Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th April 1911

Shocking Fatality At Harrington Colliery

The Inquest, Last Night

The inquiry into the shocking fatality which occurred at the Harrington Colliery on Monday, when William Chester, a machine attendant, was snatched up into the machinery and instantly killed, was opened by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry last (Wednesday) night, in the Parish Room, Parton. Mr. L. T. Helder appeared for the Colliery Co., while Mr. W. Leck, Inspector of Mines, was also present. Mr. J. T. Spencer was foreman of the jury.

Daniel Chester, who said he was employed by the Workington Iron and Steel Co. at the Harrington Colliery, identified the body as that of his son, who was an unmarried man of 19 years of age, and lived with him at Beech House, Parton. His son was a machine attendant at the Harrington Colliery. On Sunday night his son went to bed about ten o'clock, and got up to go to work the next morning a letter before five. That was the last time he saw him alive. Deceased was in good health when he left the house, and as far as he could tell, there was nothing the matter with him. He never knew deceased to have any fits or illness of any kind. He thought that deceased's duties were to look after the electric plant on the screen.

Wm. Henry Johnstone stated that he resided at Egremont and was the surveyor at the Harrington Colliery. He then produced a plan, drawn by himself, of the place where the accident happened, which he stated was correct. Witness then explained the plan to the officials and the jurymen.

John Peacock, 54, Lonsdale-street, Workington, said that he was an inspector of the screens at this colliery. His duties were to look after the cleaning of the coal. He was at work on the 24th inst. and remembered seeing William Henry Chester at 12.20 in the morning. He was talking to a woman; and that was the last time he saw him alive. Deceased walked away towards the motor house. Witness then noticed that the coal started to come thick on one of the tables and so he shouted to one of the boys to put some coal on the other table. No notice, however, was taken of his request. So he slipped up to see what was wrong. One of the boys told him that there was something wrong with the "tippler," and witness asked "Where is Chester?" The lad replied, "I don't know." Witness told the boy that he had better go and look for him. They had no idea where he was. He wanted Chester to see what was wrong with the "Tippler." It was the deceased's duty to put it right. At about ten minutes to one the other screen inspector — Hugh Campbell — came on duty and witness asked him to go up and see what was wrong that all the coals were coming on one table. The next thing he saw was Campbell running to fetch a fitter named John Vendall. When Campbell came back witness went to see where they were going, with the result that they found poor Chester among the machinery. Chester was fixed underneath the jigger. He couldn't see his face — just his legs and half of his body. The body was fixed between the belt on the machine and the top of the ceiling. Deceased had used a ladder to get up; he was not big enough to reach it without. He thought that he must have been oiling a cup or something of that kind. Deceased was quite dead when they found him.

The Coroner: Do you know how long he had been there? — He must have gone straight there when I saw him at 12.20, so that he would be there until we found him about 12.55.

The Coroner: Was the machinery stopped? — Yes; the tippler wouldn't work. As soon as we liberated him, however, it started to work all right.

The Coroner: So that you think he must have been like that ever since you noticed the tippler had not been working? — Yes, sir.

The Coroner: When you found that the tippler was not working did you not think of going to see what was wrong? — As a rule when there is anything wrong one of the boys goes over to see the reason.

The Coroner: Had one of the boys gone over on this occasion? — Yes; but they could not find Chester.

The Coroner: Do you know how the deceased could have got into the position you found him? — I think he must have gone up to oil or grease something and his coat must have caught on a stud. The machine must then have drawn him up.

The Coroner: Do you think there is any danger in oiling these cups when the machine is in motion? — Yes. I think there would be. Continuing, witness stated in reply to further questions, that the machine attendants did their oiling between two o'clock and half past two, when the machines were not in motion. It would have been entirely within the option of the deceased to have stopped the machine had he wished.

Cross-examined by the Foreman: The distance between the ceiling and the machine was about two feet.

By Mr. Leck: Did you notice whether there was any oil-can about or a grease tin? — Yes, there was a grease tin close beside him. It was that that led him to think the deceased had been greasing the cup.

Mr. Leck: Are there any notices about attendants oiling machines when in motion? — I have not seen any.

In reply to further questions from the Inspector, witness said that it was not necessary for deceased to tell anyone before he stopped the machine. Deceased could stop it when he wanted. He did not notice that deceased was mutilated when they got him. He only saw a little mark on his forehead. Witness was led to believe that the deceased had been caught by his clothes, by the fact that they were torn. Deceased had been machine attendant for about six months.

By Mr. Helder: Deceased had had considerably more experience than six months on electric machinery.

Had he thought there was any danger at this time could be have stopped the engine at once? — Yes, sir.

Would that have stopped this wheel which was supposed to have caught him — Yes, sir.

Philip McGuire, 23, Copperas Hill, Harrington, who stated he was a tub cleaner, was the next witness to be called. On the 4th inst., about 12.15 at noon he noticed that something was wrong with No. 3 tippler. On account of this he went round looking for Chester, because he was the man to put it right. He went in the haulage and then into the joiner's shop, but could not find him. He then went back to the screen and saw deceased on the ladder.

The Coroner: Did you see anything wrong with him? — I saw he had a white face, and so I thought he must be dead.

The Coroner: Why didn't you go to the screen first when you went to look for him? — I shouted there before I went to the haulage, but I got no answer.

Witness, continuing, said that deceased's feet were not resting on the ladder. His head appeared to be caught between the roof and the machinery. Witness thought he was quite dead. He then went and brought the "gaffer", who extricated the deceased.

Hugh Campbell deposed that he was a screen foreman and came on duty on Monday at 12.50 at noon.

The Coroner: What do you know about this accident?

Witness said that when he came to work Peacock told him there was no coal coming down the screen, so he went up and asked the lads what was the matter. The lads said they didn't know. So he went to the motor-house and shouted for Chester but received no answer. He then went in, and saw McGuire get hold of the deceased and shake him by the foot. Witness shouted, "What's up Chester?" but deceased made no reply, he was dead. He ordered the lad McGuire to go and stop the motor and then went and fetched John Vendall, and they extricated Chester. He had never known this tippler fail to work before.

The Coroner: Could you form any opinion as to how the deceased got there? — No, not unless he was caught by that set stud.

In answer to another question, witness said that deceased was bruised on the right side of his face.

Replying to the Foreman, witness stated that there would be no chance of deceased's body going right over between the machine and the ceiling.

Mr. Leck: Supposing he had stopped this machinery of his own accord, would there have been any complaint from any official about it? — No, I don't think there would.

Hodgson Phillipson stated that he lived at Parton, and was a machine assistant at No. 9 pit. He looked after the machinery at the screens, and his duties were the same as William Chester's — the deceased. They worked on opposite shifts. Their duties were to start the machinery and keep it going all right. They sometimes changed and repaired the beltings and also did oiling. The oiling they did from five to six in a morning before they started, or between two to half-past two in the afternoon. They also oiled on Sunday. During these periods the machine was not in motion.

The Coroner: Have you ever to oil between five in the morning and two in the afternoon, and do you stop the machinery for oiling purposes? — Yes, we do sometimes.

The Coroner: Do you ever oil the machinery when it is in motion? — Yes, I have done it sometimes.

The Coroner: Do you think it is dangerous to take the risk sometimes? — Yes.

Is there anything to prevent you from stopping the machinery? — Yes, it would keep the pit standing.

Do you mean you take the risk of oiling while the machinery is in motion so that you won't stop the pit? — Yes.

Do you see any risk in it? — No.

Witness further stated that he knew the place where the deceased had been killed. He thought that deceased would have gone there to fill the cup.

The Coroner: Can you account for his doing it when the machinery was in motion? — No.

The Coroner: Was he in the habit of doing it? — No, sir.

Cross-examined by Mr. Leck, witness said that Mr. Miller had told him that he was never to oil anything while it was in motion. The officials would not have complained if they had stopped the motor.

Andrew Miller, manager of the colliery, said that the men had had instructions from him not to oil anything that was in motion. By this he did not mean all the machinery. There were some parts that could not be oiled unless the machine was in motion, but with respect to this there was not the slightest possible danger whatever. He agreed with Mr. Leck that it might be better to have rules printed with respect to the oiling, so that the men could see them.

The Coroner, in addressing the jury, said that from the evidence submitted they should have no difficulty in ascertaining the cause of death, which in all probability was caused, as the surveyor had suggested, by his coat being caught in the machinery and breaking his neck. The department in which he was working seemed to have been entirely in Chester's control, and there was nothing to prevent him from stopping the machinery.

After a short deliberation the Foreman said that the jury had unanimously decided on a verdict of "Accidental death." They could find no blame attached to anyone. They recommended, however, that the set screws which apparently caught the deceased and brought about his death be counter-sunk, if it would not interfere with the work.

Mr. Helder, on behalf of the Company, said he was sure that if this was at all feasible the Company would comply with the request. He expressed his sincere regret that this accident should have happened. He understood deceased was a very estimable fellow and a good workman. His death was very much regretted, and on behalf of the Company he expressed their heartfelt sympathy.

The Foreman: On behalf of the jury, I wish to do the same for them.

Mr. Chester: Thank you.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Campbell, Hugh    Screen Foreman  
Campbell, Hugh    Screen Inspector  
Chester, Daniel    Miner  
Chester, William Henry   19 Machine Attendant  Deceased, Individual Page
Helder, L. T.    Solicitor  
Johnston, William Henry    Colliery Surveyor  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
McGuire, Philip    Tub Cleaner  
Millar, Andrew    Manager  Whos Who Page
Peacock, John    Screen Inspector  
Phillipson, Hodgson    Machine Attendant  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Spencer, J. T.    Jury Foreman  
Vendall, John    Fitter  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Harrington Colliery  Harrington Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print