Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th November 1910

Wellington Pit Disaster

The Inquest And Home Office Inquiry

Thursday's Proceedings

The Court resumed at about a quarter to eleven Thursday morning.

JOHN WEAR was cross-examined by Mr. Rigby Swift: I am aged 47. I am a Whitehaven man and was brought up in Whitehaven. I was turned nine years old when I first went down the pit. In those years, 40 years ago boys went down the pit earlier than they are allowed to do now. I have been working off and on at the pit all the time since. I have also worked on the dock. For the last 17 years I have been working down Wellington Pit, and before then I had many years' experience in the pits and gained considerable experience of my own job, coal hewing. I can tell when a roof is dangerous and when there is gas about in dangerous quantity, and I understand testing for gas and have on many occasions tested for gas Nine marrows make a company, and they work in three shifts, three at a time. The two men of my company who worked as my marrows on the night of the explosion were my son and Michael McCumiskey. My son was 21, and had been in the pit five or six years. McCumiskey was a married man and had been in the pit for some years. The deputy in charge on the 11th of May was Benjie Cowie. He had been in charge of my shift all that quarter. I know there are supposed to be rules about the conduct of miners. I know that those rules are supposed to be put up; and I know that they were put up. I cannot read. I have never talked about the rules to any of the miners.

Do you tell those gentlemen you would start without rules and then when rules came into force there would be a lot of talk about them, would not there? — Well, there might be, and maybe me not hear of them.

Was there talk about rules among the miners? — I can't say.

You really want these gentlemen to believe that you never heard the rules discussed in all those years? — I never heard it.

You saw them up? — Yes.

Could your son read? — No, he was like me.

Your son was 21 and born in Whitehaven? — Yes.

Did he go to school in Whitehaven? — Yes; to two or three schools; to the National school and to Trinity school.

Mr. Redmayne: What standard did he pass?

Mr. Richards: Is it of any importance whether his boy can read? As far as it refers to the son, what bearing has it upon this inquiry whether he went to school or not?

The Coroner: I think you are right.

Mr. Rigby Swift: If you will allow me, I will show at once the very great importance of the inquiries I have just been making. This man has made some very startling accusations against responsible officials in this mine; and he bases his allegations to a large extent upon his own ignorance of the rules; and he said with regard to that that he never saw the rules and that he could not read. Well everybody must know that even people who cannot read get information as to what rules are. And when he tells us he cannot read, I naturally go to the man with whom he would be most likely to discuss these things, his own son, who obviously could read and with whom he would naturally talk about them. A question will arise as to whether you and the jury are able to rely upon this man, and if I can establish, as I venture to think I can, that he is not accurate in some of the things he tells you, that will help you to come to a conclusion as to what reliance you can place upon his evidence when you find him in conflict with other people. This man has made very damaging statements against my clients, and I am entitled to shake his credibility.

The Coroner: I don't think the question has any bearing.

Mr. Rigby Swift: Then I leave it at this point that this man says his son of 21 could not read. I must allow the gentlemen of the jury to draw their own deduction.

Witness was then asked what he would do in case he found gas. He replied that he would lower his lamp and leave the place.

So that although you do not know the rules you would do exactly what they tell you to do? — Yes.

Then we don't need to trouble about your absence of knowledge of the rules. Now you said yesterday that you have complained of gas to the deputies, and they had told you to go back and try and get your shift work in? — Yes.

I want to know the name of any deputy you complained to? — The deputy is dead.

I want to know the name of any man alive or dead that you complained to? — These two deputies, Cowie and Ritson.

During the 17 years you have worked constantly in the pit did you ever complain to any except Cowie and Ritson? — No, I had no occasion.

Are those the only people? — Yes, I had no reason to complain when there was no risk.

On how many occasions did you complain to Cowie. — I complained to him that week we were sent out, in July.

Did you ever complain to Cowie before July? — No.

Or after July? No.

So that in 17 years only once had you complained to Cowie? — Yes.

Tell me about Ritson. When did you complain to Ritson? — The same day, I complained to him on one occasion before that; and I complained to him after July, in March. I was working then on No.1 brake No.3 level. That is March this year. the March before the accident. I complained in other cases but I cannot tell you the name of the man I complained to. When I complained to Cowie I was working in No.3 level in the farthest brake.

Mr. Rigby Swift: I dare say you and the jury understand it better than I do. I am rather at sea in a coal mine. (Laughter.)

Witness contended that he was working in the narrow board brake. They had come out and sent for Cowie. He came in and fetched them all out off the level.

Could he have done more than he did? — No.

Did he do his duty as a deputy? — Yes

Mr. Redmayne: Is that withdrawal recorded?

Mr. Rigby Swift: I will endeavour to find out afterwards. (To witness): You have no complaint against Cowie? — No.

Now take the three occasions you complained to Ritson?. — In July, 1909, I was working in the same district. I came out when I observed gas and sent for Ritson, who came and told us to work out our shift. I cannot tell whether or not he tested for gas before telling us that. He did not test for gas that I am aware of. I worked out my shift. I did not object.

You went on? — Yes, but not in that place.

Where did you go? — To another working place.

And have you any complaint against Ritson? — Mr. Redmayne said he would have to have this cleared up. Were these withdraws reported. (Applause in Court)

Mr. Rigby Swift: Then I shall have to ask for a ruling as to whether my examination is to be broken up or this should be taken at the finish.

Mr. Richardson said what the witness was saying, would be found in the deputy's report book. He handed this to Mr. Redmayne.

Witness continued that he complained again to Ritson in July, 1909, when he was working in the same part of the mine. He sent for Ritson and Ritson came, and Benjie Cowie as well. Witness and his marrows had withdrawn. They did not go back to the same place. He never went back to work in that part of the mine again. Cowie and Ritson did not allow them to go on working where there was gas, but fetched them out and they went home. That was in July; he could not tell any nearer than that. On another occasion at the second brake, the whole place was stopped for gas. They were not allowed to go in. The joiner told them at the lock-shop, just outside the friction-gear. They were stopped going to the forehead, and were sent to work at another place. He had no fault to find with that.

So that you have no fault to find with anybody in regard to these instances you have been telling us about? — No.

They acted, so far as you could say, perfectly properly? — Yes.

Do you remember saying you were chased out by gas at the far brake? — Yes.

As far as you know was that far brake ever worked again? — No, not there.

Now you told us yesterday about an incident with the manager of the name Parker, I think it was. Was that before Mr. Steele came near the pit? — Yes.

Cowie and Ritson are both dead. Tell me, what has become of the manager, Parker? — Oh, I don't know.

You know he has left Whitehaven and gone to Africa? — Yes.

Have you seen him anywhere in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven for the last three and a half years? — I have not.

Who was with you when you spoke to the manager? — Joseph Lucas and Henry O'Pray. They are both alive.

Did the deputies come round that shift? — Yes. I don't know whether I said anything to them about it. They knew there was gas there.

Witness was then taken to the occurrences on the night of the 11th May. He said they finished between a quarter and twenty minutes to eight. They then knew there was something wrong. Between a quarter to eight and eight o'clock they filled another tub. They all went on with their work. McAllister had gone to see what was wrong, and sent Robertson in before eight to tell them they had all to come out. Then they went to the bottom of the air-split. When he and Kenmore left they found that from the doors down to the main intake was full of smoke. They had their lamps, but could see very little. They walked slowly for fear they might lose their lights. He could not say whether it was 726 yards down to the friction gear. When they got to the friction gear they saw a small fire on the left hand side of the friction gear. The fire had got hold of the boarding of the friction gear. They walked past on the iron flat-sheets on the right hand side. They saw then that the road was clear, and so far as they knew there was nothing wrong with the rest of the road, and all was clear to the pit shaft. There was the road behind them that they had just come. The men they had left were all alive when they left them. He knew one of these was his son. If it had been humanly possible for him to go back to them he would have gone, or anybody else, but he could not. The fire was every moment increasing. They sat down for a minute or two to get breath and discussed the possibility of putting the fire out.

You had promised, hadn't you, that you would go back? — No.

What? — No.

Are you sure? — Yes, I am certain.

Did not you write a letter to the paper? — No, I didn't.

Did you get one written? — Yes.

Do you know that in that letter it says "We left the others, promising to return?" — Yes.

How does that happen? — I got a party to write that letter. I did not tell them to put that in and they did put it in.

Who wrote the letter? — A lady called Mrs. Murphy.

And do you say Mrs. Murphy put that in without you saying anything about it? — Yes.

That you did not promise to return? — No, I did not.

Witness went on to reply that after they had rested a minute or two they walked on and met Mr. Henry. We went back with Mr. Henry. The smoke had come up 250 yards in about 35 minutes. He could not say about the fire, but the smoke was very much worse. He did not think it was then humanly possible for anybody to go through that smoke.

Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: Mr. Redmayne yesterday put this question to you, "Has a deputy never withdrawn you from a working place?" and you replied, "No, they never think about withdrawing us." You have corrected that now, and told Mr. Swift that the deputies did withdraw you. Was that answer of yours true? — Yes, I stick to it.

Then were your answers to Mr. Swift quite true, that deputies withdrew you? — I don't say they withdrew me. We went out ourselves. (Applause in court.)

The Coroner read that was the third time this had occurred, and if there any interruption again the Court would have to be cleared. He must insist that there should be no demonstration of any description.

By Mr. Chapman: He came out before the deputy came, and he gave us a new working. He did not mean to make any complaint of the deputies.

If yesterday you conveyed the impression to any of your inspectors that you were making accusations against the deputies you did not intend to do that? — I can't see where I did.

Did you or did you not yesterday intend to make any accusations against the deputies? — No; show me where I did?

Did you or did you not? — No, I did not.

Mr. Redmayne: When you withdrew yourself or were withdrawn was the place fenced off? — Yes.

Mr. Chapman read the letter witness said was written for him by Mrs. Murphy of the Green Dragon, Church Street, to "The Whitehaven News," and then questioned witness about it.

Do you mean to say that was a fabrication of Mrs. Murphy's brain? — Yes. I gave her no material. I did not dictate it to her, I just told her to write me a letter to clear me from the slander that I had left my son. I did not afterwards get her to contradict the statement that I had promised to go back.

JOSEPH KENMORE said he lived at 14, Bardy Lane, Whitehaven, and had been working 13 years at the Whitehaven Colliery and about 8½ of those at Wellington Pit. He was working on the night of the 11th May in No. 5. They first thought they heard a fall, about twenty minutes to eight. They went to the air-split. They sent for McAllister, the deputy, and Robertson, assistant-deputy. These came and went out for about five minutes and came back saying they could not get through the doors. Three lads coming from No. 5 junction said they thought it was a big fall between the two junctions, McAllister said he would go to the door again, and he did so, and said he could not get through. Witness said if he could not get that road he had better go through the air-courses. McAllister said he had not a key to open the door. Witness replied that he would soon find a good key; he would break it open with a hammer. They never got to the door, because of the black damp. Someone said that no one living could get between the two doors. Wear spoke up and said he would go if someone would go with him. Witness said he would go with him. They left without making any arrangement to return. As they passed they saw some writing on a door. The message was "William O'Pray and John Lucas cannot go any further and had to retreat." Witness and Wear could only see a little way with their lamps. There was dust as well as smoke. When they got to the friction-gear they saw a big fire on the left hand side. It was too hot to stay there. Fifty yards further on they sat down for two minutes, they were done out. Wear wanted to go back to put the fire out. They thought they might put irons on and whatever they could lay hands on to put the fire out. The smoke however, was so dense that they could not stay there. They went on and Mr. Henry met them. Witness had known gas in the place he had worked in; but could not say when. It was not this year.

By Mr. Redmayne: Had never been withdrawn because of gas. They sometimes had to put their lamps in a tin of water to keep the lamps cool, owing to gas burning in them. He could not tell when that took place nor what year it was.

Cross-examined by Mr. Pope: He had experience as a miner and knew how to test for gas. They sounded their roof every day and when they smelt gas in the area they tested. There was not much gas in "robbery." At No. 5 north it was robbery. Some time last summer he was working at the solid in No. 6. That made gas pretty freely. Their lamps generally showed half an inch of cap on the flame of their safety lamps from gas. In No. 6 it was all top coal and their heads touched the roof when they were working. They did not make a constant practice of testing for gas. They tested when gas showed on the light of their lamp on going in to the working place.

How often would it show on the lamp? — Some times we would see it every day and sometimes not.

Then you suggest that you still go into your working place? — Yes, we are sent into work.

Then you would be working in gas? — Yes.

How long would you be in gas without testing it? — We were visited during the shift, but sometimes the deputy would not come in until half a shift was over. We came out ourselves. I have never been withdrawn by a deputy. We would go home without waiting for the deputy.

Questioned as to the time Wear and he took to come out, witness said Wear had a watch. He had not. They left about 9.35, and got to the friction-gear about a quarter past ten, and he thought they sat at the friction-gear not more than two minutes. They made an attempt to go back, but only got about ten yards.

Cross-examined by Mr. Hanlon: I would not know my way out by the return airway. I had no idea there was a road past the friction-gear, by the back drift. It would be after half past ten that you had a conversation with me at the fan site. No collier is able to lower the wick of his lamp and know what percentage of gas is present or what percentage is indicated by so much cap on the flame. I have complained of the ventilation not being good, but I have never come home on my own accord. I have gone back next day and found it no better. I had never been removed from gas in No. 3 section, but I have heard of workmen being removed. The road along No. 3 level coming out to the friction-gear is thick with dust; sometimes we are up to the knees in it. Sometimes you cannot see before you for dust rising.

Mr. Rigby Swift: You say you have never been withdrawn by a deputy? — No.

You are quite capable of telling when there was gas? — Yes.

When you saw there was gas did you wait for a deputy to come; or did you take yourself out? — We took ourselves out if there was over much.

Can you tell us the name of a single man who ever tried to make you go back to work when you came away and said it was not safe? — No. Nobody ever told me to go back.

The Coroner pointed out that he had a note of a statement by Kenmore to the effect that he had been sent back to a place to work when there was gas there.

Mr. Rigby Swift said he intended to try to clear that up. (To witness): Have you got a single complaint to make against anyone with regard to his conduct as to gas? — No.

When you say you were sent to work you mean that you went there without being stopped? — Yes. The deputy told us it was right.

The deputy had been there to inspect it? — Yes.

And when you got there you found it was not all right; there was gas? — Yes.

Could gas collect after the deputy had been there and before you got there? — There must have been some in when he said it was all right. It could not all collect in a hurry.

Has a single person ever tried to make you work in a place after you pointed out that there was gas there? — Not that shift.

And by the next shift, it has been cleared away? — Some was; not all.

Mr. Redmayne: I should like to be quite clear upon that point. You say you have gone to a place in which there was gas after it had been reported clear? — Yes.

When you have gone there and found gas what have you done? — If it was not over much to work in we used to bat it out.

You mean you took something and bashed it about? — Yes.

Is that allowed? — So far as I know it is allowed.

I know it is the old-fashioned way of removing gas, but do you consider it safe? — No, I don't think it is safe.

Have you ever been found fault with for doing it? — No.

Have the deputies known you have done it? — Yes.

What have they said to you? — They said nowt.

Then, if the place was clear when the deputy made an inspection, and you batted it out, was it likely to come back again? — Yes, after we have done working.

Have you ever informed a deputy that there has been gas in a place and been removed? — No.

Have you ever told them and not been moved out? — Yes; but it was clear when we told them.

How do you examine for gas? — We pull down the wick of the lamp. There will be a blue light on the top of the flame of the lamp, or the lamp may go out.

What height of blue light above the flame do you consider dangerous? — Half-an-inch or an inch.

Well, that is a good margin. (Laughter.) Then you would go out, in practice, if there was half an inch or an inch? — Yes.

Then when you go out of a place do you tell the deputy? — Yes.

Can you go to another place without informing the deputy? — No.

Then you go so far out by and wait for the deputy to find you another working place? — Yes.

Then what does he do? — Well, when he sends us to another spot we don't come back and watch what he does. (Laughter.)

When you have been transferred to another working place have you ever afterwards been back to the old place? — No.

And you don't know whether your place has been fenced or not? — No.

Mr. Rigby Swift: You said that at times you were sent by a deputy to work at a place where there had been gas? — Yes.

Can you tell me the name of any deputy who has done that? — No, I cannot.

He didn't come to you and say "You are to go to work there," did he? — No.

You had been working at that particular place the day before? — Yes.

If the deputy you went to said your place was all right you call that sending you into the place? — Yes.

You don't mean that he never ordered you to go into the place? — No. There is not ordering attached to it. It would be slave-driving, chasing us in. (Laughter.)

You have never had to complain of slave-driving in that pit, have you? — No.

The Coroner: I am satisfied with the explanation he had given. I have taken my note off.

Questioned by Mr. Rigby Swift as to what happened when he reached the friction-gear after the explosion, witness said if they could have gone back they would have gone.

Why didn't you go? — Because we could not go. I had had enough coming through without going back again.

Is it perfectly clear that nobody could possibly have gone through the fire after you and Wear came out of it? — Not, at the time we met the others; they could not have got through.

If anybody suggests that the colliery officials did not do the best they could that is not true? — They could have been down a long time before they were.

You were down and you felt the explosion and yet you hadn't gone more than 100 yards beyond the friction gear before the friction gear became impassable? — Yes, but they might have known long before that.

You didn't get to the friction gear and through the fire until ten o'clock? — After ten o'clock.

You and Wear got through comparatively easily until you got to the fire? — Not so easy. I wanted to turn back. I had got enough before I got out.

It is all very well to talk about the men outside, and there may be opinions about it, but let us see what the others did. You and Wear were the only men who walked out? — Aye; it's a pity there wasn't a lot mair.

I quite agree. It's a great pity the whole 27 did not walk out. If they had come with you all of them would have got out? — Yes.

When once you got to the friction gear could anybody have got back? — No.

So that at the time the colliery officials arrived at the fire — never mind whether they were too early or too late — nobody could get through to the friction gear? — No.

If anybody said they were to blame for what they did when they got to the friction gear you say it is not true? — Nobody could get through then.

By Mr. Chapman: Asked if they were to understand that a deputy allowed or ordered him formally to put his lamp into a tin of water because the lamp was so hot, witness said "Yes." It was a common thing, and the officials saw and sanctioned it. He could not give the name of any official who sanctioned it.

By Mr. Redmayne: He thought the officials could have got to the friction gear sooner. The back shift men knew there was something wrong as they left word with the manager.

JEREMIAH SKELTON, 17, Michael Street, Whitehaven, banksman at Wellington Pit, said he had been 18 years employed there. He was on the night shift on May 11th, when 143 workmen descended the pit. He entered the number of men in a book and he produced a copy from the book. He saw the reversal of the air that night and he sent word to Mr. Henry. While the cages were ascending the dust continued to come up the shaft. The dust was sucked down again ten or eleven minutes after the first noticed the reversal of the air. He tried a piece of paper and that also was sucked down. Within ten minutes after he had sent the message Mr. Henry and Benn went down the pit. The air had gone back to its natural course as near as he could see before Mr. Henry went down. Mr. Steele, the manager, went down at a quarter to ten, and Mr. Blair about twenty-past ten.

Replying to Mr. Hanlon, witness said he sent for Mr. Hanlon but was not authorised to do so.

By Mr. Swift: As far as he knew Mr. Hanlon was a good representative of the men.

A man who thoroughly understands his business? — Well, I don't know about that. (Laughter.)

And Mr. Hanlon, representing the miners, went down the pit at twenty minutes to ten? — Yes.

THOMAS GRAHAM, overman at Wellington Pit, said he had been 44 years at the colliery and about 30 in Wellington Pit. He came up the pit on the 11th May about half-past seven and went to the Market Hall, there being a cinematograph entertainment there. A watchman, Jonathan Scott afterwards came to the Market Hall for him. It was about a quarter-past nine when Scott came for him. Asked how he fixed the time witness said there was a boxing contest and they had reached the third round. (Laughter.) Witness and a deputy named Quayle got several men together, including Matthew Wilson and John Pearson, deputies, and went right down the pit. When he got there was a body of men bringing Walker and Gregory out, and, having ascertained they were alive, witness went on. At the new fan site he found Mr. Henry and a group of other men, including Dr. Harris. The road was full of smoke and was hot. The men were making ready to put brattice cloth in. Witness didn't approve of what was being done and speaking to Mr. Henry, said he would advise that they put a stop across the main road right to the South Dip. Mr. Henry said "No, Tom, we will go down this way," but witness told him they would never get down there in the world, because they had such a high roof to contend with and they would make no hand with it with the air-pipe. Mr. Henry said they would box it, "but," added witness, "any practical man knows that boxing the air pipe would be a waste of time." He remained with the rescue party until Mr. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector, came, between four and five o'clock. The heat was so intense they could not go on with the bratticing. He called John Rothery, undermanager at William Pit, and John Rothery, overman at the latter pit, and showed them that all the air was going down the South Back Dip. Witness said "This is our road if we have to go down at all." There was no smoke at all at the entrance of the place he was speaking of. He went and told Mr. Moore what he wished to do. Mr. Moore went back with him and viewed the place and he quite agreed with witness that that was the road. He asked Mr. Moore if he would give him liberty to alter the stoppings. Mr. Moore said he would go and see Mr. Turner about the proposal. Witness went up and met Mr. Turner, who said they should stop a few minutes as he expected Mr. Atkinson and some more gentlemen coming in. Mr. Atkinson came up in a few minutes and when he was told of witness's proposal he said "Let me first see where the fire is." Mr. Atkinson and Mr. Steele went down to where the fire was and when they returned in a few minutes Mr. Atkinson said he had come to the conclusion that no one was alive below the fire. Witness then said he for one believed that the men were alive in No. 5 and No. 6. Mr. Atkinson said he didn't think there was anybody alive and ordered all to leave the place. He asked Mr. Atkinson to grant him two hours. Mr. Atkinson replied it was no use witness talking as it would cause further trouble. Witness said "Don't you think I know what I am talking about?" and Mr. Atkinson asked him if he wanted to commit suicide. They were all ordered out and he disapproved of the course. Since the mine was opened out and he had seen the conditions he had altered his opinion, but he still maintained that at the time in question the men in No. 5 were alive but not in No. 6.

The Coroner: Why alter your opinion the men were alive and not in another?

Witness said because the men in No. 6 were found with their "baits" and their water bottles full of water. In No. 5 all with the exception of three had only the tiniest little drop of water in their bottles.

By Mr. Redmayne: He thought he could have got to within twenty-five yards of the fire by the South Back Dip. This was not possible by the main intake. His sole reason for going down the South Back Dip was to do without the brattice.

Questioned by Mr. Atkinson, witness stated that on the afternoon on May 11th he thought he had never seen the No. 3 District in better condition.

Did you realise that your air-crossings at the third north were blown out? — I said I would guarantee, whoever lived to see it that either one or both would be destroyed.

Did you think that the air would be short-circuited there, and that there would be less air going round No. 6 and No. 5? — Yes.

And you knew there was a good deal of gas coming from No. 6? — Yes.

Did you realise that place would soon become full of gas? — Yes, it would soon become full.

The air would take longer to go round, but when it got round it might be in an explosive condition. Did you realise that? — No, I didn't think that.

Wouldn't it be likely to happen? The explosion would not stop the gas coming off: the gas would still come off. Supposing by the blowing out of the air-crossings you have only a quarter of the air going in-by, your quarter of an inch cap would become an inch or two inches very soon, and the air would come down in an explosive condition? — I don't see how the air could come round. The gas would fill up the place and stop the air.

I agree, to some extent. But if all that gas got into the air-current, there would be a dangerous state of things; and that would come within about 40 yards of the fire, wouldn't it? — Yes.

And a very little explosion would have driven all that smoke and bad air upon the rescuers? — Yes.

Suppose you stop the main intake and go down, the back dip with your brattice? — Oh, if it would not have worked without doing that then one plan would have been as bad as the other. I expected that the fresh air going down that place would have driven the smoke back.

But you must remember the only difference between the front dip and the back dip is that one is 25 yards away from the other. You must not suppose the smoke would not come up the back dip? — Oh, I know that.

If you stop the smoke coming up the front dip it would come by the back dip? But the air there would carry the smoke away.

You suggest that the men in fifth north lived longer than the men in sixth north? Yes.

Well, I agree with you. The men of sixth north had not realised that an explosion had happened and had continued working? — Yes, I think so.

And when they realised it, it would probably be the smoke coming in on them? — Yes.

And they would come out by the main road? — Yes.

The smoke would get in to them by what time? — Starting at twenty minutes to eight, it would be nine or ten o'clock before any smoke would get to them, with the air-crossings blown out.

Then they would begin to come? Yes.

And they would all be out probably before twelve? — Witness suggested that in the chalked message on the sleeper, the hour might have been rubbed out by the imprisoned men and altered from time to time; but when the message was produced he changed his opinion and thought it was all written at one time.

Friday's Proceedings.

The Court resumed at half past ten on Friday.

The Coroner announced that Mr. Redmayne had been willing to arrange his London engagement so as to enable the inquiry to go on without any break. Unfortunately that could not be arranged; and therefore the inquiry, if as probable it was not finished on the 22nd, would be adjourned, subject to what might now be said, on the 29th.

Mr. Rigby Swift urged that the adjournment should be till the 5th December. He had an important engagement on the 29th. He saw the possibility that some of them (looking to the labour representatives) might be engaged in the much more congenial occupation of soliciting votes. (Laughter.) He did not know whether that was a thing that could be contemplated.

The Coroner: Others may be engaged in the same manner.

Mr. Richards urged that the adjournment should take place to-morrow (Saturday). Whatever date was fixed for resuming, that would have given them an opportunity of getting home; and if they were going to adjourn on Tuesday it was hardly worth while coming back for Monday and Tuesday.

Mr. Pope left the matter in the hands of the Coroner.

The Coroner ruled that the adjournment should be from the 22nd to the 29th. It was strongly desirable that the inquiry should be continued without any break for any length if time that was not actually necessary.

THOMAS GRAHAM, recalled, was cross-examined by Mr. Pope.

Speaking of working in the solid, we have been told that you can always find half an inch of cap on the flame of your lamps? — No, that is not true, only in some places.

If that were so, that would indicate that the ventilation was not adequately reaching the working place? — Whenever it occurred the brattice was not "check" up to the forehead.

We have heard a great deal about men having to put their lamps in water to cool them? — I never saw that in my time.

When you found gas in the working place what would you do? — If I found gas I would stop the men until I got brattice cloth put into place. I would send for the joiners to put some ventilation in.

If you found gas, not a serious accumulation, but which had to be attended to that had to be removed but was easily removed, would you report it? — No, I would not. Suppose if could be done, in a quarter of an hour I would fetch the men out and let them stand there two or three minutes while I got it done.

If it was full of gas you would report it? — Yes, sir.

But if there was a bit showing, which you could clear off by putting up a bit of brattice you would not report it? — No, sir.

Mr. Pope quoted general Rule 4 requiring gas to be reported and asked witness if his practice was not contrary to the rule? — Witness said he did not report gas in those cases because there was no danger. His rule was that the men should work without any cap showing on the flame of their lamps.

If it showed a cap you would withdraw your men? — Yes.

Did you ever withdraw any men during your 13 years as an overman? — Oh, yes.

When you have withdrawn them have you made any entry of it? — I made an entry in the report book that I had stopped that place.

When I find in the report book 23rd November, 1909, "G. Magee's place stopped for gas in No. 5 north," that does not tell us whether it was stopped for gas during examination before the men went to work or whether it was stopped some time during the shift? — No, sir.

Don't you understand by Rule 4 that it was your duty to record gas if you found it, even if you had cleared if off and it was a small show? — Well, I have overlooked the rule to book a small item like that.

During the whole of last year I can only find three reports of gas from you, and I take it from your experience in the pit that you are probably one of the most experienced men on the ground there.

Mr. Rigby Swift said they were not bound to say that men were withdrawn. When they said that the place was stopped for gas, there was a report as to the condition of the mine.

Mr. Pope (to witness): Did not you understand from the rule that if you found it necessary to withdraw men from the place you should make a report of it in the book? — What gas there was in those cases, I consider it was not dangerous.

Then why withdraw the men? — Because I did not want them to have it said that there was gas there, I withdrew the men for a few minutes to put the brattice up.

The Coroner: You did not want it to be said that there was gas there. Why?

Witness: Because I did not want the men to go to work amongst it, if I could clear it away. I reckon it would not be dangerous with a quarter of an inch cap. The report book was kept in the office at the surface. When making an inspection I made it before the men went in.

You never made any more elaborate report? — No.

And were never asked to make a fuller report? — No.

During 1909, I find you reported gas three times. That would not represent by any means the only times you found gas? — No. I might have found gas at the end of a district but I would not enter it. If I went into a place and found an inch of cap I would stop that place and enter that.

Have you ever seen colliers batting or wafting out gas themselves from their places? — Never.

Do you consider that a bad practice or not? — Most decidedly.

Did you ever have any complaints made to you by any of the men that their places were troubled with gas? — No, sir.

Do you think a collier would send to the overman if he found gas troubling him? — Well, I would think he would.

He would not try to bat it out with his coat? — Not that I am aware of.

It would be a very improper proceeding, would not it? — Yes, I would think so.

Of course they want to get as much coal as they can? — Just so.

And every stop is loss of time? — Yes.

Do you think they are inclined to continue working after they are stopped? — I have never seen that.

What is you idea of when a place is fir for working? — When it shows no cap on the lamp.

Witness went on to say that if a man were to prick a blower he would smell it and he would get down from that place and send for the joiners and overmen if he was in that district.

Then was he permitted to go on working there? — No.

Questioning the witness as to the ventilation, Mr. Pope elicited from him that No. 5 got its only ventilation from No. 6 so that the air going up No. 6 level had to ventilate the goaf and No. 5 as well.

Mr. Pope: So that it has a fair amount of work to do? — Yes.

What is your idea of where the explosion took place? — I think that the explosion originated at the far end of No. 2 brake.

Is that getting near the dilly? — Yes.

Where is the dilly? — Witness pointed on the plan.

A little higher up I see. And what are your reasons for that? — Because it shows most force in No. 2 brake.

And, what started it? — I could not tell you that.

What was the condition of No. 2 brake when you were last in it? — First-rate. I tested it for gas at five o'clock the same night, and there was nothing to indicate that anything was wrong.

Questioned about the blasting in the cross-cut drift. Witness said there was no record kept of the number of detonators taken down the pit and the number of them that were used.

So that if you lost one you would not miss it? — I could not lose one. It could not get out of the case I put them in a box, and I have the key of the box.

We know that No. 3 north was moderately dusty. Had you anything to do with the cleaning of the dust? — Well, any time I was doing a thing like that was on a Sunday night.

What did you do; take it off the floor? — Yes.

Take it off with the spade? — Have men clearing the road; instead of throwing it aside, filling it in tubs.

How often did you do that? — Well, maybe one Sunday out of six.

Every six weeks? — Yes.

Was there any watering done on the brakes? — Not up the brakes. But I had watered the road in and out only once in three weeks. It was very dusty. It was done with a water barrel with holes in it.

Cross-examined by Mr. Richards: He came up the pit on the night of the accident at eight o'clock, and talked a few things over with Mr. Henry. He then went to the cinematograph entertainment in the Market Hall — the first time he had ever done such a thing. He was sent for there. If it was ten o'clock when he got back to the pit, that would be two hours and twenty minutes after whatever had taken place there. When he got to the fan site they could not commenced to brattice. They had decided before he got down to carry the brattice down the main in-take. He did not agree with that. He wanted to stop the main intake and let the air go down the back south dip, without the use of brattice; and if the stoppings at the friction-gear were blown out, as they were, the air would go upon the fire. The fire would thus have assisted his ventilation. He made that suggestion to Mr. Henry, but Mr. Blair and Mr. Steele were not there at the time.

When you saw what they were doing, I think you used some very strong language? — I called it laiking at a Punch and Judy Show. (Laughter.) I was as sure as where I am standing that it would never succeed. They proceeded until they were stopped by the heat.

What assisted you in becoming so convinced of the practicability of your plan? Did you find that the air was already passing down the south dip? — I saw when they were putting up the brattice that we were not getting the full force of the air that we should have done, and I went round the back side to see if there was any air going that way, and I found we were losing fresh air there; I found half of the air already going down the way I wanted it to go.

Wasn't that a natural thing for them to do, to go down to the fire? — Yes.

At the time Mr. Atkinson ordered everyone out, witness said he believed that the men in No. 5 and No. 6 were still alive. He believed that the danger to the explorers and to those attempting to get in was very great. After what was discovered on the re-opening of the pit he altered his opinion and thought the men in No. 6 could not have been alive then. There was brattice with which the men in No. 5 district might have walled themselves in if they had thought of doing it, but he thought they could not have done better than they did do. He said that "6.30 and 7.30" on the chalked messages were the following morning, and that "4 o'clock" was the following afternoon. The reason why he thought that was that the ventilation on No. 5 level had became bad, and the men could not come out beyond the door; and they would not go out hours after four o'clock in the morning to leave the 7.30 message outside.

Witness said he did not consider a cracked lamp dangerous; but the men knew that if a lamp glass was cracked they had to put the lamp out.

Do you think a lamp with simply a glass cracked would cause an explosion in an explosive mixture? — No. I don't think it would.

Then if Mr. Redmayne, as I read the other day somewhere, says that a crack in the glass of a safety lamp that would not even admit water would be dangerous, you would not suggest that was not correct? — I would not argue that.

Witness continued: He told Mr. Pope that when working virgin coal they got more gas than when working robbery. No. 6 district was where they were working the solid. He might have made a report on gas in that district this year; he did not know.

There is no report by either yourself or the other two overmen of gas having been discovered there during the whole of 1910? — No, it is all kept well bratticed up, is that district.

This district was stopped in 1909 for some period? — Yes, sir.

Do you know how many times gas was reported in 1909 in No. 6 district? No. — I could not say.

Do you know the cause of the stopping of the district? — Yes, sir; it was the making of too much gas, owing to the number of workings in it.

In reply to Mr. Richards, witness said that if the deputies went down and found gas the workmen were stopped. He could speak as to cases marked by himself, and he did not accept responsibility for any deputy who was not on his shift. After some discussions, Mr. Richards said: I must press for an answer.

Mr. Coroner: Do you say — do you not know — that your deputies whenever they discover gas in a workman's place withdraw him from that place. Do you or not, from your own knowledge? — Witness: No, I do not.

Mr. Richards referred witness to a specific occasion and date and asked him if he remembered a man being withdrawn from his working in that occasion? — Witness said coal had fallen out by the side of the man's working, and brought the air pipe down, and gas was in the place and work was stopped until the air pipe had been rectified. In reply to further questions witness said it would be on very few occasions he had time for a minute examination of the whole of No. 3 district or any of them, it was very nearly impossible for them to go round the whole three districts. He had to depend upon the deputies. He could hardly detect gas in No. 5. It joined the road where the fresh air came into No. 5 and it so diluted it you could not detect it.

Would not you report half an inch of gas in the main intake return? — No, I do not make a report of half an inch of cap in the return.

When you found a cap at all in the working places did you withdraw the workmen? — Yes, if I found gas.

How would you discover gas? — By trying it with my lamp.

So you consider that when a cap is shown in a safety lamp that does indicate the presence of gas it is unsafe? — Well the gas is there but with a small dilution it does not say it is dangerous.

How would you decide as to what quantity there was? — Why with the cap, it would show.

Well what cap would you think sufficient on you safety lamp to justify your withdrawing workmen because it is dangerous? — If I detected gas in the working I say I would remove the men and put air in.

So you say any cap. If you found any cap? — Yes.

And you would not withdraw the workmen unless you thought it dangerous for them? — I do no want to go into a working and have men know I left them amongst gas. You mean to say that, I say that gas is dangerous — any quantity. Well, half an inch of top is not dangerous.

Would you like the workmen to continue working? — Not at all, no, no.

How much cap would you see on your lamp and think it not dangerous enough to withdraw? — I say if I saw a quarter of an inch of cap on my lamp in that working I would keep the men out till the joiner put in the air.

Mr. Richards asked if No.3 level was a dusty one and witness said it was. It made it uncomfortable for the men and if an explosion occurred it extended it.

Mr. Richards, referring to various rules setting out the duties of deputies, asked if witness did not think there were enough duties set out there for the deputies to perform without having anything else to do but looking after the safety of the men and witness said he did.

In reply to Mr. Smith witness gave a negative answer to the question whether he had any suspicion that from time to time gas had not been systematically reported. Supposing it had been possible for Ritson to get into Reeds place and withdraw him he thought the brake lad would also have been withdrawn.

In reply to Mr. Sharp, witness said the men generally worked with their lamps further away than two feet. They would hang them on a prop or place them on a piece of coal.

In reply to Mr. Hanlon, witness said if there had been gas in Reed's place it would have got to Mathers first, before it got to Reed.

In reply to Mr. Rigby Swift, witness said he did not know the boy who was on the brake in Reed's place, but if it was going to be of any advantage he could get to know. Supposing Reed had been removed for gas naturally the other men in the working would have been removed. As they had not been it followed he thought that Reed was not removed on account of gas.

And do you not think that the more likely cause was that there was something wrong with the roof in the goaf? — Yes.

You put it this way — first of all you say you do not think he was moved at all, but if he was moved it was on account of the roof in the goaf? — Yes.

In reply to further questions witness said he could not definitely say what height of cap would be dangerous, it would only be guesswork. He knew that half an inch cap was just about four per cent of gas. That was very much below the explosive point.

But if you found half an inch cap would you let men work there? — Not at all.

At the request of Mr. Rigby Swift, witness indicated on the plan the place where he had seen half an inch cap at the end of the return. It was he said, a good while since, before No. 6 was closed. There were no men working there to be removed and he did nothing at all, it was in the air-way, and along in the return air-way. No one was in danger from it. The return air-way was the likeliest spot to find gas. As to the occasion as to which he had been asked about the withdrawal of the men it was only about twenty minutes of work to make the place right, and they came out whilst it was being done. Witness had worked in all the three Whitehaven pits and also for a short time in a pit at Lowca. He had been employed in all capacities from boy to deputy. He had been in every part of the mine and knew it thoroughly.

Now just tell us, is the mine properly managed? — Yes as far as practical knowledge leads me to think.

Are the interests of the men in the pit properly looked after? — Yes, sir.

And do you think, with your experience of mining, that proper precautions are taken for their safety? — Yes, sir.

Now, I just want to ask you a few questions about the night of the fire, and you theory. First of all you tell us that at four o'clock — I am not quite sure, when Mr. Atkinson came you know — you said that all that time when you were withdrawn you thought the men in No. 5 and No. 6 were alive, but you had changed your mind about it since — can you tell me at what time of day it was you thought the men were alive? — That was on the 12th.

At what time? — About four o'clock, between four and five o'clock in the afternoon.

Do you know that the stopping was not completed, that the communication was not entirely cut off until four o'clock next morning, Friday. Was it not, continued Mr. Swift, some hours before the brick stopping was sealed? — Yes.

In further reply to questions, witness said there was no regular time to eat bait. They eat it when it was convenient to them, and they would most likely eat it all and drink their water. Witness would eat all that he had. (Laughter). When they got into No. 6 level they found the men there with their bait and the men in No. 5 without it. From that he drew the conclusion that the men in No. 5 lived longer than the men in No. 6.

Mr. Swift, in further questions pointed out that according to the evidence they had had the men in No. 5 had eaten their bait between half past eight and half past nine. Suppose these gentlemen are satisfied that they had eaten their bait before Weir and Kenmore left them you cannot any longer draw any distinction between the two lots of men. The important point is to try and find out if you can you know whether there is any reason for saying the No. 6 men died before the No. 5 men? — Witness explained with the plan, said his belief was that the deadly fumes from the fire went into No. 6 first and it was only when that was full that they climbed into No. 5. In reply to further questions, witness said he agreed that there were marks of fire all round the place of the friction gear.

Mr. Swift having observed that Professor Galloway only marked two places, Mr. Richards said that those were the places the fire was supposed to be confined to when Mr. Graham made his suggestion to try to get in by the south side.

Mr. Swift: Could anyone in the world, Mr. Graham, possibly tell where the fire was at the time when you first made your suggestion? — No.

All that we can tell now is that after we were able to get down the fire had been all round this spot? — Yes. Witness pointed out on the plan the locality of the fire at this place. Although he did not argue with the plan that was being carried out when he got down he agreed that the manager's believed it to be the best.

Do you agree with me that in trying to carry out what they believed to be the best plan Mr. Henry, and Mr. Steele, and Mr. Blair worked as hard as any men could work? — They did.

Do you agree they showed all the bravery any men could show? — Yes.

And were their lives in peril as much as anybody's? — Yes.

Witness, continuing, gave an account of his proposal much as in his evidence in chief and described it in detail on the plan in answer to various questions.

When you came back at twelve o'clock on Thursday, you told somebody to-day, you thought it looked like a Punch and Judy show? — Yes.

You did not at the time say to anyone else that it looked like a Punch and Judy show? — No.

You kept that to yourself? — I knew that whatever I said it would have no effect.

An outburst of applause at the back of the room followed this answer, and the Coroner sternly rebuked the disturbance, stating that he had said that he would not permit these expressions of feeling from any quarter, and if the disturbance was repeated that part of the room whence it came would be cleared.

Mr. Swift: You say you knew if you said anything it would have been of no effect? — I had that belief. When Mr. Henry ignored me then I thought it was no use mentioning it again.

Do you know Mr. Steele? — I think I should know him.

Do you sometimes have to speak to him in the course of your work? — Many a time.

Asked why he did not mention his plan to Mr. Steele, witness said he did not think it was advisable to do that unless Mr. Henry was present.

Do you mean to tell us you thought so highly of this scheme of yours, you thought it was right and would be effective, and yet you stood on etiquette and did not mean to go behind Mr. Henry's back to Mr. Steele? — Yes.

And do you mean to say you let the scheme lie, which you confidently believed would be successful, you let it lie, because you did not want to hurt Mr. Henry's feelings? — Yes.

Asked if he could not have gone to Mr. Hanlon with it, witness said they would not let Mr. Hanlon take authority down the mine, to do anything he thought right. He had afterwards mentioned it to Mr. Moore and he said it would be considered. Witness did not go into the south dip and he did not know that anyone else had been three times into it to see if he could get through. He could see a good way into it. The success of his scheme depended upon getting past the fire and putting a step on the other side. The main road and the south dip were about on the same level and were about the same width. He was going to the same place as the others, but he meant to go on one side of the fire and they on the other. He would be, maybe, twenty yards from the fire when he put in two stops at the friction gear which he proposed. At the stand pipe where the other party had to stop they were 350 yards away, and he would not say that brattice cloth could have been put up with the fire 20 yards away. He had been to the friction gear and he knew that the fire had been so hot that it had melted the heavy iron wheel and the steel rope into a mass soldering them together.

Do you think you could get past within 20 yards of a fire like that? — It was not like that at that time.

The fire where Weir and Kenmore could walk past at ten minutes past ten was of such a character they could not go back again two or three minutes after? — Yes. Witness, added if the fire had been too hot he would have put the stopping further back, and it was necessary to go that way, and he pointed out on the plan where he thought he could have got through.

Witness continued to reply to Mr. Rigby Swift: No one ever made a suggestion of the south back dip to me. Henry is a man of experience, and he stuck at nothing. Steele knows something about mining. Hanlon, the miners agent, I don't suppose would know about the south back dip. I don't suppose Mr. Steele would know.

Would Henry know? — Oh, yes, because it was made in his time.

Henry would know the possibilities of it? — Yes.

And he was quite as keen to get down to the men as you were? — Every bit.

Do you think if your scheme had appealed for a moment to Mr. Henry to be practicable that he would not have tried to work it? — No.

Or to Mr. Steele and Mr. Blair? — I never told them; and as to Henry he did not think it was practicable.

And as the remains of the fire show now it was an impracticable scheme very soon after you arrived, if it was not then? — Excuse me. Do you think the other was a practicable scheme? (Laughter).

I don't say the other was a practicable scheme.

We say nothing could have been done at that stage, when Henry met Wear and Kenmore? — Well I say it could have been done.

But until it was all over until these men who fought and failed came up, nobody knew anything about your scheme except Mr. Henry? — Well up to that time.

JAMES DUNLOP, the next witness said he was a master wasteman employed at Wellington Pit. He had been employed there for over 22 years, and for five of those years had been a master wasteman. He measured the air in the pit once a month with an anemometer. The anemometer was periodically adjusted. They used it at the bottom of the shaft. At the down cast they got about 59,000; at the Infidel Drift, 39,009.

Mr. Redmayne (who was examining this witness): Then there was a very considerable leakage? — Yes.

You did not estimate any other point? — No, just for leakage.

Where else did you measure? — I also measured where the stop was put in, and found 29,000; but the witness said that 1,300 went up by another district. The next measurement was down in the main dip, and he got about 15,000. He measured No. 3 high north at the first crossing and got 13,000 in that split. He measured nowhere else; in the dip was the last. At the bottom of the up-cast he got about 80,000.

How is it that you got 80,000 going out? — It was coming from old air-courses, those of old Duke Pit, and the witness mentioned some others.

The inquiry at this stage was adjourned for the day.

Saturday's Proceedings.

The Court resumed at half past ten on Saturday morning. There was a continued attendance of widows and other relatives of the deceased men.

Mr. Richards applied through the Court that the Colliery management might send some reliable person to take air measurements at the air-crossing at the entrance to No. 3 level; and also a measurement of the air passing in No. 3 up at the goaf. They would accept the officials — some one who could measure it properly. They desired that a correct record sheet should be handed in on Monday. They were prepared to leave it entirely to the Colliery management. He desired to say that he was making the request at this stage to the Court, not because he thought the Colliery Company would not immediately do it, and not that he was casting the least reflection on the officials; for he was glad to bear testimony to their readiness to give Mr. Smith and himself every facility and every particle of information they asked for since the opening of the inquiry. But, they felt that the matter was now in the hands of the Court, and therefore that this application should be made through the Court.

The Coroner said he also could bear testimony to the readiness of the Colliery officials to supply himself and everybody connected with the inquiry with all the information in their power.

Mr. Rigby Swift: Might I say how gratifying it is to us to find that we have been able to give yourself, Mr. Richards and the Government Inspectors all the information you have asked for up to the present. I will at once see that what is required is done; and I would suggest that measurements may be taken this afternoon by Mr. Blair. But if they would rather it was someone else, I will put at their disposal any one they may name.

Mr. Richards: We readily accept Mr. Blair.

Mr. Rigby Swift: Then Mr. Blair will get the information.

The Coroner: That is quite satisfactory.

JOHN DUNLOP, the master wasteman, was again called, who was under examination when the Court adjourned.

Mr. Richards said the suggestion that the air should be measured did not arise from anything Dunlop had said or anything else that had occurred at the inquiry and cast no reflection upon any one or upon anything that had taken place.

Mr. Rigby Swift said he had no knowledge of what the result of the test might be. The air today might be some indication of what it was on the 11th May, or it might not. He was willing to give the information, but it would be understood that he did not so, without admitting that it affected the question of the condition of the ventilation on the 11th May.

Mr. Herbert Smith, before proceeding to cross-examine the witness Dunlop, said he would like to draw the Coroner's attention to a paragraph in the "North-Western Daily Mail" of the previous evening, and to say that he was rather sorry it had appeared. Mr. Smith read the matter alluded to : —

"To-day will probably see the close of the inquest into the disastrous explosion of the Wellington Pit, Whitehaven, in May last, and it must be a consolation to those who are relatives of the victims to know that all the evidence points conclusively to the fact that when the pit was sealed not a single workman could then possibly be alive. It is quite evident that there were two explosions, and that by the first several of the safety lamps would be broken, and that a fall of stone liberated gas which came in contact with the broken lamps and caused the second."

Mr. Smith said he was sorry these newspaper people should take it upon themselves to make these observations, because he submitted that all the facts had not yet been brought out, and there had been no decision as to what was the cause of the explosion.

The Coroner: I quite agree. I will communicate with the Editor and ask him to give a written explanation or to have a representative here on Tuesday morning.

Mr. Smith then proceeded to cross-examine Dunlop. He said he did not go into the goaf to make any measurements.

Questioned by Mr. Hanlon, witness said he was aware that the South Back Dip was open.

I don't think many men would know it was open, did they? — Oh yes, I would think so.

Well, I did not know it was open till I went through it. The last measurement you took at Benk's Brow you took in the main dip, below No. 4 section? — Yes.

You did not take any sectional measurement in No. 3 north? — No, not with these men.

So that you would not know what was going into No. 3? You could not actually say that 12,600 was going into the high right-hand? — Only by taking the difference.

You assumed that was not going down the dip must be going into the high right-hand? — Yes.

But there might be a great amount of leakage between No. 3 and No. 4? — No, we never lost past about 700 or 800 feet.

Something would be lost? — Yes, something would be lost.

Would 250 be a fair allowance per man? — Witness said he thought it would.

JAMES LAIDLOW, the next witness, said he had come there upon a subpoena. He was at present living at Station Road, Stanley, near Derby, and was a shiftsman. He used to live at 114, Queen Street, Whitehaven. He left Whitehaven on the 5th July last. Before he left he was working at Wellington Pit as assistant deputy. He was there from December 15th, 1909. He was down the pit on the back shift on the 11th May, and came up at about half-past seven or twenty minutes to eight. He was in No. 3 district, high right-hand.

Did you make any inspection there during the time you were down? — Yes, in company with John Wilson, the deputy.

Were you at any time in Reed's working place? — I don't know Reed's working place.

(The place was pointed out to witness on the plan on the wall of the Court).

Can you follow it? — Yes.

Did you examine that working place with Wilson? — Yes.

Do you know what time it was you were there? — No.

What was your report? — That is left to the deputy. I did not make any report.

Can you say what was the condition of the working place when you were there with Wilson? — As it usually was.

What was the usual condition of the place? — The usual condition?

Yes, was it all right or not? — It was all right.

Do you know if there was any kind of gas about the place? — No.

Did you see any mark made by Wilson before he left to notify that the place was all right — mark by chalk? — No, I did not.

Is that a usual thing to be done? — Yes, when there are no men in the working.

Were there any men working there at the time when Wilson accompanied by you made the inspection? — Yes.

Do you know what they were? — No, I had forgotten.

Do you know how many there were? — There would be three.

By Mr. Richards: Witness never worked as a hewer. He never attended any classes on mining or had any instructions in regard to mining.

What were you employed as before going into the mine? — I served my time as a fitter and turner.

Who appointed you as assistant deputy? — Mr. Henry, the under manager.

Witness said he did not remember Wilson, the deputy, setting props in Reed's place. He could not say whether the usual men were working in Reed's place for three shifts before the accident.

Now can you tell me this — and I want you to be very careful, in your own interests. Did you have any talk with any or all of those men when you were passing workmen on your way out; did you have any conversation? — I don't remember.

William Nixon, Henry Steel, Hugh Walsh, Wm. Crooks (Kells), and Kirkpatrick. It seems five men say you did pass them and did talk with them would you be able to deny it? — I do not remember.

First of all, did you see that they had finished clearing the top coal, when you were going past them on your way out? — I don't remember them, filling the top coal.

It is said by three workmen that just as they were in act of finishing, "Are you going in to finish your shift?" meaning into their working place; and one of them looked at his watch and said that it was about ten minutes to six and they thought it would be hardly worth while, as they would be knocking of soon after? — I cannot remember saying that.

Can you remember them saying anything? — No; I don't remember having a conversation with them at all.

If three workmen say that you said to them, "If you are going in you must be careful, as there is a bit of dirt there," do you remember telling them that? — No.

Is the term "dirt" used to indicate gas? — I have never heard it used before.

Cross-examined: Every deputy had an assistant, I stayed with Wilson for the greater part of the time I was below. He always left me for a couple of hours or so before the shift ended. I understand he was having a final look round the workings; and during those two hours witness was left to see that nobody was "slighting" the coal. On the night of the 11th May Wilson left him in the usual way.

Mr. Redmayne: Supposing the deputy was off work, did the assistant deputy ever make an inspection? — I could not tell you that; I was never left in charge.

Mr. Rigby Swift: I will find that out for you.

On the suggestion of Mr. Richards, it was agreed that the five men referred to as having been spoken to by Laidlow, should be called at once.

HENRY STEELE said he lived at 145, Queen Street, Whitehaven, and was a coalminer, and had worked at Wellington Pit for three or four years. He was working there in May last. He was working up the dilly on the left-hand side of No. 3 level,

By Mr. Redmayne: It was clear enough of gas last time we were in it. Last time we had gas, as nearly as I can say, would be three or four weeks before. There was somebody working in it at that time. First when we went we were troubled with gas.

When did the gas come off during the shift? — When we first went in; but we were bothered with it more or less.

Were you allowed to go into the place with gas in it? — Oh yes. You are allowed to go into a spot where gas is. More or less.

How often? — I could not say how many times, but a few times.

Did you complain to the deputy? Well we said there was a bit of dirt in.

Where was the gas? — On the forehead.

How far from the coal face? — Perhaps two or three yards; sometimes not that much.

Did it fill your lamps? — Well, it might put your lamp out, if you did not put it two or three yards back.

Was it clear there? — Yes.

Would your lamp become very hot, three or four yards back? — Yes; lamps are hot at ordinary times.

And you still went on working under those conditions? — Oh, yes.

Did you complain to the manager? — Well, it was nothing unusual to work among a bit of gas.

Have you ever been withdrawn from you place because of gas? — About 18 months previous we were withdrawn.

Where were you working then? — In No. 6 north.

And the gas came off while you were at work? — It was there when we went in.

And you were withdrawn? — Yes, from this spot.

Tell me exactly what happened? — I complained to Mr. Henry about it, and he said, "Yes, there's a bit of gas in here, and I will get you another spot," and he did.

When did you go back to that place again? — Oh we did not go back to that spot any more.

Mr. Henry withdrew you? — Yes.

Have you ever complained to anybody other than the management about gas? — Yes; to the joiners when they would come round.

You regarded it as a common practice, did you? — Yes.

Cross-examined by Mr. Pope: I occasionally tested for gas myself while working. I have some times looked round and found gas in my lamp with a big light on.

You have? — Yes.

How often had that happened? — Oh, a few times.

What have you done then? — Moved the lamp back.

How far has the lamp been from the forehead when that has happened? — Four or five yards or perhaps ten nearly.

What had you been doing to bring the gas upon your lamp? — Just working away.

Where did that happen? — No. 6 north.

By Mr. Richards: Laidlow stopped to talk with them about twenty or ten minutes to six, and asked them if they were going back to finish their shift, telling them that if they were they were to be careful as there was a bit of dirt in there.

By Mr. Rigby Swift: I suppose you know gas is dangerous? — I dare say it is.

You know it is, don't you? — Yes.

And that the danger consists in the quantity present in the air? — I don't know, I am a miner not an analyst.

No, you are a miner, and therefore I expect you to know when gas is dangerous. When you got gas in your working place in a quantity that is dangerous do you continue working? — Well, my "marras" might not come out.

Do you mean to say that your marrow would go on working? — He might not.

Gas is making all the time, and the overman cannot be everywhere at the same time. Supposing the deputy had been round to you and afterwards you and your marrow found gas that was dangerous, would not you come out? — We would try and work the shift out, if we could. It depends on how far the shift is advanced. We might come out or we might not.

You mean you take the risk in order to get the coal? — Well, there's a good bit in that.

You do not suggest anybody is to blame for that but yourself? — No.

By Mr. Chapman: I know we were infringing the rules in not coming out when there was gas, I agree it is wrong not to report it.

The Coroner called witness attention to the rule, "No person shall do anything to endanger his own or another person's life."

Have you any preference for electric light? — I have heard workmen say you cannot test for gas with electric lamps; and if that is so I think the old lamp is better.

WILLIAM SKELLY, 23, Senhouse Street, Whitehaven, said he had worked at Wellington Pit for 15 years. On the 11th May he was working there on the back shift, and he saw Laidlow and heard what the last witness had said Laidlow said.

WILLIAM CROOK, Kells, said he had been a hewer for 25 years. He was with the last two witnesses on the night of the 11th May when the conversation with Laidlow occurred, and he corroborated them.

Mr. Richards called attention to questions that were put to the witnesses as to whether they had been talking together of what had taken place. He did not know what was meant to be inferred from that, if he had asked Mr. Blair if he and Mr. Steele and Mr. Turner had been talking together he was sure he would have had to reply that they had. It was natural that they should talk about what had happened.

Mr. Rigby Swift: Yes perfectly natural. The unnatural thing is when they come here and say they had not been talking about it. (Laughter.)

GILBERT KIRKPATRICK, trailer, Wellington Pit, examined by Mr. Richards, said that when he saw the place where the explosion occurred, after the explorations, he thought on the conversation with Laidlow. When he saw the dilly he judged that the explosion had occurred there.

Questioned by Mr. Rigby Swift as to how he happened to go to the see Mr. Richards to tell him about his conversation, witness said that the miners had a meeting, at which it was asked if there was anyone present who knew of any gas in No. 3 north level. There were some there who knew about gas, and they would not speak about it. Nobody spoke. But there were two of them willing to speak. One of them had two brothers in the pit. Matthew Armstrong was one and witness was the other. They informed Mr. Hanlon. He was afterwards told to go and see Mr. Richards, and he gave Mr. Richards the names of the men who were there when Laidlow spoke to them.

WILLIAM NIXON, 26, Plumblands Lane, Whitehaven, said he had been a coalminer for ten or twelve years. He corroborated the last three witnesses' statements as to the conversation with Laidlow. It was 14 months before the accident since they had had trouble with gas.

By Mr. Richards: I was working in the narrow fourth brake on July, 1909, and was withdrawn from my working place because of gas. John Wilson withdrew me.

By Mr. Rigby Swift: I had never told anybody about this conversation with Laidlow.

The Court rose at a quarter to two and adjourned until Monday.

Mondays Proceedings.

The Court resumed at half past ten.

Mr. Rigby Swift (to the Coroner): You remember on Saturday Mr. Richards asked me to have air measurements made at two points I have had it done, and I will give Mr. Richards one copy and will pass you another. At a convenient time I will call Mr. Blair who took these figures.

The Coroner: Thank you.

JOHN WILSON, deposed: I live at 40, Newtown, Whitehaven, and am in the employ of the Whitehaven Colliery Company as deputy at Wellington Pit. I have been working at Whitehaven Colliery 45 years altogether, and I have been a deputy for the last 18 or 20 years. On the 11th May I went down the pit at eleven o'clock in the morning and went to No. 3 north district. I remained there till half past seven, inspecting and setting up prop wood. At the time he left all was right as far as he could see. I think I would come up in the second cage. I could not exactly say who came up with me. It was shortly after nine o'clock before I heard there was anything wrong. I was then at home. My son gave me the message. As soon as I received word I made myself ready and went back again. I got back to the pit about a quarter past ten as nearly as I can say. I went down with my son Matthew.

By Mr. Redmayne: How were the men engaged working in the dilly? — They were engaged filling in a fall of top coal into their tubs. They had been doing that the whole of their shift. I told the incoming shift that if there was any top coal left they could go on filling it but supposing there was none they had to go up to their own working. The top coal had fallen about four o'clock the day before. The men had been out of their working place since then. There was nothing wrong in the working place.

Then seeing it was unoccupied was there a fence up? — No, there was no occasion.

You regarded the place as working? — Yes, they were filling this top coal out-by, but the place was all right.

How long is it since there has been any gas there? — I have not seen any gas since it started.

When you found gas in a working place what would you do? — I would withdraw the men.

What else? — I would fence it off, if I could not clear it.

Then what do you do when the place is clear of gas? — Of course I would let the men go in next shift.

Would you report the withdrawing of the men? — I would fetch the men out and put them in another place.

Do you tell the manager you have done this? — I would put that in the report.

You report it in the report book? — Yes.

Would you report it when it was clear? — If might be clear on some other shift, and they would report it.

But you always reported gas when you found it? — Yes.

Suppose you found gas first thing in the morning and the men were not in the place at all, did you report it? — Yes, sir.

How long is it since you withdrew anybody? — I don't know but I think some time in March this year that I reported gas.

You heard those statements with respect to men working in gas. Do you know of any case in which men worked in gas? — Not that I am aware of.

Would you be astonished to hear that men worked in gas? — Oh, I don't know; that all depends on what people say. As far as I was concerned, if I found gas in a man's place, I set him back until it was made all right.

But from your knowledge of the mines was it so gassy as all that? — No, it was not.

By Mr. Atkinson: It might be about two o'clock when I got to the face. I was in Reed's place. I put some props in there. They were working there then I was in Mather's place, and they were working there, too.

You had been in since the explosion? — Yes.

Do you think the Reeds were working their ordinary place or some other place? — I could not say that.

Why not? — Because I sent them to their ordinary place. I don't know for what reason they had been brought out.

Do you think they had been brought out? — It is quite possible.

You know where they were found? — Yes.

Isn't it probable that they were brought out or their own working place? — Well, it appears that they had been brought out.

Can you suggest any reason why they should be brought out? — Well, I don't know unless the roof in the goaf had started to work.

But they would have been quite safe where they were, wouldn't they? — When a big working of that kind commences the men fall back because they don't know where it might stop. They will come back for their own safety.

And when the roof begins to work like that don't you expect to get gas off? — Yes.

And they would be at the highest point, where the gas would be likely to come first? — Yes.

Would they be any safer where they were found, as regards the gas? — Well, they were forty yards lower down than in their own level.

Would the gas from the goaf come over then? — Yes.

They were only a little further away? — I would have moved everybody to the out-by side if I had been there.

Have you been in the place since and seen Mathers's place? Yes.

Can you tell us whether there has been much of a fall since you were in on the 11th May? — There has been a very large fall.

Now if anybody was up the dilly for a whole shift the place was really not working. Do you know that by special rule 53, an inspection is necessary before the work is resumed? Did you make it? — Yes.

Did you make a written report? — No.

What time did you make the inspection? — About four o'clock. But I did not make the official inspection.

Who made the official inspection? — Tom Graham.

Did he make a report, do you know? — He likely would make a report in the book.

But do you understand that it is your place as deputy, if a place is off for a whole shifts, to examine the place before the next shift and make a written report? — Yes.

By Mr. Pope: From January, 1909, to 30th March, 1910, witness said he had only made three entries in the report book. Those were records of inspections during the shift. The official investigation under Rule 4 was the inspection made by the deputy who would inspect two hours before the first shift, in the early morning. Witness's inspection was during the process of the shift, and it was optional whether he made a report on it or not.

By Mr. Herbert Smith: The working of the roof and the consequent gas would affect Mather's place as much as it would Reed's place; it would be equally dangerous. It might be as dangerous to the men at No. 1 brake wheel. If it was necessary to withdraw Reed and Mathers, it was necessary to withdraw the brake men. If men are put into the box to say that I did not always examine for gas it will be incorrect. He never saw men trying to beat gas out with their shirt. Asked as to whether he had withdrawn in July, 1909, a number of men whose names Mr. Herbert Smith mentioned witness said he did not remember. If it was not in the report book, he did not withdraw them. They kept the brattice well up to the face when it was required. When working in robbery it was not required. Working in the solid he would say it might be 10 or 15 yards from the face. He admitted that it would be better if it was much nearer — say six feet.

By Mr. Richards: Graham sent to me about half past four to say that Reed's place wanted two props. It would be about a quarter to five that I was in. Mr. Graham would be in Reed's place at the time he sent to me. I did not see him when I got there, but I met him when going, about 200 yards away from the place. Witness had changed and fired Hastings holes many a time. It would take about half and hour to bore and fire four holes. Mr. Graham told me he was going to inspect my district, but I was not the less careful on that account. I do not accept Mr. Graham's examination; but I did not think it was necessary to go and examine the place after him.

Then it was Mr. Graham, not you, that examined the place prior to the accident? — Yes.

Did Mr. Graham have any talk to the workmen in the dilly? — I don't know.

Did you? — Yes. I sent them away.

If Mr. Graham was in Reed's place at half past four and he was out at the lock shop at a quarter to six, do you think he had sufficient time in an hour and fifteen minutes to examine the whole of the district, go to the far drift and charge and fire four holes and be out at the lock shop at quarter to six? — It seems a very short time to do so much work.

Do you think he could have made an examination of every working? You have been so long at it and you will know almost to a quarter of a minute how long it would take you to do it. Do you suggest that one hour and fifteen minutes is sufficient time? — No. I don't.

Then if Mr. Graham told the Court that he made a careful examination of this district, he cannot have done it? — Well it seems a very short time to do it.

Which would you expect to have most gas a place which had been standing or a place where workmen had been continuously working? — It has more tendency to have gas when it has been standing.

This place up the dilly had been standing since four o'clock the previous day. I made a very careful examination in the dilly.

Witness said Laidlow was with him at Reed's place and helped him to carry the props up there. He heard Laidlow say he could not remember it.

Did you believe him? — How could I believe him?

Do you think it is possible he could have forgotten the incident that he assisted you to carry these props up? — I think it is a very unlikely thing.

Do you think it was possible that if he had a conversation with these five men he could have forgotten that? — Well, I cannot say for that.

Do you remember passing those five men? — Yes. I remember perfectly well.

Did this young man go with you? — Yes.

Do you think it is possible that he should forget that these five men were out-by working out of their ordinary working place? — I would think not.

If he has told the Court that one day you took him into the goaf and showed him the gas exploding in a lamp is that correct? — To my knowledge it is not.

If he says you took him for his special edification to show him the gas? — No, I never did show him.

Laidlow appeared to have forgotten everything that day bearing on this enquiry. Do you think be ought to have forgotten? — I think he might have remembered.

By Mr. Cape: I passed all the men who were coming into the night shift into their place. That was on Mr. Graham's inspection.

Do you think that was a right system? Rule 55 says the person who has made the examination should instruct the men. Were you prepared to bear the responsibility of anything that might be written in his report? — No, he would have to do that himself.

Then in your opinion do you think this is a proper way to carry out the special rules of the Coal Mines Regulation Act? — Well, I don't know what I think about it, but it always has been done in that way.

But you think it would be better if you as deputy of that district had sole charge of the inspection of that district prior to the men going in? — Yes, I think it would be better.

The Mining Disaster

The Adjourned Inquest

By Mr. Rigby Swift: I have a pretty fair memory myself. I cannot possibly say what memory somebody else has. I cannot say whether Laidlow can remember or not.

Not about this examination of the dilly. According to Rule 53 the deputy or some other person appointed for the purpose shall within two hours before the commencement of the shift make an inspection. I understand you made an inspection of the place at four o'clock. Was there anything wrong with the dilly at four o'clock? — It was about half past four. There was nothing wrong with it then.

Did you expect somebody else coming within the two hours? — Yes, Tom Graham was there, and he said all was right.

Do you know any reason in the world why you should not pass on to the workmen what the overman told you? — No.

WILLIAM CAMPBELL, 6, Marlborough-street, Whitehaven, said he had worked as deputy at Wellington Pit for 13 or 14 years. He was working there on May 11th, from half past five in the morning till half past one.

By Mr. Atkinson: He was the deputy who preceded John Wilson. He was round both brakes in No. 3 north, and he found the district all right. All the dilly men were filling top coal that had fallen the previous evening. He was there all day putting the timber and scouring the roof. The roof was not working. He was in Mather's place; it was all right when he saw it.

By Mr. Pope: The report book is used for official examinations and also when we had to withdraw men and stop their place. When he was going round making examinations the previous shift was still working. He had found men on the previous shift working in gas.

Do they want looking after like schoolboys? — Well, if there's gas they want removing.

You don't understand me. If you found men continuing working in gas have you ever spoken seriously to them about it? — I took them out of it.

I suppose if you interfere too much with the men they don't like it? Have you ever seen the men, as one of them as stated, working with gas, burning in his lamp? — No, I never say that.

A man who would do that ought to be sent out of the pit? — He should be.

By Mr. Hanlon: He had heard of gas in No. 3 north being fired by a shot. The road was watered once or twice a week. It was watered a week before the explosion, but would have time to dry. Witness did not examine the dilly working. The men had no right to go there, because there was plenty of top coal from the fall. I only examined where I sent men to.

Mr. Hanlon: But still you know the men might go up to that place.

By Mr. Richards: It would take him about two hours to make a careful examination of his district. He had a number of other special duties.

If you had nothing to do but look after gas a man would not be able to work in gas without being found out? — Of course, he would be bound to be found out if one had nothing else to do.

If the Government are going to make any alteration in the Coal Mines Regulation Act don't you think they should confine your duties to looking after gas and the safety of the men? — It would be much better for the pitmen if they did do it.

By Mr. Rigby Swift: When I wanted men to assist me in manual labour I could get them.

Has this Colliery Company every crumped you or hampered you in doing your work? — We should have had more help.

Have you asked for it? — The management know it themselves.

Have you asked for it? — No. I have not asked for it.

You were asked if it would not be better if you had a deputy to do nothing but look after gas. I suppose it would be best if you could have a deputy for every hewer, then nobody could work in gas. (Laughter.)

GEORGE McCLELLAN, 60, Front Row, New-houses, said he was an onsetter at Wellington Pit. He had worked for the Colliery Company for 11 or 12 years. On the 11th may last he went down at 2.30 in the afternoon, and he did not come up till three o'clock on Thursday morning, the 12th. He was at the bottom of the shaft, and about 20 minutes to eight noticed the reversal of the air for about 15 minutes and there was a kind of mist and dust coming from the in-by side of where he was standing.

By Mr. Atkinson: One of the seven or eight paraffin lamps at the bottom of the shaft was blown-out. There was not the least panic amongst the men who were leaving the pit from the previous shift.

Did you hear any conversation amongst them as to what had happened? — Yes. I heard two men pass a remark at the time.

What did they say? — They said they thought it was an explosion from what they had seen. One of them said, "We'll go into the cabin for fear it should occur again; and don't say anything about it for fear it should not be so, or else we will get into trouble."

Witness said that during the whole time the air was reversed it was carrying dust.

Do you find much coal dust goes down your shaft? — Yes, a little bit goes down, but it depends upon the direction of the wind.

THOMAS DOUGLAS, 15, Bransty Road, Whitehaven, said he had been in the Whitehaven Colliery as roadman for 20 years, and worked at Wellington Pit. On the 11th May he went down at half-past one in the afternoon and came up from half-past nine to ten. He felt the air reversed while he was travelling the road. He came upon the two men lying insensible at Benk's Turn and tried to rouse them, but he could make nothing of them. The air was thick with dust. He himself felt rather heavy and he came away. He met Mr. Henry, Daniel Benn, and a lad named Lupton. He told Mr. Henry there had been something very seriously wrong and that when he got to Benk's Turn he would find some men dead. Witness knew they were not dead when he left them but he thought they would be before they got to them, for they had three quarters of a mile to go. Mr. Henry told him to send for Mr. Steele and the doctors and get assistance.

By Mr. Redmayne: He was at Infidel Drift turn when he felt the air reverse. It did not put his lamp out.

By Mr. Atkinson: He had a portable telephone with him. Before finding the two men lying he thought what had happened was a fall of roof. He could not say that he had ever seen such a fall of roof cause a reversal of the air.

By Mr. Smith: He would have thought that the reversal of the air for 15 minutes would have affected the fan. He heard the fan man say in evidence that it never made any difference. 20 or 30 yards from Infidel Drift Turn witness telephoned for help.

THOMAS SWINBURNE, 9, Back Row, New-houses, Whitehaven, said he had worked in Whitehaven Colliery for 4¼ years and was a deputy. On the 11th of May he saw Wear and Kenmore about eleven o'clock at night. Wear might be a bit timid, but he was alright. Wear told him how he and Kenmore had escaped. He told him that before they came away the men in No. 5 broke the door open at No. 4 scuttle, but they could not make any headway in the return. Wear, who did all the talking, Kenmore never saying anything, did not say anything about there being any arrangement that they should return. Witness believed he did ask Wear what was the reason he did not fetch his lad with him, "Well," he says, "Tom, he would not come." "Well," witness said, "By heavens I would have fetched him by t'neck if it had been me."

By Mr. Richards: No. 6 was stopped from February till June last year. He had never found any gas there since, of any consequence. What would be considered of consequence? — Well, if he saw a cap on a lamp-flame, of above a quarter of an inch would not have the men there; in fact the men were always instructed themselves. He did not think half an inch would be dangerous. Three quarters? Yes, of course the higher the flame got the more dangerous it was. What would he consider dangerous? Anything above a quarter of an inch. He had found quarter of an inch cap in the intake of No. 5. He did not think that was a matter of any consequence; he did not think it was dangerous.

Mr. Smith: Now just let me ask you one question with regard to Wear. Do you think he was in a proper condition to be properly examined by you after coming out of that fire when you examined him? — I hardly think he would be.

Do not you think he would be somewhat affected by what he had gone through? — There is no doubt he would.

Mr. Hanlon: Do you remember men any time in 1906 or 1907 working with their lamps a long way from the face and turning very dim? — Not to my knowledge.

You say you have never seen it? — No, I cannot say I have seen it out of the ordinary distance from the forehead.

What is the ordinary distance? — Well, four or five feet.

FLETCHER YOUNG, deposed that he was a miner employed by the Whitehaven Colliery Co., in Wellington Pit. He was working on the 11th May last, from 11.30 in the morning to twenty minutes to eight in the evening. He went to the pit in the first cage and the second portion of it, and he felt the air reverse, afterwards hearing something was wrong he went back to the pit and descended the shaft to the exploring party already down. Mr. Henry and others went into the South Dip until the smoke was gathering on them in the main road, and then they were shouted to and came back.

In reply to Mr. Pope, witness said that the rope of the friction gear broke as he was going from the pit bottom to where he met Mr. Henry. The place witness worked in No. 5 was not a hot place and they were never had want of air.

In reply to Mr. Smith, witness said he did not hear Graham's suggestion about going in by the South Dip.

JOHN MULHOLLAND, hewer, in Wellington Pit for about 24 years, who accompanied last witness generally, corroborated his evidence.

Mr. Atkinson: I think you are one of the local inspectors? — I am.

You signed the report that had been read. When you made that inspection did you travel up the air-way? — Yes, it was all right when we were there on that day.

Could you see the smoke in the south back dip on the night of the explosion? — No, I was standing in the main intake.

In reply to Mr. Pope as to the inspection made, witness said they went round all the air courses, travelled all round the workings seeing they were clear. This was his first inspection. When they went into the place they asked the men whether they had anything to draw their attention to, and if they had made any findings they would have reported it. In reply to Mr. Smith, witness said that there were two tests made for gas on that occasion. Having made a further reply as to no complaint about the dust Mr. Smith observed that they might be timidity about making a report about dust.

Mr. Rigby Swift protested that that was a most improper remark.

Mr. Smith: It may be an improper remark but it is true nevertheless.

Mr. Rigby Swift said he must ask the Coroner to give his ruling upon that.

The Coroner: You are right and Mr. Smith is wrong.

Mr. Richards asked if it would be correct to say that both employers and workmen in this pit which had been working so long without an explosion treated gas rather lightly? — Gas was treated rather lightly because we were all used to it.

Then you yourself after this inquiry would you be likely to treat gas as lightly as you did formerly? — No.

In reply to Mr. Rigby Swift, witness said when they went round they were allowed as far as the officials were concerned to see all they wanted to see.

Now just tell me this has anybody tried to intimidate you or prevent you coming to give evidence here? — No.

JOHN THOMAS MATHERS deposed that he was a hewer in Wellington Pit and had been employed there ever since the present Company came in. He was at work in No. 3 district on the 11th May. When he went to work the place was quite good, when they used to get about half way up it used to show gas on the lamp. Half way up the pillar there was a slight show, not a quarter of an inch, just an indication. If it showed too much they would have come out, but it never showed anything but very slight and then away again. He was with the last witness on the inspection. The under manager was with them and he tested for gas twice. He tested in likely places for it and did not find it. He might find maybe a quarter of an inch in the low back end in No. 6, but nothing material. He had been inspector and delegate for Wellington Pit about two years. Owing to some business he had with Mr. Henry, it might be a quarter to two or two o'clock on the 11th, when he went into his working place. They get 39 tubs filled himself and his mates. Witness indicated the place of the working on the edge of the goaf where they were robbing pillars. He saw no gas there on that day. Some of their tubs were blown into the goaf at the point he indicated.

How do you account for Reeds being where you found them? — I could not say that. That would be more than I could say how it came that they were down there.

You would not expect to have found then there if they had been in their proper working place? — Well, they might easily have been down collecting some of their gear. They might easy have their gear down and be getting it up.

This explosion did not happen until an hour and a half after they had begun their shift. They would have plenty of time to take the gear to the place? — Witness thought an hour would be nearer the time.

You found a pick in one of the Reed's hands? — I saw the pick in his hand when we found them, that is in the father's hands.

Do you think they had been set to work there? — I could not say, would not like to say neither.

Does not it look very like as if they had been brought out of their regular place and set to work there? — It might have been the place. I cannot see why they should have been fetched down there.

Do you know where your night shift mates were? — Yes.

How do you account for the position in which you found them? — They had been running out of the road. They had heard the rumbling in the goaf.

The rumbling that means the roof fall? — I say gas rumbling perhaps.

If gas did come out whose place would it pass through first? — It would pass from the goaf right through our place. They perhaps saw it coming and ran.

Which would get it next? — Reed's place.

And if they were not there, if they were working on the high level where they were found they would be the first for the gas to meet? — It would come down on top of them.

In reply to Mr. Pope, witness said that after the inspection some men in No. 6 had said it was a bit warm there. Mr. Henry went with them on the inspection as a rule and that was the time to make a complaint when they were all there. They were not required to ask the men. They expected it to come from them.

How long had you been working there? — Five weeks and three days.

If you were getting 39 tubs a shift you were doing well? — Well if there had been any danger I would have been out.

In reply to Mr. Richards, witness said the places where the men's tokens were found were no indication of what happened. They were sometimes kept in one place and sometimes in another.

Was there an empty tub in the Reed's place? — One.

Is there any probability that having taken that one in there the whole of them might have gone to fetch a tub each before starting? Would it be at all likely? — There are men do that. It might have been the case. They generally take one apiece with them.

So that may be the reason why these men were found there? — It might be very easily.

Having indicated the place where Ritson, the deputy was found, witness said at the time of the explosion Ritson was laying flat sheets in Taggart's place.

Do you think he had enough time to go in and change Reed's from their working place to another working place before the explosion took place? — No, I don't think he would have time to do it, because he had three sheets down and he would have the timber to put down. It would take him some time perhaps half an hour or more.

Now if you were going round to-morrow to make the next examination of this colliery would you examine for gas in every working place? — Yes, I certainly would after this.

By Mr. Smith, witness said that if the fall had not taken place in the dilly they might not have seen some resemblance of what they saw on the level.

By Mr. Hanlon, witness said he saw men stretching out to go down the south dip and when they had gone some distance they were called back because the smoke was gaining in the main intake and they might have been cut off.

What do you mean to imply when you say your mates were on the run? — I mean to say they saw fire coming out of the goaf and they were on the run.

As to Ritson? — I think he saw something too, and he ran.

Mr. Rigby Swift: I suppose you have given us the benefit of all you know about it? — I have told you all I know about it.

You are not hiding anything from us? — Most certainly not.

That is what I thought — telling us all you know. Now do you agree with me whether the explosion began where the Reeds were found or whether it began in the dilly? — In the dilly I consider it did.

Well, wait a minute you have not heard the question or whether it was caused by a fall of roof in the goaf, so what in fact did happen is merely a matter of speculation, there is not positive proof or what did happen? — No, but I believe that in my opinion it came from the dilly.

Do you agree with me that it is a matter of opinion? — It is from the indications I have seen.

Do you agree other people might quite honestly form an opinion that it came another way? — Well, everyone is not of the same opinion.

I want you to make it quite plain. As many men there are so there are so many questions? — I have my own opinion.

I do not want you to alter it. Will you admit other people may have different opinions? — Likely they will have a different opinion to me.

The you will agree with me that they may be quite as honest in their opinion as you are in yours? — Yes, you would naturally expect so.

At this point the Coroner read a letter from the "North Western Daily Mail" Office, explaining how the paragraph complained of on Saturday came to be written, disclaiming any intention of unfair or premature comment and apologising to the Coroner.

Mr. Smith said he accepted that as satisfactory.

The witness's evidence being concluded the inquiry adjourned.

Tuesday's Proceedings

On the resumption of the Court on Tuesday morning.

The Coroner said that the foreman of the jury desire it to be specially known that their wish was that these proceedings should be in no way curtailed; on the contrary they were desirous that every information which could be brought before them that had any bearing upon this calamity would be brought before them and that they might be alleged to take part in the proceedings. It had also been communicated to him that some at least of the jury desired to have an inspection of the mine. Under what regulations would the various parties to the inquiry desire that the inspection should take place? He thought the strongest direction should be given that no indication should be made to them of any controversial matter. It should simply be pointed out to them "This is the friction gear" "This is the dilly," and so on.

Mr. Pope said he would prefer that some one representing the Coroner should be of the party.

The Coroner: Would Mr. Atkinson be satisfactory to all parties — the Inspector of Mines?

Mr. Chapman said naturally those of whom he acted would desire that the view should be entirely free from any suggestion of partisanship, and the Coroner's suggestion of Mr. Atkinson would be very acceptable to them. If it was desired that Mr. Steele or anyone else should act as guide they would be at the disposal of the Court.

Mr. Swift desired to say, on the first point mentioned by the Coroner, that when he threw out the suggestion that the jury might not desire to hear the whole of the evidence that would have to come before H.M. Inspectors, he in no way desired that the proceedings should be curtailed or that anything should be kept from them — that was the last thought he had, to deprive them of the right of inquiring full. He hoped anything he said would not lend itself to that view.

The Coroner said he thought Mr. Swift had made himself perfectly clear yesterday that he did not desire to curtail the proceedings or keep anything from the jury.

Mr. Swift said he was glad to hear the Coroner say so. With regard to the other point, if the Coroner would tell them the time and who wanted to go down every arrangement would be made for their personal convenience in the pit. He thought if the conduct of the party was left entirely to Mr. Atkinson he would have control of the whole matter. Of course, directly they should have representatives on one side they would have to have representatives on the other side, and he entirely agreed that it was expectantly desirable that there should be no controversy whatever.

Mr. Richards said he and his friends entirely agreed with the Coroner's suggestion. It would certainly be irregular that anybody should attempt to bring any controversial matter before them; and they agreed that Mr. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector should have charge of the jury. As it would be necessary for Mr. Steele to be there, Mr. Hanlon should accompany them.

Mr. Rigby Swift said he should like that under no circumstances whatever should there be the slightest ground for comment hereafter as to what happened in the pit when the jury were there. He did not anticipate that it would happen, but one had known it before. If they had people interested suggestions might afterwards be made that something had happened. Mr. Steele was perfectly willing to go, but he (Mr. Rigby Swift) ventured to think that it would be much better that nobody who was in any way interested should go.

Mr. Richards said he should be very sorry if it were thought for a moment that they had the slightest want of confidence in H.M. Inspectors; they had not. But Mr. Smith and he and Professor Galloway had been making explorations to try and find out how this explosion had happened. They knew that there was a difference of opinion on that question between H.M. Inspectors and themselves; and therefore, it was better that he (Mr. Richards) should not be present.

The Coroner said he would ask each of the parties to nominate a representative and let him have the name after luncheon, and then he would decide.

Inspector DOWTHWAITE said that during the time the bodies were recovered he was on duty at the top and took possession of articles found on the bodies. There were fourteen watches.

In reply to the Coroner, the various representatives said they did not attach anything to the times at which the watches had respectively stopped, and the Coroner ordered their return to the representatives of their late owners.

The Coroner addressing Inspector Dowthwaite, said the attention that he gave at the pit as regards the bodies when they were brought out, the way in which he assisted the relatives in respect to identification, and the work he did generally, they all knew. It had a serious effect upon his health, but if he had suffered in that respect there was one satisfaction to him to have heard of the good feeling and regard not only of the relatives of those who lost their lives in the disaster, but of the public generally. (Applause.) The Inspectors services were worthy of the highest commendation. (Applause.)

Mr. Richards said on behalf of his colleagues and himself he should like to join with the Coroner in his very hearty commendation of the work done by Inspector Dowthwaite at the colliery. He (the speaker) had had an unpleasant task from day to day in going down the pit, and he thought that was very gruesome indeed, but when watching the Inspector at the top of the pit, performing his duty, he really thought he should have chosen his own. He was struck by the great patience, care and trouble he took in order to get the bodies identified and the relatives soothed as much as possible, and he joined most heartily on behalf of the workmen in the Coroner's commendation of the way he performed his duties.

Mr. Rigby Swift, on behalf of the Colliery Company, and Mr. Chapman, speaking for the managers, added their tribute to the manner in which the Inspector had performed his trying duties.

Inspector Dowthwaite: I thank you all for the kind remarks. Anything I did at the pit top I considered it my duty to do. (Applause.)

MR. J. B. ATKINSON, Inspector of Mines, said he had had charge of the Newcastle District since 1902 and he and his assistants had made various inspections of Wellington Pit. The last inspection was made by Mr. Nicholson on the 17th February this year and a report was sent in by him. Witness received a communication with regard to the explosion about half-past six on the morning of the 12th May. He went to Whitehaven, arriving at the mine shortly after three in the afternoon. After descending the pit he went in-bye and got to the smoke, which was some distance below the fan house. It was very dense. He found men and officials working at it and brattice was being carried forward. Witness came to the conclusion that the situation was hopeless, and great risk was being run by the rescue parties, and he didn't feel that he could take the responsibility to allow the work to go on. Before going down the pit a plan was produced, and the situation explained. He interviewed Wear and Kenmore, and Mr. Steele and Mr. Blair, and he then practically came to the conclusion that the position was hopeless before he went down. At five or six p.m., on the 12th he came to that conclusion. The rescue apparatus men had been telegraphed for, and as they were not expected till 10.45 p.m., they decided to go with them as a final effort. When they descended with the rescue men, the latter were sent into the smoke. They were away nine minutes. They came back much exhausted, and the name-plates on their helmets were practically melted by the heat. It was then decided to put in the stopping, which was partly built when he went down the pit. Witness saw nearly all the bodies found.

By the Coroner: I think the explosion began not at Reed's working place but at the place where I think he had been working. I think it began somewhere about here (pointing out the place on the plan.)

Mr. Redmayne then read the following report which he had prepared: —

I have come to the conclusion that fire-damp was ignited by the flame of one of the safety lamps of the Reeds or J. Garroway at or near the place where the Reeds were working on the highest up trailing road to the right of No. 1 Brake, and that this developed into a considerable explosion of fire-damp and air, which, raising coal dust from the floor, at once developed into a much more considerable explosion of coal dust and air, which propagated itself in several directions, sweeping along the trailing roads near the faces, down both brakes, and the old places between and on either side of them and reaching the 3rd North haulage road, passed out-bye with great violence to the friction gear, and also passed a short distance in-bye of the foot of No. 2 brake. All the persons in the 3rd North and on the roads extending to and including the friction gear would be killed at once, excepting the four drifters who, had travelled 216 yards out after the explosion. The explosion when dying left three fires — one at the friction gear, one in an old place to the north of No. 2 brake, and last of the inner part of the 3rd North haulage road, and one just below the extremity of the trailing road on which the Reeds were working. All three fires, and there may have been others, were near where the requisite supply of coal dust for carrying on the explosion no longer existed, and where fresh air was more or less available after the explosion had died out, leaving burning dust or other material. The explosion would instantly kill all the persons near the friction gear, so far as some time necessarily elapsed before any person arrived there, that fire, fed by the strong current of fresh air, soon attained considerable proportions. We have heard from Wear and Kenmore what happened in No. 5 district, and how the lads from the 6th North junction came to that district. I think that the men in the more remote No. 6 North workings had not felt sufficient movement of the air to alarm them, and they continued working until smoke from the fire reached them, or possibly they may have become alarmed by the distribution of the air circulating owing to the short circuiting due to the air crossings and stoppings on the 3rd North haulage road being destroyed. If the 6th North men had come out directly after the explosion they would have arrived at the 5th North junction before Wear and Kenmore made their escape, and would have been seen by them. On finding smoke in the air current most of the 6th North men, led by Isaac Wren, the deputy, had come out by the haulage road, and would quickly succumb to carbonic oxide poisoning. I think all these men would have died before midnight on May 11th. Seven men from the 6th North, some or all of whom may have travelled by the airway to the 5th North, had joined the men there. We know from Wear and Kenmore that all the persons in the 5th North were alive when they left, and we have further evidence in the shape of three messages in chalk that they were alive at 7.30, which I think means 7.30 a.m., on the 12th May. How much longer they survived is problematical; from tests made as to the length of time the safety lamps will burn it is probable that some lamps would be burning for some time after 7.30 p.m., and it is a fair assumption that had they all been alive at 8.30 or 9.30 am., further messages would have been left. It is probable that all were dead by ten a.m., on the 12th. The air would be more and more vitiated as time went on, and they (the men in the 5th North) survived longer than the men from the 6th North, who came direct by the haulage road, because the air which had poisoned the 6th North men travelled a considerable distance and would become somewhat diluted before reaching the 5th North.

Returning to the point of origin of the explosion, I think that the roof stone in the goaf adjacent to the robbery working on the left side of No. 1 brake had suddenly fallen, and alarmed Johnson, Fisher, and McQuilliam, who had come out to the brake with their lamps. The effect of a fall in the goaf as regards fouling the air current with fire-damp is twofold. First, the fall displaces lying gas and forces it into the current, and second, new surfaces are exposed, from which gas may issue freely.

The Reeds were not working where they were expected to be, taking down top coal in a place above the brake wheel and adjacent to the robbery working, and they may have been removed from here by the deputy Ritson owing to their proximity to an uneasy goaf. They had evidently been working on the trailing road to the right of the brake, where two projecting masses of benk coal would provide them with work during the shift. They had removed a 18 foot rail on the highside next one of the masses of benk coal, and probably slewed the sleepers in order to facilitate filling. Possibly one of them may have been engaged filling loose coal further in next the narrow Bord Brake, where one of their tokens was found, and a shovel lay against the in-bye side of the in-bye mass of Benk coal. It is a circumstance worthy of note that for 20 yards in-bye of the displaced fall, the rails were clear and rubbish and loose material had not been swept on to them as was the case both in-bye and out-bye of this undisturbed length. The Reeds had each a safety lamp, as well as J. Garroway, whose body was found near them, and who trailed for men further in-bye, and these lamps were all found near where their bodies lay; in fact, so near that I am inclined to think they had been alarmed by noticing gas on the flame of their lamps, and had seized them, and were on their way to the brake. The indication of force showed that Reeds' place of work was the point of origin, and there is no other probable means of ignition than the flame of one of the lamps there, as no shots were fired up the brakes, and there was no evidence of smoking or use of matches or open lights. The four lamps were as follows: John Reid, No. 330; John Reid jun., No. 13; Jos. Reid, No. 325; J. Garroway, No. 103. All were locked — Nos. 325 and 103 were found intact, and were tested at Leeds University with an explosive current passing at 1,250 feet per minute, and in both lamps inflammable vapour burnt in the gauze without passing flame, the testing lasting two minutes No. 330 was found in three parts. First the shield, second the oil vessel with one pole and third, the gauze. The metal ring with air holes at the bottom of the shield and three of the poles have not yet been found. The glass was missing. There were large pieces of coal lying near this lamp, which, from some of their clean and undusted surfaces from which they had fallen proved that they had fallen since the explosion and had probably damaged the lamp. No. 13 was not much damaged, except that the glass was gone, and the double copper ring at the bottom of the gauze which fits on to the glass showed somewhat peculiar indentations, one in especial looks as though it had been caused by the blow of some pointed instrument, possibly a pick; this lamp has I think been damaged before the explosion and has passed flame. John Reed had lost one eye, and he may have inadvertently struck the lamp. It will be noticed that if gas came off from the goaf at the robbery place and entered the air current, the Reeds' place of work was the first point, where it would pass over lighted lamps. The reason why the explosion did not extend in-bye and out-bye on the main road on its arrival with great force and flame at the friction gear appears to be due to the absence of coal dust on that road. This is partly accounted for by the fact that at the leaders of the two troubles crossed by the main road out-bye of the friction gear small feeders of salt water issued and ran down the road, keeping it moist on the floor nearly to the friction gear. From the 6th North damp coal not producing much dust was led, and salt water collecting in the extremity of the main road was daily brought out in water barrels, some of which were emptied on the 3rd North haulage road to allay the dust there. The speed of the loaded tubs up to the friction gear was only half the speed out-bye at that point, and this, coupled with the lesser air currents, prevented the accumulation of much dust on the upper parts of the road. Even on the 3rd North haulage road, which was the driest road, there was probably not much upper dust, and for considerable distances not much roof timber on which it could collect. The dust on the 3rd North haulage road appeared to be principally on the floor and was derived from dry coal from the robbery workings escaping from the tube. The main road out-bye of the friction gear had recently been and was, in fact, at the time of the explosion in the process of enlargement. Old timber was taken down, side and roof stone shot down at the week-ends, after removing or watering the dust, and these operations helped materially to reduce the quantity of dust, and sufficient time had not elapsed for new deposits to form. It is worthy of note that the explosion had not extended in the direction of the return air way which carries off all the gas made in the workings, further than coal dust extended. Beyond the dusty area the return was undamaged."

By Mr. Redmayne, witness said that it could be told by the clean surface that some of the falls had taken place since the explosion. As to the dilly being the site of the explosion he considered it quite out of the question on account of both force and direction of the explosion. It was ruled out by evidence both of force and want of force.

Mr. Pope (referring to dust): Is there any ground for believing that it would give rise to trouble in the roadways if they were treated with water here? — Well, in some cases it might.

But there has been exemplified, here the value of what might be described as a wet zone? Yes, certainly, and if it had not been for the unfortunate circumstance of the fire at the friction gear all the men in-bye would undoubtedly have escaped.

Have you had any complaint from the men as to being compelled to work in gas here? — No.

I assume there is some natural disinclination of the minds of the men to work in places of that kind? — Yes, but the men can make complaint, or the miners' agent, or it can be done anonymously. We attend to anonymous complaints as well as others.

But none were brought to your notice? — No.

Have you made a special study of explosions? — Yes.

And given a great deal of attention to it and also in association with your brother you have written upon it? — Yes.

In reply to Mr. Richards, witness said there were 251 coal mines, 118 metalliferous mines, 359 altogether and 438 quarries, or altogether mines and quarries, 807, in witness's district to be inspected by himself and three assistants. It was not possible that the four of them could inspect all these once in each year. If the fire had been a small one the attempt that was being made to overcome it when he arrived might have been effective. He came to the conclusion that it was not a small fire. He did not think Graham's theory would have been successful even if it had been put in operation when first suggested. Those who went into the back drift got down about 25 yards by creeping on their hands and knees under the smoke, so he assumed he might be wrong, that the smoke was about the same distance up the back drift as up the incline.

Mr. Richards said he had rather gathered that they were able to go much further down the back drift that the main incline and it was only because the smoke was coming up the main incline they were called back.

In reply to Mr. Smith, witness said one reason for thinking the operations of the managers were preferable to Graham's plan was the facility of short circuiting in the intake, where they had the return on one side. In the back drift they would have to break through a stopping into the intake and again into the return.

Mr. Smith: It was rather taking up a strong position for a man like Graham to suggest any thing to his superior officers? — Oh, I rather think it would be his duty.

Do you think from the experience you have had in that pit there was adequate ventilation going into the pit? — I think they were rather pinched for air in No. 6 north.

Would they not be rather pinched for air in No. 3 level? — Well, from the evidence I cannot say that I think so.

In reply to Mr. Rigby Swift, witness said he knew the Company were making efforts to improve the ventilation by putting in a fan in the pit, which had been delayed by the explosion. He remembered the conference in the office in the evening about nine o'clock, and he agreed that certain names of persons present, including Mr. Hanlon, were there. At that conference the situation was generally discussed, including Mr. Graham's plan. The pros and cons of it were fully discussed, and it was decided that the scheme was impossible.

Did Mr. Hanlon say one word of protest against the scheme not being adopted? — No.

Witness continued that it was generally agreed that it would be better to leave the sealing of the mine until after the men came with the safety apparatus.

As far as you remember did Mr. Hanlon urge in any way that the mine should not be sealed? — Not that I remember.

In reply to Mr. Chapman, witness said that the operations which were proposed in the back drift would have brought the fire and smoke against the brattice stopping in the main intake and would probably have destroyed it, and imperilled the lives of the rescue party to a very great extent.

Mr. Richards asked whether witness was really positive Mr. Hanlon was present at the conference at eight o'clock on the night of the 12th, because the fact was Mr. Hanlon was in bed at the time? — Witness: I say he was there.

The luncheon adjournment having been taken, on resuming there was some further discussion as to the arrangements for taking the jury down the mine and it was eventually agreed that Mr. Atkinson, Mr. Steele, and Mr. Hanlon should accompany the party.

The Coroner then said it was with very great grief indeed that he announced that the death had occurred of the mother of Dr. Harris. They all of them, and everybody in the locality, knew what work Dr. Harris had done and the services he had rendered in recovery of the bodies, and he felt sure he would be expressing the wish of all in offering their sympathy and extreme regret to Dr. Harris in the affliction which had befallen him.

The Foreman, on behalf of the jury, associated himself with the Coroner's remarks.

HENRY ARNOLD ABBOTT was then examined by the Coroner. He said he had been assistant inspector of mines for this district for the last eight years. His last official inspection of the pit prior to the explosion was made in November 1909. He accompanied Mr. Atkinson to Whitehaven after the explosion. He had seen Mr. Atkinson's report on the explosion, and with this he agreed.

Replying to Mr. Atkinson, witness said he believed Mr. Hanlon was sitting in the room at the conference at which it was decided to close the pit.

Mr. Richards: What was the first cause of this explosion? — The ignition of fire-damp.

Where was that fire-damp in your opinion? — I think it was on the highest point, somewhere about where the Reeds were working. I think it came down the level from the goaf on the high side.

What do you suggest about the goaf? Do you think it contains gas all the way along from the dilly to Reed's place? — That I don't know.

Is it highly probable that it did? — Yes, it is probable up against the fault.

Questioned as whether he was positive Mr. Hanlon was in the room at the conference when it was decided to close the pit, witness said he was not certain about the time of the conference as it was dark in the evening. His impression was that Mr. Hanlon was there sitting in a chair in the room, as far as witness's memory served him.

You won't say as confidently as Mr. Atkinson that he was there? — I won't swear to it. As far as my memory serves me he was there.

JOHN HANLON deposed that he was the miners' agent, and had held the appointment about seven years. A boy came to his house about 25 minutes to nine o'clock and told him he had been sent to tell him that there was something seriously wrong at Wellington Pit. He went to the pit and went down as nearly as he could say about 25 or 26 minutes to ten, along with some other men. When he got to the fan case the smoke was about 15 yards beyond. Mr. Henry and others were there and Mr. Henry and others lined out and went down by the back drift, and one or two stood on the main intake and presently called out to them to come back as the smoke was creeping further up the intake and might have fastened them in the back drift, and so they all came out and it was decided to go on with the brattice. There was no consultation, nobody suggested anything else. Witness had no conversation with Tom Graham, and did not hear him make any suggestion. Witness came out of the pit about two o'clock in the morning and went back in half an hour and remained until three o'clock on Thursday afternoon. With the work they had had in hand everything was being done that could be done and he really thought when he left they were making good progress. It was said they had reached about 80 yards from the friction gear, and he had good hopes that by night they would have reached the friction gear. Witness did not urge any disapproval of what was being done. There was no discussion with him about the closing of the pit that night. He first got word about the pit being closed between eight and nine o'clock the following morning.

Were you in any way consulted about the closing of the pit? — I was not.

In reply to Mr. Redmayne, witness said he thought Mr. Graham's scheme was much better in the first instance and was still good as the last.

Mr. Atkinson: What were you before you became mining agent? — A collier for eight or nine years.

You don't pretend to pretend to be a mining expert? — No sir, I am a long way off that.

You say you thought they got within 80 yards of the friction gear? — That was the communication I got from Mr. Steele and Mr. Blair that afternoon.

Is it a fact they never got nearer than 250 yards? — Yes, it is now. That was the calculation at that time.

Mr. Richards: We want it perfectly clear as to whether you were or were not at this conference when the discussion of sealing up the pit took place? — I was never in Mr. Steele's office on that night.

Now let us follow your movements if you will. First of all you heard there was something wrong at the pit some time after nine on the evening of the 11th. You immediately went to the pit, went down to give what assistance you could in the operations. You had no fault to find with anybody as to the risks they run and the hard work they did in striving to get down to the friction gear — everyone tried their very best? — Yes.

Witness continued he didn't hear Graham's theory discussed. He hardly expected Graham to come to him about it after he had brought the scheme before Mr. Henry, his superior. He came out of the pit at three o'clock on the afternoon of the 12th after having a long innings. He didn't do any manual work. There were plenty of men willing to work.

Mr. Steele and Mr. Blair wouldn't be doing any manual work either? — No.

It would be rather an unusual experience for the three of you, don't you think? — Witness (smiling): Yes.

Most of us get out of that if we can, Mr. Hanlon? — Well, I think we do. (Laughter.) Continuing, witness said he went home at ten minutes to five, along with Mr. Cape. He did not go to bed when he got home. It was six o'clock when he got home as people stopped him with inquiries on the way. Then he had five or six interviews and parties to meet and then he laid down on the bed. A man afterwards brought word that the Inspector had withdrawn the men from the pit again. Witness left the house about ten minutes to nine. At the pit he went into the lamp house and was there about half an hour. He then went into what they called the back office. The others were in the other room. Dr. Harris came in after witness and after two or three minutes Dr. Harris went into the lobby and witness followed. He was never inside the office sitting down there. None of the gentlemen there said anything to him that they were going to discuss the sealing of the mine. He had no idea what they were considering at all. Dr. Harris stood at the door cheek and witness stood along with him. Mr. Blair said something to the effect that some of them had other work to do and those who had no business might go. He took that as a hint and he and Dr. Harris both left.

So that when Mr. Atkinson says definitely and Mr. Abbott somewhat qualifies it that you were present at that discussion you give it an absolute unqualified denial? — I do sir.

In answer to further questions, witness said he was never in the company of the inspectors when the question of sealing up the pit was discussed, before it was done. At eleven o'clock on Friday morning he was asked to be at Mr. Steele's office, and he went accompanied by Messrs. Ennis, Smallwood, and Mathers, pit delegates. He protested to Mr. Steele and Mr. Turner against the sealing up of the mine. He told them he was still confident that the men were alive in No. 5 north. They said they could not help it, it was the inspector's orders.

In reply to Mr. Smith, witness said he considered the workmen's representatives should be called in on the occasion of such an occurrence as this as well as the managers and inspectors, and have a consultation.

In reply to Mr. Smith, witness said that there was no objection to his going down the mine, and there was nothing to prevent him speaking to the inspector if he had seen him.

There is nothing in the suggestion that you as representing the men were kept away? — I think there is a good bit in it. I think we might have been sent for, and asked to go with the inspector.

Do you suggest he was kept away from you or you from him? — I have never inferred it.

Witness, continuing, said he did not speak to any of the managers when he was in the lobby at the office because they had decided to proceed with the operations to go down the mine again. Mr. Blair told them that some of them had to go down again.

If eight people say positively you were there at that conference do you say it is not true? — I do say it is not true.

You never tried to find out what happened at that conference and never asked any question from anyone? — No, because they were going down the pit.

It was you business to get all the information you could as the representative of the men? — I got that information outside the office.

It was you business to stand out for the pit not being closed? — It was.

And you did it by not saying a solitary word to any of those people about it? — I took the first opportunity I had. The first protest I made was at eleven o'clock on Friday morning immediately or soon after I learned that the pit was sealed up.

Asken if the matters complained of were always remedied, witness said the promise to remedy them was always made and as far as he knew that was done.

RICHARD WALKER MOORE, of Cartgate, check viewer of Lord Lonsdale, who is lessor of the Whitehaven Collieries, said he had been connected with the collieries more or less for forty years. The last occasion on which he was in Wellington Pit prior to the explosion was on April 19th. Witness afterwards described his visit to the pit on the night of the accident. The conference with reference to the closing of the pit was held when the came out of the pit in the office. He should think between eight and nine o'clock. He could not tell the exact time because he had no watch with him. Mr. Atkinson took the lead, and asked all those present if they had anything to say against the proposition to complete the stopping which had been partially erected in the main intake. There was a pause, and, as no one spoke, witness finally thought some protest should be made, and said he did not agree to the erecting of the stopping until some further effort was made. He said there would be a riot. Graham's project was thoroughly discussed, and it was considered, as it had been all along, that the scheme was not feasible and was most dangerous. Mr. Atkinson asked witness if he would be satisfied if with the Meco apparatus men, they went down the pit again, and made another attempt. He agreed to that, and the second party descended the pit about 11.30. They found, however, all attempts to get down the front or back dip impossible, and it was then decided that the pit should be sealed.

In reply to the Coroner, witness said there was no probability of any of the workmen who had gone down the pit being alive then. He thought they were all dead long before.

Was or was not Mr. Hanlon present at the time of the discussion as regards sealing of the pit? — He was. I took particular notice of him. He was sitting in the opposite coroner to me, and I took particular notice of him. I was looking at him to see if he would say anything on behalf of the men and when he did not speak at all I did. I think Mr. Atkinson, the inspector, would be sitting almost in front of him.

In reply to Mr. Redmayne, witness said he did not think there would have been a good chance had Graham's scheme been applied in the first instance. There was no material for a brick stopping within a thousand yards. If they had put a canvas stopping it might have been burnt and the rescue party cut off.

In reply to Mr. Atkinson, witness said on his inspection of April 19th ventilation was quite clear in the places he was in. At first he thought the explosion began in the dilly, but after seeing the ground and considering effect of the explosion he agreed Mr. Atkinson's reports.

Mr. Smith: Am I to take it that you went down the pit in the interests of Lord Lonsdale to see what revenue he had to draw? — No, no. How could I judge what revenue he had to draw from an inspection.

Did you report to Lord Lonsdale as to what was your opinion? — No. I could not make a negative report. The ventilation was all right so far as I remember.

Did you ever report to Lord Lonsdale as to Wellington Pit? — No.

Are you telling this Court seriously that you have never in your position as an official to Lord Lonsdale given a report on Wellington Pit? — I have not made any written report to Lord Lonsdale as to Wellington Pit.

After reminding witness that as to the time of the conference on Thursday evening there was a clock in the office, Mr. Smith asked: Can you tell me particularly where you saw Mr. Hanlon, what part of the office? — He was sitting near the door. Mr. Hanlon was sitting in the corner near the door leading to the lobby.

Do you remember whether Mr. Hanlon objected or not? — He did not open his mouth. I took particular notice of him. I wondered what action he would take.

You particularly well remember Mr. Hanlon did you not say anything. Rather a confident memory, is not it? — It is true at any rate. I watched him particularly to see what he would do, and I was very much astonished he never took any part.

You had rather a suspicious eye on Mr. Hanlon? — No.

I put it he will be looked upon as a good citizen? — Oh, yes; he is a member of the Whitehaven Town Council. (Laughter.)

Why look at him more than anyone else? — Because he was there representing the miners. I wondered what part he would take. I fully expected he would have backed me up.

Would not you have naturally expected that Messrs. Steele, Henry, and Blair would have backed you up? — I dare say they did. I cannot remember the exact expression; they consented to make another descent and if it failed there was no other way.

Some questions having been put by Mr. Cape, Mr. Richards questioned witness as to whether he thought it would not be better if some better precautions should be taken for dealing with the after effects of an explosion. Witness said if there had been trained men there with apparatus who could have acted within an hour or so they would have had a better chance of doing something.

Mr. Rigby Swift: Have you the slightest interest in the world in making it appear that Mr. Hanlon was at the conference if he was not there? — No.

Is it the slightest advantage to you to make it appear he was at the conference? — I am very sorry to have to say he was there when he contradicts it.

The inquiry was adjourned to Thursday next, November 29.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Abbott, Henry Arnold    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Armstrong, Matthew    Miner  
Atkinson, John Boland    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Benn, Daniel    Miner  
Campbell, William    Deputy  
Chapman, —    Solicitor  
Cowie, —    Deputy  
Cowie, Benjie      
Crook, William    Hewer  
Crooks, William    Miner  
Douglas, Thomas    Roadman  
Dowthwaite, —    Police Inspector  
Dunlop, James    Master Wasteman  
Graham, Thomas    Deputy  
Hanlon, John    Miners' Agent  
Harris, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Henry, James    Undermanager  
Kenmore, Joseph    Miner  
Kirkpatrick, Gilbert    Trailer  
Laidlow, James    Shiftsman  
Lucas, Joseph    Miner  
Magee, G.    Miner  
Mathers, John Thomas    Hewer  
Mcclellan, George    Onsetter  
Mccumiskey, Michael      
Moore, Richard Walker    Viewer  
Mulholland, John    Hewer  
Murphy, —, Mrs.      
Nicholson, Arthur Darling    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Nixon, William    Miner  
O'Pray, Henry    Miner  
Parker, —    Manager  
Pearson, John    Deputy  
Quayle, —    Deputy  
Redmayne, Richard Augustine Studdart    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Richards, T.    M.P.  
Ritson, —    Deputy  
Rothery, John    Undermanager  
Scott, Jonathan    Watchman  
Skelly, William    Miner  
Skelton, Jeremiah    Banksman  
Smith, Herbert      
Steel, Henry    Miner  
Steel, Robert    Manager  Whos Who Page
Swift, Rigby      
Swinburne, Thomas    Deputy  
Turner, —      
Walsh, Hugh    Miner  
Wear, John      
Wilson, John    Deputy  
Wilson, Matthew    Deputy  
Young, Fletcher    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Wellington Colliery  Wellington Colliery
Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
12 May 1910  Serious Accident At Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News)
13 May 1910  Colliery Disaster, Many Miners Entombed (The Times)
13 May 1910  Terrible Pit Disaster, 137 Men Buried In Blazing Mine, Frantic Women's Vigil (Times & Express)
13 May 1910  Avalanche Of Death, Terrible Scenes, Four Men's Rush For Life (Times & Express)
14 May 1910  The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Rescue Measures Abandoned (The Times)
16 May 1910  The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Royal Sympathy And Donations (The Times)
17 May 1910  The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster (The Times)
17 May 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disasters (The Times)
18 May 1910  The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Experts' Conference (The Times)
19 May 1910  The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, The Mayor's Fund (The Times)
19 May 1910  The Disaster At Wellington Pit, 137 Men And Boys Closed In By Fire, Appalling Calamity (Whitehaven News)
19 May 1910  Coincidences (Whitehaven News)
19 May 1910  Looking Back (Whitehaven News)
19 May 1910  The Brick Wall (Whitehaven News)
19 May 1910  The Colliery Calamity (Whitehaven News)
19 May 1910  The Inevitable (Whitehaven News)
19 May 1910  Those Who Mourn (Whitehaven News)
23 May 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Mayor's Relief Fund (The Times)
24 May 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
26 May 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Further Exploration, Pit Now Doubly Sealed (Whitehaven News)
26 May 1910  A Suggestion (Whitehaven News)
26 May 1910  The Colliery Relief Fund (Whitehaven News)
26 May 1910  The Miners And The Disaster (Whitehaven News)
26 May 1910  What To Do With It (Whitehaven News)
27 May 1910  Whitehaven Colliery Disaster (The Times)
28 May 1910  The Whitehaven Disaster (The Times)
02 Jun 1910  Allerdale Colliery Company's Clifton Pit, Doubling Of The Shift (Whitehaven News)
02 Jun 1910  Dangers Of Coalmining (Whitehaven News)
02 Jun 1910  The Men Out Of Work (Whitehaven News)
02 Jun 1910  The William Pit Men (Whitehaven News)
02 Jun 1910  Stoppage At William Pit, Gas In The Pit, Inspection By Men's Representatives (Whitehaven News)
07 Jun 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
09 Jun 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Further Exploration, Fire Probably Out (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Meeting Of William Pit Men (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  Mayor's Relief Fund (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  Pit Lamps (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  The Analysis Of The Gases (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  The Unsealing Of The Pit (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  Whitehaven Pits (Whitehaven News)
09 Jun 1910  William Pit Re-Started (Whitehaven News)
10 Jun 1910  Mr. Keir Hardie and the Whitehaven Disaster (The Times)
13 Jun 1910  The Whitehaven Disaster (The Times)
16 Jun 1910  Wellington Pit Disaster (Whitehaven News)
16 Jun 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Exploring Party Who Descended The Pit On Sunday Last (Whitehaven News)
16 Jun 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Cumberland Miners' Association, Whitehaven Relief Fund (Whitehaven News)
16 Jun 1910  The Progress Of The Pit Exploration (Whitehaven News)
16 Jun 1910  The Sealing Of The Pit (Whitehaven News)
16 Jun 1910  The Union And The Relief Fund (Whitehaven News)
16 Jun 1910  Unthinkable (Whitehaven News)
23 Jun 1910  Whitehaven Pit Accident (The Times)
23 Jun 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Exploration Stopped, Another Conference Of Experts (Whitehaven News)
23 Jun 1910  The Wellington Pit Disaster, Discussion In Parliament, Home Secretary Promises Amending Legislation (Whitehaven News)
07 Jul 1910  The Mayor's Fund (Whitehaven News)
07 Jul 1910  Pit Rescue Work (Whitehaven News)
07 Jul 1910  The Causes Of Explosion (Whitehaven News)
14 Jul 1910  The Mayor's Fund (Whitehaven News)
14 Jul 1910  Wellington Pit Disaster, The Mayor's Fund (Whitehaven News)
21 Jul 1910  Letter (Whitehaven News)
22 Jul 1910  Award of Edward Medals (London Gazette)
28 Jul 1910  Wellington Disaster, The King Edward Medals For 49 Rescuers (Whitehaven News)
28 Jul 1910  An Important Mining Experiment (Whitehaven News)
28 Jul 1910  And "The News" (Whitehaven News)
28 Jul 1910  Dividends And Safety (Whitehaven News)
28 Jul 1910  Hasty Speech, Lame Apology (Whitehaven News)
28 Jul 1910  Judging After Event (Whitehaven News)
28 Jul 1910  The Sealing Of The Mine (Whitehaven News)
04 Aug 1910  The Miners And The Medals (Whitehaven News)
04 Aug 1910  Presentation Of The Medals, Departure From Whitehaven (Whitehaven News)
05 Aug 1910  Award of Edward Medals (London Gazette)
24 Aug 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
20 Sep 1910  The Whitehaven Colliery Accident (The Times)
26 Sep 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
27 Sep 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
28 Sep 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Finding Of Bodies (The Times)
29 Sep 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
29 Sep 1910  Re-Opening Of Wellington Pit, Quick Progress, Finding Of Bodies (Whitehaven News)
30 Sep 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Fifty Bodies Found (The Times)
01 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, More Bodies Discovered (The Times)
03 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
04 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
05 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
06 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
06 Oct 1910  The Re-Opening Of Wellington Pit, Thursday's Good Day's Work, 50 More Bodies Found (Whitehaven News)
06 Oct 1910  A Common Grave And Monument (Whitehaven News)
06 Oct 1910  A Town Of Mourning (Whitehaven News)
06 Oct 1910  A Veritable Way Of Death (Whitehaven News)
06 Oct 1910  Sanitary Restrictions (Whitehaven News)
06 Oct 1910  The Crux Of The Coming Inquiry (Whitehaven News)
06 Oct 1910  The Monument (Whitehaven News)
07 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
08 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
10 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Disaster, Identification Of The Bodies (The Times)
12 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
13 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
13 Oct 1910  Coroners And Juries (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  The Mining Disaster: Identification Of Bodies (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  A New Electric Lamp (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  Coroners' Inquests (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  Fees For Service (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  Identification Of Bodies (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  The Mystery Of The Mine (Whitehaven News)
13 Oct 1910  The Mine Disaster, Thursday's Developments, Futher Exploring (Whitehaven News)
15 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Supposed Cause (The Times)
15 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Supposed Cause (The Times)
17 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
18 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
19 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
20 Oct 1910  The Mine Disaster, Thursday, 12 Bodies Found (Whitehaven News)
22 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disasters (The Times)
23 Oct 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
27 Oct 1910  Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News)
27 Oct 1910  The Stoppage Of The Pits (Whitehaven News)
27 Oct 1910  The Mining Disaster, Friday's Findings, The Friction Gear Fire And Falls (Whitehaven News)
03 Nov 1910  The Mine Disaster (Whitehaven News)
03 Nov 1910  A Serious Rumour (Whitehaven News)
03 Nov 1910  Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News)
16 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Official Inquiry Opened (The Times)
17 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
17 Nov 1910  Wellington Pit Disaster, The Inquest And Home Office Inquiry (Whitehaven News)
18 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
19 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
22 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
23 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
24 Nov 1910  Wellington Pit Disaster, The Inquest And Home Office Inquiry, Thursday's Proceedings (Whitehaven News)
30 Nov 1910  The Whitehaven Disaster (The Times)
01 Dec 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
01 Dec 1910  The Mining Disaster, The Inquest And Inquiry, Tuesday's Proceedings (Whitehaven News)
01 Dec 1910  Discovery Of More Cremated Remains (Whitehaven News)
02 Dec 1910  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster (The Times)
02 Dec 1910  The Wellington Pit Inquiry (Sunderland Daily Echo)
03 Dec 1910  Verdict on Whitehaven Disaster, Officials Absolved From Blame (The Times)
08 Dec 1910  The Mining Inquest, Thursday's Proceedings (Whitehaven News)
15 Dec 1910  Wellington Pit Disaster, Recovery Of Another Body, The Inquest (Whitehaven News)
15 Dec 1910  The Last Of The Bodies Recovered, Mistaken Identification (Whitehaven News)
22 Dec 1910  Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, Colliers' Public Meeting, Petition To The Home Office (Whitehaven News)
22 Dec 1910  Wellington Pit Disaster, Memorial Service, Address By The Bishop (Whitehaven News)
29 Dec 1910  Miners Unions (Whitehaven News)
29 Dec 1910  Pit Explosions (Whitehaven News)
14 Feb 1911  Award of Edward Medals (London Gazette)
16 Feb 1911  Disasters In Coal Mines, Home Secretary And Legislation (Whitehaven News)
16 Feb 1911  Edward Medals For More Whitehaven Miners (Whitehaven News)
16 Feb 1911  Safety Lamps And Coal Dust (Whitehaven News)
17 Feb 1911  The Whitehaven Pit Disaster, Home Office Criticism (The Times)
23 Feb 1911  The Whitehaven Disaster (Whitehaven News)
23 Feb 1911  Whitehaven Pit Fire, Home Office Reports, Dust And The Spread Of The Explosion (Whitehaven News)
03 Mar 1911  The Whitehaven Disaster, Report Of Miners Representatives (The Times)
23 Mar 1911  Wellington Pit Disaster, Mayor's Relief Fund (Whitehaven News)
23 Mar 1911  Exits And Standard Ventilation (Whitehaven News)
23 Mar 1911  Safety In The Mines (Whitehaven News)
23 Mar 1911  The Whitehaven Colliery Disaster, The Inspection Of Mines (Whitehaven News)
13 Apr 1911  The Prospects Of Wellington Pit (Whitehaven News)
18 May 1911  Whitehaven County Court, Colliery Compensation Dependants (Whitehaven News)
18 May 1911  Whitehaven Colliery (Whitehaven News)
06 Jul 1911  The Local Miners' Union And Distress Funds (Whitehaven News)
11 Mar 1933  Pit Disaster Recalled, Death Of Man Who Was Decorated By King (Cumberland Evening News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Wellington Pit
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Report Page  Text of the official report into the incident
Memorial Page  Memorial images gallery

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print