|
19th January 1911 Sad Fatal Accident At No. 9 LowcaTwo Distington Young Men KilledEarly on Saturday morning quite a gloom was cast over Distington when it became known that two Distington young men, Arthur Dempster, aged 28, son of Mr. and Mrs. Tom Dempster, Town Head, and Robert Allen, aged 21, of Wood View, Distington, had both lost their lives while following their employment in the No. 9 Colliery, Lowca. It appears the deceased, along with other workmen were engaged on the main haulage in cutting out a place wherein to build an engine-house, the place being pretty high in the roof. The two unfortunate young men, who had only been about one and a half hours at work, were engaged clearing away some debris that had been brought down by the night shift, when a stone about five tons in weight suddenly, without any warning, came upon them, crushing them instantly to a frightful death. The contractor (Mr. Peart) had a very narrow escape, he receiving some very nasty cuts and bruises by the falling stone. A young brother of Dempster had also a very narrow escape, a fellow-workman having just shouted of him to give him a lift with some gear. He was only a yard or two away when the accident occurred. Had it been a couple of minutes later he would have been hit also. Arthur had been partly in two minds whether to go out that morning or not, as he did not feel quite up to his ordinary form, but, however, he went with the sad result. Young Allen was a fine, promising young fellow, just reached his majority. Only on Saturday night he was initiated into the Helvellyn Lodge of Oddfellows at their monthly lodge meeting. A large number of people turned out to meet the sad cortege bringing home the dead. The poor fellows had a few hours before gone out healthy and strong to work. Much sympathy is felt for the bereaved parents in their sudden and sad bereavements. Both bodies had been nearly crushed out of recognition by the heavy weight that had fallen on them. They were brought home on a lorry during Sunday afternoon. The full story of the sad affair which cast a deep gloom over the district was told at the inquest which was held at the Albert Hall, Distington, on Monday afternoon, by Mr. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont. Mr. T. Wilson was foreman on the jury, and those present at the inquiry included: Mr. J. B. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Mr. O. F. Ormrod (Messrs. Brockbank, Helder and Ormrod), representing the Workington Iron and Steel Company, Ltd., owners of the colliery; and Mr. A. Miller, manager of No. 9 Pit. Maxwell Dempster, Townhead, Distington furnaceman, identified the body of his brother, Arthur Dempster, who was 28 years of age. He was a shiftsman at No. 9 Pit, Lowca, and worked for Messrs. Peart and Smith, contractors for the Workington Iron and Steel Company. He went to work on Sunday morning, leaving home about five o'clock. Deceased had been working for the same Company for some time and had had a good bit of experience. By the Inspector: His brother was formerly a farm servant, but had been some years at mining. Robert Allen, Woodbank, identified the body of Robert Anderson Allen as that of his son, who was 21 last birthday and was a shiftsman. He worked for Mr. Peart at No. 9 Pit. He last saw his son alive on Saturday night, between seven and eight o'clock. He was then at home. His son worked at Oatlands Pit before he went to Lowca. He had had two or three years' experience at mining, and before that time was a farm servant. Mr. Allen said he should like to ask how it was that after shots were fired the spot was not timbered. The Coroner said Mr. Allen would have an opportunity of asking questions later. Thomas Peart, who appeared with a bandaged head, said he was a contractor at No. 9 Pit. The deceased men were in the employ of witness and Mr. George Smith, who was also a contractor. They had the contract for making ready a new engine house underground. There had been blasting to make room for it. Their contract was to blast the roof down. The place where the accident occurred was about 20 yards from the pit bottom. They started the work a month ago, but had not followed it regularly, as they had other jobs on, drifting, &c. The deceased had been working odd shifts at the week-ends. Witness had to blast the roof down and clear the metal away. The roof was composed of freestone. They last worked at the place about Tuesday before Saturday night, when they started about ten o'clock. Alexander Pugh and another man named Harry Wilson were then drilling holes to blast in the morning before they came off. Witness and Smith were not at work that night. Blasting would take place between four and five o'clock on Sunday morning. Witness and Smith went into the place about six o'clock on Sunday morning, and looked round it. That was before the other men went in. Witness usually superintended. He did not see anything dangerous or wrong when he went in. He looked at the roof, and it appeared to be quite sound. It was a strong freestone post roof. After they had looked round the other men came in — two to fill tubs and two to drill. Witness was smashing stone, and work went on all right for about an hour and a half. There was nothing done to shake the roof while witness was there, as far as he knew. The drilling machine had just started when a stone came down from the roof. It would be about two tons weight. Witness was standing at the side breaking a piece of metal, and Arthur Dempster had just been away with a full tub. Thomas Smith and William Brown were drilling. Allen went away a short time before for a tub, but he did not see him come back. When the fall took place witness was knocked down by a piece of stone, and he was stunned for a short time. As soon as he could he got out of the way altogether. The stone smashed the air pipes, and put the light out, and witness could not see. He went to the side of the brick wall, and Brown came to him. Brown then went away for help, and Geo. Smith and Thos. Kelly came with lights. Witness was not fit to go in, and see what was the matter. As soon as the men came with lights witness heard that someone had been killed. They told him some men were under the stone. He did not know what caused the stone to fall, and he had no theory to offer. They protected the roof when it needed it. They had taken all bad roof down a fortnight or three weeks before. They could see the roof well there when they were working. It was about ten feet high. The stone had broken off, but he had not seen it since. It was usual to protect a roof by putting props up if it did not appear safe, but this was considered a good roof, Dempster and Allen were good workmen. Dempster had been working about twelve months, and Allen since August last. They understood the use of props, and had helped to put wood in. In his opinion he thought they were quite capable of protecting themselves. By a juror: It was witness's or Smith's place to sound the roof and see if the place was safe. The men who fired the shots cleared the place, and Mr. Greener, a deputy, reported as to its condition. By the Inspector: This was work that required to be done at the week-ends. About six shots had been fired, and the place had been dressed down afterwards. The shots would go a little above, where the stone was. They used Samsonite as the explosive. There was long timber at the shaft, but witness did not think it was necessary. He believed a prop or two had been put up since the accident. Witness heard no warning. If the roof had begun to work a bit the machinery might have drowned the sound, as it made a good bit of noise. Greener told him the place was all right. Witness saw the previous shift, and they told him what they had done — fired six shots and dressed the place down. Brown and Wilson were experienced men. They sounded the roof with a pick shaft. He could do it satisfactorily. The Inspector said he couldn't see how he could do it with a pick shaft, when the roof was 10 ft. high. Witness said there was a lot of loose metal lying, and they could stand on that. Wm. Henry Johnston, mining engineer, produced a plan of the place, and Peart explained from this how he sounded the roof. They never used a jumper, or anything like that. They had a good light. By the Inspector: Witness had a very narrow escape. He had every confidence that the roof was safe. If they had thought it wanted timber they certainly would have put it in. Their instructions were to fetch any bad stone down. He had had no instructions from the deputy about putting timber in. The overman passed the place before the accident that morning. They stood talking during the shift, and he didn't say anything about it. A shot might have set the roof off a bit, but he didn't think so. In reply to Mr. Ormrod, witness said they could have sounded any portion of the roof with the drill, but didn't think it necessary to use that. He had had a life-long experience of this class of work. Mr. Allen asked witness if he sounded the roof on Sunday morning? — Witness: Yes. How does it come that Dempster put his clothes on to come out that morning? — Witness replied that Dempster did not do that. He knew he didn't. Should this spot not have been timbered after the shots were fired — while they were getting it cleared out? — It should have been timbered if it was wanted. Whether it was wanted or not, would it not have been safer to timber it? — It if was required. Allen repeated his question, and the witness pointed out that it was not considered necessary to timber the roof, which appeared strong and sound. Allen asked if timbering would not have prevented this accident? — Witness repeated that the place appeared quite safe. Allen: How could it be safe when there was an accident like this? — witness said freestone was a queer thing. Why was the place not timbered after shots were fired? — Because it did not require it. Allen: Well, I say it did. It was a moral certainty, he added, that the place should have been timbered. He also contended that the roof was 20 ft. high instead of 10 ft. as stated. Thomas Smith, Lowca, stoneman at No. 9, said he was working on the same shift as the deceased. He was drilling a hole, and started his work about seven o'clock. Previously he was helping the men to fill the tubs with metal. The drill was worked by compressed air. Witness examined the roof where he was drilling. The drill made a tremendous noise, and if there was any crack such as a stone would make in coming down he didn't think they would hear it. Witness was about 30 feet from where the stone fell. A man named Brown was working with witness. He did not think the drilling machine 30 feet away would have any effect upon the roof that fell. Witness saw nothing, but just heard the stone fall. They also heard a head (wooden support) cracking and the air pipes come down. He and Brown came down from the stage on which they were standing, and went for assistance. He didn't know then whether any men were under the stone, but he expected the deceased would be there. The roof appeared to be a solid body, and witness didn't know of anything that could have been done to avoid the accident. He heard that the place had been examined before the accident happened. By the Inspector: He didn't know what caused the stone to fall. Asked by Mr. Ormrod if he didn't know it was the duty of each man to examine his place, witness said it was examined by two others. He examined the place where he was drilling. Mr. Ormrod pointed out that witness was working under the whole body of roof. It was each man's duty, according to rule, to examine his own place. Wm. Brown, 30, Peter-street, Whitehaven, stone drifter at No. 9 Pit, who was working with the last witness, gave similar evidence with regard to the fall of stone. He saw Smith with a pick in his hand examining the roof. He was leaning over the wall, on which there was a head, and was tapping the roof. He had seen the stone since it fell. It had a slape back. By the Inspector: Nothing was said by any of them about going away after they had started the shift. The stone was about eight or nine inches think and about 9 ft. across. It took about 2½ hours to get the deceased out. They put some timber in after the accident. A post roof like that very often stood all right without any timber. They could not always depend upon sounding. Thomas Greener, 29, Foundry Road, Parton, deputy at No. 9 Pit, said he examined the place at ten o'clock on the Saturday night, and went in again next morning about half-past four to fire the shots, that being part of his duty. The nearest hole was four or five feet from the stone. He fired six shots, and he did not think they would have any effect on the stone. He fired that last shot about half-past five. He afterwards examined the roof by sounding it. He sounded it all the way along with a steel jumper, as he could not reach with a pick. It took him three or four minutes to sound the whole of the roof carefully. It appeared quite safe. Witness then got Pugh and Wilson to dress the loose stone from the roof before he left. At six o'clock he saw George Smith, the contractor, and he told him he had fired the shots, and all was right. He saw Peart and said "Good Morning" to him, but he didn't remember saying anything to him about the roof. He wrote the report about twenty minutes to six both in the book in the lamp cabin and that in the under manager's office. He would not have been afraid to work under the roof himself. He had since seen where the stone fell down, but he could not give any explanation as to what caused the stone to fall. The only thing to have prevented the accident would have been to timber the stone or blast it down, but, as he had said, he considered the stone safe. He was terribly particular because he knew men's lives largely depended upon his examinations. By the Inspector: He fired two holes at a time. They had from five to six cartridges in. By Mr. Ormrod: If he had thought it necessary to timber the place he could easily have got the props. The Coroner said he thought in inquiry had been fairly exhaustive, and they had got all the facts it was possible to get, with regard to the accident. Apparently the Legislature had done all they could to prevent accidents as far as possible by making rules and regulations with regard to the inspection and examination of mines, but, at the same time, these accidents were always occurring, and, he supposed, always would occur, and so long as the rules made in pursuance of the Coal Mines Regulation Act were complied with they could not very well attach blame to any person. In the present case the deputy had told a very straight-forward story, and both he and the contractor stated that they had examined the place, and thought everything was safe. Probably a lot of these accidents might be prevented if the roof could be propped everywhere, but he supposed that would interfere with the working, and where practical miners and deputies examined the roof and considered it perfectly safe, the men were justified in working under it. If they considered it unsafe at all, of course it was their duty to see that it was properly protected, and to prevent men working under it until it was. At the same time the very best examinations of places occasionally were useless, and accidents did happen. Very often a stone like that which had fallen in this instance — one with a slape back — came down without any warning, whereas five minutes before the stone might have sounded quite right. Possibly blasting operations or something of that sort had affected the roof in this case, but there was no evidence to account for the fall. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death." Mr. Ormrod, on behalf of the colliery owners, expressed sympathy with the relatives of the deceased.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||