|
22nd December 1910 Whitehaven Colliery DisasterColliers' Public MeetingPetition To The Home OfficeA public meeting promoted by the Whitehaven Miners' Union was held in the Oddfellows' Hall, Whitehaven, on Sunday afternoon. The hall was quite full. Councillor Hanlon, C.C., the men's agent presided; and there were also on the platform Mr. T. Graham, Mr. J. T. Mathers, Mr. T. Ferryman, Mr. Wm. Telford, and Mr. Isaac Curran. The Chairman said this public meeting had been called for the purpose of considering the advisability of petitioning the Home Office for a further inquiry or investigation into that serious disaster that happened in our midst on May 11th. At the outset he might say that personally he had no doubt in his mind but what Mr. Redmayne, the chief inspector of mines, would give a fair and true and accurate report of what transpired at that inquiry. He had not doubt that. But they thought there might be a possibility at the Home Office to not think it advisable to have another investigation; and they as miners thought they might give the public an opportunity of expressing their opinions as to what they thought with regard to a further investigation. That might strengthen the hands and the report of the Chief Inspector in its effect upon the Home Office. Because without saying anything about the Home Office at all or the people that constitute it, as they all knew, they were not miners - they were not men that worked underground. If the report were given to such as themselves, men who had to follow such work, they had not the least doubt what the result would be. But these men had not to risk their lives. They said nothing wrong about them at all; but not having to do that, they might think so many men has sat and decided and had not left anything for the Home Office to do, and they might think it was not work while going any further with it. It was not in any vindictive spirit that the men had arranged for this meeting - not in any sense of the word. Their idea was that nothing should be left undone. There was no need for anything to be left undone. They knew that at best the miners' life was very risky; and they claimed that everything should be done to make the risk as small as it can be. (Applause.) He repeated that they bore no vindictiveness to anybody, but that was what they wanted. If they could not bring their commands back, they ought to make things better for their sons and relations for themselves and those that had to follow them. (Applause.) They had not come there to condemn anybody, or to condemn the jury, in any sense of the word. It might be said the jury did their best. Well, may be they did, with the knowledge that they had. (Cries of "Ay.") But he might say that they had had expressions from both the two men that sat assisting them at the inquiry, and he could tell them they were very much upset. They did hope that having a joint inquiry and having a Government Inspector joined to it, something good would have been done. But so far as that inquiry was concerned, there was nothing. It might never have been held, and was a waste of time. They did hope that something would have been the outcome of that inquiry, and they were very much upset that there was nothing. So it was with these feelings they asked this public meeting to give expression to their opinion of the matter. They did not want to do it themselves, but it was only right that they themselves ought to be the promoters of a meeting of this description, to see what people thought of the idea of petitioning. They had no idea of condemning anybody so far as the inquiry was concerned. The pity is that practical men do not sit to adjudicate on practical matters, but they hoped for better things in that respect in the future, and it would not be long before they got better things. He had drafted a resolution, but he would leave it to see if anybody else had any resolution to propose. If not, he would submit the one drawn out. The Chairman went on to say that he had had a piece of paper handed up, but he did not know whether what was written on it had anything to do with the purpose of this meeting. Responding to cries that he should read it, the Chairman attempted to do so, but did not succeed in making it intelligible, further than that it seemed to be a proposition that in the opinion of the meeting the jury consisted of men with no knowledge of colliery work; as proved by the action of the foreman in requesting the Coroner to write down a few of the most important points for them to consider, to answer yes or no, so that they should not ask questions that should cause ridicule. "Where any questions put by the jury to the witness?" ended the writing. Well, as he said, resumed the Chairman, we don't want to prolong the agony with respect to the jury; but he said they hoped in future that when things like that were concerned practical men would be put to consider them. (Applause.) But that was their idea. They engaged one of the best experts this country could produce at present, as a scientific man - Professor Galloway - and his evidence was slighted, his evidence was considered of no consequence whatsoever; and, of course, so far as Professor Galloway was concerned they might have to deal with those things in future; but they did everything they could to bring science to bear and practical knowledge, but it was of no avail. He need not repeat that their only idea was to bring about a thorough investigation, because they thought it had not got the investigation it ought to have, and it had not got answered satisfactorily after the investigation; and they thought that by having a Government inquiry by itself or a Royal Commission as to the cause or causes of this disaster something better might be done for people in future. That was the main object of their committee in suggesting that this public meeting should be held. He would leave it to them now, whether anybody had any resolution to submit. If not they would submit the one they had drawn out. Someone asked if there were no practical men on the jury? The Chairman said not that he knew of. The speaker in the body of the hall said there was one - Mr. Ellwood, who had been a practical miner. The Chairman: Well, don't let them deal with the jury now. Their business to-day was to see what was thought of a petition to the Home Office for a further investigation. He was satisfied it ought to be done, but it was for the people of Whitehaven to say. They would have a petition signed. That was what they wanted to get at. They did not want ridicule. They wished to use the best weapon possible to secure benefit for their people in future. Because they knew as practical men that although those mines were far underneath the sea they could be worked safer, owing to the high stratification of the coal, than any mines, if the miners were taken into account. There might be danger attending the way they were worked or something like that; but they could be made safe. That was the position; and they thought that if another investigation was done to make a man well satisfied that he was going to less risk than in times gone by. (Applause.) Someone in the body of the hall made an observation the purport of which did not reach the reporters. The Chairman said practically the result of the inquiry, so far as the jury was concerned, was that something happened, and nothing was wrong and nobody was responsible. Somebody must have been responsible. So that, nobody being responsible, it left a very thin space to remedy anything in future. As he had said, he had no doubt Mr. Redmayne would do them justice in his report; but they wished to assist him by this public meeting to show that the people of Whitehaven were dissatisfied and wanted a further Government inquiry. So far as the jury was concerned, they must wait for the passing of better Acts to get better juries; they were not dealing with that to-day. A Voice: Are you dissatisfied with the jury that has been sitting? The Chairman: Oh, yes, we are dissatisfied. The Voice: Then you mean by this meeting that the jury be competent men? The Chairman: No, we want a Government inquiry, which will go on without any jury. (Hear, hear.) The jury is finished and there is nobody to blame. We want a Government inquiry into the cause or causes of this disaster. They say there is something happened and nothing to cause it to happen. But I want to keep the jury out of it. As to the constitution of the jury, when you send your own members to the House of Commons in sufficient number you will get that done. (Applause.) The Voice: There was nobody but shop-keepers, who know nothing about it. We want practical miners on the rights of this case. (Applause.) If it is not done that way this business will never be done any other way. Never mind us poor fellows that's down below. (Applause.) I say wipe it out. (Applause.) The Chairman: I would wipe it out, if I could. The same voice asked if there was upon the jury anyone interested in the Colliery Co.? The Chairman: No, not as far as we could investigate; we could not find anybody interested. The Voice: I would like to move as an amendment that we wish for practical men on the jury. (Applause.) The Chairman explained again that they were petitioning for a Government inquiry. It was then formally moved and seconded that a petition be sent to the Home Office, and this was carried unanimously. Mr. Bray said that he had worked in other collieries, and in his opinion they in the Whitehaven Colliery did not work under any more dangerous conditions that at other places. He thought from the remarks of the Chairman it might be supposed that they did. (Loud cries of protest and a voice: You should be ashamed of yourself.) The Chairman: Just allow people to express their opinion. It is not a question of what we like. I say the time has come when we ought to demand better conditions. (Applause.) Well, I have a resolution here: "That we, the residents of Whitehaven, in public meeting assembled in the Oddfellows Hall, December 18th, 1910, authorise a petition to be forwarded to the Home Office, asking for a further investigation into the cause or causes of the Wellington Pit disaster, and are of opinion that this can be best done by the holding of an inquiry. Someone suggested that Mr. Bray's suggestion should be put to the meeting. Mr. Bray rose and commenced: "I think these men have known me," when he was stopped by a storm of interruption. The Chairman restored order. Mr. Bray: There is one thing; I am a Union man. (A Voice: Thoo's a bad un, any way.) But I think they have misunderstood what I said. I did not say there were not many things we work under that could be amended. ("Why didn't you say that at first?") What I say is that we don't work under more dangerous conditions than in other pits in Cumberland." Another workman: And I say you should be ashamed. The Chairman: Well, I don't want anyone to say I have prevented anybody speaking; I want to let everyone have an opportunity. If we have opposition, we have a better opportunity of letting you know what we think and you know what I think. A Voice: Your idea was that we want better conditions. I think Mr. Bray is misunderstood. He says we are working under as good conditions as any men in the county. Another speaker in the body of the hall thought it would be a good thing if they could get the opinions of the inhabitants of Whitehaven, and would be beneficial both to them and to other colliers in the county. Mr. Murray, a compositor, said the jury found there was no one to blame, and this meeting was a protest. It was not a matter of what prevailed in other pits. No doubt the Chairman and others knew that the miners' condition needs remedying, and a new Coal Mines Regulation Act would have to come; and he thought the Whitehaven miners were on the right course in petitioning for a further inquiry into this matter. (Applause.) As working men, although they might have different avocations in life they should take an intelligent interest in each other. Everyone knew that something must be done in the immediate future to remedy the evils and dangers that exist in connection with the miners' life; and he had great pleasure in supporting the resolution that they petition the Home Office for a further investigation into this matter. (Applause.) The Chairman: You know, men, there are accidents and disasters. This has been named a disaster; but we generally call a thing a disaster that could have been prevented; an accident is a thing that could not have been prevented, but a disaster is a thing that could have been prevented. And we are fully satisfied, from the conditions that prevailed, that this was a disaster that might have been simply prevented. It might have been overlooked: I don't say anybody has done it intentionally; we are not here to say that; but still it is serious that through somebody overlooking a thing, 136 of our brothers are carried away; and I say that in trying to get things improved we ought to be assisted by everybody, officials and all, without ill-feeling; because we are trying to make their lives better than they are at the present time, at the same time as we improve our own. The Chairman went on to specify some things which he alleged took place in the working of the colliery, which needed altering. But when the inquiry came on they were on they were asked for days and dates. It was a different thing when they went to the manager's office. They had to knock and be very careful; they had often to stand on their feet and defend themselves. But at the inquiry it seemed to be all creamy kind of things on which they could shake hands. (Laughter and applause.) That was the opinion - that he or a delegate could go and demand what they liked. It was a silly thing to think that. They tried to put it on the workmen. He wondered who was responsible for what happened last Friday. ("Nobody.") He had heard some people say that the delegates should do this and do that. The delegate was a delegate of the Association, and so far as the pit was concerned had no power to do anything. He had to look after the men if they got dismissed; he had practically nothing to do with the safety of the mine. The agent was similar; he had no power as the safety of the mine. If he went to-day they would tell him he had no power - he had no legal right. What he had to do was to look after his men as to the payment and such-like things; and the delegates similar. The only one with power was the check-inspector. Some of the public were likely to blame delegates and agent; but that was the position - they had no power, except the check-inspector; and the workmen had nothing to do with the disaster, helping it on or anything else. The resolution was then put and carried unanimously, with the addition at the suggestion of Mr. Murray that a copy of the petition should be sent to each of the members for Cockermouth and Egremont Divisions and the borough of Whitehaven, with a request that they would use their influence in support of it. The Chairman asked as many as would to stay behind and sign the petition, and the meeting terminated.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||