|
16th February 1911 Colliery Prosecution At WorkingtonQuestion Of Pipe And MatchesWeak Point In The EvidenceAt the Workington Police-court, on Wednesday, William Lamont (30), coalminer, Workington, was charged by Mr. Jas. Gilchrist, colliery manager, with having in his possession in William Pit, Great Clifton, a box of matches and one pipe, on the 1st inst. Mr. St. George Curwen prosecuted on behalf of the Allerdale Coal Co., and Mr. Gilchrist, the manager, was present. Mr. Curwen said the defendant worked below the ground in William Pit. Portions of the pit were fiery, and in the latter there were caution boards, beyond which line of demarcation no person was allowed to take matches or pipes. On the 1st inst. during the morning shift a deputy named McTear was in a fiery part of the mine. He met defendant where he ought not to have been, and after a conversation he produced the pipe and matches. In consequence these proceedings were determined upon. Henry McTear, deputy, Great Clifton, was called, and deposed his district in the mine was the little main seam. He was in charge on the 1st. He saw Lamont first at 5.30 a.m. in the ordinary portion of the pit, and had been smoking, which was allowed there. Later on he saw him in the prohibited part of the pit, where a caution board was placed. Defendant was in the dib 30 yards from the lamp station. He ought to have been 50 yards further down the dip at his work. Defendant complained that lads had stolen things out of his pockets, and asked if it could not be stopped, as it had gone on for two or three weeks. Witness, however, had never previously received a complaint. Before the conversation ended, defendant showed him a pipe and a box of matches. The box was half full. He blamed a boy called Bright for having put them in his pocket. Witness reported the occurrence. Defendant said he had a pipe and box of matches at the lamp station and he produced them. It was a similar pipe, and defendant's second box contained more matches. By the Bench: When he saw the defendant later on in the day he was coming towards the lamp station. By the defendant: You said you saw Bright put the pipe and matches in your pocket. Defendant: Could I have concealed the pipe and matches where I was working? - You could have done. Defendant: Was it not necessary for me to explain how I became possessed of the pipe and matches? Witness: Of course. Defendant: Do you think the explanation was unnecessarily wrong? - You blamed Bright, but I have never seen him smoking The Clerk: Did you then smell tobacco smoke about? Witness: Not in the prohibited part of the pit. Thomas Stephenson, Great Clifton, rolley way man in the pit, deposed he was with McTear on the morning in question and heard the conversation. Defendant said his knife, scarf, and other things, had been pilfered by the lads. The complaint ought to have been made to him, but defendant did not do so. He saw defendant hand over the pipe and matches to McTear. By defendant: You did not tell me on the Tuesday that you had lost your pipe and matches in the presence of Fletcher and Carlton. Defendant: Did not McTear say to me that the pipe and matches had been put into my pocket for him to find when he came down to see the water, and thus get me into trouble? Witness: I didn't hear him. James Gilchrist, manager, said he had been manager of the mine for 13 years. He described the mine as fiery, certain parts being more dangerous than others. Naked lights were only allowed on the main roads, and matches were prohibited in the dangerous zone. He thought this was a matter that should be investigated. There were 280 men working in the pit that morning. Defendant: When Mr. Wilson reported the matter to you did he give full details of McTear's story? Mr. Gilchrist: You told your story first. Defendant: Before I came in? Mr. Gilchrist: No; he didn't. Defendant: Did Harry Wright admit having been in my pockets on certain occasions? Mr. Gilchrist: He admitted having taken two cigarettes out of your pockets, and on another occasion something about a knife, which showed to me he had been in your pockets. Henry Wright, the boy referred to, was called and examined by the defendant. In reply he said defendant had promised him a full packet of cigarettes for helping him, and he (Wright) took two out of his pocket. By Mr. Curwen: He never put a pipe and matches in defendant's pockets on the Wednesday in question, and had not taken out of them any of the articles mentioned. This was the case for the prosecution. Defendant then elected to give evidence. His defence was that on the 1st inst. on arrival at the lamp station he had his pipe and matches in a certain place, and proceeded to his work. At nine o'clock he went to the lamp station had his breakfast and a smoke. Then he placed the pipe and matches in the same place. Afterwards he returned to work. At 11.30 a.m. Wright was working near to where his coat was hanging, and it was afterwards that he found the pipe and matches had been placed in his pocket. By Mr. Curwen: It was a few months ago since he lost the articles. Have you ever reported anybody for having stolen handkerchiefs and knives form your pockets? - No. I have never had any evidence. The Clerk: Was there anyone you thought who was going to cause you trouble? There was no one had any reason, to my knowledge. The Chairman: How long have you worked in this pit? Defendant: I commenced on June 2nd last. The Bench then conferred in private, and on returning into Court the Chairman, after touching on the seriousness of the charge, said there was a weak point in the evidence owing to the fact that the boy had admitted having tampered with the defendant's pockets. Therefore, the Bench were disinclined to convict, and gave instead the defendant the benefit of the doubt. They hoped the management, as far as they could, would endeavour to keep a sharp eye on the boys and see that they didn't get into proximity with the men's clothes in future. It was, of course, a proper case for the Company to bring. Defendant asked for his costs, but the Chairman said they could not allow them.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||