|
20th April 1911 Colliery Case At WhitehavenReaping The Fruits Of Another Man's LabourAt the Whitehaven Police-court, on Thursday, John Pilkington, collier, 10, West End Row, Lowca, was charged with contravening a special rule at No. 9 Pit, Harrington Collieries, by going into a working-place other than the one in which he was employed, on the 23rd March, 1911. Mr. W. H. Chapman, who appeared for the Colliery Co., in outlining the case, said that it referred to the special rule 111, which stated that a workman could not go into any other part than that in which he was employed. The facts really savoured more of larceny than anything else, but the manner in which the defendant was now charged was the readiest method by which he could be reached. Proceeding to the facts of the case, Mr. Chapman said that on the 23rd March there was a shortage of tubs in this pit. The manager, Mr. Andrew Miller, took advantage of this to make an inspection, and with this intention he went down, together with John Wilson and George Miller, the deputy. On coming to the working place of Alexander Powe they found a tub and a shovel lying beside it. The tub was about half-full. As there was a shortage of tubs this seemed rather unusual, and they proceeded to examine the token, and found that the token on the tub was No. 302, which was the number of the defendant. From Powe's place they proceeded to defendant's working-place, and Miller asked him if he had been in Powe's place; and told him that if he had done so he had violated the rules, which stated that a man could not go into another man's place. The manager also told him be would have to take proceedings against him. The system, it seemed, was on of two shifts in 24 hours. Each company was made up of three men, and the arrangement among the men was this: that if a company of three men went out leaving the coals for the other company, the latter might take advantage of it, and they were allowed to take it up. This, of course, was six of one and half-a-dozen of the other, because there would be a corresponding advantage to the other men when their turn came round. If, however, a man of another working place proceeded to get it he was defrauding someone, and that was why this case savoured of larceny more than anything else. Andrew Miller said that he was the manager of No. 9 Pit of the Harrington Collieries. On the 27th ult. there was a shortage of tubs, and he took advantage of this to make an examination. With John Wilson and George Miller, witness proceeded on this examination, and at Alexander Powe's place found a tub half-fully as Mr. Chapman had stated. Defendant had no right to go into another man's place, unless he got orders from the deputy. John Wilson gave corroborative evidence. Asked if he had any statement to make, defendant said that it was a known thing for a man to go into another man's place. The Chairman: Do you mean that you had right to? Defendant: I have done it before that time. It is a common thing for men to take it when they have gone home. Mr. Chapman said that was why the manager wished to stop it. It was reaping the fruit of another man's labour. A meaner thing he couldn't imagine. The men were naturally very indignant at what this man had done. The Chairman said that the very fact of it having been done before made the case worse and all the more urgent it should be stopped. Defendant: I don't see how you can stop it. The Chairman: But we are going to stop it. Defendant was fined 20s or default 14 day's imprisonment.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||