22nd December 1910
Employers Liability
When the Employers' Liability Act came into operation hosts of objections were raised as to the multitude of cases that would arise in which it would be impossible to say who was the employer. So far as we have not observed any very great difficulty in
reaping, the advantage of this beneficial Act. Under the system of general insurance against liability under the Act, all the fighting is done by the insurance companies, and individual hardships do not appear, if they exist, as some small employers say
they do. A curious case under this Act was heard at the Whitehaven County Court yesterday. An owner of property who was not a builder, but who was in fact a working mine manager, had conceived the idea that he could manage to do better with certain
building work that he wanted done than by accepting a builders contract in the ordinary sense. So he went to a firm of builders and asked them to undertake to direct and carry out the work and he would pay for all materials and work and wages required,
and pay them for the services of one or both of the members of the firm, at the rate of 8d an hour for the time they spent on his work. One of the firm took the matter in hand and used to submit weekly pay-sheets, which the owners settled by cheque.
Men were employed by this builder, and when they were not required on that particular work he transferred them elsewhere to work for the firm itself. One of the men was killed while employed upon the work of the mine manager; and the question for the
County Court judge was, who was the "employer" in this case. Judge Steavenson admitted that it was a fine point of law, and advised the parties to settle the case, but in the absence of settlement gave judgment that the mine manager was the
employer.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Steavenson, — | | Judge | |