15th December 1910
Safety Lamps
Startling Statement By University Lecturer On Mining
The Detection Of Gas In Pits
Mr. George H. Winstanley, Lecturer in Mining at the Manchester University, speaking at a meeting of the Manchester Geological and Mining Society on the safety lamp in mines, said that in the hands of one man the safety lamp was merely a source of light,
whilst in the hands of another, properly trained, it become a scientific instrument capable of giving fairly accurate results as regards the detection of gas. The Coal Mines Act required not only for inspection for gas shall be made by the properly
appointed officials, but also by the miner himself, who was required "before commencing, and whilst at work," to "carefully examine his working place and see that it is free from gas." It was perfectly certain that a large proportion
of colliers were incapable of carrying out this regulation; and, when one reflected upon the generally inaccurate knowledge of the subject, could they be blamed?
Dealing with the necessity for care in testing for gas, he pointed out that the operation of testing for gas is one not unattended with danger. Indeed, he demonstrated by means of a simple experiment that a coal-dust explosion may be initiated by the
operation of testing for gas, if by chance the lamp used should happen to be defective. "There is," he added, "a good deal of misplaced confidence in what are called ‘safety lamps.' Official returns show that there are in regular use in
British collieries about 700,000 so-called safety lamps. Of this number, however, more than half have only one gauze, which is almost equivalent to saying that they are not safety lamps at all. There is no ‘permitted list' of safety lamps, nor are they
required to be put to the test, and the result is that one sees some dreadful imitations of safety lamps taken into mines, both faulty and imperfect in workmanship. And what of the undetected defects? Suppose all the lamps in use at the present time
were called up and submitted to actual tests; how many would fail?
Mr. Winstanley also urged the importance in the interests of greater safety, of the individual training of all firemen and other colliery officials whose duties require that they should be able not only to detect the presence, but also to estimate the
amount, of fire-damp present in the atmosphere of the mine.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Winstanley, George H. | | Lecturer | |