15th December 1910
The Last Of The Bodies Recovered
Mistaken Identification
On Friday last, Mr. E. Atter, coroner for West Cumberland, held an inquest on the last of the 136 bodies of the men and boys who were killed by the disaster of the 11th May last, in Wellington Pit. The Coroner and jury viewed at the pit-head a body
identified as that of George Armstrong, whose brother was found on Wednesday. They afterwards returned to the magistrates' court-house and heard the following evidence :—
Jeremiah Skelton, 17, Michael-street, banksman at Wellington Pit, said he knew George Armstrong, and knew that he was on the last shift down Wellington Pit on the 11th May.
The Coroner: I am told that he and his brother were the last to go down the pit?
Witness: No, they were not. I have seen the body now at the pit top. I cannot identify it.
Thomas Birkett deposed that he lived at 17, Back Ginns, and was a shiftsman in Wellington Pit. He knew George Armstrong, and was present when his body was recovered yesterday and brought to the pit top. He could identify the body by the clogs, which
had butterflies cut out on them, which was something exceptional.
By the Foreman: The body was found about 12 yards below where the body of John Armstrong, deceased's brother, was found, on the dilly brow, going up to their working place.
James Henry, under-manager at Wellington Pit, of 2, Harbour View, said he knew the deceased very well. Deceased had been a collier in the employ of the Colliery Company for many years. It was within witness's knowledge that on the 11th May there was an
explosion in Wellington Pit, by which deceased and 135 others were killed.
Dr. Harris, the colliery medical officer, said he had known deceased personally for some time. He had seen the body and could identify it by the profile and by the peculiarity of the hair of his head. He had been killed by the violence of the
explosion. The body was charred, mummified, and much decomposed. Both legs were broken. It was not so much charred as some others, and witness would say he had been blown against two tubs.
Nelly Armstrong deposed that she was the widow of the deceased and lived at Hensingham. Deceased was 27 years of age. She could identify the body by the clogs having butterfly patterns on them. The funeral would be on Sunday afternoon, and she would
take the coffin away from the pit on the Saturday, and it would be sealed up and would not be re-opened.
James Armstrong deposed that he gave evidence on Wednesday on the body of his brother John. This was another brother. Witness was a blastfurnaceman and lived at 13, North Watt-street, Workington. He had seen the body at the pit top and could identify
if as that of his brother George by the hair on his head and the clogs that were described before-hand by the widow.
The jury found a verdict that deceased had been killed as the result of an explosion of gas and coal-dust.
The Coroner said he believed there was someone present who wished to say something about the body of Edward Taggart.
John Taggart stepped forward and stated that he lived at Arrowthwaite, and was employed at Croft Pit. He was the father of Edward Taggart, a single man, who lived with him, and was a collier working at Wellington Pit at the time of the explosion. There
were two other brothers working in the pit. They were found and buried. The body of Edward had not been found.
Have you carefully examined the three bodies which have been buried as unidentified? — No, only one, not the other two. There was only one that was working in the same district, and the others I have not seen.
Then you cannot say that one of the other two was not one of your sons? — Oh, they were working nothing near one another.
That might be. Then you have only examined one of the bodies unidentified? — Yes; that came out of No. 2.
Then you cannot say one of the others was not one of your sons? — I cannot say; but it was impossible; they were not in the district.
Have you read the description of the things that were found on the bodies of the other two? — No, I have not.
Well, you spoke to me yesterday; what was it now, that you wanted to put before the jury and myself? — That my son has not been identified and he must have been closed up and buried under another name, by mistake.
But why are you of that opinion if you have not seen two of the three bodies that were not identified? — Because he was not in the district.
But he may have moved? — You see when you got to identify a body at the pit top, you go to identify those that were working in that district; you don't see those that are closed up; but Mr. McMellon saw the three that were unidentified, and he knew
Edward very well and knew that he was not among those three.
The Coroner: Very well, we will have Mr. McMellon.
Alexander McMellon said he knew Edward Taggart very well. He could not say, whether he was one of those who were buried as unidentified. The only thing he could say was that he assisted Inspector Dowthwaite and P.C. Wilkinson in the identification of
the bodies. There were three brothers Taggart. The first two unidentified came out of No. 5 and No. 6 levels. That was another part of the pit altogether to what the Taggart's worked in. the Taggart's were not down at the pit-head when those two
unidentified were found; they did come down once over and were told their sons worked in another part of the pit altogether, and that they need not trouble until No. 3 high right hand men started to come up. They came down and saw the third unidentified
man, but anything that was left as regards clothing was not of the description that they gave, at all; they gave a description before they saw the body.
You cannot say, then, that one of the three buried as unidentified was not that of Edward Taggart? — I won't swear to it, sir; the only thing is the features were very poor.
One distinguishing thing was a broken finger and another a gold watch and portrait? — Yes, but the faces were not very plain of any of them; but, of course, the distinguishing mark you speak of was very conspicuous, the loss of the finger-end.
That one also had a brass watch on, with a cracked glass.
And a photograph in the watch, if I remember aright? — The glass was cracked, but I don't think there was a photograph.
No; very probably it is my mistake? — No, John Forrest was marked on the watch on the name of the maker and it was a "William Tell watch." The description given of Edward Taggart was that he had a boil on his neck and he did not wear a
neck strap; but the body that was unidentified had a neck strap on.
The Coroner (to the father): Well, I suppose that you wish to let the public know that although Edward Taggart has not been identified you have done all you could to identify it? — Yes, and I think there has been a mistake.
The Coroner: Well, I am extremely sorry for you if that should be so. Your only satisfaction is that you are assured he has had a Christian burial.
The father: This one had a neck-strap on.
The Coroner: Well, whether it has been someone else or not you have the assurance that the body has been recovered.
The father: And buried in mistake as someone else.
The Coroner: And buried in mistake. We are sorry for you if it is so, and it seems to me from what you have said it has been so.
The Coroner then addressing the jury said it was most satisfactory that the eighteen of them had been able to keep their health to finish this long and protracted inquiry. They had had 25 visits from here to the pit top for the purpose of identifying
the bodies, and they had in addition the eleven days of the inquiry, making 36 different attendances. That had gone on from the 30th September; and though it was of no importance it was a strange fact that on all those 25 visits they had never had a wet
day in going to the pit top. (Hear, hear.) He thanked the jury for the way in which they had discharged their duty in this the most painful matter of which any of them had had any experience.
The foreman (Mr. R. Wilson) said the jury had discharged their duty as well as they could and they were glad if they had given the Coroner satisfaction.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Armstrong, George | 27 | Miner | Deceased, Individual Page |
| Armstrong, James | | | |
| Armstrong, John | 36 | Miner | Deceased, Individual Page |
| Armstrong, Nellie | | | Widow |
| Atter, Edward | | Coroner | |
| Birkett, Thomas | | Shiftsman | |
| Dowthwaite, — | | Police Inspector | |
| Harris, —, Dr. | | Doctor | |
| Henry, James | | Under Manager | Whos Who Page |
| McMellon, Alexander | | | |
| Skelton, Jeremiah | | Banksman | |
| Taggart, John | | Miner | Father |
| Taggert, James McKenzie | 28 | Miner | Deceased, Individual Page |
| Wilkinson, — | | Police Constable | |
| Wilson, R. | | Jury Foreman | |
 |
 |
|
Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
Pub. Date | Article (Newspaper) |
| 12 May 1910 | Serious Accident At Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 May 1910 | Colliery Disaster, Many Miners Entombed (The Times) |
| 13 May 1910 | Terrible Pit Disaster, 137 Men Buried In Blazing Mine, Frantic Women's Vigil (Times & Express) |
| 13 May 1910 | Avalanche Of Death, Terrible Scenes, Four Men's Rush For Life (Times & Express) |
| 14 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Rescue Measures Abandoned (The Times) |
| 16 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Royal Sympathy And Donations (The Times) |
| 17 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster (The Times) |
| 17 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disasters (The Times) |
| 18 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Experts' Conference (The Times) |
| 19 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, The Mayor's Fund (The Times) |
| 19 May 1910 | The Disaster At Wellington Pit, 137 Men And Boys Closed In By Fire, Appalling Calamity (Whitehaven News) |
| 19 May 1910 | Coincidences (Whitehaven News) |
| 19 May 1910 | Looking Back (Whitehaven News) |
| 19 May 1910 | The Brick Wall (Whitehaven News) |
| 19 May 1910 | The Colliery Calamity (Whitehaven News) |
| 19 May 1910 | The Inevitable (Whitehaven News) |
| 19 May 1910 | Those Who Mourn (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Mayor's Relief Fund (The Times) |
| 24 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 26 May 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Further Exploration, Pit Now Doubly Sealed (Whitehaven News) |
| 26 May 1910 | A Suggestion (Whitehaven News) |
| 26 May 1910 | The Colliery Relief Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 26 May 1910 | The Miners And The Disaster (Whitehaven News) |
| 26 May 1910 | What To Do With It (Whitehaven News) |
| 27 May 1910 | Whitehaven Colliery Disaster (The Times) |
| 28 May 1910 | The Whitehaven Disaster (The Times) |
| 02 Jun 1910 | Allerdale Colliery Company's Clifton Pit, Doubling Of The Shift (Whitehaven News) |
| 02 Jun 1910 | Dangers Of Coalmining (Whitehaven News) |
| 02 Jun 1910 | The Men Out Of Work (Whitehaven News) |
| 02 Jun 1910 | The William Pit Men (Whitehaven News) |
| 02 Jun 1910 | Stoppage At William Pit, Gas In The Pit, Inspection By Men's Representatives (Whitehaven News) |
| 07 Jun 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Further Exploration, Fire Probably Out (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Meeting Of William Pit Men (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | Mayor's Relief Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | Pit Lamps (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | The Analysis Of The Gases (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | The Unsealing Of The Pit (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | Whitehaven Pits (Whitehaven News) |
| 09 Jun 1910 | William Pit Re-Started (Whitehaven News) |
| 10 Jun 1910 | Mr. Keir Hardie and the Whitehaven Disaster (The Times) |
| 13 Jun 1910 | The Whitehaven Disaster (The Times) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | Wellington Pit Disaster (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Exploring Party Who Descended The Pit On Sunday Last (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Cumberland Miners' Association, Whitehaven Relief Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | The Progress Of The Pit Exploration (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | The Sealing Of The Pit (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | The Union And The Relief Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Jun 1910 | Unthinkable (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 Jun 1910 | Whitehaven Pit Accident (The Times) |
| 23 Jun 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Exploration Stopped, Another Conference Of Experts (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 Jun 1910 | The Wellington Pit Disaster, Discussion In Parliament, Home Secretary Promises Amending Legislation (Whitehaven News) |
| 07 Jul 1910 | The Mayor's Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 07 Jul 1910 | Pit Rescue Work (Whitehaven News) |
| 07 Jul 1910 | The Causes Of Explosion (Whitehaven News) |
| 14 Jul 1910 | The Mayor's Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 14 Jul 1910 | Wellington Pit Disaster, The Mayor's Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 21 Jul 1910 | Letter (Whitehaven News) |
| 22 Jul 1910 | Award of Edward Medals (London Gazette) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | Wellington Disaster, The King Edward Medals For 49 Rescuers (Whitehaven News) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | An Important Mining Experiment (Whitehaven News) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | And "The News" (Whitehaven News) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | Dividends And Safety (Whitehaven News) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | Hasty Speech, Lame Apology (Whitehaven News) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | Judging After Event (Whitehaven News) |
| 28 Jul 1910 | The Sealing Of The Mine (Whitehaven News) |
| 04 Aug 1910 | The Miners And The Medals (Whitehaven News) |
| 04 Aug 1910 | Presentation Of The Medals, Departure From Whitehaven (Whitehaven News) |
| 05 Aug 1910 | Award of Edward Medals (London Gazette) |
| 24 Aug 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 20 Sep 1910 | The Whitehaven Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 26 Sep 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 27 Sep 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 28 Sep 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Finding Of Bodies (The Times) |
| 29 Sep 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 29 Sep 1910 | Re-Opening Of Wellington Pit, Quick Progress, Finding Of Bodies (Whitehaven News) |
| 30 Sep 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Fifty Bodies Found (The Times) |
| 01 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, More Bodies Discovered (The Times) |
| 03 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 04 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 05 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | The Re-Opening Of Wellington Pit, Thursday's Good Day's Work, 50 More Bodies Found (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | A Common Grave And Monument (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | A Town Of Mourning (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | A Veritable Way Of Death (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | Sanitary Restrictions (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | The Crux Of The Coming Inquiry (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Oct 1910 | The Monument (Whitehaven News) |
| 07 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 08 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 10 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Disaster, Identification Of The Bodies (The Times) |
| 12 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | Coroners And Juries (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | The Mining Disaster: Identification Of Bodies (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | A New Electric Lamp (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | Coroners' Inquests (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | Fees For Service (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | Identification Of Bodies (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | The Mystery Of The Mine (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Oct 1910 | The Mine Disaster, Thursday's Developments, Futher Exploring (Whitehaven News) |
| 15 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Supposed Cause (The Times) |
| 15 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Supposed Cause (The Times) |
| 17 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 18 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 19 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 20 Oct 1910 | The Mine Disaster, Thursday, 12 Bodies Found (Whitehaven News) |
| 22 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disasters (The Times) |
| 23 Oct 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 27 Oct 1910 | Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News) |
| 27 Oct 1910 | The Stoppage Of The Pits (Whitehaven News) |
| 27 Oct 1910 | The Mining Disaster, Friday's Findings, The Friction Gear Fire And Falls (Whitehaven News) |
| 03 Nov 1910 | The Mine Disaster (Whitehaven News) |
| 03 Nov 1910 | A Serious Rumour (Whitehaven News) |
| 03 Nov 1910 | Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Official Inquiry Opened (The Times) |
| 17 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 17 Nov 1910 | Wellington Pit Disaster, The Inquest And Home Office Inquiry (Whitehaven News) |
| 18 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 19 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 22 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 23 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 24 Nov 1910 | Wellington Pit Disaster, The Inquest And Home Office Inquiry, Thursday's Proceedings (Whitehaven News) |
| 30 Nov 1910 | The Whitehaven Disaster (The Times) |
| 01 Dec 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 01 Dec 1910 | The Mining Disaster, The Inquest And Inquiry, Tuesday's Proceedings (Whitehaven News) |
| 01 Dec 1910 | Discovery Of More Cremated Remains (Whitehaven News) |
| 02 Dec 1910 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times) |
| 02 Dec 1910 | The Wellington Pit Inquiry (Sunderland Daily Echo) |
| 03 Dec 1910 | Verdict on Whitehaven Disaster, Officials Absolved From Blame (The Times) |
| 08 Dec 1910 | The Mining Inquest, Thursday's Proceedings (Whitehaven News) |
| 15 Dec 1910 | Wellington Pit Disaster, Recovery Of Another Body, The Inquest (Whitehaven News) |
| 15 Dec 1910 | The Last Of The Bodies Recovered, Mistaken Identification (Whitehaven News) |
| 22 Dec 1910 | Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Colliers' Public Meeting, Petition To The Home Office (Whitehaven News) |
| 22 Dec 1910 | Wellington Pit Disaster, Memorial Service, Address By The Bishop (Whitehaven News) |
| 29 Dec 1910 | Miners Unions (Whitehaven News) |
| 29 Dec 1910 | Pit Explosions (Whitehaven News) |
| 14 Feb 1911 | Award of Edward Medals (London Gazette) |
| 16 Feb 1911 | Disasters In Coal Mines, Home Secretary And Legislation (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Feb 1911 | Edward Medals For More Whitehaven Miners (Whitehaven News) |
| 16 Feb 1911 | Safety Lamps And Coal Dust (Whitehaven News) |
| 17 Feb 1911 | The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Home Office Criticism (The Times) |
| 23 Feb 1911 | The Whitehaven Disaster (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 Feb 1911 | Whitehaven Pit Fire, Home Office Reports, Dust And The Spread Of The Explosion (Whitehaven News) |
| 03 Mar 1911 | The Whitehaven Disaster, Report Of Miners Representatives (The Times) |
| 23 Mar 1911 | Wellington Pit Disaster, Mayor's Relief Fund (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 Mar 1911 | Exits And Standard Ventilation (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 Mar 1911 | Safety In The Mines (Whitehaven News) |
| 23 Mar 1911 | The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, The Inspection Of Mines (Whitehaven News) |
| 13 Apr 1911 | The Prospects Of Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News) |
| 18 May 1911 | Whitehaven County Court, Colliery Compensation Dependants (Whitehaven News) |
| 18 May 1911 | Whitehaven Colliery (Whitehaven News) |
| 06 Jul 1911 | The Local Miners' Union And Distress Funds (Whitehaven News) |
| 11 Mar 1933 | Pit Disaster Recalled, Death Of Man Who Was Decorated By King (Cumberland Evening News) |
 | Main page for Wellington Pit |
 | Accident/Disaster Page |
 | Text of the official report into the incident |
 | Memorial images gallery |