Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd March 1911

Theft Of Pencil Ore At Frizington

Smart Fines Imposed Upon Stealers & Receivers

At the Whitehaven Police-court, on Monday, before W. McGowan (in the chair), W. H. Watson, J. H Robinson, T. Machell, J. Flynn, and W. Hayston, Esqs., two miners named Thomas Fortune (27), of 32 Aldby-street, Cleator Moor, and Daniel Kilfoy (88), residing at 5, Crossfield-road, Cleator Moor, were charged on remand with having stolen about threequarters of a hundredweight of pencil iron ore from Parkside Mine, Frizington, between the 2nd and 4th inst., the property of the Parkside Mining Company, Frizington.

John Graves (69), mineralogist, living at 4, Main-street, Frizington, was charged with receiving the ore on the 3rd inst., well knowing it to have been stolen.

Joseph Dixon, fitter, in the employ of the Parkside Mining Co., Frizington, stated that there was a wooden building at the mine which was used as a store. On Saturday, 4th inst., he had occasion to enter the store. He found that the door had been prised open, and the lock was hanging by one screw. He also found someone had been tampering with a box of iron ore, a little bit of which was lying on the floor. Witness had not been in the building for two days. He had seen the pencil ore frequently.

Wm. Gray, living at Crossgill Cottages, Frizington, storekeeper at Parkside Mines deposed that on Thursday, the 2nd inst., he was in the store where there was kept amongst other things two boxes of pencil ore. The ore produced was similar to that which was kept at the mine. The boxes were all right at eleven a.m. on the 2nd, and from what he was told on the Saturday following he went and examined the boxes and found one of them almost empty.

Wm. Thompson said he resided at Parkside House, Frizington, and was under-manager for the Mining Company. On Saturday, March 4th, inst., in consequence of what he was told, he visited the store in the morning. He examined the door leading into the place, which he found had been tampered with. On entering the building he saw a piece of pencil ore lying on the floor near to the door. On examining the boxes he found about ¾ cwt., of pencil ore missing. At a later date witness visited the Police Station at Frizington, where he was shown a quantity of iron ore (produced), which was similar ore to what they had in the store. Fortune had recently been employed at Parkside Mine. Witness produced two samples of the ore from the bag produced, which were similar to the ore in the box.

George Scoular, manager and partner of the Parkside Mining Co., stated that the two boxes of pencil ore were selected by customers, but they could not come to terms. The value of the ore was about £50 a ton, and the ¾ cwt., produced he estimated would cost £1 17s 6d.

John Doyle, a miner, Frizington-road, Frizington, employed at the Parkside Mine, said he knew prisoners, and he had seen the two of them at Frizington, the first week in March. He thought it was on a Friday, and witness was standing at the corner of the Royal Oak. There was another man (John Howlett) with accused. Prisoners were proceeding in a direction away from the mines. One of the men had a small parcel on his shoulder. It was John Howlett, who was carrying the parcel. On their return the man had no parcel with them, and proceeded in the direction of Cleator Moor.

Inspector Sheffield stated that about ten a.m. on Saturday, March 4th, from information received he had inquiries, and at 5.40 the following Monday evening he arrested Fortune and later the same evening he apprehended Kilfoy. The officer cautioned and charged them jointly with the theft of the ore. Fortune replied "I was never in this trouble before. We sold it to Graves, but I cannot tell you the weight. Certainly there was not one cwt. Graves weighed it and gave us 4d a pound for it - twenty-five shillings in all. We divided it. We are all alike, Kilfoy and Howlett is as bad as me. We are guilty together; the three of use were together." Kilfoy replied, "I am guilty. Old graves is as bad as us. I have sold him many a hundredweight. He has been in my house many a time. I borrowed 5s off him that night. He was in my house last Saturday. He is always asking me to get him the stuff. He gave us each a bottle of stout that night." Witness proceeded to Mr. Graves and took possession of two boxes of pencil ore.

When asked had they anything to say, Kilfoy said he would say in the next case all he had to say. Fortune had nothing to say.

The Chairman said the Bench found the case proved, and would give their decision after they had heard the charge of receiving.

Dealing with the charge against Graves, P.C. Batey said in consequence of information received in respect of a quantity of ore being missed from Parkside Mine he made some inquiries and visited Mr. Graves premises about mid-day on the 4th inst. Witness told Graves that he was inquiring about the pencil ore which had been stolen from Parkside Mines. Defendant asked "How long ago," and the officer said it was missed that morning, but it might have been stolen within the last two or three days. Graves then said he hadn't bought any. The Sergeant then asked him if he had bought any pencil ore within the last ten days or a fortnight, and defendant replied "No, I haven't bought any for some time."

Mr. Atter, at this stage, was not going to contest, as regards the receiving. He was going to plead guilty. They did not admit the amount, but they did admit there was a purchase from these three men. They pleaded guilty to the charge as in the summons.

Proceeding, P.C. Batey said he asked him to let him see the pencil ore he had on hand, and defendant took him to the back of the premises and produced about three stone of the metal, which was in a box, and also some specimens of spar. When asked if that was all the pencil ore, he had defendant replied, "Its getting very scarce now." Witness told him he was looking for a greater quantity than that.

Cross-examined by Mr. Atter (who appeared for Grave): He had known defendant 4½ years as a honest, trustworthy, and honourable man, but there was something in his business which he did not like, as it was rather suspicious. How-ever, he was a steady respectable citizen. Witness was not satisfied with the answers he gave to the questions when he went to inquire about the ore. Defendant's yard was an enclosed one.

Inspector Sheffield gave corroborative evidence, and added that on the 11th inst., witness again visited Mr. Grave's premises and said, "Now Mr. Graves, we are making more inquiries with reference to the theft of pencil ore from Parkside Mines. I am endeavouring to connect three men with this offence. I am informed that these three men were in Frizington on Thursday or Friday of last week. Their names are Thomas Fortune, Daniel Kilfoy, and another. Did these three men offer any pencil ore for sale? Defendant replied, "What date did you say?" Witness replied, "The 3rd." Defendant thereupon said, "I will let you see what I have got." He took the Inspector into the yard at the rear of the premises, and showed him about three stones of pencil ore he had in a box. Witness said, "Is this the ore the three men I have named sold to you?" He replied, "What are their names?" The Inspector repeated the men's names, and defendant said. "I don't know them. I thought you meant (meaning two other men). I have never seen or bought anything from the three men you have named." Defendant then wrote the three men's names down on a piece of paper. Sergt. Batey, who accompanied witness asked defendant, "How do you weigh the ore. Have you a weighing machine" - He replied, I have no weighing machine. I guess it, I pretty well know the weight. I have been in the business for many a year." The Inspector then left the premises, and returned at about 8.15 the same night. He said to Graves, "I have two men in custody at Cleator Moor, charged with stealing about one cwt. of pencil ore, the property of the Parkside Mining Company. The two men admit stealing it, and have informed me that they brought it to you. You bought it; you weighed it, and gave them 4d a pound for it 25s." Defendant replied, "Oh you have them locked up have you? What date did you say?" The Inspector replied. "You bought it from them on Friday, the 3rd." Defendant took witness and Sergt. Batey to a wooden shed at the back of the premises, and showed them the two boxes produced, the lids of which were nailed down. Defendant said "These two boxes contain pencil ore, and are packed ready to go away." Witness told him that he only wanted the ore that the three men sold to him. He said, "It is in both these boxes. It is inside with other pencil ore, and I cannot pick it out." Witness took possession of both boxes of ore.

Mr. E. Atter, addressing the Bench, on behalf of his client, said he was going to ask for every consideration for Mr. Graves in this case, and when he did so he did it on very strong grounds, and he did not know on any occasion in a case when he had stronger grounds to work on than he had in this particular case. First of all he would refer to Mr. Graves the person who was charged with the offence. He was in his seventieth year, and for forty of those years he had carried on the business at Frizington where he resided, and during the whole of that time until the present accusation made against him he had never had a charge against him of any description of wrongdoing. During the forty years he had been in business he had carried on a trade of making purchases of samples of ore and kidney ore, spar, and other materials of this description. He (Mr. Atter) submitted that the purchases had not been made with the slightest concealment, and the greater portion of the purchases were made in jewellery. In addition to Mr. Graves age, he had now only trouble brought upon himself, but there was a highly respectable family of sons he (defendant) had brought up and therefore not only was the trouble upon himself by the present charge, but it was naturally a great blow to all those connected with him. There were two sons schoolmasters, one a doctor, and one an architect and, that alone spoke a good deal for Mr. Graves, not only as regarded his conduct, but the privilege of having such a family connected with him. Character naturally would tell in a case of this description, and after the evidence regarding the man's character had been called, he was satisfied and submitted that this was a case which strongly applied to the Act of Parliament under what was known as the First Offenders Act. The circumstances connected with the character of Mr. Graves naturally went a long way. He (Mr. Atter) was quite mindful of the accusations of the charge of this description, but they had to take into account, the circumstances of this one. Referring to the purchase of small quantities of ore, Mr. Atter maintained that if they went to Frizington they would find a number of houses where there were miners who used a great quantity in their homes of kidney ore and spar, which had been taken away from the mine with the intent of stealing it, but which persons think they had a right to take away through working at the mine. He went on to say that Mr. Graves had been a man most honest himself and trusted others to be honest, and without making any inquiries purchased that which he ought not to have done. He had to call evidence of persons who would testify to the good character of his client. The first was a magistrate in this part, who was taking no interest in the case, and who had known Mr. Graves number of years. He alluded to Mr. Dixon, who he would ask to give evidence to his personal knowledge he had of his (Mr. Atter's) client. He would also call two clergymen, the Rev. W. Taylor, of Cleator Moor, and also the Rev. R. S. E. Oliver, and the schoolmaster in the locality, Mr. Marlow, who knew his character. He would also hand in letters of persons who could not attend. Mr. Joseph Kerr, of Inkerman Terrace, Whitehaven, who had known Mr. Graves for forty years, and Mr. Kerr was known to the magistrates; and letters from Mr. Wandless and Mr. Jones. He contended that it was a case in which the Bench could exercise their power in dealing with his client under the First Offenders Act, considering the character and age of Mr. Graves.

Mr. G. Scoular remarked that they did not wish to be severe as they understood the position.

Mr. T. Dixon, a magistrate stated that he had been personally acquainted with Mr. Graves for many years, and found him and always looked upon him as a man of absolute integrity and good character. He believed him to be eminently so a respectable person and his family were very respectable. He (Mr. Dixon) was surprised to see him being brought up in a case like this.

Rev. W. Taylor, vicar of Cleator Moor, who had been acquainted with Mr. Graves for the past twelve years, said he was an absolutely honest man, and he was eminently upright and thoroughly trustworthy.

Defendant was also given an exceptionally good character by the Rev. R. S. E. Oliver, vicar of Frizington; Mr. Henry Murphy (District Councillor), Frizington, and Mr. Marlow, headmaster.

Mr. Atter also asked the letters of Mr. Joseph Kerr, Mr. Wandless, and Mr. Jones, to be considered.

In reply to the Bench, Superintendent Hogg said there was nothing against Fortune for dishonesty, but he was sorry he could not say the same for Kilfoy, who was before the Court in 1905 for larceny.

The Bench retired, and after a few minutes' deliberation, returned into Court, and the Chairman said the Bench had considered the cases, and the decision was that Thomas Fortune and Daniel Kilfoy each would have to pay a fine of £2, with the alternative of one month's imprisonment with hard labour. In the case against John Graves he would have to pay a fine of £10 or in default of payment, to go to prison for two months.

Before being led from the dock Kilfoy said, "Well, he is not getting half enough."

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, —      
Batey, —    Police Constable  
Dixon, Joseph      
Doyle, John      
Flynn, J.      
Fortune, Thomas      
Graves, John      
Gray, William      
Hayston, W.      
Hogg, —    Police Superintendent  
Howlett, John      
Jones, —      
Kerr, Joseph      
Kilfoy, Daniel      
Machell, T.      
Marlow, —      
Mcgowan, W.      
Murphy, Henry      
Oliver, R. S. E., Rev.      
Robinson, J. H      
Scoular, G.      
Scoular, George      
Sheffield, —    Police Inspector  
Taylor, W., Rev.      
Thompson, William      
Wandless, —      
Watson, W. H.      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Parkside (Iron Ore)  Parkside (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print