Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd August 1911

Serious Charge Against A Collier

Smart Sentence

Albert Bestford (21), collier, Bridge-street, Musselburgh, was charged at the Whitehaven Police-court, on Monday, with attempting to obtain the sum of 1s 8d in money by false pretences from the Whitehaven Colliery Company, on the 1st June.

Mr. W. H. Chapman said that the man had been arrested last week, but had been remanded until today, and was charged with having attempted to obtain the sum of 1s 8d from the Whitehaven Colliery Co. The sum in itself was not a large sum, but the effect was quite serious. He outlined the case with considerable detail, in the course of which Mr. Chapman described the scheme of charging for the tubs of coal.

The magistrates on the Bench on the resumption of the Court were: W. H. Watson (in the chair) and T. Machell, Esqs.

Wallace Thompson, hewer, William Pit, 27, Strand-street, Whitehaven, said on the 2nd of June he was working with Anthony Sewell and was trailing to the siding of the six-quarter seam drift. The defendant was in an adjacent working, trailing to the same siding. At about three p.m. on that afternoon witness brought out a full tub and placed it at the rear of the train of full tubs. Before doing so he securely fastened one of his tokens, No. 272, on the tub. The defendant's token number was 276. Both tokens were produced in Court. Defendant was on the flat sheets with an empty tub when witness came out with his full tub. The token was fixed to the tub by passing the hook through a hole in the tub. Defendant was working by himself on the day in question. There was no tub for witness so he had to go to the Main Dib, about 70 yards away. I got an empty tub there, which would make me absent from the working about six or seven minutes. Defendant was still on the flat sheets when he returned. The flat sheets were close against the train of full tubs. Being suspicious, he went to look at the full tub that he (the witness) had left at the rear of the full tub train. On examining the tubs he found that his token No. 272 had been removed, and defendant's token No. 276 was on the tub. The tub was the end one of the full tub train, and witness was sure that it was his tub from the position that it occupied on the flat sheets. On still further examining the tubs he found that defendant's token was also on that tub instead of witness's. Jas. Wren was passing at the time, so witness asked him to look after his tub. Defendant had by this time went about 12 yards. He asked him what his token number was, to which he replied 276. When asked what the token was doing on the end tub he replied, "I don't know I did not put it on." When the defendant's token was examined it was found to be fastened by a simple knot. Witness's token strings were always tied with two knots. He thereupon went to find Wm. Hully, the deputy, leaving Wren in charge of the tub. Hully, upon arrival, asked the defendant how he accounted for the token being on Thompson's tub. He replied "It has been put there in the same way as cigarettes and matches were put in my pocket." Witness's token was lying on the buffer of the same tub, lying loose. Including Bestford there would be about three other men working on the sheets. It was impossible for defendant to have two full tubs on the train, because in the other workings there were two men working together, against Bestford, who was working alone.

James Wren, 87, Mount Pleasant, a hewer at William Pit, said he was on the back shift on the 1st of June, and was working near the last witness, bringing full tubs out on to the siding. About three o'clock on that day he brought a full tub out, and there was Thompson and Bestford standing together by the end tub of the train on the flat sheets. Thompson shouted to him, "Come and watch this tub." Thompson then pointed out a loose token that was lying on the buffer on the end tub, the number of which was 272, while the token that was affixed in the proper place was 276. The string of this token had been broken and tied with a single knot. The token on the next to the end tub was also 276. Thompson went away and brought Hully, who, on arrival, pointed to the token 276, and asked Bestford how it got there, to which defendant replied, "I don't know. It's like the match and cigarette case." Bestford was working by himself that day, and therefore could not possibly have had two full tubs together. The system of working was to hew and fill one tub at a time.

Wm. Ross, 4, Dobson's Court, Rosemary-lane, deposed he was a hewer at William Pit, and was at work on the back shift on the 1st of June. He said that he brought out a full tub on to the flat sheets. There were also four others bringing tubs out. The order was witness first, Rennie second, Penrice third, and Bestford last. The tubs were placed on the train in that order. Witness went for an empty tub and took it to their working. Defendant was then on the siding close to the full tubs. Returning again to the siding with another full tub in about 15 minutes time, defendant was still standing where he had left him. When witness asked him if he had not got back with his empty tub he replied, "No, I have been putting a new lace into my clog." There were then present, Redmayne, Wren, Penrice, Thompson, all standing close by. Thompson said, "This is a cop." And asked him to look at the end tub. Bestford's token was on the tub, and strange to say, it was only tied with a single knot, while Thompson's token was lying on the buffer of the tub, with no string on it. The time required to hew and fill the tub would be at least three quarters of an hour.

John Redmayne, 3, Heslop's-court, West Strand, a hewer in William Pit, said he was on the back shift on June 1st last. He was bringing tubs out on to the siding at the same time as the last witness; Ross first. Penrice second, witness third, and defendant fourth. After placing his full tub on the end of the train witness went for an empty tub towards the Main End, a distance of from 14 to 16 yards, being absent about a couple of minutes. Bestford was standing on the flat sheets, and on returning Bestford was putting a full tub on to the train. Witness went on to the flat sheets with his tub. Bestford was then holding his lamp about half-way up the full sett. When asked what he was doing there, knowing that he had no right to be there, he replied, "Nothing, but I am going to do a job for myself." Bestford was working single-handed the whole of the shift, and it would be impossible for anyone to fill two tubs single-handed.

Wm. Hully, 40, Peter-street, a deputy in William Pit, deposed that he was on the back shift on the 1st of June, and on the request of Wallace Thompson he went to a siding at the bottom of the drift. He found there T. Penrice, Jas. Wren, Wm. Ross, John Redmayne, Wallace Thompson, and prisoner. On examining the tubs he found tokens number 276 on the last two tubs. The 272 token was lying on the buffer on the last tub. The 276 tokens were only tied with one knot, and had the token been in the condition they would never have travelled so far. He asked defendant how the tokens came to be put there, to which he replied, "They have been put there the same as the cigarettes were put into my pocket." Defendant was working alone that day, and it would have been impossible for him to have had two tubs that day. The advantage gained by placing a token on a tub was that the defendant would gain 1s 8d. John Sayles was the weighman on that day, and when the tubs are taken up the pit a lad wheels the tubs on to the weighing machine and at the same time shouts out the number of the token to the weighman who credits the man who owns that token. With regard to the tub in question witness wrote on the tub, "Side off at pit top, Wm. Hully."

John Sayle, 41, Foundry-road, Parton, said he was employed as a weighman at William Pit. On the afternoon of June 2nd he was on duty. His particular duty was to credit the owner of the tub with the weight of coal they contained. On the date in question two tubs came up the pit marked "Side off, Wm. Hully." The tubs had each token No. 276. Had these tubs been entered to No. 276 that would have been deceiving the hewer and the Colliery Co.

P.C. Armstrong stated that at five p.m. on the 26th inst. he received prisoner into custody from the Musselburgh police. The warrant was read over to him, and on being charged he replied, "There is no proof." A summons was served, but the person was found to have absconded.

Prisoner had nothing to say.

Supt. Hogg said that he was sorry to state that there was a previous offence against this man. He was here on the 8th of November last, when he was fined 40s for having matches and tobacco in his possession.

The Chairman said that the charge of attempting to obtain money by false pretences from the Whitehaven Colliery Co. had been proved. The effect was really to defraud his fellow-workmen, and this was in itself a very shocking thing to do.

Prisoner was fined £5 or one month's imprisonment with hard labour.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Armstrong, —    Police Constable  
Bestford, Albert   21 Miner  
Chapman, W. H.    Solicitor  
Hogg, —    Police Supt.  
Hully, William    Deputy  
Machell, T.    Magistrate  
Penrice, T.    Miner  
Redmayne, John    Hewer  
Rennie, —    Miner  
Ross, William    Hewer  
Sayles, John    Weighman  
Sewell, Anthony    Miner  
Thompson, Wallace    Hewer  
Watson, W. H.    Magistrate  
Wren, James    Hewer  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print