|
14th September 1911 Inquest At FrizingtonOn Friday afternoon an inquest touching the death of Thomas Doyle, residing with his parents at No. 4 Dyke Street, Frizington, was opened in the Police Station, Frizington, before Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, and a jury, of which Mr. H. Murphy was foreman. Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines also attended. Catherine Doyle identified the body as that of her son, who was aged 19 years. He was employed at Winder Ghyll Mine, and met with an accident there on the 12th of June. He had not followed his occupation since. He had been attended by Dr. Ryan and Dr. Morris. He complained of pain after the accident, and gradually grew worse until he became paralysed, and was unable to help himself. He died at 4.20 a.m. on Thursday. The inquest was adjourned till Monday. The adjourned inquest touching the death of Thomas Doyle, aged 19 years, residing at 4, Dyke Street, Frizington, was held at the Council Chambers, Frizington, on Monday evening, before Mr. G. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, and a jury, of which Mr. H. Murphy was foreman. There were also present: Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Mr. J. Hope Brown, solicitor for Winder Ghyll Mining Co., and Mr. F. Jackson, manager. When the inquest was opened Catherine Doyle, mother of the deceased, identified the body. She said her son told her he had an accident at the Winder Ghyll Mine on the 16th June. She examined his back where he said the pain was and noticed some red spots near the small of the back. He said some iron ore had fallen down a hopper upon him. He went to his work the following day, but did not go on the Wednesday or Thursday, and had not been able to work since. Mrs. Doyle, continuing her evidence, said her son had not been complaining before about his back. He had been medically attended before, his complaint then being bronchitis, and that was all the medical attention she thought he ever had. By Mr. Hope Brown: She admitted she was wrong in saying he was not at work on the Wednesday and Thursday after the alleged accident had taken place. Notice of a claim for compensation had been sent in to the Company. The claim, which she thought was a written one, was made by James Greer, who gave it to some one in authority about the mine. The young man also told the doctor who attended him that some metal had fallen on him. The deceased's father had not made any claim or given any notice to the mining company. Thomas Jackson, miner's labourer, Skelaceugh Road, Winder, stated that in June he worked at the Winder Ghyll Mine. He remembered Thomas Doyle coming towards the pit shaft one day. When he asked what was the matter he said he had got slightly hurt. He would not give the date. Dr. Ryan, Frizington, deposed that Doyle went to his surgery on the 16th June and complained of a pain to his back. He gave him a certificate to go on the sick benefit society's club, and said he would examine him at his own house, as it was more convenient to make an examination there. When he examined him he found evidence of old spinal trouble. Doyle told him he had suffered a slight accident at the mine, but when he examined him he found no evidence of such an accident. Such an accident as the deceased said he suffered might have been sufficient to affect the latent disease of the spine. With Dr. Speirs he made a post mortem examination. This did not reveal to them any evidence that the deceased had had an accident recently. Dr. Morris, Frizington, said he knew Doyle, and had attended him about two years ago for bronchitis. Doyle also came to him for a bottle of medicine when slightly out of sorts or run down. He succeeded Dr. Ryan in attending him because he was the medical officer of the sick club of the mine where Doyle was employed. Doyle's mother told him he had an accident at the mine. Witness really could not decide whether the accident had any bearing on the young man's death or not, although he had paid a good deal of attention to him. Witness was suspicious of nervous trouble, lung trouble, an old spinal curvature disease. An accident to the young man might affect these old troubles, though witness hardly thought they had. It was a difficult matter to decide. The deceased bore no external marks of violence upon his back when he first examined him. Dr. Morris corroborated Dr. Ryan regarding the post mortem examination. Edmund Jackson, manager of the Winder Ghyll Mine, where the accident was alleged to have taken place, said his first hearing of an accident occurring to Doyle was on Friday last when the inquest was opened. The Company had not received any claim for compensation. He found, on referring to the pit book, that Doyle was at work on Wednesday and Thursday after the alleged accident. By Mr. Leck: The duty of a tally boy was to check the bogies of ore that were emptied down the hopper. He had no right to be down at the bottom of the hopper, and it was not his duty to shove the metal down the hopper even if it was sticking. James Greer, residing at No. 4, Dyke Street, Frizington, said he reported the accident to the Mining Company where the deceased was employed. By Mr. Brown: He reported the matter one month after it occurred. On the 17th of July he also sent in a claim for compensation. He wrote the claim out on a sheet of notepaper, and signed it. In reply to further questions, witness admitted that his sister wrote out the claim afterwards, and this was the one he sent in. He gave it to one of the men at the mine, and he said he would give it to the manager and that the claim would be looked after. There was no one else present at the time when he handed over the claim. The Coroner summed up, and the jury decided to consider the verdict in private. A good deal of time was occupied, and eventually the services of the Coroner was again sought. After further deliberations, the jury found there was a slight accident to the deceased, but whether the disease from which he died was accelerated by the accident they were unable to say.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||