|
30th March 1911 Whitehaven Colliers Breach Of Contract.Ordered To Pay Company's LossSequel To A Death At The MineAt the Whitehaven Police-court, on Thursday, before Wm. McGowan (in the chair), W. H. Watson, J. Braithwaite (Mayor), and E. F. Lowthorpe-Lutwidge, Esqs., 147 colliers and pithands were charged at the instance of the Whitehaven Colliery Co. with committing a breach of contract of service, by which the Company suffered loss at Whitehaven, on February 16th. Mr. W. H. Chapman, solicitor, Whitehaven, represented the Company, and Mr. Bendall, solicitor, Maryport, defended. Mr. Chapman, in opening the case against Wm. Telford, one of the coal hewers, said this was one of a large series of cases of technicality, and was brought under the Employers' & Workmen's Act, in which the Company claimed the sum of 5s 7d damages. They were only dealing now with an individual case. The breach of contract he contended was caused by defendant (Telford) not going to work on the morning shift of February 16th. He would prove to them the contract in this particular case, which he would read to the Bench, and the contract was in respect of which the breach complained of was committed. The contract as read by Mr. Chapman showed that the defendant had put his signature to an agreement, in which it stated he had to give to and receive from the Whitehaven Colliery Company 14 days notice to terminate his employment, and in the event of his leaving either individually or in company with others, temporarily or permanently, without giving such notice, he rendered himself liable to be proceeded against. Mr. Chapman then related the facts leading up to the case. He said it was a breach of contract which unfortunately they were for today. The contract in question was a new one and was drawn up within the last few years, and this particular form was adopted by consent between the Colliery Company and the representative of the employees. This amendment, he contended, was found necessary, because, unfortunately the Colliery Company were suffering periodically by men leaving on account of similar lapses on the part of the men. He wished to again say that this was an unfortunate matter and a matter of regret to those who instructed him, and he need scarcely say that the Colliery Company was not vindictive in taking the proceedings, but what was a Company to do when standing charges was to go on, vessels missing the tide, which was a loss to the Company, and trade was dislocated and injury was caused not only to the town but to the men themselves and also the Company, and the only desire that it was foolish and an act uncalled for, and was injurious to all concerned, and instituted. If notice of these kind of lapses was not taken he (Mr. Chapman) was afraid the Colliery Company might expect a repetition of similar lapses and they were bound to take proceedings. The first witness, John Rothery, under-manager at William Pit, produced the contract book bearing the signatures. Witness said he saw Telford sign the book on the 3rd September 1908. Wilson Graham, overman at William Pit, stated that he arrived at the pit at 4.20 on the morning of February 16th, ready for the morning shift. The shiftsmen were just arriving to go down. Witness was informed that William Young was ill in the lamp cabin. While witness was in the cabin Telford went in. Telford, witness understood, was on of the committee of the Miners' Union. Telford said to witness that the men wished to know if there was any hope of Young coming round? Graham told him that he could not say just then, but he would be able to tell them in a few minutes as artificial respiration was about to be tried. This was tried in witness's presence, but unfortunately without result. Witness then went to the door and saw Telford and the other defendants, and told them that Young was dead. Telford then said the men had decided not to go down. After this, witness lost sight of Telford, as several other men went to the cabin and began to put their lamps back again. The whole of the shift then left the pit. The 11.30 a.m. shift was affected also by the stoppage. As a matter of fact only half of the next shift went down. Cross-examined by Mr. Bendall :— He had been 40 years employed at the mine. The men he thought would have gone down the pit if the unfortunate death had not occurred. A sudden death below ground had resulted in the men leaving the pit, but never when a death occurred on the surface. The men leaving work through a death underground had occurred on more than occasion. Witness did not know of a case being brought up, but he knew the management had complained about it. The whole of the men returned to work the following morning. The names of the men were ascertained, as they knew how many were engaged on each shift. They took the names from the books. He could not say that a lot had been included who were not present that morning, because the shift went home in a body. Mr. Bendall: Will you take it from me there are some men at any rate, never mind how many or few who were not there at all as part of the shift on that morning? Witness said they had got word since that some were ill and some detained by the rough weather. It was a wild morning on February 16th. In reply to further questions witness said he could not say whether they had been summoned. Mr. Bendall: The effort has been to get at everybody who was known to be in the shift? — No. For instance the shiftsmen are not summoned, and they were almost all there. Witness further replied that there were shiftsmen who left and had not been summoned. The shiftsmen suffered a loss through the stoppage as they were paid on day wage. He knew one man that went home, but he was a relative of the dead. The shiftsmen went home because the hewers left. Nobody had been summoned except the hewers. Witness had heard that John Donald was not at the pit on the 16th as he was ill, and Mr. McDonald was away. When the body of men went home he asked McKenzie to stop and assist, but witness did not ask Barwise to assist. McKenzie took the body of deceased home, but he was going to leave with the other men all the same. By Mr. Chapman: There was no work for the shiftsmen after the hewers had left the working. Samuel Turner, manager at the pit, said when the shift left the Company suffered a loss of several standing charges, which were thrown away. It was money thrown into the gutter, and the charges had to be paid all the same. Defendant had cause damage to the amount of 5s 7d. The total amount of the loss was £41 1s and Telford's share of this was 5s 7d. The contract signed by the employees was an agreement between the masters and men. He (Mr. Chapman) was right in what he stated to the Bench was the motive of the Company instituting these proceedings. Cross-examined by Mr. Bendall :— Witness said he had been manager for 13 years. He remembered two similar occurrences of death having taken place at the pit during the time he had been manager, but these deaths occurred underground and not on the surface. If a death occurred underground he thought it was the general rule for the men to come out. On the previous occasions the Company had not taken proceedings, but they had said something. No proceedings had been taken on previous occasions as the Association stepped in as a rule and in one or two instances they (the Association) had paid the money rather than the men. On one occasion the Association paid 2s 6d for each man. He could not tell them the exact way in which the money was paid. Mr. Bendall: I understand from Mr. Chapman that the object of the Company was not to be vindictive, and not to roughly assert your rights, but simply to put a stop to the awkward feature of the working of the colliery, and consequently the Company don't ask for damages, but simply to bring them in on individual cases as an arithmetical result? Witness: Oh no; we have not asked for all we have suffered, but only asked for standing charges. Witness here put in a statement showing the total loss of £41 1s. The Chairman: 177 was the full shift, and 147 went back? Yes. Answering further questions, witness repeated two cases of deaths had occurred underground. One was the death of Tom Young, no relation of the present deceased. On that occasion the whole of the shift left the pit for a whole day, but nobody was then summoned. On another occasion a man named Storey died. The men again left, and this resulted in the drawing up of the present contract. After that the same thing occurred again in an accentuated form, and you didn't summon the men? — I think so. Witness said it had been the custom for the men to leave when they saw these occurrences take place. They got the names of the men of that particular occasion from the time book. The 147 men summoned were known to be able to work. He witness told Mr. Sharp of the pending proceedings, but he did not tell Mr. Hanlon the legal agent. He told Mr. Smallwood, a delegate. He (witness did not agree with Mr. Bendall that Mr. Hanlon dealt with all disputes between master and the employees. This concluded the evidence for the prosecution. Mr. Bendall, addressing the Bench on behalf of his clients, submitted that in the case they were exceptional circumstances as it was to a very great extent on custom that he replied. They knew what miners were, and they also knew what effect an incident of this kind would have upon them, the deceased being one of their number and right in their midst practically falling dead on the spot. The men would naturally be very much upset, and he submitted that it was really only an expression of sympathy on the men's part and respect to the dead man's memory, and acting what he termed as humanitarian in this matter, and he contended that they were not to blame, because the men were following what they looked upon and had treated for many years past as an established system amongst colliers. They would only have to look back a few years to find cases parallel to the one in question, and the same attitude was adopted as on this occasion. The agreement drawn up was to put a stop to any succession of this kind of complaint on the part of the managers, and it simply dealt that any person signing this agreement was giving the Company the legal remedies at law, but to put it in statute form. The powers of management would have been exactly the same without the agreement. Mr. Turner had admitted that when the occasion arose when they (the Company) would have put into operation their agreement or to carry into force their notice they did not seize it. Mr. Bendall referred to the occasion of a death when the whole shift left the mine for the whole day and no proceedings were then taken. He suggested that there had been a little hot headedness in instituting these proceedings, with a view to putting an end to instances of this character, and the facts showed that they were acting without any feeling whatever, and so teaching the men a lesson by these proceedings. What the Company should have done, he maintained, was to make a selection of the ringleaders and bring them before the Bench and convey officially to the rest of the shift through their representative, Mr. Hanlon, that the management were not going to have any more of this thing, and that they were going to put their foot down, and whoever caused a breach the utmost rigor of the law would be enforced. Referring to the dismissal of the ringleaders of the breachers, it any, Mr. Bendall submitted that what they should have done and did not do was the dismissal of the men and without saying anything to the men through their official representative they let the men go back the next morning without a word about taking proceedings. He submitted that by doing that they had waived the law of any remedy they had against the men. Mr. Bendall here cited the case of Philips against Foxall. In conclusion he contended that his case must be dismissed, and this was his serious contention. John Hanlon, the miners' local representative, said he was intimately connected with the men at William Pit, and all questions of disputes between the men and managers came before him, and he, as the men's representative dealt with them. He had had letters of complaint and disputes from the managers, and had dealt with them. On this particular occasion he was not officially informed by either Mr. Turner or the manager of these proceedings being taken. If he had received intimation of it he would have dealt with it with the managers, with a view to being of benefit to both sides and saving expense. It was the custom of the men to "loose out" in case of a death of a man either above or below ground. It made no difference whether the death occurred above or below, so long as deceased was on the premises. They had compromised when the men had come out of the pit when they should not have done, but they did not compromise with the managers, as Mr. Turner had said. The Bench retired, and on returning into Court the Chairman said the Bench found the case proved, and ordered Wm. Telford to pay the sum of 5s 7d with costs. As agreed by both advocates, the following cases were withdrawn:— John McKenzie, Jeremiah Barwise, John Donald, Wm. McDonald, Patrick Pilkington, John Grears, Tom Grears, Joseph Skelton, John Glover, Thomas Woodend, Thomas Parkinson, Robert Benson, and Albert Atkinson. The Bench ordered the other defendants to pay the amounts claimed, with costs. At this stage there was a demonstration in Court, the men in a chorus exclaiming that they would not pay, and would go to gaol. Mr. Bendall was called back and told that his clients were not going to pay. Mr. Bendall said he had done his best for the men, and it was simply now a matter of law. If it was a matter of sentiment between themselves he had nothing to do with it. Eventually it was decided to issue orders for the amounts on Monday next.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||