|
27th April 1911 Death Of A Hodbarrow MinerVerdict Of Natural CausesWilliam John Blackwell, a miner at the Hodbarrow Mines, met with an accident by which he broke his leg, and before leaving the Hodbarrow Hospital, died on Sunday last. Up to the last day of his life the deceased appeared to be making very good progress towards recovery, so much so that he was nearly ready to leave the hospital when he was seized with a fainting fit, from which he expired. The inquest was held at the Hodbarrow Hospital on Tuesday, before Mr. W. T. Lawrence, deputy-coroner, and a jury, of which Mr. C. Ward was foreman. William Jenkin Blackwell, miner stated that the deceased was his son, and lived at Concrete Square, Haverigg, and was 33 years of age. He was an iron ore miner. He identified the body viewed by the jury as Wm. John Blackwell. Witness worked with the deceased at the Hodbarrow Mines. The deceased was employed by the Company about 15 years, and witness was employed by the Company for 40 years. On Thursday, 6th April, the deceased was working with witness and Samuel Park, another miner, in No. 6 Pit, in the seaward direction. This would be about on o'clock. Witness was arranging to put in a prop after firing a shot, and the other two were cleaning up the metal. The shot that was fired did not do any harm to the timber, which appeared to be safe and sound. Though there was no appearance of danger, in accordance with the usual custom they put a prop in. Without any warning the wood slipped and crashed down, and fell on deceased. There was a fall of a good many head trees. The other two men were not hit by the fall, but it covered the deceased all but one hand. Witness and his companion immediately removed the timber and they got deceased out in about five minutes. At the time he was not insensible, and he asked if there was any more rubbish to come, and on replying there was not, witness, with assistance, had the deceased taken to the hospital. The deceased them complained of his breast, back, and leg. Witness and deceased at the time of the accident happened were engaged on their usual work and they had not done anything out of the common. They carried out the instructions of the mines, everything being done in proper order. The place was not a dangerous one. It was at the other side of the old sea wall, and he was not aware that there was any more danger there than in other parts of the mine. About one hour previous to the accident the place was inspected by Capt Coade. and Capt. Sampson. Everything then was looking safe and sound. The only direction they got was to keep themselves safe, and they replied they always did so. Witness saw his son twice before his death. The last time witness saw him he appeared to be in a deal of pain. That would be the previous Wednesday. Nothing was then mentioned about the accident, but deceased complained of a pain in his left side. Though no teetotal he never drank to excess. Witness never knew him to lose more than a week through illness. Witness thought when he went into the pit he was in his usual good health. Examined by Mr. Leck :— Does an official visit and inspect the working every shift? — Yes, sir. That is done regularly? — Yes, sir. Can you tell us which captain was in the working place last before the accident? — Captain Sampson. You say that you had to put in plenty of timber. Did you put in any timber after you got the instruction? — No. I was getting ready to put in a small prop. There was no room for further timber? — No. You will have seen the rules posted up, that there was not to be more than 6 ft. between the last headtree and the forebreast? I will put in one of the special rules (rule 18) to this effect? — We were not 2 ft. The last headtree was close to the forebreast? — Yes. So far as the special rule is concerned you were well within it? — Yes. What kind of work was this — slipe or solid? — A slipe. We took the body in front and it was loose at both sides. Was the working nearly finished, or had it to go on a good while? — It was nearly finished. Was the stone coming down in front? — Yes. How many shots did you fire before the accident? — Three shots. How long did you wait outside? — Ten minutes. Was the place full of smoke when you came in? — Not so much. There was plenty of air. Did you notice if any of the folks had suffered from the effect of the shot? — No, sir. Did you notice if the wood was disturbed in any way? — No, only one piece had not much hold, and it was there because he was putting in a prop. So that as your opinion goes the shot did affect the timber? — No, sir. What height was the place? — 7 ft. high. When the timber came down did any of the roof fall? — No, sir. It was solid rock on the top. Then you put timber to support the roof in all cases, so that when the timber came away the roof remained standing? — Yes, the roof was good enough. Do you timber where the roof is good? — Yes. Well, that is the proper protection, and I am glad to hear that you do so: and so, although a place looks safe you put timber in? — Yes. If a rush of roof came in it would have buried the three of you? — Yes, if anything came except the timber all three would be buried. Was there an ambulance man there? — Yes. Did he render first aid? — Yes: one was sent for, and he rendered first aid immediately. In reply to Mr. Lawrence, deputy-coroner, witness stated that they were always well supplied with timber. He had nothing detrimental to say as to the way the miners were allowed timber or as to the way they were treated. Mr. Leck said he was glad the question was asked, but it was so well known that everything was provided at Hodbarrow that he took it as a matter of course. Dr. Stoney, medical officer for the Hodbarrow Hospital, stated that he was called to see deceased on the 6th April at the hospital in the afternoon, about 2.30. He arrived before he was stripped. The deceased's right leg was broken and the ankle joint. That was all witness found. Deceased did not make any complaint about any other injury, neither then nor afterwards. He was, therefore, only superficially examined. The fracture was reduced, and the leg put in splints, and he attended him regularly. There was no increase of temperature for a week after the accident, and no bad symptoms of any kind. In fact, he went on so well that the leg was taken out of splints sooner than usual, and he was allowed to get up and get out of bed, but witness understood that he never did so. It was last Friday that he was allowed to do this. When witness left the deceased he seemed to be almost as well as ever, laughing and joking, and witness suggested that he might be able to go home at the end of the week. On Sunday afternoon witness got a message that the man was much worse, and that he had to come at once. Witness found that he was then dead. In his estimation he considered that death was due to a weak heart, though witness was not told the man had such a complaint, nor were there symptoms of it. The deceased had told witness that he was never to a doctor in his life. He was a man that smoked heavily, and that might cause a weak heart. Continuing, in reply to the Coroner's questions, the doctor stated that the deceased was a stout man, and was such as might have a flabby heart, which would be affected by heavy smoking or by drink. He did not think the accident had anything to do with the cause of death. One day he complained of pains due to colic, but that was due to him eating a lot of nuts and oranges which his friends had brought. The deceased was in such a fair way for recovery that he was prepared to let him go out at once. The doctor stated that everything possible had been done for the deceased. The nurse that had been with him when he died was a capable ambulance man. He had not complained of any pain beyond the colic. In reply to Mr. Greenwood, witness stated that the explosion he alluded to and feared at first would not be the cause of death, nor did the oranges affect the deceased. The explosion he referred to was some outbreak which might have arisen through the change in his surroundings. He was unable to tell what the cause of death was without a post-mortem examination, but if that was made he would be greatly surprised to find that the man died from anything but a weak and degenerate heart. Mr. Leck: But you did not suspect that he had a weak heart? — There was nothing in the pulse to show that he had a weak heart, but still the heart might have been flabby without it being indicated by the pulse in a man in middle life. You mentioned that it was possible that there might be haemorrhage of the brain? — Yes, a clot of blood might get on the brain. In consequence of the accident? — No, I could not see how it could do that. John Henry Stephens, railway clerk, employed by the Furness Railway Co. at Millom, stated that he knew deceased from the time he came into the hospital. He frequently saw the deceased. Last Sunday, between a quarter and twenty minutes past three the deceased rang the bell, and witness, who was in charge of the ward, went to see what was the matter. Deceased was the only patient in the ward. He was looking pale and complained of being ill. About ten minutes past two witness saw him in the ward previously, when he was apparently all right. They had been then talking about half-an-hour. He was then cheerful, and apparently well. He did not them complain of anything. Witness left him as the door bell rang. In about an hour after deceased rang the bell, and witness went to see what was the matter. When witness went in deceased asked him to open the window as he felt faint. He said his visitors had been smoking cigarettes and the room was full of smoke. Four young men had visited him during the hour. The deceased was a smoker and had smoked a pipe that afternoon. The man was partially in a convalescent stage, on a good way to recovery. After the window was opened that deceased fell over in a faint. Witness caught hold of him and gave him a drink of water, and in about a minutes he came round, and witness asked deceased if he could hold up till a little brandy was got. Witness got the brandy and gave it into his hand. It was diluted with water to the extent of one half. Deceased took it and drank about half of it. There would be a quarter of a tumblerful in it. He then said "I don't think I am coming on right somehow." Witness told him to drink the remainder of the brandy, and witness then went and opened the big window. When witness returned deceased started to go off in a faint again, and witness caught hold of him, pulled out the bed rest and laid him flat on his back, and tried to give him the remainder of the brandy. He swallowed part and died soon after. The brandy and water was all he had to drink. Witness was used to dealing with sick persons during the last four years, when he was at it. Witness was a certificated ambulance man, and had passed six examinations. He knew how to deal with a patient in the state of collapse. Witness could not call for assistance, as there was no one near. The nurse and witness's sister was out only an hour and ten minutes. The Coroner having briefly summed up, a verdict of "Death from natural causes" was returned.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||