Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

22nd December 1910

Disaster Near Wellington Pit Head

Collapse Of A Retaining Wall

Three Persons Killed

On Friday morning a disastrous occurrence startled the people of Whitehaven, who were just shaking off the effects of the great disaster of the 11th May. This time it was near Wellington Pit Head, but not connected with the pit itself. All Whitehaven people are familiar with the high embattled towers and retaining walls that are characteristic of Wellington Pit top and its approach. One of these retaining walls collapsed about half-past eight or twenty minutes to nine yesterday morning, and in an instant it fell down upon the cottages behind the Wellington Inn, on Catherine Place, as it is called, and obliterated two cottages and partly ruined a third, burying the families in the ruins - altogether eight persons - of whom all but three were miraculously recovered alive in a case that seemed to forbid any such hope.

Those who have visited Wellington Pit top by way of Rosemary-lane will remember that after passing the lodge and under-manager's office there is a high retaining wall on the right hand or harbour side, which looks down upon the tramway by which coal is taken from the pit to be shipped at the hurries in the south harbour. The tramway is several yards in width and then there is another retaining wall against which the cottages in Catherine Place are built. On the very top on the road into the high yard where the fall took place, there were a number of long longitude boilers, that were used for storing water. It was thought at first, by those who viewed the scene from below, that the weight of these boilers full of water must have had an effect in causing an outward strain on the top of the retaining wall. There appeared to be an imminent danger of the boilers themselves toppling over, so near did they appear to the edge of the debris which formed a steep inclined plane right down to the level of the Wellington Inn; and had they come there would have been further ruin, if not loss of life, for they would have broken through Messrs. Kennaugh's warehouse there and landed on the West Strand embankment. But actual investigation and measurement on the road above showed that the boilers were standing some 15 feet back from the collapsed retaining wall. So that it is not so evident that the presence of the boilers there had anything to do with the disaster. However this may be, Mr. William Wilson, who is in charge of the pit engine-house, promptly had the boilers emptied of their water, which greatly lessened the risk of further disaster.

Mr. William L. Kennaugh was an eye witness of the fall of the wall, which he says came down suddenly. Dinah Mooney, 36 years of age, the wife of John Mooney, collier, Catherine Place, was in the cottage of David Magee's at the time of the fall. It was supposed that she had gone to warn the inmates that the wall was falling, but this does not agree with Mr. Kennaugh's evidence that it came down like a flash of lightening. The woman may have been simply calling on her neighbour. In any case she lost her life by it; for Magee's cottage was one of the two that were completely overwhelmed and obliterated. The other was that of Robert William Charlton, collier of Catherine Place. Charlton was at work at the time, and David Magee was in hospital; but Mrs. Magee had one daughter in the house with her; and Mrs. Charlton had four of her family with her. The whole of these were buried among the debris. It was at first thought that a second child of Mrs. Magee was with her mother, but it proved that this one had gone to school.

The fire-horn gave the alarm, and police officers and fire brigade were quickly on the spot, with a big crowd of spectators; and rescue operations were at once commenced. William Cradduck and his wife and family occupied the house which was only partly wrecked. They were in bed at the time, but were unhurt. Under direction of Captain White and Lieut. Forsyth, the fire brigade dug out the victims, while Mr. R. Blair assistant general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery Co., and Mr. R. Steele manager of Wellington Pit directed operations from above. Prior to the arrival of the brigade, a number of the colliery workmen had rendered most effective service. As already said, it was marvellous that there was anybody alive in the two demolished cottages; but in Charlton's house a door had fallen and remained on the slope protecting three children beneath it from the stones above. From this place of peril, Robert Cradduck Charlton, 10 years of age, was got out unhurt, and was singing like a little hero, "God save the King" when he was found. Ethel his two year old sister, had been less fortunate, and had a broken leg. She was taken to the Infirmary. Mona, another sister, 5 months old, had also escaped unhurt. In this house Mrs. Charlton (35), and Joseph Robinson Charlton, aged 4 were the last to be recovered. It was nearly two o'clock before they were got out, and they were both dead. They were so long in being recovered, and there was no sound from them, that it was scarcely thought possible that they could be alive. Meanwhile, Mrs. Magee had been got out of the other cottage. She was taken to the Infirmary, where she was found to be suffering from fractured ribs and contusions on the back of the head. Her daughter, too, was rescued, simply suffering from shock. But Mrs. Mooney, was quite dead. Dr. Tawse and Dr. Thorpe (Dr. Harris's assistant) were on the spot, and there was no doubt that those three - Mrs. Mooney, Mrs. Charlton, and Joseph Robinson Charlton - were quite dead. The Magee's are Catholics, and Father Murphy and Father McEvoy were quickly in attendance at the Infirmary and on the scene of the disaster, and the event excited great sympathy and commiseration for the unfortunate victims.

As to the cause of the collapse, apart from the boilers already mentioned, there has been long and heavy rainfall, following severe frost. It is quite common for these natural causes to occasion falls of cliff. The retaining walls of the colliery are substantially and strongly built of freestone; and though it is a long time since they were built this is the first time there has been such an accident in any appearance, so far as we are aware, to awaken the slightest fear of anything of this kind.

The Collapsed Wall Disaster.

The Inquest.

On Saturday forenoon, at the Whitehaven Young Men's Christian Association Institute, the inquest was opened on the three persons who were killed by the collapse of a high retaining wall near Wellington Pit yard. These were Kate Charleton, 35, wife of Robert Wm. Charleton, collier; Joseph Robinson Charleton, aged four, their son; and Dinah Mooney, 36, wife of John Mooney, collier.

Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland, held the inquest, and the jury consisted of Messrs. Robert Wilson (foreman), Charles Brownrigg, Martin Hexham, Peter O'Hare, James Bewick, John Wallace, John Magee, Thomas Dyson, John Rogan, and Wm. Gair. Supt. Hogg and Inspector Dowthwaite were present.

Mr. L. T. Helder said he attended this inquest on behalf of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, who were the lessees of the portion of the property which fell and caused the death of these poor unfortunate people. He understood that the Coroner did not intend to go on with the inquest today, but to adjourn it to some day to be arranged. He might not himself be able to be present on that occasion, and he wished to take this opportunity of expressing on behalf of his clients their sincere regret that this accident should have happened, and their heart-felt sympathy with the relatives and friends of the poor unfortunate sufferers.

The Coroner: Mr. Helder would appear by himself or partner, at the adjourned inquest?

Mr. Helder said that was so.

The Coroner, addressing the jury, said he was sure it was with very great regret that they had again to meet, and upon the occasion of another very sad calamity, in close proximity to the one they had had the long investigation about. He was aware most of yesterday, and he had had not had the opportunity he should like to have of inspecting the premises, where the accidents happened, and also of ascertaining what the evidence was. To give him that opportunity he proposed adjourning the inquest after taking evidence of identification until Tuesday, at eleven o'clock, at the Magistrates Court.

The Foreman suggested that the Coroner and jury would view the place when they went to view the bodies.

Mr. Helder: I have seen the place. I think it is very desirable to view it.

The Coroner: Is there a plan?

Mr. Helder: Yes, there is a plan prepared. By Tuesday you will have it. I will give instructions that you may be supplied with every information you may require.

The Coroner and jury then proceeded to view the bodies, and to view the scene of the accident.

On their return evidence of identification was taken.

The bodies were identified by Robert Wilson Charlton, who said he was for the present living at No. 1 Park View; and John Mooney, at present living at 19, Mount Pleasant.

To the first witness, the Coroner said, in telling him, that the inquest would be adjourned until Tuesday: And if you would like to have anyone represent you, of course you have the right of doing it.

To the witness Mooney, the Coroner said he was sure all of them sympathised very much with both him and Charlton, in this most sad calamity, especially so as regards Mrs. Mooney, who they understood went to give her neighbours warning of their danger, and unfortunately went into that danger herself with the result that she lost her life.

The Coroner: Mr. Hogg, the jury, and myself have seen the premises, and we saw the boilers there. Has the water been removed from them, and all that can be done, been done in order to make the place as safe as possible?

Supt. Hogg: Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Can you also say that persons living below there have been warned of the danger and risk they run if they live still there?

Supt. Hogg: Yes, sir.

The Coroner: All have been told of that?

Supt. Hogg: Yes, sir.

The Coroner: Well, gentlemen of the jury, we will adjourn now till Tuesday. We have seen very many sad sights recently, and a very pathetic one we saw today, and that was the mother and the child in bed, both lying dead. It is extremely sad when we have to view such sights as we have had.

The Foreman: I am sure Mr. Coroner the jury will agree with me that these two gentlemen have our very deepest sympathy in this sad calamity.

Adjourned Inquest

At the adjourned inquest at the Magistrate's Court on Tuesday, Mr. Ormrod appeared on behalf of the Colliery Company. There was no legal representative for the relatives of the deceased. The two fathers were present.

Robert Blair, assistant general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, produced and put in a plan showing the wall, the boilers, the tramway, and the cottages and surroundings. He explained this to the jury.

David Moore deposed: I live at King Pit, Whitehaven, and am employed by the Whitehaven Colliery Company, at the coal washer at Wellington Pit. On Friday morning between 8 and 9 o'clock. I was inside the washer. It would be about 20 or 22 minutes to nine o'clock when I heard something wrong. There was a fall from the centre of the wall, somewhere about 38 or 30 feet in depth. I was inside when the fall took place. I had the engine running at the time, but I stopped the engine and ran to the window. Before I left the window a second fall occurred. The first fall had hardly landed on the ground till the second one followed; the second one was the heavier of the two. It was at the top wall on the roadway to Wellington Pit. The rails and everything were carried away by the second fall. Just two minutes before that a locomotive had passed. It was just an empty engine - no trucks attached to it. After I stopped the engine, I ran down; and all the men in the yard also went down. A son of mine and another man were with me in the engine house, and we all came down together. The first fall filled up the vacancy on the line-way below. The second one carried the line away and went down on the cottages. We saw dust and heard shouts from women. The wall that had fallen was like a circle 8ft. in diameter. There was no fall of any moment after the second - just loose stones; a little fell while we were working. I went right down and took two with men and others followed. When we got to the houses there was no one to be seen, and we stopped and were as quiet as we could. The houses were knocked down and we listened to see if there were any voices; as there must be somebody alive. We heard the sound of two voices. We heard the sound of the firehorn, but that was long after we got down. We started at once to get the debris away - all that were there: I could not mention more than a dozen names. We remained there working until some of the bodies were recovered. Whilst we were there the youngest of the family belonging to Bob Charleton was got out. It was outside clear of everything. The next one was a little one; I don't know his name. It was fast down underneath altogether. The woman was fast as well. The time that elapsed from the fall till the rescue of the first body was very short - inside half an hour. We remained there till the last one was got out, as near as I can tell about two o'clock.

Well now at any time have you seen any cause of danger with regard to this wall whilst you have been working at the washer? — Never.

You never anticipated anything whatever? — No.

Has there been much rain recently? — Yes.

Frost a little time before? — Well, at nights there has been frost.

The Coroner asked the fathers if they had any questions to ask and they replied no. No questions were put by Mr. Ormrod or by the jury.

George O'Neil deposed: I live at Wellington and am a collier employed by the Whitehaven Colliery Co., at Ladysmith. On Friday morning I was in my house near to where this wall fell in. The children had just gone to school; and it was about five minutes after; it would be about twenty minutes to nine.

Tell us what you saw and what you know as regards this occurrence. Your children had gone to school you say, and about five minutes afterwards something happened? — I was standing at the window, filling my pipe. We generally have a look at the wagons going past, when we get up in the morning. And I saw this wall coming. It just came in a bend. I saw it coming before it fell. There was no sound then, but my mother said she heard just like thunder at eight o'clock.

Did she say what direction the sound came from? — She did not say.

You did not ask her whether it came from the direction of the wall? — No, sir.

Then did you say you saw the wall bending? — I saw the wall coming, and it gave one slope - a bend - and when I saw it was coming I gave one rush and clicked my sister, who was in the lobby. Our back window is just opposite the houses that fell down. When I came out the fall had not taken place, but I saw it coming and I gave one rush outside.

Did you see more than one fall? — No, I just saw one fall, that was the lot, coming.

Could you have any idea as regards the weight and quantity of stuff that fell? — I could not form any idea; where I was there was just a portion of it.

Had you ever seen any warning of this before - anything to give you warning that this might have happened? — No, there was no warning.

But no other time? You never had reason to anticipate anything of the kind? — I never heard of anything.

Either by hearing or seeing you never had any fear of anything? — No, sir.

What happened afterwards? — I rushed up the lane went to Cradduck's window and clicked a little boy from the window after getting Mrs. Cradduck out. Their house had a portion of it knocked down. I got the little boy; it was not hurt, and Mrs. Cradduck had just got a shock, as she said she saw daylight break through the house as she awoke. I then went to the assistance of Eliza Magee. I recovered Eliza Magee and her mother. Eliza Magee was partly lying on her side. You could just see her face, and there was a beam on top of her. She was all right. She was telling me to hurry and get the stuff off her. She was the first that I recovered. She was hurt in the knee and she was taken away to the Infirmary. I also assisted in getting this girl's mother out - Mrs. Magee. I could not exactly tell when the last body was recovered, because when I came across Mrs. Magee the sight was too much for men and I collapsed in the house.

Eliza Magee, a girl about fourteen or fifteen, deposed: My mother's name is Isabella Magee. I was living with her on Friday at No. 4, Catherine Place, West Strand, Whitehaven. We have lived there all my life-time. I was in bed and did not know anything until I heard a sound like thunder; and as I was going to get out of bed a lot of stuff fell on top of me. My mother was downstairs. No one else was in the room I was occupying; I was in the room by myself. I did not become unconscious. I remember persons coming and getting the stuff off me.

Where did it fall on you? — I was smothered.

You mean covered all over? — Yes, sir.

Did you fall on your side or face? — I don't know.

Were you hurt? — Yes, on the right leg. I went to the Infirmary on Sunday and saw my mother there.

Did you hear Mrs. Mooney that morning talking to your mother? — Yes, sir; that was about half-past eight. I heard Mrs. Mooney shouting to my mother asking if she knew whether Mr. Kennaugh was any better. She was going to the pantry for some bread for the children's breakfast. No one called to me to give me warning of any danger; no one told me. I saw my mother at the Infirmary on Sunday. My mother was cut all over her body. She said when she saw Mrs. Mooney she was going to the water tap and Mrs. Mooney asked if she knew whether Mr. Kennaugh was any better.

Did she seem to think Mrs. Mooney came to give her any warning about the wall? — No; she said she did not know until it was on top of us.

Did she say where Mrs. Mooney was out at the time it took place? — Yes, sir; she was standing at the pantry door.

Can you tell us - I hope it is so - whether your mother is getting better? — No, sir.

You don't know. Probably the Inspector or somebody may be able to tell us.

Robert Cradduck Charleton, a bright boy, ten years of age, was questioned by the Coroner before being sworn. He said he went to school and could read and write, and he went to Sunday School.

Do you ever tell a lie? Sometimes. (Laughter.)

You won't tell one now, will you? No, sir.

The boy was sworn.

You remember last Friday, don't you? — Yes, sir.

What time did you get up? — Eight o'clock.

Who were in the house when you got up? — My little brother, and then my mother got up.

And what were they doing at about half-past eight? — My mother was dressing my little brother.

Did you see Mrs. Mooney? — No, sir.

You did not see her or hear her? — No, I went to see what time it was, and then I came back.

To whose house? — Mrs. Mooney's.

And what was the time? — It was nearly half-past eight.

What do you remember happening after you went back? — I was looking for a boy's scarf when the house fell in.

Did any of it fall on you? — No, only a big plank.

Did it seem a long time to you before anyone came to where you were? — Three hours.

Could you see your sister; was she in the cradle? — No, there was nobody in.

Well, what were you doing during this long time - this three hours you thought it would be? — Shouting and singing.

What was it you were singing? Were you afraid? — No.

Not afraid at all? What were you shouting? — For my daddy.

And what was it you were singing? — "God save the King."

Do you know all the verses, or a lot of them? — No, sir.

Did some one call out to you? — Yes, sir.

You heard some voices? — Yes, sir.

What did they tell you to do? — "Shut your eyes and sing on."

And did you keep singing, did you? — Yes, sir.

Were you hurt? — Please, sir, only a little scratch at the bottom of my chest.

You had not gone to school that morning? — No, I was just ready to go.

What time would you have gone - nine o'clock, school time, or what? — Quarter to nine.

You were just going? — Yes, sir.

Well, you will always remember when you sing that now that the singing of "God save the King," probably saved your life. Do you know when that house fell in where your other brother, the baby, was, and the other brother - what room they were in? — They were in the middle room.

By the foreman: I heard my mother about five minutes after the fall give three moans. She would be about a yard from me.

Asked whether he had any questions to put to the boy, Mr. Ormrod said he had not; but he would like to say what a remarkable lad he thought this was.

A juryman: I think we ought to write and let The King know he had one loyal subject.

The Coroner: I did send a paper to The King on Sunday. I did not put my address to it.

Inspector Dowthwaite deposed: I ran from the Police Station after the firehorn blew, and I would get there about a quarter past nine. I found there had been a land slide from Wellington Pit yard, which had demolished two cottages and part of a third at Wellington. Rescue work had started before I got there. Eliza Magee had been got out and the infant - Eliza Magee out of No. 4 and the infant out of No. 3. They had been upstairs in bed. The infant was all right - in no way injured. Ethel, the two year old girl, was got out after I got there. She had a broken leg and was immediately sent to the Infirmary. The next one to be rescued was Mrs. Magee; she was alive. She had been near the door, and was outside; she was lying in the court, opposite the door of No. 4 her own house. The next one to be found was Mrs. Mooney. She was outside in the court as well. The body of Mrs. Mooney was examined by Dr. Tawse and Dr. Thorpe, and they both said she was dead. That would be somewhere between nine and ten; I could not definitely say, being too busy at the time. There was a good deal of stuff upon Mrs. Mooney. Mrs. Magee had fallen and been covered by the door check, which had fallen and on its edge and kept the stuff off her, and I should think it was the door check that had broken her rib. Mrs. Mooney's body was a good deal marked. I was present when Mrs. Charleton and child were found. The mother was first to be found. They were sitting on the fender stool, near to the fireplace, and it was about 1.30 when they were got out. They were both together, and they were both got out together, both dead, when found. It was very difficult to get them out. There was a tremendous fall on the top of them. If it had not been for Wellington Pit officials I don't know when they would have been got out.

Were there many there assisting? — Yes; in fact there were too many, sir. Everyone wished to do their best.

You are satisfied there are no more bodies buried? — No, sir; a good deal of the debris has been removed.

And you are satisfied there are no more? — Yes, sir; I made every inquiry, and they are all accounted for that were living in the house.

Were you present when this boy was rescued? — I was sir, I called for order when we heard him shout, and as soon as all was quiet he commenced singing "God save the King."

Did he continue that? — Yes, sir; and I was there when he was got out. The superintendent of the Fire Brigade was the first to get hold of his hand. It was a staircase door that knocked the boy down, and it left a space to protect him. The door was all splintered by what fell on it.

He will be under a wrong idea, I suppose; he would not be there three hours? — No, about an hour or an hour and a half; but it would seem long in a place like that.

I quite realise that. Did you hear him singing? — Yes. I heard him distinctly. I believe I was the first to say that he was singing "God save the King."

The Foreman said he thought the way the men went about their work was very fine, and so was the heroism of this child.

Robert Steel deposed: I am manager of Wellington Pit. The first knowledge I had about this occurrence was a telephone message about a quarter or ten minutes to nine, at Ladysmith Pit. I came right down on a locomotive and would be there a minute or two after nine o'clock. I went to the top where the bodies were I looked at the boilers and thought they were in a dangerous condition, and I had the water emptied out of them. There are four boilers - egg-end boilers, five feet six inch in diameter. They are sitting on brick pillars about the same radius as the boilers, sitting in a bend built on slag lime. They have been there ten or twelve years. They were filled with water. They are storage tanks; in case anything goes wrong with Ennerdale mains we have these to fall back upon. I emptied the tanks right away as soon as I came down. I put a haulage of manilla rope round them and fixed them to a field behind, and made them as safe as possible. The height of the wall would be about forty feet. Some parts of it, since it has been exposed, it was six feet thick at the top and tapered down to about 2½ feet thick. There is a battering on the foundation, up to about 15 or 18 feet built of heavy masonry. I think the wall would be there before 1842 when the shaft was sunk. I have consulted Mr. Moore, and as far as I can gather the walls were built before the pit was sank.

Under whose responsibility is the wall? — It is part of our wall. We are the occupiers.

About what length of the wall came down? — About sixty feet in length at the gap.

Could you give any idea of the weight of it? — Yes, it would be between 1,200 and 1,300 tons; that is counting the batting that came out as well as the masonry.

Is there any sign of decay in the masonry? — No, it was built of yellow lime. I think it came from Wales. I dare say at that time it was reckoned lime which would suit in Whitehaven.

The question is, does the remainder of the wall show any signs of decay? — No; it seems in pretty good condition, what is left.

Well, you have thought over this naturally. What in your opinion caused the fall of the wall? — Well, the only thing I can account for is that it must have been the water behind the wall from the rising strata behind.

There has been a heavy rain fall? — yes; but I don't think it is water that has run behind the wall; for we have a channel which would stop any water lodging. But it is rising ground; the strata rises towards the Old Brake, and any water made there would naturally bat against the wall.

Is there anything to prevent other portions of the wall coming down? — We have both portions tied in the meantime, and the question is what is the best way to secure the remaining portion of the wall.

Yes, that is the all-important question. Anything might break down unless you take precautionary measures? — In the meantime we have it stayed with 36 feet props.

Is it fully protected now? — Yes.

There is no danger? — No.

Had you any reason to anticipate an occurrence of this description? — Not the slightest.

Has the wall be noticed to show any sign? — I passed the wall the previous day with my engineer Mr. Wilson. We were putting electric lights along; and he remarked to me, "This is a splendid wall for the job."

There was no bending? — No, in fact I would have thought it would stand for a generation, the same wall.

You know of nothing passing that would tend to loosen it - no trucks? — No, the heaviest thing that passes over the wall is a man travelling.

Then everything was done to rescue those alive and recover the bodies of those who were unfortunately dead from those houses? — Oh, yes I think everything was done that could be done, sir. Everyone was very anxious and willing to do what they could.

The Foreman: There is a great amount of rock round there. There should not be great weight upon that wall. It is all rock; there should not be a great deal of weight; and if anything had been wrong the railings would have given way.

The Coroner: Had the boilers anything to do with it? — The boilers are on the rock foundation.

There is no sign of their giving way? — No; we have examined them very carefully, and every boiler is joined by connecting pipe, and any sign of movement would show itself on the connecting pipe, and there is no sign whatever.

By the Foreman: And there is a man working there on the electric light. He saw nothing? — No. He saw nothing.

By Mr. Ormrod: There are stays in this wall, are not there? — Yes, built into the solid rock.

Is there one sticking out still? — Yes, I dare say the Coroner and jury might see it.

In reply to further questions by Mr. Ormrod, witness said the boilers would be 18 or 20 feet from the outside of the wall. It was his opinion that they were on the solid rock.

Mr. Atter put some questions as to who was responsible for the wall. You do not say that the Company are responsible? — No, I don't know who is responsible.

The Coroner said the only object of his question was to ascertain whose property it was, and that the wall was under their management.

Mr. Ormrod: I misconstrued the intention of your question.

The Coroner said that was so, and Mr. Ormrod was quite right in putting his question to make that clear.

Mr. John Walker (one of the jury): Are there no weep holes in the wall? — I don't know. There have been none in my time.

Mr. Wallace: There are generally weep holes are there not? — That is quite correct; there are generally weep holes in any wall against higher ground behind.

Mr. Wallace: There does not seem to be any in any of these walls? — No, there are not.

By Mr. Ormrod: The wall was built before 1842. There were weep holes as that time. Probably the wall is in the same condition as it was when it was built, in that respect.

By the Coroner: The stays have not been put in since the wall was built. It is intended to keep the boilers empty in the meantime; but I am quite certain, Mr. Coroner, that the boilers had nothing to do with the fall of the wall. The boilers are about 14 tons weight, and they would hold about 20 tons of water. They would not fill them in the meantime. We can do without them; the pit is not going full swing.

Would not you say there is a danger if these boilers were filled with and additional weight of water? — There will be no danger if the foundation is on rock. I will ascertain that before we do fill them.

Robert Blair, assistant general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery, said he had known this wall for about eleven years. He had never had any cause of alarm about or anything of that description - none at all. He agreed with Mr. Steel as to the cause of its fall - that water may have got behind it; and that the boilers filled with water had nothing to do with it. He had examined them very closely, and there was no signs of cracking, nor any sign that the boilers have moved at all. There was no danger from them as they were, without being filled; they could not fall.

This was all the evidence.

The Coroner, addressing the jury, after again referring to the sadness of the accident, coming so soon after the other calamity that they had had to investigate, said the question of liability and compensation, if there was any such question, would have to be determined by another court. The only question was any fault or neglect on the part of any one; and it was for that purpose he asked Mr. Steel as to who was responsible, if there was any responsibility; that would enable the jury to know, if there was any neglect on whom the responsibility rested. The party responsible was the occupier, those who had control of the premises; and those they understood from the answer were the Whitehaven Colliery Company. This wall seemed to have been as it was for a considerable number of years; and those who had been connected with the Colliery for a long time past seemed to have had no reason at all to anticipate anything wrong taking place. No signs in the wall had occasioned any alarm. As they know they had been recently heavy floods and rain and that was the explanation given by Mr. Steel and Mr. Blair as to what had occasioned the fall of the wall.

Well, it was for the consideration of the jury, but there did not seem to have been neglect on the part of anyone. It seemed to have been an occurrence which had been occasioned in all probability in the way suggested by Mr. Steel and Mr. Blair, by the heavy rains, and that the boilers which otherwise might look to be dangerous had nothing whatever to do with it. As regarded prevention for the future they had had the assurance of both Mr. Steel and Mr. Blair that every precaution would be taken as regards protection of life and property of those who might be otherwise in any danger from it. Whether or not there was any question of liability for compensation the verdict of the jury would not affect it; and he suggested their verdict should be that the deaths were occasioned by a fall of the wall on the 16th instant. He left it there for the determination.

The jury at once returned their verdict as the Coroner had suggested.

The Coroner said he certainly thought the recognition of the pluck of this lad should not rest here. (Here, here.) He would like them to pass some resolution commending the pluck of the lad, and he would join in it and would have great pleasure in sending it to the highest quarter, to the King. One of the jurymen made the remark that The King had one loyal subject; that was so and a very useful one. A more plucky lad, under the circumstances it would be impossible to know. It was really hard to realize how under the terrible circumstances in which this lad was placed, how he could show the pluck he did. If the jury approved of this suggestion that occurred to him, he would have great pleasure indeed in giving effect to it.

The foreman said he was quite sure they would all approve of it. The boy had been a very brave boy, and they should make some recommendation.

Mr. Ormrod: If I am in order, my clients would like to be coupled with the recommendation. They admire the boys pluck. Under such awful conditions it was marvellous that he should speak at all, let alone sing.

The Coroner's suggestion was adopted, and the jury made a collection for the boy.

Sympathy Of The Borough Member.

On Sunday the following telegram was sent to Mr. T. Richardson, M.P., to his election agent, Mr. J. Thompson, Senhouse Street, Whitehaven:

"Kindly convey to relatives of victims of house accident my deepest sympathy. Forward me particulars."

Richardson.

Petition To The King.

Mr. Atter, The Coroner, drew up the following petition to His Majesty, and forwarded it on Tuesday evening :—

"Whitehaven.

December 20, 1910

To His Majesty the King:

May it please your gracious Majesty.

On the 16th instant two houses were knocked down by the fall of a high wall which was at height above them, and two women and a child were inmates of the houses, were killed.

From the ruins of the fall of the houses there were recovered alive a woman, a boy, a girl, and a child.

The boy is ten years of age, and is the son of one of the women who were killed. He was in the ruins for about one and a half hours before he was rescued and during the period that the rescue operations were going on he continued to sing the first verse of the National Anthem.

To-day upon the inquest held upon the deceased women and child the boy gave his evidence in a most intelligent and becoming manner, and at the conclusion of the inquest the boy was highly commended for his loyalty and pluck, and a subscription was raised, which amounted to sixteen shillings, and given to the boy, who, at the Court sang with great feeling and effect the first verse of the National Anthem, and then cried at the sympathy evinced towards him.

The Coroner and Jury respectfully express their humble opinion that the conduct of the boy was worthy of being brought to the notice of your Majesty, and so humbly beg and petition to be allowed to present this our humble memorial on the subject to your gracious Majesty and your memorialists will ever pray.

(Signed) Edward Atter (Coroner), Robt. Wilson (Foreman), William Gair, John A. R. Wallace, Tom Dyson, John Rogan, Peter O'Hare, John Magee, Robert Miller, William Holmes, Charles Brownrigg, James Bewick, Martin Hexham, William Bewsher (jurors).

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Bewick, James    Juror  
Blair, Robert R.    Asst. Manager  Whos Who Page
Brownrigg, Charles    Juror  
Charlton, Ethel   2   
Charlton, Joseph Robinson   4   
Charlton, Kate, Mrs.   35   
Charlton, Robert Craddock   10   
Charlton, Robert William    Collier  
Craddock, William      
Dowthwaite, —    Police Inspector  
Dyson, Thomas    Juror  
Forsyth, —, Lieut.    Fire Brigade  
Gair, William    Juror  
Harris, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Helder, L. T.    Solicitor  
Hexham, Martin    Juror  
Hogg, —    Police Supt.  
Kennaugh, William L.    Warehouse Owner  
Magee, David      
Magee, Isabella      
Magee, John    Juror  
McEvoy, —, Father      
Mooney, Dinah   36   
Mooney, John    Collier  
Moore, David    Coal Washer  
Murphy, —, Father      
O'Hare, Peter    Juror  
O'Neil, George    Collier  
Ormrod, —    Solicitor  
Richardson, T.    M.P.  
Rogan, John    Juror  
Steel, Robert    Manager  Whos Who Page
Tawse, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Thompson, J.    Political Agent  
Thorpe, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Wallace, John    Juror  
White, —, Capt.    Fire Brigade  
Wilson, Robert    Jury Foreman  
Wilson, William    Engineman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Wellington Colliery  Wellington Colliery
Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print