|
15th June 1911 Colliery Manager FinedNo Manholes And Unauthorised Shot-FiringAt Maryport, on Friday, Thom Thompson, Flimby, manager of the Ellenborough Colliery, was summoned by John Boland Atkinson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Newcastle, for failing to comply with certain provisions of the Coalmines Regulation Act, of 1887, and of orders made there under. There were seven charges. Defendant was summoned, for that he, on the 29th March, did fail to observe and comply with rule 12 of the general rules contained in section 49 of the Coalmines Regulation Act, 1887, inasmuch as there were taken into the mines of the said colliery certain substances to witness five pounds of stowite, otherwise than in a secure case or canister. That on the 11th April, he failed to comply with rule 14 of the general rules, inasmuch as the dip engine plane to the virgin seam in which persons travel, and which is worked by an engine, was not provided with sufficient man-holes or places of refuge at intervals of not more than ten yards, there not being room for a person to stand between the side of the plane and the tubs, not being moved by an endless chain or rope. He was also summoned for having on the 28th March and 11th April, permitted charges to be fixed otherwise than by an efficient electrical apparatus, so enclosed as to afford reasonable security against the ignition of inflammable gas. That on the 28th March he did, in the mine of the said colliery, where inflammable gas had been found within the previous three months in such quantity as to be indicative of danger, allow explosives to be used without observing the condition presented by clause 2a of the Explosives in Coalmines Order of the 21st February, 1910, inasmuch as a certain person, to wit, Humphrey Evans, fired a shot, not being a competent person appointed in writing. He was also summoned that, on the 29th March he failed to observe and comply with clause 4a of the explosives in Coalmines Order of the 21st February, 1910, inasmuch as detonators were taken for the purpose of use into the mine, and were issued to Thomas Evans, he not being a shot-firer or other person specially authorized by the owner, agent, or manager in writing. He was also summoned for that on April 11th, he failed to observe and comply with clause 4b of the Explosives in Coalmines Order of the 21st February, 1910, inasmuch as detonators taken for the purpose of use into the mine, and issued to one Robert Stewart, were not kept until about to be used in a securely locked case or box, separate from any other explosive. Mr. Skerry appeared to prosecute by instruction from the Director of Public Prosecutions, and Mr. Lightfoot defended. Mr. J. B. Atkinson, H. M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. Abbot, his assistant, and Mr. Leck, Inspector of Metalliferous Mines, were present. Mr. Skerry, in opening the case, detailed the charges. The defendant must have known that shots were being fired by a person not authorised in writing; that explosives were being taken into the mine, otherwise than in canisters, and he must have known there were no man-holes. Mr. Lightfoot suggested that as the charges Nos. 4 and 5 were precisely the same, and as he was quite certain his friend did not wish to be vindictive, that it was unnecessary to proceed with both charges. He therefore suggested that No. 5 might be withdrawn. Mr. Skerry consented to this course. Mr. Lightfoot said that on his advice, Mr. Thompson had decided to plead guilty to the other charges, but he should have a few observations by way of extenuation or explanation. Mr. Skerry said he would take No. 3 charge. John Boland Atkinson, H. M. Inspector, gave formal evidence as regards that shot-firing by Humphrey Evans, who was not authorised in writing to undertake that work. Witness considered that clause very necessary to be observed in the coalmine. He did not think that Mr. Thompson had taken all reasonable means to prevent this. Humphrey Evans, drifter, working in the Ellenborough Colliery, said that on the 28th March, he fired two shots. He used explosives, and fired them about 20 yards from the face of the drifts. There was gas found in the far end of the drift. The drift was making gas every day. It was coming from the metal band of coal. It was a day drift. He had never been appointed in writing. He got verbal orders. By Mr. Lightfoot: Dempsey authorised him to fire the shots, Mr. Thompson did not. Mr. Skerry: Did Mr. Thompson know you were firing? - Yes, sir. Dempsey would tell him. Mr. Skerry said it would be an unnecessary waste of time under the circumstances to call any more evidence. Mr. Lightfoot said that although Mr. Thompson was probably wise in pleading guilty, yet there was a considerable amount to be said in extenuation of his guilt if he might call it such. There was one charge relative to the absence of man-holes in the place where man-holes ought to have existed. The remaining charges had reference to explosives, and he asked the Bench to deal broadly with them as two charges. Man-holes were places of safety, placed by the side of a main road so that men might get into them and avoid the tubs. This particular road had been out of use up to about two years ago. Then it became necessary to work certain coal, and the road had to be repaired and timbered. Then the timber broke at the top, and to heighten the road, they took 3ft. 6ins. of metal of the roof. This metal was stowed in the workings. It was in a state of transition. They intended taking the metal into some old workings, but as it happened, there were no man-holes. Mr. Thompson had arranged for the metal to be moved, and had taken every precaution, giving an order that no man should be allowed in the place while the tubs were running. Mr. Thompson was an experienced manager, and knew the necessity of man-holes. It was an exceptional case. The road had not been in use, it was being altered and he wanted them to understand that it was not part of the ordinary working of the mine. With regard to the other charges, Mr. Thompson did not know that Humphrey Evans had fired the shot; it appeared that instructions to fire the shot were given by the under manager. Evans had that been appointed in writing as shot-firer, but it could not be challenged that Humphrey Evans, as people in mining circles know, was a very experience man. He was not appointed, but he was a man perfectly safe to fire a shot, as he had been connected with mining all his life. Evans would be the last person to suggest he was not competent to fire a shot. With regard to the other charges respecting explosives, Mr. Thompson had nothing personally to do with them, as they were breaches of the discipline of the mine, and were very much against defendant's consent. Still Mr. Thompson was responsible, but that was a very different matter from any personal neglect. Mr. Thompson had a life-long experience of mining, and 20 years experience of mine management, and he was the last person to do anything grossly neglectful, or to commit any breach of the Act that could reasonably be prevented. He had never been before a Court of Justice on any charge connected with the management of a mine, or any charge, and he suggested that as there were only practically two charges the scales of justice might be met if the inflected a substantial penalty, what they considered would be right and fair in the one, and deal with the others by imposing sums of a more nominal character. Mr. Skerry said, as regards the penalty personally, be thought the Director of Public Prosecutions might agree with Mr. Lightfoot as regards the penalties, but personally, so far as he was concerned he did not care to take it upon himself to do so. The magistrates retired, and on their return the Chairman (Mr. Maughan), said they were quite alive to the danger of carelessness in mines. They had had very serious explosions and fires in their own neighbourhood, and while they would be very glad to be lenient with a neighbouring Company, yet, at the same time, they had to make an example for the safety of the miners in the neighbourhood, and they had decided that in the case of firing the fuse by an official, who had not been appointed to make the fine £5 and costs, and in the other five cases £1 and costs in each case.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||