blown the carrier down, because he was of opinion that it could be nothing else. There was a wooden hut at the top of the shaft, but he couldn't say how thick the wood was. The carrier was a skeleton, but he did not see any reason why the hut should have been blown down because the carrier was, because the latter was on wheels. An iron bar would be better than a wooden one, as it would be less liable to break. Mr. Duffy: Wouldn't it be stronger? Witness: It might. Mr. Duffy: That's an evasion. Mr. Atter: No, no; don't say that. Mr. Atter asked Mr. Duffy if he was making certain allegations of neglect. Mr. Duffy said that the man was brought from the pit at eleven o'clock. A doctor was sent for, and the manager was preset. Yet he thought that it was a shame for a man to be left lying in his wet clothes from twelve midnight until 4.25 in the morning. It was not human, and it was inclined to make one use strong language. Mr. Atter said he did not see where there was any neglect. Mr. Duffy: No neglect! Allowing a man to be in his clothes from twelve midnight until 4.25! It is brutal! Mr. Atter: I wish you wouldn't use such expressions. Mr. Duffy was understood to say that he did not complain against the treatment at the infirmary. He knew that everyone that was admitted were well attended to. What he complained of was the delay. The first witness then got up from his seat and said the deceased was not left in his wet clothes. He was wrapped up and bandaged. After further discussion the matter closed. Thos. Menhennet, banker, said he tipped two kibbles, and Mr. Thompson one, before the accident occurred. He then went down to the surface, and his torchlight was blown out. He then heard a crash, and he shouted down to the men "Look up." It was the tram that had fallen, and he thought it was the gale that had blown it down. When deceased was taken to the engine-room he was bandaged and made comfortable. The doctor arrived at the pit-top at about mid-night. When the deceased was brought to the top it would be about 11.15 p.m. They telephoned to Cleator Moor to come and remove the deceased. There was no un-necessary delay on the part of anyone. He never thought that the wind could blow the tram down the pit. He was of opinion that the arm had been forced up. An iron bar might snap, and he did not know whether it would be an advantage over the wooden one. By the Inspector: He had been to the pit-top since the accident. There was a crack in one of the stands which supported the bar. The top of it was leaning towards the pit top, whilst the bar was forced up. It was not broken, however. He would not tell him the condition of the bar after the accident. He left the carrier about six feet from the bar. There was no kibble on it, but the carrier was secured by a chain which was fastened to the railings. There was a chain on the carrier, but he did not use that one to fasten the carrier. He stuck the hook of the other chain from the railings into a hole in the carrier, which he thought was used for an oil hole. He had never had any instructions to use the chain on the carrier for the purpose of fastening it. It was used when the carrier was tippled. The officials had seen him fasten the carrier by the hole, and Mr. James had told him to put it round the arm. He himself thought the other way was more secure. Mr. James had not told him to secure the carrier by the oil hole. He had seen the hook on Friday, and he noticed that the link had been opened a little, as though it had been prised. He had never heard of a carrier being blown forward before. The carrier, if put slowly forward, could not get under the bar. Since the accident, however the bar had been placed five or six inches lower down. A sudden gust of wind might have forced the link to open a little. He had been with the inspector at the shaft that day; and although it was very windy, it was much worse on the date of the accident. His view was that they gale struck the end of the carrier, forced the link open,and then went towards the shaft, forcing the bar up and breaking the standard, and then going down the shaft. He would not be afraid to work in the bottom now that the bar had been lowered. By Mr. Duffy: His real opinion was that the wind blew the carrier down the pit. His wooden hut was left standing whilst the iron skeleton was blown away. He did not know what to think about this. Dr. Eaton's house was either a mile or a mile and a quarter away from the house. He could not tell what time the ambulance arrived. The chain to hold the carrier was put there by one of his friends, and it had been there before 1st of November. He did not know who provided it, and he had never heard any of the men complain and say that they had put it there for their own protection. If the whole of the standard and the bar had been made of either iron or steel it could not be broken. When they took the deceased into the engine-house they wrapped him up with old clothes and bandaged him. With the exception of these there were no other clothes used. He did not know whether anyone had straightened the hook to get it into the oil hole. By Mr. Brown: When they were on the pit-top there was no one left behind. The only suggestion was that the wind blew the carrier down the shaft. Had the standard been firm and complete it cold not have got by the rod on the top. By the Foreman: The chain was not broken, but it was straightened out. By Mr. Brown: The bar was quite low enough if the standard had been firm. By Mr. Duffy: The chain was made of stretched iron. Mr. Samuel James, John-street, Moor Row, said he was under-ground manager, and had been at the pit for three years. The first knowledge he had of the accident was at about twelve o'clock, when he was "knocked up." He at once got up and went straight to the mine. He saw that deceased was taking no harm. There was not much blood, but there was a little coming from the arm. The deceased shouted a little. The doctor arrived about half-an-hour later, and he did his duty. Witness, after having the advice from the doctor, sent a man to telephone for the ambulance. After a long while the ambulance arrived, and he thought that the wild night had had something to do with the wires. They could only get to the exchange, so a lad was sent for the ambulance. He got there before the telephone message was received. Although they thought it a long while they did not think there was an unreasonable delay. As soon as they got the message the ambulance was quickly on the scene. He was certain that something must have moved the carrier. It was quite probable that when the standard was broken it forced up the arm and allowed the carrier to go through. The bar had now been lowered, and he thought it was quite safe. A steel bar of the same length as the wooden bar would bend very easily. Again, it would not be able to work right, and he himself preferred a wooden bar. Every Monday he inspected the pit head, and before the accident he considered that everything was safe. By the Inspector: It would have been better had the banksman carried out his instructions. He examined the standard shortly after the accident, and found that the bar would lift a foot or so, although it was actually down when he saw it. There was a mark in the centre of the bar, but the pin was in, and the thing was locked. He did not pay much attention to the chain. The same arrangement was used at No. 6 Pit, and he understood that Mr. Kendall was the inventor of it. By Mr. Duffy: He had been at the mine for 16 years, and had been under-manager for three years. One the day of the accident he did not call at the pit, but his deputy was present. He reported to him that all was safe. A blacksmith supplied the chain, but he could not say when the chain was put up. By the Foreman: An iron bar might make the standard safer. They were willing to carry out any recommendations made by them. By a juryman: He did not know that it was a stormy night until he went to the pit. Had he been present he would not have allowed the men in a sinking pit on such a night. By Mr. Brown: The men working below were not his servants. Mr. Thompson, re-called, said he had worked in mines all his life, and he did not see any danger in working that night. There were no suggestions by the men to come out. He had worked in gales. By the Inspector: He had sunk shafts for almost 20 years, and he had only had to come up once. The Inspector: In some respects people are safer underground in wild weather. Dr. Craig stated deceased was admitted to the Infirmary on the Thursday at 4.30 a.m. His injuries were severe. He had a compound fracture of the thigh. His right arm was broken, and one of his legs was broken in two places. He was in an unconscious condition. There was a light would on the head, and Telfer died at ten o'clock on Thursday morning. He died from shock, consequent upon the injuries, and there was little hope for his recovery from the very first. By Mr. Duffy: Had the deceased had medical treatment two hours previous to admittance to the Infirmary, he would not then have been able to save him. Inspector Sheffield said as far as he knew everything was done to obtain the ambulance. Mrs. Telfer, the widow, said the deceased had been employed at the Postlethwaite Pit for nine months. The Coroner, in summing up, said it had been a very exhaustive inquiry. The model and the plans had been of very great assistance. The witnesses had given their evidence in a very fair and honest manner. Since the occurrence there had been a slight alteration to the bar. He thought that the witness Menhennet had given his evidence very satisfactorily, and although he had disobeyed orders he submitted that it might only have been an error of judgment. He thought if there was any blame on his part it was not wilful. The Inspector had said that some people were safer down the pit than on the top. There was no foundation for what Mr. Duffy had said with regard to the treatment of the deceased. In his estimation everything was done possible to help the deceased. Where the brutality came in he did not know. An observation which was not justified made mischief, and should ever be made. If they found there was no neglect he suggested that they should return a verdict of "Accidental death," as occasion to him on the night of the 7th. The jury retired to consider their decision, and on returning the Foreman said they thought the accident was quite unavoidable. They took no notice whatever of the remarks made by Mr. Duffy, and they thought they were uncalled for. The Coroner: I quite agree with your decision on both points. Mr. Duffy said that he was entitled to say a few words, to which the Coroner said he did not think so, but he would allow him. Mr. Duffy then said that it was the family's wish that the matter should be raised. He contended that deceased had not been treated properly. Mr. Atter: I cannot allow this. Mr. Duffy: It amounts to nothing. The Coroner: If as you say it amounts to nothing I shall take steps to stop it. It is totally unjustifiable. Further words then passed between the Coroner and Mr. Duffy. Mr. Brown, on behalf of the Company, expressed his deep sympathy with the relatives of the deceased man. Deceased was buried in the St. John's Church-yard, Cleator Moor, on Sunday, amid manifestation of much grief and sorrow. During the time he had resided on Cleator Moor, he had made a host of friends. He was a member of the Whitehaven Section 4th East Lancashire (Howitzer) Brigade, R.F.A., and a large number of the members of the brigade preceded the remains, which were borne by six of the members of the 5th Border Regiment. The funeral cortege left Duke-street shortly after three, and from thence to the church large numbers of sympathisers were in evidence, notwithstanding the most inclement weather prevailing. The coffin, which was draped with the Union Jack, was covered with wreaths, and on top was placed the hat and belt which deceased wore when associated with the brigade. In the church the hymn, "Abide with me," was feelingly sung, the service being conducted by the Vicar (the Rev. W. Taylor). As the coffin was being lowered into the grave, the members of the brigade fired a salute. Many beautiful wreaths were sent, including one from the workmen at Fletcher Pit, the officers and non-com-officers and men of the Whitehaven and Workington Brigades. Mr. James, the manager of the pit, was present at the funeral.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||