27th April 1911
The Death By Poisoning At Whitehaven
Workmen's Compensation Act
Questioned Cause Of Death
On Saturday forenoon Mr. Atter, Coroner, held an inquest at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary, upon the body of William Fitzsimons, collier, Park View, Newton, the sad circumstances of whose death were reported in the Free Press.
Mr. R. Wilson was chosen foreman of the jury.
Elizabeth Ann Fitzsimons, the widow, deposed that her husband was 33 years of age, and had been working at William Pit for the past few months, having previously worked at Wellington Pit. He met with an accident on April 12th, getting his hand crushed
while moving a tub of coal. He had been off work since, and was attended by Drs. Harris and Thorpe. His hand got worse. On Wednesday night he was very restless, told her he was suffering from pain in his hand. About four o'clock on Thursday morning
he got up, saying he would go next door to witness's mother for a cup of tea. Witness offered to get him a cup of tea, but he persisted in getting up and she helped him to dress. The next time witness saw her husband was about a quarter past seven when
she went to her mother's house in response to a call by her sister Jennie. Her husband was sitting in a rocking chair. He was sick and looked very bad, and she asked him if he had had anything to eat. He had not been able to eat much since the
accident. Anything he did eat caused him to vomit. In reply to witness's question her husband said "I went to get a dose out of Alf's bottle of quinine, and I have taken spirits of salt in mistake." She asked him how much he had taken, and
he said "about a mouthful," and that he had got the bottle out of the cupboard. Witness sent for her brother Alfred, and asked him how much had gone out of the bottle, and he said "very little."
By the Coroner: From what her husband said she had no doubt that he had made a mistake. He had been cheerful and only complained about his hand. He had no other trouble. Witness's sister went for Dr. Harris about twenty minutes to eight.
Elizabeth Choyce, married woman, who lives at No. 1, Park View, said she had seen her son-in-law at different times since his accident at the pit and he complained about the injury to his hand, saying he was about sick of it. When he came to her house
on Thursday morning she made him a cup of tea, and he afterward lay down on a sofa. At six o'clock witness got up to see her son off to his work, and deceased was then awake and sitting on the sofa. She went upstairs again, and shortly after seven she
heard her son-in-law vomiting. When she went down stairs to him he told her what had happened. There was a cupboard in the room. It was kept locked, but the key was in the door. There were all kinds of bottles in the cupboard, and amongst them was
one containing some spirits of salt and zinc, which had been got for soldering purposes. There was also a bottle of quinine, which her son Alfred had got for a tonic. Deceased said he had taken the bottle containing the spirits of salt in mistake for
the other one. She thought her son got the spirits of salt from the place he worked. She never heard her son-in-law threaten to take his life. He had no trouble except his hand.
By the Forman: Her son was a tinsmith and brazier, and had the spirits of salt and zinc for doing little jobs.
Alfred Choyce, brother-in-law of the deceased, said the latter had often complained to him about his hand. When he got up on Thursday morning he found the deceased lying, as if asleep, on the sofa. He asked him how he felt, and deceased replied that
his hand was very bad. Witness got the bottle of quinine and iron on Tuesday, because he could not eat, and he asked deceased to take some, because he thought it might encourage him to eat. Deceased said he would. He did not get the bottle out of the
cupboard for his brother-in-law, as the latter knew where it was. When witness was shown the bottle of spirits of salt later on he asked if much had gone out of it, and he said "No, if any." He gave deceased some salt and water to make him
sick. He did not say anything to witness, but he (witness) felt sure what had happened was quite an accident.
By the Foreman: He thought deceased much have had some of the tonic on Tuesday, because he told witness it was nothing to take. The bottle of salts was similar in height to the bottle of tonic, and it would be easy for deceased to make a mistake, as
the blind was only partly up. If the bottle had been labelled he would have seen what it was.
By Mr. G. Palmer (a juror): The quinine bottle was not labelled.
Mr. Gair (another juror): It was very careless work, and should have been seen to by all means. It was a vital thing that the bottles should have been labelled.
Nurse Hampton said that in response to a message brought by a girl she went to Mrs. Choyce's house about half-past one on Thursday, and she then found Fitzsimons in a dying condition. About eight o'clock on Thursday evening deceased told her he intended
to take quinine and got the wrong bottle by mistake.
Dr. Thorpe, assistant to Dr. Harris was next called, and a written statement which he had drawn up, was read by the Coroner. This was to the effect that Fitzsimons had been attended by Dr. Harris and witness since April 12th for a septic finger.
Deceased was an extremely nervous and delicate patient. On Thursday morning they received a message that he had passed a very bad night, and as he was too bad to go to surgery, would they call and attend to him. It was also stated that he had taken a
spoonful of methylated spirits. As the quantity was small and the drug was not uncommonly taken by men in the district they concluded that the deceased had taken it with a view to it acting as a stimulant. On witness's arrival at about 10.30 to 10.45
am, he found the patient lying on a couch in his mother-in-law's house. He sat up for witness to attend to him. He was vomiting occasionally, and had been doing so for some days, and he had some diarrhoea. As no mention was made of anything poisonous,
witness considered his condition was due to the state of his finger. About half-past two Nurse Hampton called on witness, and stated that she had found Fitzsimons in a collapsed state. Witness then asked her to make preparations, as he might find it
necessary to operate on the spot. At the time neither Nurse Hampton nor himself had heard anything of the poison. On his way to the house he met Dr. Harris, who returned with him to the patient, and then he was shown a bottle which contained a liquid
said to be spirits of salt, of which Fitzsimons had taken a mouthful, and which had since proved to be a solution of chloride of zinc with hydrochloric acid. Witness relieved Dr. Harris, and with Nurse Hampton attended to the case all the afternoon and
evening. Deceased become more and more collapsed, and died on Friday morning. Witness was of opinion that death was due to the shock following irritant poisoning, a small dose of which, self administered, had acted with a special force on constitution
already debilitated by blood poisoning.
Witness, in reply to the Coroner, said a slight operation was performed on the injured finger which was on the right hand, on Tuesday. He was of opinion that the quantity of poison which deceased had drunk was not sufficient to cause death in a healthy
man.
The Coroner: But he would be in a nervous and weak condition as the result of the accident, and as he had been vomiting everything he took his stomach would be in a bad way.
Witness: Yes. I think the salts would kill him in the state he was in.
Replying to further questions, witness said that blood poisoning might ultimately have caused that man's death if he had not drunk the poison. There were symptoms of blood poisoning before Thursday, and when Nurse Hampton called he thought that possibly
he would have to amputate the man's arm.
Inspector Rae also gave evidence as to the result of the inquiries which he made on Friday morning.
The Coroner said the fact of deceased having drunk the poison by mistake seemed to have been kept back.
Dr. Thorpe said there certainly seemed to have been a great deal of secrecy about it.
Jane Choyce, sister-in-law of Fitzsimons, stated that she went to Dr. Harris's a little before eight o'clock on Thursday morning, and asked the doctor if he could go to see her brother-in-law, as he was very ill.
The Coroner: Did you mention about his having taken this (referring to the contents of the bottle) to the doctor? - Witness: Yes.
What did you say? - I think I said he had taken spirits of salt, but I cannot be sure. She didn't take the bottle with her.
The Coroner said that probably if he had known all the circumstances as he know them then, after hearing the doctor's evidence, he might have considered it desirable that the Inspector of Mines should have notice of the occurrence in order to give a full
opportunity of testing whether or not the accident Fitzsimons met with on April 12th was really the direct or indirect cause of death. It might be considered as indirect in one way - that the man being restless and constantly suffering from pain, drank
a portion of the contents of the bottle, apparently mistaking it for quinine. As regards the actual cause of death they had heard the medical evidence, and he took it the jury would be guided by the evidence. It was rather strange, remarked the
Coroner, that neither the doctor not the nurse had any information given them as to Fitzsimons having made the mistake of drinking the poison until half-past two on Thursday afternoon.
Mr. Palmer asked Dr. Thorpe what was the nature of the operation performed on Fitzsimons finger?
Dr. Thorpe: It was a slight incision to let out the pus.
Was he in a dangerous state then? - Certainly not.
Was the any likelihood of him dying from blood poisoning? - Not from the local blood poisoning.
You made the remark that he might have to lose his arm? - That was from Nurse Hampton's statement.
Does that mean that blood poisoning might have killed him? - Blood poisoning might kill anybody if it sets in.
Replying to the Foreman, the doctor said that in this case the blood poisoning might have spread.
By Mr. Palmer: The accident was one of the indirect causes of death - he did not say it was the direct cause.
After the jury had deliberated for some minutes, the Foreman said they were rather divided in their opinion.
The Coroner again suggested that they might be guided by the medical evidence.
During further deliberations a question was put to Nurse Hampton, who stated that deceased told her he only had a mouthful of the spirits of salt, and when he discovered his mistake he spat it out.
Mr. Palmer: That proves that the man did not die from poisoning. I think blood poisoning from the accident has caused his death.
Dr. Thorpe: I cannot agree with that. Death was undoubtedly due to shock caused by the irritant poison.
The jury ultimately retuned a verdict to the effect that Fitzsimons died from shock following irritant poison, which acted with a special force on a constitution already debilitated by blood poisoning, occasioned by an accident on April 12th to one of
his fingers.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Atter, Edward | | Coroner | |
| Choyce, Alfred | | | |
| Choyce, Elizabeth | | | |
| Choyce, Jane | | | |
| Fitzsimmons, Elizabeth Ann | | | Wife |
| Fitzsimmons, William | 33 | Collier | |
| Gair, — | | Juror | |
| Hamton, — | | Nurse | |
| Harris, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Palmer, — | | | |
| Palmer, G. | | Juror | |
| Rae, — | | Police Inspector | |
| Thorpe, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Wilson, R. | | Jury Foreman | |