|
7th September 1911 Workington Iron & Steel Company, Ltd.Mr. Gavan Duffy & Wages Question At Woodend MinesDisputation With Sir J. S. RandlesOn Friday morning last the second ordinary general meeting of the proprietors and shareholders of the Workington Iron and Steel Co., Ltd., was held at the general offices, Moss Bay, Sir John S. Randles (chairman of the directors) presided, and the other directors present were: Mr. W. Burnyeat, Mr. Joseph Ellis, Mr. H. E. Wilson (managing directors), Mr. Herbert Valentine, Mr. Wilfred Ellis, Mr. G. G. Glen, Mr. Henry Westlake, Major Arthur Handley, Mr. Franklin Mallalieu, Mr. R. Critchley, Mr. Albert Henry Mallialieu, Mr. Harold Mallalieu, Mr. W. J. D. Burnyeat, Mr. Valentine Ellis, general manager; Mr. James Wiley, secretary; and a large number of shareholders. The Chairman, in moving the adoption of the balance-sheet and statement of accounts, said at Woodend mine they had a Dispute With The Men. They asked for more wages, but they (the directors) had not seen their way to pay the higher rates. Of course, the men were quite free to do as they thought proper in regard to their labour. If they didn't care to sell it at the price they asked they as employers, were equally free. Incidentally he might say it was perhaps a fortunate time to have this dispute, because they had very large stocks of both iron and steel on hand. Owing to the disturbance in the shipping world and the railway, their deliveries had been very much kept back. In the interest of the men, however, he should be glad to see the dispute settled. (Hear, hear.) They would notice they had at the end of June last at the back some £111,000. This was very fortunate, because they required every penny to enable them to carry these large stocks and pay all the charges on developments for mines and manufacture, &c., making in all a very substantial sum. Their cash balance would have been a very difference one if their balance-sheet had been struck to-day instead of at the end of June last. He supposed they had something like 60,000 tons of pig-iron of different sorts lying in their yards. He next referred to the appointment of Mr. Critchley from Lancashire, as a director, saying they had in this respect acted on the suggestion thrown out by the shareholders twelve months ago, who wanted him to be on the Board. Mr. Critchley was an expert in coal mining in Lancashire, and they enjoyed the benefit of his advice, more particularly in reference to mine matters. Mr. Gavan Duffy rose and asked if he understood the Chairman to say that the iron ore miners at Woodend were out on strike because they demanded an increase of wages. On the Chairman replying in the affirmative. Mr. Duffy said that was not a fact. The position at the present moment was that the Combine stood alone in not paying the wages received by the iron ore miners at the other pits. Five or six months ago the men set out to secure an increase of wages. In some places they succeeded. Then there was unsteadiness in the iron market and alight reductions took place of 4d. per shift for iron ore miners, and 3d. for labourers. In all places where these reductions took place the "cuts" had been restored, and the only thing the men asked was that the Combine's directors would follow the example of the other mines and restore the "cut." The Chairman said that was asking for an advance. Mr. Duffy replied it was only giving the miners 6s. 3d. per shift, and the labourers 5s. 3d. He was glad to hear the Chairman say that all the disputes in the Combine's iron and steel works had been amicably settled by the representatives on both sides. It seemed strange that with regard to the iron ore men the same machinery did not exist. He thought if it were extended good results and amicable relations would prevail between them. It was to the interest of the Combine that this unanimity should prevail, for it was a truism to say that when the men were discontented whilst at work, they did not secure the best results for their employers. The Chairman: You are a shareholder? Mr. Duffy: Yes. He was looking practically after his interests. They recognised that this Company had come to stay and that upon its prosperity depended to a large extent the fate of the district. It was because they wanted to see this community of interests that they asked the Board to consider reasonable the necessity for extending to the iron ore miners the same sort of machinery that operated in securing the basis of a sliding scale in the ascertainment of blastfurnacemen's wages and the steel workers. The Chairman replied he didn't think a shareholders' meeting was the place to go into these matters. Mr. Duffy said they were anxious to discover a way of ending the petty squabbles and unrest which existed between the employers and the employees. The Chairman said he was pleased to see Mr. Duffy at the meeting. He (Mr. Duffy) was a shareholder of the Company and as one of the proprietors he was within his rights in making any remarks which he thought would conduce to the advantage of the shareholders and be for their benefit. He took it the remarks Mr. Duffy had made were for the benefit of the shareholders. They, however, had nothing to do with any pits which didn't belong to the Workington Iron and Steel Company. There was no strike except at Woodend. He was informed they asked for an advance of wages to a point at which wages stood some little time ago. Therefore, they were on strike for the last rates of pay. There was a reference to a "cut." He (the chairman) didn't think Mr. Duffy was aware that the plan of ascertainment he suggested was the one they had been asking for. They based their advance on wages on the selling price of pig iron, and it so happened that there was an Association in the district which ascertained for the purpose of wages the selling price of pig iron. On these occasions during the last 18 months as a result of these ascertainments they had advanced the wages of the iron ore miners without any application being made by them. This had been done from a sense of fairness to the men. In the same way on one occasion there was a reduction in the rates of pay. It might interest shareholders who sometimes got disturbed on these questions to know when these advances were given. In December, 1909, and for the previous months the price of pig iron varied from 56s. to 61s. a ton. But in January of 1910 the price of pig iron as returned was just over 64s. Accordingly they didn't wait for a request, but instead gave the advance. This remained until March, when pig iron again went up, the ascertainment being 66s. 8d. per ton. Again they didn't wait, but instead they gave the advance. That price continued roughly until February of this year, when again they gave an advance without being asked for it. The price was over 66s. and they felt justified in giving it. In July the price was down to just a shade over 61s. 2d. — a large reduction in the selling price, — and they asked for one of those advances to be put back. That reduction was accepted by the men at Woodend who continued at their employment. He didn't want to say whose influence it was that brought them out to-day, but they were out, and they wanted the advance back again to the rate of wages they previously had. Under these circumstances, and with the facts before them he couldn't agree to overrule his responsible officials, the managers, on Mr. Duffy's advice, even if the shareholders were in consequence to go without a dividend for twelve months. As, however, the Woodend mine was only a small part of the Company, he didn't know that this was a contingency. With regard to the question of machinery, Mr. Duffy knew perfectly well that there was no absolute solidarity amongst the iron ore miners such as prevailed amongst the blastfuracemen. He (the Chairman) had no objection to meet any Trade Union, because he thought it was a good thing to deal with responsible people. But there was a division in regard to the iron ore miners. They were in two unions and he didn't think unanimity existed. At any rate, as far as the directors were concerned, there was a desire to act amicably with every class of employee. But when they took a thing into their own hands and went out on strike they as directors carry out their own policy. The duty of the directors came between the shareholders and the employees. They were trustees for both and the servants of both. (Applause.) Mr. Duffy wanted further detailed particulars of the advances of 4d. to iron miners and 3d. to labourers at Woodend. In reply, the Chairman said on August 19th they offered the miners 6s. 10d., 94 per shift and the labourers 4s. 9d., 68 per shift of eight hours. Mr. Duffy said that was not in accordance with the statement of the men. In regard to their Union he stated there was as much unanimity existing amongst the iron ore miners as there was in that room (the Combine meeting). The Chairman: I shall be glad if there is unanimity. Mr. Duffy: These "cuts" have been given back to the miners by all the owners but the Combine. The Chairman: We must be awful sinners. There were no further questions, and the resolution was carried. The Chairman moved that a dividend of three per cent be paid to the ordinary shareholders. Mr. Burnyeat seconded, and the motion was carried unanimously. The Chairman moved the re-election of Mr. R. Critchley, as director. Mr. H. Mallalieu seconded, and the resolution as carried. The Chairman moved the re-election of Major Hardley as director. Mr. Westlake seconded, and the motion was carried. The Chairman moved the re-election of Mr. Franklin Mallalieu. Mr. G. G. Glen seconded, and the motion was carried. Mr. J. G. Oldfield moved the election of Messrs. W. B. Peat, and Company, and Messrs. Alfred Tongue and Company as auditors. Mr. W. B. Turner seconded, and the proposition was carried unanimously. Mr. Turner moved a hearty vote of thanks to Sir John Randles for presiding. This was carried by acclamation. The Chairman: I think the staff and officials should also be included in that motion besides myself. Mr. Turner: I am sorry I made the omission.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||