Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

15th June 1911

Cleator Moor Young Man's Death

On Sunday morning the death took place of Mr. Patrick Doyle, at 109, Bowthorn Road, Cleator Moor. Deceased was employed at Parkhouse Mines, Bigrigg, and met with a slight accident on Saturday, 27th May. It appears on that date he had finished his work as a miner, and was making his way to the pit shaft when a loaded bogie, which was coming along the full road in charge of a trailer named Clement Croasdell, knocked him down. When the bogie was approaching deceased, Croasdell shouted, "Look out," and Doyle, while stepping on to the full road was caught by the bogie. To save himself deceased put out his left hand, and received injuries to his hand which was afterwards dressed at the pit top, and subsequently he was attended by Dr. Byers. Five days later deceased developed pneumonia, and died on Sunday last. Deceased has only worked one week previous to the accident.

An inquest touching the death of Patrick Doyle was held in the New Crown Hotel on Monday evening, by Mr. G. L. Skerry (Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont), Mr. Charles Gowan was chosen foreman, and there were present; Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. J. Hope Brown, representing the mine proprietors; Mr. Isaac Walker, mine manager, Park House Mines; Mr. D. Gill, and Mr. W. Sherwen, mining engineers; Peter Doyle, representing the widow of deceased, and Inspector Sheffield.

Mrs. Rose Doyle gave evidence of identification. Deceased was 31 years of age, and was employed as a miner at Park House Mine, Bigrigg. He had been working for a couple of years, and had enjoyed the best of health. He had been very ill since he cut his hand a fortnight ago. On the day of the accident he had his hand bandaged when he came home, about 12-30. He was on the morning shift on the day in question, and left his home at five o'clock. After returning home he changed himself, and went to Dr. Byers's surgery about half-past three. It was usual for him to have dinner when he came home, but he had got such a shock he could not eat. After being to the surgery he came home and went straight to bed. He went every other morning to the surgery to get his hand dressed up to the following Thursday week. Since the accident he had complained of pains in his back. (Mr. Peter Doyle interrupted several times at this point, and was courteously told by the Coroner to refrain, otherwise he would be obliged to ask him to leave the room.) Continuing, witness said her husband went to the doctor up to last Wednesday week, which was the last time he was out of the house. He had been in bed since that time, and was attended by Dr. Byers.

By Mr. Brown: My husband had been ill a little time before the accident, but was quite well when he went back to work.

Mr. Sherwen, mining engineer with Messrs. Dixon and Gill, engineers for the Park House Mines, produced a tracing of the pit road where the accident occurred. The width of the road was seven feet six inches. There were two sets of rails two feet apart, one set for the full tubs going towards the shaft, and the other for empties coming from the shaft. The bogies he mentioned were 2ft. 7 inches at the top and 1ft. 10 inches at the bottom.

By Mr. Leck: The height of the drift at the point where the accident happened would be seven feet, and the width 7ft. 6 inches. The drift is lighted all the way from the shaft by electric light.

By the Foreman: It is possible to see the bogies two hundred yards away.

Clement Croasdell, Moor Row, said he was a trailer at Park House Mines, and know Doyle very well. He was present when the accident took place. He along with other trailers were standing with their bogies in the drift. They had to wait until the shot firing ceased further down the drift. There would be four or five trailers. A man named Stephenson was first, and he, witness, was next. We were each in charge of a tub, and were taking them to the shaft. It is an incline to the shaft, and we were holding the tubs by hand. He saw Doyle standing two or three yards further down the drift towards the shaft. There were two or three other man waiting along with him on the empty road. There were no tubs coming along the empty roads when witness started to move his tub after the firing was over. Doyle stepped on the full road to pass a man named Clare, who was standing on the empty road, and as he was doing so his bogie caught him. As he was falling he threw his hand out to save himself and caught the left side of the drift and cut his hand. I stopped my bogie, and he jumped up and got on to the empty road again. There were pushing their tub slowly. The palm of his hand was cut, but he could not say whether it was the drift side that cut it or the rails. Mr. Clare and two or three others were looking at his hand when I went on with my tub to the shaft. I saw Doyle after he had got to the shaft, and asked him if he was much worse. He replied not so bad only I have cut my hand. It seemed a deep cut about 2½ inches long. He did not get it bandaged as he said he would wait until the trailers went up. Mr. Clare, the boss of the trailers, suggested he should go and get his hand washed, and about ten minutes afterwards I went up with him. He went straight to the changing house, and he did not seem much worse for his fall nor did he appear to have got much of a shock. I saw him at Cleator Moor on the Monday following with his hand in a sling, but had not seen him since. Reverting to the place where the accident happened, witness stated that Doyle had his back to the tubs when he stepped on the full road. The road was well lighted by electricity. Stephenson's tub had passed Doyle, and I was coming next, perhaps about five yards away.

The Foreman: I suppose he would know you were moving the bogies?

Witness: You would think he did when one had gone past him.

By Mr. Leck: He did not notice that Doyle was one of the men in front.

By the Coroner: We know there were some men there.

By Mr. Leck: I know Clare and others were standing there and that all had been stopped because firing was going on there. When my tub struck Doyle I had no difficulty whatever in stopping it.

He never made any complaint about my tub having struck him. At the place where I was waiting the bogies would stand by themselves until we pushed them on. The accident would happen about a quarter to twelve. All the other men with the exception of Clare would be going to the shaft. We get a check every morning and ride according to that check. There would be about twenty men on the first shift trailing. The empties had stopped coming up at the time of the accident. It is the usual practice both on Saturdays and other days for the empties to stop-say half an hour before ride away.

The Foreman: If he had stopped where he was until all the bogies had gone past would he have been in time to go up the shaft?

Witness: Yes.

Mr. Leck: Do you know whether Doyle had an early check?

Witness: I don't. He was early at his work as a rule, but whether he had an early check or not I cannot say.

By the Foreman: The bogies would have to go up the shaft before we did.

Mr. Brown: How far had your bogies travelled before it struck the man?

Witness: About three or four yards.

Mr. Brown: Then it would not be travelling very fast?

Witness: No, I had just got it started.

Mr. Brown: It would strike him on the back of the legs, but not very violently?

Witness: No. It was not a blow that would give him a great shock. There would be a light about two or three yards from Doyle, who would see Stephenson's bogie pass. The men walk to the shaft on the empty road.

Jonathan Clare, 3, Marlborough Street, Whitehaven, described himself as a charge hand at Park House Mine. His duties were to see all the trailers on his road keep their turns regularly, to see that any bogies tipped get filled and sent off, and to assist generally at stoppages. All the men going to the shaft must come down this road, which is the main road to the shaft. The road is not worked by any mechanical power. On the date of the accident, he was on first shift from six to twelve. Doyle would be finished before twelve to enable him to get to the shaft by ride away. He saw Doyle at a quarter to twelve about half-way up the drift, probably a quarter of a mile from the shaft. He was going out, and I stopped him, as they were shot-firing further down the drift. I stopped all the men coming out at that time, also four or five bogies. There were no empty bogies coming up. I stood in front of the men with an acetylene lamp. After the firing was over, I instructed all the men to stand on the empty road, until the four or five bogies got past. There were no men standing on the full road. They stood while the first bogie got past, and knew there were more bogies to follow. When the second bogie was coming on, about 18 feet behind the first, Doyle tried to dart round the men standing, and to get on the empty road again, and in doing so he stepped in front of the second bogie, which struck him on the lower part of the back. It threw him forward full length on the road, with his hands stretched out. I asked him if the bogie hurt his legs, and he replied no, but he had hurt his hand in falling. I noticed his hand cut, which may have been caused by the edge of the rail or a sharp stone. I accompanied him to where the shot-firing had been going on, and gave him in charge of another man. He did not seem much worse. I am not aware he was injured anywhere, but his left hand. There are three or four places where a man can get in for safety, when the full bogies are coming down. The road is not worked by engine power. Doyle started before he got permission from me, and his reason was, he said, because he had an early check. If he had asked me I could easily have stepped back to let him pass.

By Mr. Leck: Doyle did not make any complaints. I have been on this road at trailing and other jobs for about 2½ years. It is a double road. I saw Doyle at the shaft, and he said he was all right, and would go up after the trailers. We have men both on the top and bottom, who can dress wounds, but as he was going to the shaft, I thought he could get it dressed quickly at the top.

Thomas Thompson: Penzance Street, employed in the charging house at Parkhouse Mines, said Doyle came in about dinner time to the changing house and complained of a wound in the hand. It was a slight wound on the fleshy part of the hand. Witness washed his hand with a disinfectant, and put a boracic dressing on it. The injury did not seem bad, and the man seemed in fairly good spirits. He did not appear to ail anything else. He seemed quite normal, and witness would not expect him to go to bed through the injury.

By the Foreman: He did not complain of any other pain. He was quite lively.

By Mr. Leck: We have an adequate ambulance outfit for injured persons.

Dr. Byers, Cleator, said Doyle came to his surgery about 5 o'clock on the evening of May 27th. He had a wound in his left hand, which had been properly dressed, and I redressed it. It was a semi-circular lacerated wound, about 1½ to 2 inches long on the palm of the left hand. It would be about a quarter of an inch deep. It appeared to have been done by some blunt instrument, which could be accounted for by failing on stone or some rough iron. It did not seem to be a dangerous wound. He did not show any symptoms of being shaky I did not examine his legs or body. I told him it was not necessary to come on Sunday, so he turned up on Monday. He was then complaining more of bruises and said his body was very sore. I dressed the hand again, and he said he would come down on Wednesday. I thought it was not necessary for him to come every day. He came late on Wednesday morning, and consequently I could not see him. I saw him in the town on Wednesday, and he seemed all right. I told him then if he was not fit in the morning, I would call and see him. I saw him on the Thursday morning, I was sent for, and found him in bed suffering from a touch of pneumonia. He had had a shivering attack on Wednesday evening, after he had been to my surgery. By examining him I found he had pneumonia in the right lung. I treated him accordingly and attended him until his death on June 11th. He had been in bed all the time, and in my opinion he died from septic pneumonia.

The Coroner: Is there any connection between the septic pneumonia and the accident to his hand?

Dr. Byers: He may have absorbed septic germs into this wound, and the germs might plant themselves in any part of the body, where they would find a weak spot. I had not attended to him previous to this illness. I was informed he had had pneumonia, and had received medical attention. In my opinion he would have been alive to-day if it had not been for the accident.

The Foreman: His previous attack of pneumonia would leave him subject to it again?

Dr. Byers: Of course, there is always the tendency to another attack.

Mr. Brown: Septic pneumonia has been very prevalent in this district, and it does not of necessity arise from an accident.

The Coroner, in asking the jury to decide as by what means deceased came to his death, said it had been suggested by the witness Clare, that deceased ought to have known the tub was coming, as Stephenson's tub had passed him. In any event no blame could be attached to anyone else. He explained that there was no statutory obligation for man-holes to be provided in this case. On the day in question there had been a little shot-firing below. Doyle seems to have been anxious to get to the shaft, and in trying to pass his mates, stepped on to the full road and met with the accident. There was no doubt he received an injury to his hand. This had been properly dressed at the pit, and afterwards by Dr. Byers, and subsequently he had to take to his bed. I think you will have to take the doctor's evidence as to the cause of his death. It is for you to say whether the accident led to the septic pneumonia. Dr. Byers has told you in his opinion if it had not been for the accident the man would not have caught the pneumonia. At the same time he tells you there have been cases of septic pneumonia, which have not been caused by any accident, but an accident of this kind would make a man more liable to contract it, as there would be a chance of the septic germs being absorbed in the hands. You can say in your opinion whether death was due to septic pneumonia, caused by the accident or not, or you can leave it an open question. This inquiry has nothing to do really with the question of workmen's compensation because any verdict you give is chiefly for registration, and, of course, to prevent any accident in future. Any ruling you may give will be forwarded to the registrar of deaths.

The jury, without retiring, accorded a verdict of death from septic pneumonia.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brown, J. Hope      
Byrers, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Clare, Jonathan    Charge Hand  
Croasdell, Clement    Trailer  
Dixon, —      
Doyle, Patrick   31 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Doyle, Peter      
Doyle, Rose      
Gill, D.    Mining Engineer  
Gowan, Charles    Jury Foreman  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Sheffield, —    Police Inspector  
Sherwen, W.    Mining Engineer  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Stephenson, —    Miner  
Thompson, Thomas    Miner  
Walker, Isaac    Manager  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Park House (Iron Ore)  Park House (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print