|
9th March 1911 Shocking Fatality At Great CliftonSharp Passage At Arms With Mr. Andrew SharpAmusing SceneOn Thursday afternoon, Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland, and a jury, of which Mr. Clement Mossop was chosen foreman, held an inquest , on view of the body of Joseph Daly, at Stainburn Old Hall, where he resided with his sister, Mrs. Rafferty, a widow. There were present, on behalf of the Company: Mr. J. Gilchrist, manager of William Pit, and H.M. Inspector of Mines, Mr. L. Clive, and Mr. A. Sharp for the relatives. Michael Daly, Stainburn, brother of the deceased, said the deceased was a single man; and 25 last December. He had worked for the Allerdale Coal Company two years and four months. Previously he was an engine driver. Witness worked in the same pit as his brother. He last saw him alive on Tuesday, when he was in good health. He identified the body. Henry Bacon, Moor House, a fireman at the William Pit, and previously a shiftman, deposed he knew the deceased, and saw him on Wednesday, at five minutes to seven, at No. 6 break top, when he was trailing a tub. The accident occurred at seven o'clock. He was standing at the corner of the tub talking to him, when the stone fell on the deceased. It knocked him against the tub. A lad named Dockeray was also present. Witness went for assistance into the face, and a good few men came. The stone was then released. It would be between two and three tons weight. This was the deceased's first tub. He could not account for the stone falling. There were marks that the roof had been tested. They were in chalk, by Birkett, and dated March 1st. Witness had not noticed the stone before it fell. He thought the place .was safe. There was a stay in it, and no, prop had been knocked out or anything loosened. Three quarters of an hour elapsed before the stone was removed from the body. Death would be instantaneous. By the Inspector: They put the marks on the stone to show the day of the examination. Witness only examined one part of the district, and made a report on it. In deceased's district the stone roof was a mixture of freestone. It was more or less the same throughout. They used their judgment in the timbering. He thought the place was quite safe. They were hardly able to fell by knocking at the stone. By Mr. Sharp: It occurred on the ten quarters seam. He examined his section for gas. This road was not in it. Mr. Birkett examined this locality. The place was 60 or 70 yards from the facing. The roof was brushed. It had two brushings taken off it. It would be three yards wide. There was a stay cross or gear head, which was let into each side. It was under the stone. The stone brought the stay down with it. The end of the stay was where the tubs had to go, and it was not possible to get a prop in it. The stone was marked so that the deputy could see it had been examined. It was marked as safe on the side. Witness had been a deputy for three months. He had never hewed coal, and only "popped" in the faces. He had not gone through any examination before he was made a deputy. The stone gave no indication that it was going to fall. It just fell down. By the Coroner: Whilst he had been acting as deputy, there had been no other accident. Lancelot Stephenson Dockeray; a youth, 48, Concrete Terrace, Great Clifton, said he had worked two years at the pit, engaged in breaking. Daly worked with him. He put his tub on the brake, and whilst picking some metal off it, the stone fell five feet on to him. Witness was six yards from the deceased, but no part of the stone touched him. Bacon was three yards from witness. He could give no opinion as to what caused the stone to fall. The stone was not marked, as usual with a cross. He had worked in the place for six weeks, and had not seen a cross. There was, however, a mark in the manhole of the brake. Wm. Birkett, he understood, went round every night and examined the workings, before they started work. He had noticed the stone, and it never seemed awkward. There had only been two tubs mined since he was at the brake top. By the Inspector: There was no cross on the roof. The Foreman: Bacon said it was marked. The witness may not have observed it. By the Inspector: There was a date further up the stone. Something had fallen further down the brake, but not near the stone. By Mr. Sharp: His duty was to put the tube on the brake and run them. How many gears or stays were there on the brake top? — Three stays. Was there any middle legging under the stay? — There was a stay just about the edge of the stone, but there was no legging under the stay. Then there was not any legging under this stay? — No. There was no cross on the stay or near to it on the stone. There were five or six dates on the side, but he didn't know whether there was one for the 1st of March. William Birkett, Crossbarrow, deposed he had worked at the pit for the last 15 years, and had been a fireman for eleven months. He made the inspection of a portion of the working places. He was always on nights. He knew the place where the deceased worked and examined it on March 1st, and put the date on it. He always marked it every morning to show that it was right. He sounded the place with his stick and it sounded all right. Joseph Burrow was present. The time was 3-30 a.m. He examined all the siding. It was a careful examination. He would have had no hesitation in working the place. The stone, he said, again, sounded quite right. There was a stay in it, which had been there for a couple of months. The stay was new wood, and was quite sound. The stone had come out by a dip and was he thought, caused by the water loosening it. There was a good bit of water about the place. The timber was still quite good. He had known the deceased for eight months, and he regarded him as a good workman. The Inspector: Would that stay be put in as a protection against the stone or the top side? — They always do put these stays in. There was no danger attached to the stone. By Mr. Sharp: There were props about the brake. The stone was touching the stay, but it had no weight bearing on it. It was put in for the purpose of acting as a stay. Were there any legs under the stay? — No. It didn't require any. There was a prop fairly under the stone to the flat heads — to the end of the siding. How much of the stone would be bare before it fell? What length would it be? There was four or five feet sticking out. It would be between two and three yards long, and four or five feet broad. Any props under that. place? — Yes, this one that came on to the corner. It didn't require any other stay. Mr. Sharp: That is a matter of opinion. It shows it did require it. Witness said it was propped to perfection and be considered himself as good as any other man that worked in a pit. Mr. Sharp: I have worked in a pit. Witness (surprised): Have you? (Laughter.) In further reply to Mr. Sharp's questions, witness said he saw the splits on the checks and they were up to the mark. Was there a leg underneath this stay? — No. It didn't require it. Mr. Gilchrist said he had answered the question several times, and he thought it was unfair for Mr. Sharp to press them further. Mr. Atter said he agreed with Mr. Gilchrist. Witness became most voluble, saying he was prepared to answer any questions, and he knew as much as any other collier. Mr. Atter asked him to desist, but he continued to talk to the jurymen, Mr. Sharp, and the Coroner, until the latter suggested that he should retire. The Inspector said in regard to the cause this matter of timbering was one which was left to the judgement and the discretion of the officials. Mr. Atter, in summing up thought the witnesses had given their evidence very frankly and fairly. If Birkett worked as hard as he talked then there would not be much fault to find with him. (Laughter.) He was indeed very emphatic, but it was for every man to stick up for himself, and it might possibly be thought he was on his trial. Birkett was of opinion the place was perfectly safe, and he (the Coroner) found no fault or neglect on the part of anyone. Mr. Tinnion (a juryman) thought it was a pure accident, and said this pit was one of the best managed in the district. (Hear, hear.) The jury returned a verdict of accidental death.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||