|
15th April 1911, Page: 5, Column: 5 Drift InundationInquest on Gilfach VictimsWater Tapped by Top HoleA verdict of "Accidental death" was returned by the jury at the inquest on Tuesday on the bodies of Evan Lewis and Thomas John Lewis, father and son, who were the victims of the flooding of the Dyllas Isha Drift at Gilfach Goch on the 24th March. Dr. W. N. Atkinson, Inspector of Mines, was present at the inquiry. Mr. Charles Kenshole, solicitor, Aberdare, represented the owners or the colliery ; and Mr. W. P. Nicholas, Pontypridd (instructed by Mr. Tom Lucas, miners' agent for the Ogmore district), watched the proceedings on behalf of the relatives. Mr. Edward Gill represented the Executive Council of the South Wales Miners' Federation. Top Hole which Tapped the Water. Mr. Frederick Lewis, managing director of the Etna Colliery Company, owners of the drift, said that after his company had taken over the mine he made an inspection of the old workings. There was an opening on the north-east giving entry into Gray's Dip, which ran for some distance due south. Near the end of the dip was a cross heading to the north-east. He found there was free drainage towards the south-west, and came to the conclusion that the workings, around Gray's Dip were free from any accumulations of water. They commenced to re-open the colliery from a point south-west of Gray's Dip, and after driving through solid coal they entered an old level which ran slightly south, crossing the end of Gray's Dip and running almost parallel with the cross-heading. They drove some top-holes in the direction of Gray's Dip and took the precaution to bore, as they thought there might be a pocket of water at the bottom of the dip. One top-hole, however, that in which Evan Lewis and his son were working, was driven in the direction of the cross-heading mentioned. No boring precautions were taken as it was considered that there was no likelihood of there being an accumulation of water in the heading, owing to the free drainage which witness had found there during his inspection. It was this top-hole which tapped the water. An inspection of the place after the disaster showed that the top-hole driven by Evan Lewis had struck into a place which witness felt sure was the old south-east cross-heading from Gray's Dip. About a yard or so to the right of this spot was the face, and about eight yards to the left was a fall. Between the fall and the face water had accumulated, so witness thought, to the height of a yard or so, which the deceased had tapped. Dr. Atkinson: I suggest that he did not strike into the heading at all, but into a small place shown on the Home Office record plans but not on that copy plan of yours. Dilapidated Plan. Witness said he felt positive that it was the old heading into which they had struck. The place shown on the Home Office plan was now shown on the colliery plan. Witness produced the working plan of the colliery, and said the only sign of the place pointed out by Dr. Atkinson was either a pencil mark or some faded colour. He thought the place shown on the Home Office plan was an airway driven into the coal. He was positive the top-hole had been driven into a heading because it was six feet wide, and airways in that colliery were only four feet wide. Dr. Atkinson said the mark on the colliery plan looked like a crease, and no one would have observed it. He remarked that the plan was most dilapidated. Witness: It is 20 years old. Dr. Atkinson: It might be a hundred by the look of it. Is it reliable to work by such a plan ? Witness said that in re-opening the colliery they had found the old plan reliable. Dr. Atkinson: When you made the inspection in 1909, did you see a fall which you could not get over in the heading into which you say you have struck ? — Yes. Didn't you think it possible that water might have been dammed back by that fall? — Water was running through it, and I thought that there was free drainage and no danger. Dr. Atkinson: Your idea of danger is different from mine. Summing Up and Verdict. The Coroner, summing up, said it seemed impossible for the jury to definitely decide between the theory of Dr. Atkinson and that of Mr. Lewis as to the place into which the top-hole driven by Evan Lewis struck. From the evidence given by Mr. Lewis as to the size of the place, it would appear to have been an heading, and not an airway. The jury had to decide whether there was reasonable cause to believe that the part of the workings towards which the top-hole was being driven might reasonably be expected to contain an accumulation of water, because in such circumstances the rules laid it down that boring must be carried out. The jury, as stated above, returned a verdict of "Accidental death," and found that the place which the top-hole was driven into could not be reasonably supposed to contain accumulation of water.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||