Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th June 1911

Workmen's Compensation

Alleged Injury Denied

Nanson V. Stirling

John Nanson, iron ore miner, 93, Ennerdale-road, Cleator Moor, claimed compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act, for alleged injuries received, from Wm. Stirling, of the Montreal Mines, Cleator Moor.

The claimant, John Nanson, alleged that on the 16th December last he met with an accident while employed as a deputy at the Montreal Pit. He was a married man, living with his wife and family, the members of which were all grown up. He was 64 years of age, and had been in the respondent's employ for the last 29 years. He claimed 18s from the date of the accident, 28 weeks, amounting to £25 4s, up to date of His Honour's award. This claim was based on the allegation that his average weekly earnings during twelve months previous to the alleged injury were £1 16s. The respondent alleged that the claimant's average weekly wage for the twelve months was £1 9s. The point in dispute here was whether a period within the twelve months, during which the man was laid up with bronchitis, should or should not be included in the average. But the main issue in the case was whether or not there was any injury at all, and any ground for a claim for compensation. The claimant's case was that on December 16th he was engaged on his duties at the Montreal Mine, and was carrying some timber known as flat-heads, which were required to be sent down the pit, when one of these flat-heads overbalanced and rebounded, giving him a severe blow and squeeze over his left shoulder and side. He alleged that by this accident his left shoulder and side were bruised, and there was thus occasioned an immediate haemorrhage of his left lung, and that his injury caused him to be incapacitated from his work. The respondent denied that any such accident occurred, and said applicant's illness was due to natural causes.

Mr. W. Graham, Manchester (instructed by Messrs. Paisley, Falcon, & Skerry), appeared on behalf of the applicant; and Mr. W. Procter, Liverpool (instructed by Mr. E. Atter) was for the respondent.

Dr. Tawse, medical assessor to the Court, sat with His Honour in this case.

Mr. Graham argued the point as to whether a period of illness in the twelve months should be included, and Mr. Procter replied, the former urging that the period of sickness should be excluded, and the latter that it ought to be included. Mr. Procter said if the man was off on holiday he could, if he had wished, have earned wages — he had the capacity to earn; but in case of sickness, he had no capacity to earn, and the sick period ought therefore to be included so as to lower the average.

His Honour said he would consider the point.

Claimant was called into the witness-box and examined by Mr. Graham. On the 16th December he was on the afternoon shift. He was handling flat-heads — planks, 3 inches by 7 inches by 12 ft. in length. They were standing upright, resting against the wall, and he was lifting them up and handing them to his mate, Todd. He was lifting up a plank to put it on his shoulder. It was a heavy beam, and had got water-logged, and it overbalanced over his shoulder and hit the wall and then rebounded. He felt a crunch in his shoulder and then began to cough and spit up blood, which came up so fast as almost to choke him. Todd asked "What's t' matter?" and witness replied "Ah's done." The doctor was sent for. For six weeks, some time before the accident, he was off for six weeks with bronchitis, and was attended by Dr. Eaton.

Cross-examined by Mr. Procter: Witness was asked if it was not the case that each winter he was off with illness.

Witness: No, not each winter; I have been off with a bit of cold.

Nearly every winter? — No.

Mr. Procter: Well, we shall hear about that.

Replying to further questions by Mr. Procter, the claimant said he used to work at a lead mine. He had never had an accident of this kind before. The flat-head over-balanced on his shoulder. That was because it was water-logged and heavier than he expected.

Mr. Procter said the weight of the water would be equally distributed and should not have caused any over-balancing. Then he could not understand how the plank hitting the wall could crush and injure his shoulder.

Witness said he did not think that when he vomited he vomited matter as well as blood. Mr. Gregory, the mine manager, came to see him, stayed with him about half an hour, and had conversation with him.

Now I put it to you that you never mentioned to Mr. Gregory that you had had an accident? — Mr. Gregory asked me all the questions about it.

Do you say you told him about the accident of which you have told us here to-day? — Decidedly so.

His Honour: Do you tell me so?

Witness: Yes.

Mr. Procter: Did you not tell Mr. Gregory that Dr. Eaton told you that the pressure of carrying the timber might have caused a rush of blood? — That is the way I understood it.

His Honour: Oh, wait a minute. (His Honour proceeded to take a note of that.)

Mr. Graham: That is our case, your Honour.

Mr. Procter: It is not the case that has been opened up by you so far.

Witness, further questioned, said that Mr. Gregory asked him if he had not worked in a leadmine, and when he told him he had, Mr. Gregory said his illness would be attributable to his having worked in the leadmines. Witness denied that he told Mr. Gregory that working in the leadmines had certainly affected him.

Your doctor's certificate the day after the alleged accident was "pulmonary haemorrhage"; there was nothing there about an accident. Was not that certificate for the purpose of sick allowance? — Yes.

Witness said he had sick allowance for four weeks before he gave notice to his employers claiming compensation. He told Atkinson, the under-manager, the day after the accident, that he had met with an accident, and that he would want compensation. Witness did not mention to his solicitor that he had that conversation with Atkinson; it never struck him.

Samuel Todd, deputy at the Montreal Mine, said he was helping Nanson to move flat-heads. The first thing he saw, Mr. Nanson was sitting down and he heard him coughing and vomiting. He asked him what was up, and he said, "I'm done, Sam." That was at the pit top. He had heard Nanson coughing before, but not just before the accident.

Cross-examined: The last time would be half an hour before. Witness had seen him have to stop work with his cough. Witness did not hear or see the accident itself. When he asked him what was the matter Nanson, did not tell him about the accident. Witness did not notice whether there was any matter along with the blood that Nanson threw up.

Dr. Eaton, medical practitioner at Cleator Moor, said that from time to time he had attended Nanson. He was sent for at the time of the accident, and went to the colliery and saw him in the engine-house. He was in a collapsed condition and was still throwing up blood. The blood was bright and frothy. There was a certain amount of mucus and phlegm in it. The man was not in a condition to tell him anything: he could only pump him a bit, and from him and those about at the time he had a general impression of what had occurred. Next day he inquired further. Witness said that the cause of the blood was a ruptured blood vessel, which, as far as he could make out, was in the upper part of the left lung. He had attended the man for three or four years and had known him for ten years, and he knew his constitution pretty well. The quantity of blood was very large. If it was due to bronchitis simply, he would not expect such a large quantity of blood. There are such haemorrhages in bronchitis, though not often, but the blood would come more slowly. The accident was consistent with what he saw. He examined the shoulder next day for a possible fracture. He found no fractures, but the shoulder was tender and painful. He attended Nanson for chronic bronchitis in April last year. He did not then think that there was likelihood of haemorrhage.

Cross-examined: Working in a lead mine might affect him. His lungs were in a bad condition, and he was more likely to be affected in the winter than in the summer. He was not tubercular, so far as witness knew. At the time of the accident he was suffering from chronic bronchitis. He could not say that his lungs would then be in a bad condition, but the chronic bronchitis would be a pre-disposing cause. He disagreed with Mr. Procter when the latter said a blow on the shoulder would not bring on pulmonary haemorrhage. He heard Nanson say that he told Gregory that he (Dr. Eaton) had told him that pressure upon his shoulder might have caused a rush of blood. Witness did not say so to Nanson. Nanson must have misunderstood him.

When did you begin to mention "accident" in your certificate? — Pause.

His Honour: Why did you not mention accident at first?

Witness: Because I was not certain at first.

By His Honour: I did not see any symptoms of lead poisoning. I did not notice any symptoms of kidney trouble, or of diseased blood vessels, nor were these present to my mind. I did not know he had worked in a lead mine.

Mr. Procter said his claim was resisted because it was felt that it was not one that should be met. Everything in the case was consistent with this illness being due to natural causes. There was not the slightest corroboration by Todd of the occurrence of any accident. The man was prompt enough to claim his sick money, but he did not take a single step about compensation. Gregory, the manager, called upon him a week after the alleged accident, and Nanson made no mention of any accident. It was not until the 13th January, 1911, that he made application for compensation.

Mr. Graham said Nanson stated that he told Atkinson the night after the accident.

Mr. Procter said he pointed to all these circumstances as showing that there was no accident, and His Honour was entitled to weigh these circumstances and say that the man had not made out to his satisfaction that there was an accident. They had been very seriously prejudiced by the fact that they had not had notice within a reasonable period of this alleged accident. If they had had such notice they would have been able to call in medical evidence at once. He pointed out how that Nanson looking for a cause for his haemorrhage told Gregory that Dr. Eaton thought pressure on the shoulder might have caused a rush of blood. Dr. Eaton said he did not say so. But the point of importance was that it had not occurred to Nanson at that time to say that it was due to an accident, and he made no mention of an accident to Gregory.

Edward Gregory said he was manager of the Montreal Mines, with 300 or 400 men employed in five pits. This was the first case of compensation that had ever been contested at the mines. He had been there twenty months, and all that time Nanson had been suffering from a cough which caused him to stop working. He saw Nanson a week after the alleged accident, and was with him about half an hour, and was talking to him about his illness. Nanson did not during the half hour mention that there had been any accident. He mentioned as a cause of his illness that the doctor had told him that the pressure on his shoulder might cause extra pressure upon the breast. Witness told him that he did not think that the plank should have caused any extra pressure upon his heart. He asked Nanson if he had ever worked in a lead mine, and he said he had worked in them as a boy, and that he had been troubled the whole of his life with bronchitis. Witness said working in a lead mine would affect him. Not one word was said about an accident having caused Nanson's illness. The first intimation witness received of any accident was a month after the accident, and he handed in the notice to His Honour. They ought to have notice of an accident at the time. They had to give notice to H.M. Inspector the following day, of any accident that occurred.

His Honour: Yet it was a month before you heard of it?

Witness: Yes.

Cross-examined: The first he heard of what happened was that Mr. Nanson had broken a blood vessel. Witness made inquiry about it from the engineman, but he said he did not know anything about it except that the man was loading timber. He asked Todd, who said he neither say nor heard anything until he saw Nanson sitting down and heard him vomiting, and Todd said he did not know what caused it. Witness did not report the circumstances to Government Inspector because he did not consider it an accident, they had to report accidents, not illnesses. Atkinson, the under deputy, went and saw Nanson the next day, and they had a certificate from Dr. Eaton that he was suffering from pulmonary haemorrhage. The certificate was on a printed form. If it was simply a club note, witness saw it, but did not receive it — it went to the proper officials. The certificate in this case, witness said, was a club certificate. Witness questioned Atkinson after the latter had seen Nanson, and asked how he was, and Atkinson said he was very ill. At Mr. Jukes' suggestion witness afterwards went to see Nanson. Mr. Jukes suggested that because Nanson was an old man and an old servant. Witness was interested in the origin of the illness because he had had another official who had been affected by bronchitis in consequence of lead mining. Nanson never suggested that he had had an accident.

Re-examined: I made every possible inquiry in the colliery to find out if there had been an accident. I could get no information of any accident. If the man had told me a week afterwards I would have given notice to the Inspector of Mines.

Dr. J. H. Dickson, Whitehaven, said that on the 15th inst. he examined Nanson and got from him the history of his alleged accident. He told witness about having previously suffered from bronchitis. After hearing his statement and examining him, witness thought there was no connection between the statement and the condition in which he found Nanson upon that occasion. Witness examined Nanson's chest and found on the left side signs of depression — falling in; his breathing was short, quick; the percussion notes were dull; the breathing was tubular upon a particular place, and there were signs of rals. In witness's opinion he was suffering from fibroid phthisis, probably brought on by chronic bronchitis. A man so suffering might have vomited blood by merely walking or moving about, in fact it is one of the symptoms of the disease. Witness heard the doctor say that there was no external bruise on the shoulder the day after the alleged accident. Had there been a blow such as described there would almost certainly have been signs of an external bruise. Witness thought such a blow could not cause the rupture of a blood vessel. Working in a lead mine might produce the fibroid condition that witness found in Nanson.

Cross-examined: The lungs were in a bad condition, and coughing in that condition might bring on bleeding. And exertion might cause a rupture which put pressure on the breathing. He did think pressure on the shoulder would affect the lungs. He agreed that any unusual exertion might cause bleeding.

Re-examined: The incident of the alleged accident could not have caused the man's condition.

This was Mr. Procter's case.

His Honour said he would like to hear any further observations from Mr. Graham and Mr. Procter before he retired to consider his decision. What was in his mind was this. At present, he did not think there was an accident, and if there was he did not think the man at first thought there was an accident. Secondly, he thought that even if there was an accident — he had not come to a conclusion upon it, and therefore he did not pronounce very strongly upon that point — no proper notice was given under the Act, so as to enable the employers to make inquiries immediately. The object of notice was to enable the employers to make immediate inquiries. He did not think there was any such notice, and the medical certificate that was given would have allayed all suspicions — that was pulmonary haemorrhage.

Mr. Graham said His Honour must not forget that the certificate was only for club purposes. The club wanted to know what the man was suffering from, but they did not want to know the cause, and therefore Dr. Eaton did not state the cause. Mr. Graham proceeded to review the evidence, and to content that if it was found that the bleeding was in any way caused by the work he was doing the claimant was entitled to a verdict.

His Honour said that before giving judgement he would require to have the witness Atkinson before him, who was not in court, but who, Mr. Procter said, had been sent for. His Honour then retired with Dr. Tawse to consider his decision.

When His Honour returned to Court, Thomas Atkinson was called into the witness-box, and replying to Mr. Procter, he said he was fore-shift foreman at the pit at which Nanson worked. He went to see Nanson about three days although he was not sure after the accident. Witness had no recollection of Nanson saying that he had had an accident and would want compensation.

His Honour: Did he say it?

Witness: No, sir.

Mr. Procter: What did he say to you as to what had occurred? — He said he started bleeding.

Cross-examined: He was not sure about the day; it might be the day after the accident. Witness went to see why Nanson was not at his work.

Wasn't it general talk in the district that he had been struck by this piece of wood? — Yes, well.

And you found that this man had been bleeding, and you went down to see him? — Yes.

No didn't he tell you that this came on while he was shifting this beam? — Yes.

His Honour said that he had now heard all the evidence. He felt that he ought to hear the man who had just been called because this matter was not only a very fine point, but a very difficult one, and also a very anxious one. He was very glad indeed that he had the assistance of Dr. Tawse in considering the question. He had to consider that under the Workmen's Compensation Act, the compensation must be for personal injury caused by an accident arising out of or in the course of employment; and notice of the accident must be given as soon as practicable there-after. The object of the Act apparently was that notice must be given of the accident to the employer at once, so that the employer might at once investigate whether here had been an accident or not. In this case the notice that was given was that the man was carrying flatheads, when one of them over balanced and gave him a severe blow and squeeze. The applicant had proved that one of the flatheads, which he was carrying overbalanced, and hit the wall; but he did not prove that, he suffered a blow, or a squeeze. He gave no evidence of any or either of these. He did not prove that his left shoulder was bruised. Dr. Eaton had examined his shoulder on the next day, and said, "I think the blow as described by the applicant was sufficient to bring on bleeding haemorrhage." Now, this was absolutely the only word that he had with regard to a blow. The man Todd, who was with the applicant, said he did not see the accident. He had not lost sight of the fact that the man might suffer an accident — that was an accident defined under the Workmen's Compensation Act — and not really notice it at the time. An accident might be of such a light character, that a man who was suffering like this man was would not notice it. But, although at the time and immediately afterwards, the applicant might not have though he had had an accident, the thing he could not understand was that when Gregory, the manager, went to see him the next day he did not tell him that he had suffered a blow or a squeeze. Gregory, undoubtedly a skilled man, went to find out the next day whether there was an accident. It was Gregory's duty to report an accident and he went specially to discover whether there was an accident, with a view to reporting it; and he could not believe that a man who had had a blow, a severe blow; and suffered a squeeze and a bruise on the shoulder, and had met with such an accident as he described, would not have told Gregory. The conclusion he came to, therefore, was that this man might now imagine that he had had an accident that in fact he had not had an accident. He had discussed that matter with the medical assessor, and had heard the evidence of two doctors, and this undoubtedly might be been caused by an excessive strain, and only a strain whether it could be caused by a blow or a squeeze, or a bruise, was not at all certain. Therefore in considering the question of whether there was an accident, he considered it was quite possible this old man might have thought he had an accident, and yet he might be entirely mistaken. He came to the conclusion that the old man was mistaken, and he very much regretted that the plaintiff had these things, "rebound" and "blow" and so on, upon the record because they showed him what he did not like to say — not a straight mind. The plaintiff might have suffered this. It might have happened to him in the course of his employment, but he had had not proved it to be the satisfaction of the Court. He dismissed that case with the costs on the "O" scale. His reason for granting costs on the higher scale was that he had a medical gentleman to assist him and two medical gentlemen were called in evidence, and that seemed to him to make it a case of very considerable importance.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, Thomas    Fore-shift Foreman  
Atter, E.    Solicitor  
Dickson, J. H., Dr.    Doctor  
Eaton, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Falcon, —    Solicitor  
Graham, W.    Q.C.  
Gregory, Edward    Mine Manager  Whos Who Page
Jukes, —      
Nanson, John    Miner  
Paisley, —    Solicitor  
Procter, W.    Q.C.  
Skerry, —    Solicitor  
Stirling, William    Mine Owner  
Tawse, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Todd, Samuel    Deputy  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Montreal Colliery  Montreal Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print