|
21st September 1911 Fatal Mining Accident At FrizingtonTwo Men KilledOn Thursday morning a sad accident took place in the Park Side Mining Company's Crossgill Mine, Frizington, which caused the death of William Cowin, miner, aged 30 years, who resided at Jacktrees-road, Cleator Moor, who was married and had two children, and Peter Huddart, labourer, 26 years of age, who resided at Frizington-road, Frizington. It appears these men, who were attached to No. 6 Company, proceeded to their working as usual in the middle eye of the mine, and about eight o'clock, without any warning a large fall of stone took place from the side of the working, and completely buried the two unfortunate men. An alarm was at once raised, and Mr. W. Thompson, manager, and Mr. Pidd, deputy, were soon in attendance, and made all the necessary arrangements, whilst every effort was made to extricate the unfortunate victims, which, however, took some time to accomplish. Both were found dead, and judging from their injuries were undoubtedly killed instantly. Mr. Scoular was also summoned, and descended the mine before the bodies were recovered. On being brought to the surface, Dr. Byers and his assistant were in attendance. The bodies were removed to their respective homes to await the inquest. Crossgill Mine Fatality. Fall Of 25 Tons. The inquest on Peter Huddart and W. H. Cowin, the two men who were killed on Thursday forenoon by a heavy fall in the Parkside Company's Crossgill Mine, Frizington, was held at the Frizington District Council Chamber, on Saturday morning. Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland, was the coroner, acting for Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, the coroner for the lordship of Egremont, in whose district the accident occurred, and who was himself unwell. Mr. Atkinson, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines for the district, was present. Mr. G. Scoular, general manager of the Parkside Company, was also present. He said he would just like to say, on behalf of his partners and himself how very much they regretted that this had happened, and that they wished to express their sympathy with the relatives of the deceased, who were both very fine young fellows. The Coroner: Thank you. It is well that those who have lost their relatives should know that they had the goodwill of the employers. I will see that the relatives of the deceased are made aware of the sympathy you have expressed. Thos. S. Durham, surveyor, produced a plan showing the spots where the bodies were found, and the broken ground; and the witness pointed out how the men were working and the place on the side from which the stone dropped away, the top of the fall being 11ft., in height. Adam Huddart deposed that he lived at 25, Frizington-road, Frizington, and was a miner and the father of Peter Huddart. Peter was 26 years of age, and was a miners' labourer and had been several years working at the Parkside Pit. He was a single man. Frederick Cowin deposed that he lived at 41, Trumpet-road, Cleator, and was a miner. Deceased, William Henry Cowin, was his brother. Deceased was a married man, and was 30 years of age; he worked at Crossgill Pit, and had worked with the Parkside Co. since he was 16 years of age. Joseph Thompson deposed that he lived at Cleator Moor and was a miner at the Crossgill Pit, where he had worked for 25 years. He was well acquainted with Cowin and Huddart. He went to work at six o'clock on the day of the accident, and the deceased men were working with him. He had a bogie, and the deceased were filling on the right hand side of him. The accident happened about eight o'clock in the morning. Before beginning work he examined the working himself, sounding it with a hammer. It took him perhaps 10 minutes or a quarter of an hour. There was no difficulty about it. It appeared perfectly safe, and he had no hesitation in working there. He examined the place every morning, and two or three times a day. There was no flaw to be seen, and they thought it was quite safe. There were five of them altogether. The deputy, Fred Pidd, came a few minutes before eight, and looked round. Witness had been working on the same level two or three years. Before the accident he heard no noise — not the least. A fall came down from the side like the shot of a gun. All lights were put out, and they could not tell what had happened until assistance and lights came. There was one lump of ten or eleven tons among the stuff that had fallen. He could not tell the weight of all the fall. The two men were buried. Assistance came in a minute or two, and every effort was made to recover the bodies. In an hour or so Cowin's body was recovered, and in perhaps in another hour Huddart was recovered. There had been no shot-firing since the previous Friday. He had worked there since, and seen nothing wrong. The shot-firing brought down a few tons. He thought the cause of the fall at the time of the accident was that the weight of the metal above it had brought the stone down. There was plenty of timber if they had wanted it, but anything they thought was dangerous they brought down. By the Inspector: I could not tell you whether the overman Pidd examined the place before we went in. We did not see him before we went in. We are not supposed to see him before going in. We usually do see him, and if there is anything particular he tells us in the morning. The "middling" had shrunk down about a week before, and we had been filling the metal ever since. During that time the place had been quiet. We put some shots in the metal to break it up, after the middling fell. We had not had any on the Thursday morning. The stone shot down from where the middling had been holding — the middling really had held it. There was a width of about 12ft. of it. Was there anything to prevent you putting a stay across? — I don't think a stay would have been any good. That is not the question I ask you. If it had been any use. You often put a stay in a place 12ft. wide, don't you? — Not in a place like that. What makes you think a stay would not be any use? — We naturally thought the ground was all right and that it was not required? But that is not he question. Could you have got the wood if you had thought it was necessary? — Yes. Are you working by the ton? — Yes. And you would not have got any extra pay, would you, if you had put a stay in? — No, not any. I suppose if Pidd had directed you to do anything you would have done it? — Yes. Now you say it gave no sufficient warning for anybody to escape? — No, not the least. Did it all fall at once, or did it continue falling? — No, one fall, all together. Have you looked at it carefully since? — Yes. Was there any back? — No, not the least. Just a burst off? — Yes. There were six in the company, but once of you was off, I believe? — Yes. Now in a company like that does one of you generally take charge as leading man? — No, one is as good as the other, as far as that goes. Which will be the most experienced? — They are all experienced, as far as I know. The miners' labourers would not be experienced? — Well, not the miners' labourers. Then did you all examine the place? — Yes. Do you mean to say you go over it and sounded it and all the rest also go over it and sound it? — Yes, they gave me assistance. By Mr. Scoular: We did not suspect that this stone was in any way dangerous. We expected it was solid. If we suspected it we would have brought it down. You think you would not have timbered it? — Well, if we thought it would be best to timber it we would have timbered it, and if not we would have brought it down. But you had not the slightest suspicion? — No. And the other men, who were all experienced except Huddart, never expressed any doubt about it? — No, not the least. By Adam Huddart, the father of the deceased. Had there been some severe falls in the vicinity a day or two previous? — Not where the accident was. A few fathoms away there had been, but not near this place. By the Foreman: You say all the four of you examined the stone. Had you some suspicion of it? — Not the least. Is it the practice for all four to examine the place? — Oh, it is a customary thing for them to examine it all round, and sometimes two or three times during a shift. And you had no suspicion of the thing whatever? -No. James Richie deposed that he was a miner working at Crossgill Pit, where he had worked for many years. He was working with the deceased men on Thursday morning. There were five of them. Before they started working Joe Thompson sounded the place and there was not the lest sign of danger. The deputy came up and said nothing. They had had no intimation of anyone else having sounded the place except Thompson. Nothing happened in that respect different that day to any other. The deputy had been there before them, but there was no mark left on any shovel or anything like that. Nothing happened until the fall came down like the shot of a gun. There had been no shot-firing that day. There was some stone brought down the day before. Witness had no hesitation about working there. Witness thought as to the cause of the fall that it might have been a crack behind or anything like that, but he did not know what fetched it. It could not have been propped — it was too high. The Inspector: You could have put a stay across 12ft., could not you? — We did not think it necessary. I suppose very often when you have a fall like that you get warning? — Yes, sir. But in this case you got none? — No. If you had had a few seconds warning you could have got clear — all of you? — Yes. Benjamin McWilliams deposed that he lived at Cleator Moor and had worked at Crossgill Pit about two years. He was working with the two deceased men on Thursday last. He thought the place was all right. He saw Thompson examine it before they commenced. He was quite close to the deceased when the fall came down without any warning. By the Inspector: I don't think anything could have been done to prevent it. If we had suspicion, the only way would have been to have shot her down. We would not have put a stay in, the way this ground was to be any good, with a weight of ground like that. The Inspector: I think a stay might easily have held it. However, you did not think it necessary? — We did not think it necessary — no. But if you had put a stay in and it did not hold it, it might have given you a little warning? — Well, it might. By bending or cracking a little at first? — It might. Frederick Pidd deposed: I live at 22, Duke-street, Frizington, and I am a deputy at Crossgill, and have been so for about five years, for the whole day, and for four years previously I was deputy in the morning. I inspected this place before the men went in on Thursday. That was at a quarter past five. I inspected the place and tested the side with a hammer, for about ten minutes. If anything had been wrong I would have left a mark. If something was wrong I would have marked the place with chalk. I had never marked that place; there had never been anything wrong with it. I came back to the place about a quarter to eight, and the men told me they had sounded the side before they had started. They were accustomed to sound the place every morning. I was away in another place when the accident happened, and we heard the fall, and we rushed to the place to help. There was one lump of the fall about nine tons in weight; and there might be about 18 tons in all. It took some time to get the bodies clear of the fall. It was about an hour before we got the first body out, and it would be about another hour before we got the second. I don't know what caused it, except the hanging over and the weight. I don't think we could have prevented it. I don't think we could have put in wood to have done any good. I did not think there was any risk in working there, and I would have not allowed them to work there if I had thought there was. They were experienced men. Have there been any other accidents in this pit, or has it been one very free from fatal accidents? — There has never been one fatal accident before in that pit, for 14 or 15 years. There was one 10 years ago in No. 19, but there has never been one in this pit; and we employ about 150 men, altogether, daily. By the Inspector: I have eight places to examine before the men come in. Some take a little more than ten minutes — ten minutes to a quarter of an hour. We go up the pit about ten minutes to six and stop at the surface. The men do not come down till six o'clock. If there is anything wrong we have an opportunity of speaking to them before they go down. I don't think a stay would have been any use in that place. If I had had any suspicion I would have shot the stone down. The men had to do their own timbering, the timber being provided for them. It was not usual to look to one man in a company to act as leader. Don't you think it would be better if there was a sort of leading man in each company? — I don't know, sir. By Mr. Scoular: If I had thought there was any danger I would have withdrawn the men and put dynamite in to bring the stone down; but I did not detect any indication of danger. Wm. Thompson deposed that he lived at Parkside House, and had been manager at this mine for 3½ years. He examined this place on the Tuesday in the previous week. There was nothing wrong about it and nothing that it was necessary to give directions about. He had every confidence in the overman, Pidd. In witness's opinion the nature of the ground was not sufficient to hold the lump — there was no binding about the ground. What security will there be against the same sort of thing happening again? Well, if the men are suspicious that it is bad they will shoot it down. Do you think anything could have been done here by wooding? — There was no need to do anything when the place was supposed to be secure. By the Inspector: There are other places where there is no wood in. Wood is not put in because we think it is not necessary. But the fact of the fall shows that you are apt to be deceived and therefore points to the necessity of putting in wood oftener than you do? — Yes, but if we consider it safe there is no need. The Inspector: In collieries they have introduced what they call systematic timbering, and they have to put it in whether they think it needful or not. It certainly has not resulted in any great diminution of accidents, though. The surveyor, Mr. Durham, re-called by the Inspector, said he measured up the fall and thought there would be about 25 tons of it. The Inspector said he examined the place yesterday and he thought the evidence had been given very fairly. The Coroner said he agreed with the Inspector that the evidence had been given in a very satisfactory manner — he did not think it could possibly have been given more straightforwardly then it had been by the whole of the five witnesses who had been before the jury. All the men were experienced. They had examined the place themselves, and as self-preservation was the first law of nature, if they had had any suspicion they would not have gone on working. There was always a risk, but they thought it was so small that they had no hesitation in running that risk. High testimony was given by Mr. Pidd on the previous immunity of the pit from fatal accident. That spoke very well indeed of the management. The jury found that the deceased met by their death accidentally. The Coroner communicated to the relatives of the men Mr. Scoular's expression of regret and sympathy, and both Huddart and Cowin replied with an assurance that they thought everything had been done that could have been done to have prevented the accident.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 19 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||