|
17th November 1910 Wellington Pit DisasterThe Inquest And Home Office InquiryThe inquiry into the cause and circumstances of the Wellington Pit disaster began at the Town Hall, Whitehaven, to-day (Tuesday). It is a joint inquest and Home Office inquiry, the first of its kind ever held under section 45 of the Coal Mines Regulation Act , 1897. Mr. Edward Atter, the Coroner for West Cumberland, conducts the inquiry with Mr. R. A. S. Redmayne, M.Sc, H.M. Inspector of Mines as an expert assessor. Among the other gentlemen present in the official area, there were: The Mayor of Whitehaven (Ald. J. Braithwaite), Mr. J. D. Bain, partner in the Whitehaven Colliery Company, Mr. H. M. James, general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery Co.; Mr. R. Blair, assistant general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery Company; Mr. Lewis T. Helder, solicitor for the Colliery Co.; Mr. J. G. Dees, Lord Lonsdale's Whitehaven agent; Mr. R. W. Moore, Lord Lonsdale's colliery viewer; Mr. R. Steele, manager of Wellington Pit; Mr. S. Turner, manager of William Pit; Mr. J. H. Merivale, Broomhill Collieries, Northumberland; and Mr. W. C. Blackett, Sacriston Collieries, Northumberland, mining experts on behalf of the Whitehaven Colliery Co.; Professor Galloway, mining expert for the Miner's Federation; Mr. James Henry, under-manager of Wellington Pit; Mr. W. Burnyeat, J.P., Millgrove; Mr. Watkyn-Thomas, J.P, Egremont; Mr. T. P. Martin, secretary of the Cumberland Coalowner's Association; Mr. R. Kitchin, J.P., St. Bee's; Mr. J. Davis, J.P., Mr. J. I. Fisher, J.P., Mr. J. Flynn, J.P., Mr. W. Moore, & c.. At a table immediately in front of the official shorthand writers there were seated Mr. S. Pope, barrister, representing the Home Office, together with Mr. J. B. Atkinson, Mr. H. A. Abbott, and Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspectors of Mines. The Coroner's jury was as follows :—
The Town Hall Assembly Room, in which the inquiry was held, was specially fitted up for the occasion by Mr. Joseph Dixon, under the direction of the Coroner, who in this matter, was assisted by Mr. J. G. Dees; Mr. Atter to his assessor, Mr. Redmayne, sat at a long table at the Scotch-street end of the hall, facing the end where at ordinary public assemblies the platform generally is. The jurymen were seated on their left, and the advocate's opposites on their right, the one side facing the others. The Pressmen sat facing the Coroner, and they thus enclosed a square, which extended back nearly level with the entrance. Within that square was a table at one end of which, facing the Coroner, sat the witness under examination, and at the other end the official shorthand writer. A barrier from the door straight across the hall divided the portion reserved for those officially engaged in connection with the case from those admitted in the same door by ticket; and further back was another barrier straight across the room, dividing the ticket-holders from the general public, who had admittance from the ante-room entrance. The hall was warmed by a number of small stoves in addition to the open fires at the Catherine-street end. Mr. Rigby Swift said he appeared on behalf of the Whitehaven Colliery Co., and he expressed the sorrow of the Company at the calamity that had occurred, their appreciation of the bravery that had been shown in connection with it, and their desire to assist in this investigation with a view to prevent similar occurrences in the future. Mr. A. Sharp said he was present to represent the friends of the deceased workmen with Professor Galloway, Mr. T. Richards, M.P., Mr. Herbert Smith, Mr. John Hanlon and Mr. Thos. Cape. Mr. W. J. Chapman said he appeared on behalf of the managers of Wellington Pit, who would do their utmost to throw light on the dark places to clear up if possible the causes of this disaster, and on their behalf he expressed their sympathy with the relatives of the deceased. Mr. S. Pope, barrister, said he was there to watch the proceedings on behalf of the Secretary of State, and to assist in the inquiry; and Mr. Atkinson and he were here to render the fullest assistance in arriving at a true decision. Mr. J. B. Atkinson said he appeared as Inspector of Mines — with him was associated Mr. Abbott. The Coroner then addressed the jury. He asked them to dismiss from their minds all that they had heard or read of the case. What they would have to consider was the condition of the mine prior to the accident, what it was at the time of the accident, what it was immediately after the accident, what took place on the re-opening of the mine, what it is at the present time. On the 11th May last 141 persons went down the mine. Only five of these came up again. Of these five one had since gone to Canada. The other four would be called as witnesses. There would be over 30 witnesses. This is the first inquiry of the kind, and it would be great advantage to himself to have the assistance of Mr. Redmayne. Mr. T. Richards wished that the questions put to the witnesses by the Colliery Company should precede those put on behalf of the men. The Coroner did not agree that this would either be usual or proper, and refused to adopt the suggestion. JOHN BRENNAN, lamp-man at Wellington Pit, was the first witness called. He deposed that he had been twenty years lamp-man at the top, at Wellington Pit. He had to clean the lamps and see them in the proper condition before they went down the pit. On the night shift he commenced at five o'clock at night, and remained until six o'clock in the morning. (Books were put in giving lists of the men and their lamps.) The lamps, witness continued, were numbered. On the 11th May, witness was on night shift. The men go down at five on that shift. They begin to get their lamps soon after four o'clock, and get them as they came to the pit top. John Armstrong gave out the lamps on the 11th May. Witness gave out two, Benjamin Cowie's and Robert Cooper's. Witness got the list produced written out as he ticked it. 141 men went down the pit on the night of the 11th May. Their names were in the book produced — the lamp book. On the Coroner further questioning the witness as to whether there was any; and that record of the names of the men who actually went down the pit on the occasion in question. Mr. Rigby Swift, intervening by the Coroner's permission, examined the witness to show how this was. In reply to Mr. Rigby Swift witness said the book produced to him had in at the name of the men working in the pit, hewer or boys with the number of the lamp given to each. The men kept it all the time they were down in the mine so that witness knew by looking at the book with the name of the man and the number of the lamp exactly who was down the pit. For instance, if he looked at the lamp No. 56 and it was out of the lamp-house it indicated that John Gilmore was down the mine. He had no list of the men going down the mine, except what was furnished in that way by the book. After the accident happened he desired to check the names of the men who were down the mine and he went over the lamps and the list produced was that of the missing lamps. In reply to Mr. Redmayne it was stated that there was no list taken at the time of the descent of the shift, giving the names of the men who had gone down the pit. Mr. Rigby Swift said it was not the custom and had not been required of them, and there was no statutory provision for it, but the Colliery Company were quite prepared to comply with any regulation of that kind; that might in future be required of them and other colliery companies by the Home Office, and he also pointed out that as to the identity of the men who were down they were nearly all already accounted for by the bodies which had been recovered. In reply to Mr. Richards, the witness said he had my written instructions to take a record of the names, and the Coroner said there was no Act of Parliament which required it, on which Mr. Richards observed that he was not suggesting that there was. In further reply to Mr. Richards the witness said that when a man came into the employ he was given a lamp, and he retained it whilst he was employed at the pit. Supposing his lamp became out of order whilst it was being adjusted they gave him a spare lamp. There was no record kept of them, and they were not able to tell from any record they had taken, who had got a spare lamp. There were eight spare lamps out on the 11th of May. There were eight workmen who had lamps, the numbers of which were no on this book. Mr. R. R. Blair, assistant general manager of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, deposed that the lessees of the pits of the Whitehaven Colliery, Wellington Pit, Ladysmith Pit, and William Pit, were Mr. J. D. Bain, Col. J. R. Bain, and Mr. John S. Simpson. They first began to work the pits in August, 1888. Mr. Robert Steele was the manager of Wellington and Ladysmith Pits, appointed in June, 1907, and Mr. James Henry was under-manager for Wellington Pit, and had been so for about twenty years. The number of men employed was about 700 each in Wellington and Ladysmith Pits and about 800 in William Pit. The pits were worked on three shifts and the night shift of Wellington Pit went down at 5.30 p.m. Benjamin Cowie was the overman of this shift. The depth of the shaft was 128 fathoms, and the workings extended to the end of the main end, a distance of four miles practically the whole of which was under the sea. At the main end the workings were 231 fathoms below the sea. At present levels 1, 2 and 4, were not being worked, and 3, 5 and 6 were being worked. No. 3 is 2¾ miles from the pit bottom. No. 5 level is 500 yards further in-by, and from 5 to 6 is another 500 yards. In No. 3 there were 51 men and boys, in No. 5 there were 30, and in No. 6 there were 57. In No. 3 the first brake is 790 yards in from the friction-gear, from there to the working places 440 yards, and between the first and second brakes 220 yards, and beyond the two brakes 400 yards, and to the cross cut drift three-quarters of a mile. In No. 5 it is about 600 yards to the last working place, and in No. 6 practically half a mile to the working place. The means of communication were a signal wire and a telephone communication along the middle of the main road. The lighting is by the ordinary safety lamps, the same as the one produced; there was no electricity at present. The ventilation was by a surface fan driven by combined engines, and had been in use about six years. The barometer on the 11th May was somewhat high 30.4. There was shot-firing on the 11th May in No. 3 level in the stone drift on the back shift. Thomas Barnes fired the shot. That was not for the purpose of coal, but for the purpose of breaking down the stone. No. 3 was dirty with coal dust on that day. They had had the lamps seven or eight years. He was down the pit on 10th May at six o'clock in the morning. He arranged to be down on the 11th May, but something occurred to prevent him. He went down at a quarter-past ten on the 11th. One of the men, Joe Lavery, went down with him. They went in-bye to the main turn. He went on to the Fan Syke and saw Mr. Steele, the manager, and five or six others. After a consultation they ordered brattice cloth to be put along the main road. He heard from these men that something had happened, and that there was a fire at the friction gear. He was down at four o'clock on Thursday morning, when he was asked to come up to see the Chief Inspector, Mr. Atkinson. He went down again about five o'clock and came up about eight o'clock. The condition got worse about five o'clock. There was more smoke and more heat. He went down about half-past eleven that night. It was still getting worse. He came about four o'clock in the morning. It was agreed to seal the pit up. They had a meeting in the office. Mr. Atkinson, Mr. Steele, Mr. Moore, and he dared he say half-a-dozen more. Mr. Henry was there too. It was decided that the only thing to do was to cut off the air. He agreed with that. The pit was closed. It was impossible to get down to the men, and they felt that the men were dead — he was absolutely certain that nobody was alive. On the 11th May everything was done that could possibly be done. Smoke helmets were used at eleven p.m., on the Thursday. If smoke helmets had been used before that they might have got to the fire but they could not have put it out. He had used smoke helmets himself. They had them and had six persons accustomed to them in each pit. The first time they went through the stopping was on the 12th June. It was started on the 12th, opened on the 15th, and closed again. They found it full of gas. The pit was opened on the 22nd September and had been open since. He could speak as to discovering the bodies. The first bodies found were John Dalton Lucas and Thomas McCourt. Next day they found 50 bodies, and next day 17. They found three writings on the door in No. 5. The message produced on a wooden sleeper was found near where 35 of the bodies were found in No. 5 level. He believed the writing was that of a man named Moore. There was no date on it. It ran "All's well in this air way at four o'clock; 35 men and boys," signed "J. Moore." They found two other messages on the wooden separation doors on No. 5 level, and were still there. There were two photographs of them. One of them ran "William Pray and James Lucas can't get any further." Another was "All's well at 6.30 J. McAllister"; and the third was "All right at 7.30, Wm. Robertson." That was all the writings they could find. The No. 6 men had nearly all their bait and water bottles full in each case. In No. 5 the bottles were partly empty and in some cases they leaked out. They found some broken lamps, especially 13 and 333. A lamp flame usually burned about 18 hours. The Coroner: You have heard it suggested that there are ways in which these workmen could have got out? Is there any way these workmen could have escaped? — None whatever, except by the friction-gear. There was a parallel road 25 yards away, and also a return road 40 yards away. About an hour sooner, about nine o'clock, the men could have got out. There were three fires practically in No. 3, one at the friction-gear, the second three-quarters of a miles in-bye going north, and the third in No. 3 North on the back road from No. 1 brake. Have you formed any opinion as to the cause? An explosion. Caused by what? — A gas explosion usually. What caused the gas explosion? Witness said at the top of No. 1 and No. 2 brake there was gas issuing from the coal, and a fall of roof in that place had probably wafted the gas out and probably it then got to a lamp which was either broken at the time or not in proper working order before that. Have you formed any opinion as to what caused the broken lamp? — No. Have the lamps been tested since? — They have. Examined by Mr. Redmayne: The deputy on the night shift inspected the lamps for the morning shift. The report was written after the men were admitted for the mine. There were two downcasts. One was 9ft. in diameter widening to ten; the other was nine feet, and the upcast was thirteen feet. The ventilation had been a serious problem with them all along and they were taking steps to improve it by means of a subsidiary fan being placed in-bye. There had never been an explosion in Wellington Pit in his time. You spoke in answer to the Coroner about the precautions to prevent the introduction of pipes, tobacco, and matches into the mines. Witness: I take it every man was examined before he went down into the pit. The lamps had undergone a high velocity test. When they sealed the pit they were absolutely certain every person in-bye side was dead. If they had reversed the air in No. 6 they might have driven it on to the fire. After ten or eleven o'clock on the Wednesday night they were certain the men could not be alive. He tried to go down the course indicated on the plan, but smoke was so bad that he lost his lamp, and the heat was intense. There was no means of getting water into the pit where the men were, and the only way was to carry it in. The water main was a mile and a half in-bye. Supposing the breathing apparatus had been at the top of the pit, and immediately available would it have been of use? Witness: If men had been sitting at the top with them on and there had been water in the pit to put out the fire it might have been of use. Supposing the men had walled themselves in and lived on the air — did you consider that possibility? Witness: We did. If we had got the air into the mine the fire would have increased in intensity. If they had walled themselves in until such time as the air was exhausted they were bound, in your opinion, to be killed by the fumes? Witness: Yes. The gases would have killed them. Since the explosion he had arrived at the opinion it would be a good thing to have water mains laid in the mine. The radiating point of the explosion was at Reed's place. Where an explosion started, the force was not great, but the radius of the force increased from there. He had examined the rest of the mine, and found no other radiating point. By Mr. Atkinson: They had proved coal in the Saltom district, but they hadn't won any yet. William and Wellington Pits were connected. Since the explosion William Pit men had gone through the Wellington Pit by the road shown. On the night of the explosion the weighman looked after the return air-way. What means of drawing men had you at these three shafts on the night of the explosion? Witness: The winding engine in one shaft and the use of the pumps in the others. Could you have drawn men by the upcast shaft? Witness was understood to say they could have rigged up a means if it had been possible to do so. The means of exit from Wellington Pit were William Pit and Bearmouth. The Court adjourned for luncheon at one o'clock and resumed at half-past one. Witness examined by Mr. J. B. Atkinson, explained a set of plans exhibited on the wall, and described the coal strata. Roughly the strata dipped on an average of 1 in 20. In some places it was 1 in 5. "Robbery" working was going on in No. 3 and No. 5. In No. 6 they were working the solid. Robbery consisted in taking out the pillars of coal. At the extremity of No. 3 a drift was being driven at the time of the accident. There were more men in No. 6 working than in any other. They had proved the coal in the Saltom district; and at the time of the accident they had put in an electric instalment for the haulage of that district, and which was also to drive the auxiliary fan. The intake of Wellington Pit was single along some parts of its length that the witness indicated on the plan, and at other places it was double. The return air-way was double near the pit shaft, and further in there was a portion of it that was double. The return air-ways from No. 3 were travelable. The evidence of that, that he had was that he had travelled them himself. If anyone had wanted to come out of their working places they could have done so by two distinct routes. Two of these were intakes. They had no horse haulage in the mine. It was entirely mechanical or hand-putting. The witness described the haulage by endless rope; and how wheels at the friction-gear directed the ropes in different directions. The subsidiary ropes went at half the speed of the main rope. The main rope travelled at three miles an hour for coal, and five miles when carrying men. The coal was carried in trains of tubs. These tubs deposited coal dust in the road. In addition to the mechanical haulage they had brakes, the full set coming down hauling up the empty set. When the coal was first worked it gave off gas freely, and it did so now in No. 6. When they got into "trouble" and entered a new seam they had had to stand for some time until the gas bled off. In an extensive goaf, that is where the coal had been worked out, there is almost bound to be gas. As regards the ventilation of the mine, the fan ran at 120 revolutions per minute. They had a water-gauge which indicated the pressure, and a record was also kept of the speed, by the fan engineman. They had measured the air at various points. Those were statutory measurements. They had also made measurements in connection with the subsidiary fan they were proposing to put in. There was a split of the air going along No. 3 level. Witness described on the plan the air-course in that level, and a regulator that sent the air round by No. 5 and No. 6. He described also the stoppings that were made for the purposes of the ventilation on No. 5 and No. 6. The stoppings were made of brick, with slag line. They were bound to have leakage, with any arrangement, but in this case the leakage was excessive. That was on account of the length of the roads and the old workings. Most difficulty was experienced in ventilating No. 6. Last year they stopped that district for a while, because the ventilation was not satisfactory. Virgin strata are damp, and at various points they had water feeders, which had the effect of making the road rather damp. The returns were moist and they had white fungus upon the wood. As regards coal dust he would say the pit was moderately dusty. The robbery coal was dry, after it had been standing for some years, and it was more friable. That would not get into the area of the explosion. But the dust was undoubtedly a source of danger. The water that was made in the main dip was brought out in water barrels and was used to keep the dust down. All the water in the pit is salt, and where the water has dried up on the road you can see the salt left. At the time of the explosion there were only three naked lamps in the pit, and these were at the bottom of the shaft. They used Acroyd and Bests' safety lamps, which burnt oil with a flash-point of 250 Fahrenheit. The lamps were automatic locked; as soon as they screwed it up it was locked. To unscrew it a strong electro-magnet had to be applied to the lamp. If a lamp went out in the pit it was sent by a boy to the lamp cabin down below, and the lamp locker examined it and re-lighted it. Witness did not know of any record being kept of the lamp glasses that were broken. They had never had shot-firing in the winning of their coal, and witness had no suspicion of such a cause in this case. They did use explosives in drifting. The men there were paid by shift, and the Company paid for the explosives. In the cross-cut drift they found no indication of any shot having been fired. All was just as it had been left by the last shift. So that any idea of shot-firing as a cause of the explosion had to be set aside. As regards communication, they had knocking at the shaft and telephone in-bye, fixed and portable. The barometer at the time of the accident was fairly high. He had no record as to the humidity of the air. The mine was inspected by the representatives of the men every quarter — a four day's inspection. He produced the book. The last inspection was made in March, and everything was reported in safe working order by J. Mulholland and J. Mathers. Witness never accompanied the men on their inspection. Witness described on the map the area affected by the explosion, and where the three fires were found — the two last ones being only known to have existed after the pit was reopened. There was no doubt that great force was exerted at the bottom of the brakes in No. 3. Beyond No. 2 brake the stoppings were intact. The force of the explosion had not gone in to No. 5 and No. 6. Witness was certain that the explosion originated in No. 3 North, and that No. 5 and No. 6 had nothing to do with it. The explosion seemed to have gone north from the south side of No. 1 brake. That limited the point of origin to three working places. In each of these working places three men were working, that is nine altogether. The men there were found in their working places and their lamps were lying beside them. He concluded that he explosion originated in Reed's working place — they were not working in their usual place; and witness suggested that the deputy have given them permission to work where they were. If it had been because of danger from gas that they were moved they were not moved into a safer place. If any gas came off the goaf Reed's place would be first passed over. A sort of oasis of comparative calm was shown at Reed's place; that was an additional reason why he thought the explosion originated at Reed's place. The Reed's and Garroway may have been alarmed and moved. There was no evidence on which to suspect matches. Two lamps were intact, and they were afterwards tested and stood the test. Two lamps were broken, and one of them, No. 130, was smashed to pieces. He could not say why. Coal might have fallen on it. Asked whether there was any peculiarity about any of the men working at Reed's place, witness said yes, he understood that Reed senior had only one eye. The rise of coal-dust would follow the firing of the gas, and it would travel as a dust explosion. If the 3rd north road had been kept free from dust, the majority of the men would have escaped. Examined by Mr. Redmayne, witness said he had seen a lamp explode without injury to it. Examined by Mr. Pope, witness said Mr. Steele was the certified and responsible manager of Wellington Pit. Since the Colliery Company had taken the mine, the workings had been developed considerably. Was these new workings developed under your advice? — I have been in the same position as now for eleven years. I have grown with the workings. The pit top fan was not in when witness came; it was put in about six years ago. It was always worked at the same gauge except when he had tried as an experiment to work at a higher gauge to reduce the leakage. That did not improve the ventilation of No. 6 level. It was the deputies duty to inspect all the working places, or the overmen's. There were just those two men. If there was gas found, it was their duty to report it without delay when they came up. He had no reason to think that that duty had been neglected with regard to the ventilation of the goaf. They had an office near the pit bottom. The report-book might have been kept at the lock shop near the friction-gear. The working places were inspected for the morning shift on the previous evening. The inspection had to begin two hours before the shift commenced. There had been no report of gas except twice in February and March, so that if there was gas on the 11th May that would be an exceptional occurrence? — Yes, it would. There did not appear to be any reports in the report-book of falls in No. 3 North. He had heard of one. Was there not a heavy fall a short time before this explosion? — I have heard of one. The overman and deputy had to inspect fifteen or sixteen working places. The men generally would not be acquainted with any way out of the mine except one. The overmen were all acquainted with the return-ways, which they frequently travelled. Mr. Redmayne pointed out that the report of gas on the 30th March was not entered in a special report-book, but in the general report-book. Mr. R. Steele, manager of the mine said that no one was withdrawn on account of gas. No one had ever been withdrawn on account of gas in his times. The Coroner said the special report-book ought to be put in. Mr. Rigby Swift said he would undertake to make inquiry into the matter, and if he found there was any other book dealing with gas it would be produced. The Coroner said if the book was not produced it would make a bad impression. Mr. Rigby Swift said Mr. Steele told him there was somewhere a withdrawal book, but as there had been no withdrawals there was nothing in it. That book would be produced. Mr. Chapman said there was a withdrawal book, but it had never been used. Mr. Richards called attention to this statement — that of all the reports that had been made in this mine there had never been any withdrawal of men from their working places. Mr. Rigby Swift: I did not make that statement; it was Mr. Blair. He did not intend to say, however, that the men went on working in the gas; he meant that the man was not withdrawn from the pit, but only from the working place. Mr. Herbert Smith asked if Mr. Blair meant that there was so small a quantity of gas in the workings that men could work in them with perfect ease and without danger. Mr. Blair: Not at all. Cross-examined by Mr. Richards, M.P.: Witness said he kept a barometer and had kept it for two years, and he produced the record of it to show what the effect would be upon the issue of gas. With a low barometer they would tend to have more gas. But it was a high barometer. On the 10th and 11th May his records were higher than those now produced to him by Mr. Richards. There was more than half-an-inch of fall between the 10th and 11th. That would have an affect upon the gas in the goaf. Mr. Richards: Your readings are twelve hours later on the 12th than the official record. How do you explain it? Mr. Blair: I cannot explain it. Mr. Richards: Are we to assume — and is the jury, the Coroner, and Mr. Redmayne to assume — that your diagram is incorrect; that instead of the responsible officials whose duty it is to take the record and enter it in the book, that Mr. Blair takes these readings. If so, they are hardly likely to attach as much importance to them as the one taken by the officials. The one is an official entry and the other is merely a domestic entry. Mr. Richards asked witness with regard to lamp 329 whether heat from within the lamp could have produced its condition, with the glass very much broken. Witness said he could not tell. Questioned as to report of gas, witness said that on the 9th, and 10th May, 1910, there were reports of gas in No. 5 North. As to No. 6 there were reports of gas there frequently in June and July. Witness got to the pit top on May 11th at quarter past ten and went down about a quarter to eleven. Helmets would have been of no use if they were there at ten o'clock. Wear and Kenmore came out, according to their evidence about ten o'clock. He still maintained his answer as to the helmets being useless after ten o'clock. Witness thought there ought to be helmets. They had had them at the Whitehaven Colliery Company since the accident. Supposing that the men at the top of the shaft and the bottom had been given some elementary instruction as to what ought to be done in case of accident, do you think that they might have put out the fire at the friction-gear? — Yes. I think they might. And have saved the lives of these men? — Yes. Have you ever thought that with your men so far in with your main haulage rope it would be perfectly easy to put on an ambulance van, an urgency van to be kept in a room at the bottom of the shaft? — I quite agree that there might be something in that. Government and everybody else seem not to have considered the common-sense arrangements that might be made for people underground as they are provided for people above ground. Would there be any more difficulty in running this van underground than in running an ambulance van in the streets of London? — Well, it is not very often the road will be clear of locomotion. Witness replied to other questions that he could not tell who first suggested going down the back dip Do you say there was danger in shutting off the ventilation from the main incline and sending it down this way? — Yes. If you had shut off the air from your main intake and diverted it into an opening in the back dip, would not it be likely to carry the whole thing round the return? — I am sure it would not. Why? — The stoppings were blown out; and the ventilation would naturally go to the fire; it would pass over the fire and go round the return. The Court adjourned at half-past four. Second Day (Yesterday). The inquiry was resumed at the Town Hall at half-past ten yesterday (Wednesday) morning. As on the previous day there was a considerable attendance of the widows and other female dependants of the deceased men. The Coroner announced that some of the jury thought half-an-hour was not long enough for the adjournment for luncheon. Therefore, he would make it three-quarters of an hour, and sit for a quarter-of-an-hour longer afterwards, making it a quarter-to-five instead of half-past four. If, it was probable, they would not be able to finish the inquiry by the 22nd. Mr. Redmayne had an important engagement in London; and the inquiry would be adjourned until the 29th. Mr. Rigby Swift suggested that the adjournment should be for a fortnight instead of a week, but this question was left open. The Coroner told Mr. Richards that he had subpoenaed the witness he asked for yesterday. Mr. Chapman said he had made careful inquiry as to a special report-book and found that the only dates on which there were withdrawals were August, 1899, and September, 1900. It appeared that this book was adopted then for the purpose of recording withdrawals, but afterwards the general report-book was used in substitution, and it had since been used in substitution. The rule requires that the report "shall be recorded in a book which shall be kept at the mine for the purpose." He submitted that that rule had been absolutely complied with. "A book" had been kept, and there would be found in it a faithful record of every discovery of gas in the past. At the numerous casualty inquiries that had occurred that particular book had been produced and had been admitted by the Coroner as satisfactory; it had also satisfied H.M. Inspector; and he thought he was right in saying that it had also satisfied the representatives of the employees, to whom that report-book was open, and by whom it was inspected. The Coroner: Put the book in, if you please? Mr. R. Steele, the manager of Wellington Pit, sworn, stated that this book now produced had never been used in his time. It came from the under-manager's office, Wellington Pit. Mr. Redmayne said he should like to be quite clear on the point. They had had it from the assistant general manager, Mr. Blair, that there never had been since he had been general manager a case of a man being withdrawn from a working place. A proper withdrawal report-book was kept in 1899 and 1900, when men were withdrawn; and they had it from the legal adviser of the manager that after that the other book was adopted. He wanted to ask Mr. Blair was he not right in supposing that the book now produced was the proper book? Mr. Blair: I could not say about that; I know nothing about that book. Mr. Redmayne: Well, I will leave it to Mr. Pope to probe the matter further and to see whether that book complies with the requirements, and whether it does not appear in it that a place has been examined, a man withdrawn, and the place stated to be safe and the man re-admitted. Mr. Richards said they had never seen this book before this morning, and he would reserve any questions until after Mr. Pope's examination. The Coroner: I quite agree. Mr. Rigby Swift said it would be as well to question the man who knew something about it, rather than Mr. Blair who did not. Mr. Richards, M.P., said that yesterday he pointed out a discrepancy between Mr. Blair's barometrical records for May 10th and May 11th and the official records of the pit. It was only fair to state that since then he had received the records of the Meteorological Office, and they were very similar to Mr. Blair's and dissimilar to the records in the report-book of the colliery. He hoped that Mr. Blair or Mr. Steele would make inquiry why the colliery record should differ. Mr. Blair's cross-examination was then continued by Mr. Richards, M.P. He replied to questions that he was present when Mr. Atkinson, H.M. Inspector, gave orders for suspending operations. Mr. Atkinson did give his reason for that order. Mr. Atkinson's reason was that he considered the matter so hopeless, and that if operations were continued there would probably be another 100 men killed. They were a large party at that time. No one suggested when Mr. Atkinson gave that order, that there was some hope if the operations were continued. They all agreed with Mr. Atkinson — all that were in the office; and at the time Mr. Atkinson gave the order there was no comment made by anyone, to witness's knowledge. After getting Mr. Blair to repeat the story of the finding of the chalked messages. Mr. Richards continued: Now I don't know that there is any great importance to the attached to the question that I am desired to put, but when do you suggest that the first message, "6.30" was written. There is no possibility of absolutely knowing; but what time do you suggest? Witness: 6.30 a.m., on the 12th; the next will be 7.30 on the morning of the 12th; and the message on the sleeper at 4 a.m. on the 12th. I want to suggest to you, Mr. Blair, that there is reasonable cause for a difference of opinion. You naturally, without any suggestion of mine, put the first message at 6.30 a.m. and the next at 7.30 a.m., and for some reason, when you get 100 yards further in-bye, you come back to four o'clock in the morning. Now isn't it feasible that the first message was written at 6.30 a.m., the next an hour later, 7.30 a.m., and that the four o'clock message was the last attempt, and was made at four o'clock in the afternoon? — I don't; think so. I will tell you why. When Wear and Kenmore came through this message was already written; and these men said they could not get through. Yes, but at four o'clock the whole of these men were congregated in this air-way. Does not it appear that that most have been their last message? I don't think so. Well, I am suggesting that. It is said they could not have had any light so long after the explosion — 24 hours afterwards, assuming the lamps were lit at four o'clock in the afternoon of the 11th. Was it possible that they might have had light? — It is possible. Their lamps may have burned 24 hours? — They may. It is suggested that men in that position would be very careful and conserve their light as much as possible? — That is likely. We have had no evidence as to the cause of the death of these men; but supposing the cause of death is carbon dioxide, how could that get in to them? — Well, it is heavier than air and it would naturally go right down to No. 6 and then get into No. 5. It would take a long time? — It would not take so long, judging from the men found in No. 6. Witness proceeded to reply to questions. There is one overman for each shift who has supervision of the three districts working; and there is one deputy and one assistant in each district for each shift. So that in No. 3 district there was a deputy and an assistant. The body of the overman had been found at the friction-gear. The body of the deputy had been found, but not that of the assistant; the deputy was found on the right hand side off No. 2 brake. Witness, when he had measured the air, had not done so in the presence of the men's representatives. The master wasteman would speak to the measurement of air made in the presence of the men's representatives. He would be called as a witness. They had no water within half-a-mile out-bye of the friction-gear; but they had a constant supply of water about 600 yards in-bye. It came from a fault, and was siphoned from that place and taken in-bye by the main road. Every twelve hours they filled 18 barrels each containing 300 gallons. No. 3 road was dusty. The dust was collected every week. There were heaps of dust along the level. The effects of the explosion were seen to be about 140 yards out-bye of the friction-gear. It did not go further towards the shaft because the road was rather wet in some places and it was clean. There would not be large quantities of coal-dust lodging in the crevices and upon the timber, except at the pit bottom. If it was suggested that every crevice of the sandstone rock was full of coal dust at the present moment he could not contradict it, but he had not seen it. Very well, then, we must be thankful for the wet area on the incline for preventing this disastrous explosion going further up towards the shaft? — Yes. I am satisfied about that. Has that suggested to you a remedy for preventing the occurrence of these dust explosions? — Yes, it has. That is watering certain sections of the road on the main level. You think if you had a similar wet area completely saturated with water, you would stop coal-dust explosions? — I agree with you. You told us yesterday that you set up a theory that the explosion originated in Reed's place, and that your reason for coming to that conclusion is that there had been a considerable radiation of force from there? — That is correct. I did not find any other place with similar indications. Shall I suggest that the same is to be found from the friction-gear to No. 3 level? — I have not found that. The force came down No. 3 engine plane and some went to the right and left as it came along the engine plane. Mr. Richards: I suggest that when you have more experience of force you will not speak so confidently. Have you had any experience of coal-dust explosion? — I have never been in one. Have you had any experience on investigating them? — Yes. Where? — William Pit, over three years ago. Was it a coal-dust explosion? — No, a gas explosion. Have you had any other experience? — No other. Reed's place was the highest point, and the gas would be more highly charged there than at any other point. His theory was that there must have been a fall of roof in the goaf, sending out the gas that collected there, on to the lamp of one or other of the Reed's lamps, and that that caused the explosion. He attached no importance to the fact that one of the Reed's had only one eye. There was a mark on one of the lamps there that might have been caused by a pick. And do you make the suggestion that a fall took place in the goaf and drove out the gas and that at that precise psychological moment some on struck his lamp with his pick? — It might happen. Mr. Richards: The only possible way as advanced by you is that a fall of roof took place in the goaf, driving the gas out, and at that particular fraction of a second this man struck this lamp? — Witness: Or it was broken by coal. Might be either. Mr. Richards: Well, we will put it that either from the pick or from a fall at this particular moment the lamp was broken? — Witness: Something like that. How many lamps during a course of years do you think will be struck by workmen? — I could not tell you that at all. Would there be a very large number? — I never heard of one before. Never heard of a lamp being struck by the pick of a miner? — Not in Wellington Pit. Then I am afraid it is not any use my prosecuting my question on that point any further. So that we have to leave it that you will say that there was a possibility of that occurring through the fall of the lamp or a workman striking it with a pick at just that particular moment? — Well, there might be. One chance for that. Don't you think there are many more millions against it? — I would not like to express an opinion any further. Now you told us yesterday Mr. Blair that you had seen lamps shattered by gas? — Yes. Do you still tell us that? — Yes. An experiment. Where? — In Belgium. Ah, well, they were German make I suppose were they? (Laughter.) I do no think we need follow your Belgium experiment. Was that in a swift current of gas or a still atmosphere? — In a swift current. In reply to further questions from Mr. Richards, witness said that the effects to recover the remaining bodies were being pushed on continuously. Mr. Richards said he wanted to say that he should like if possible that the splendid record of exploration and recovery of the bodies that must be attributed to Mr. Steele and Mr. Blair and the whole of the officials in connection with this disastrous explosion would not be marred by any relaxation of those efforts in getting those bodies that remained. Mr. Hanlon: At the present time you are well equipped with the Meco apparatus? — Witness: We are. Would you still say if as well equipped on the night of the 11th May you could not have done more useful work after eleven o'clock? — I say that, yes. In reply to Mr. Swift, witness said he was in the pit from a quarter to ten o'clock on the Wednesday night until four o'clock on Thursday afternoon continuously and during that time was doing what he could to control the fire. He was one of those who went in when the stopping was opened on the 21st June, and went in as far as he could with the breathing apparatus. Have you been doing your best to assist in bringing people out of the mine? — I have. Has your own life been in danger? — Many times. Have you ever considered any personal danger to yourself or had any desire except to do what you could to relieve those who might be imprisoned? — No. In reply to Mr. Chapman, witness said that when the decision was come to seal up the mine the inspectors were present and representatives of the men also. And again when the messages were discovered below Mr. Richards and Mr. Hanlon were there. On the occasion when he went in with the Meco apparatus he was so exhausted that he came out part of the way on his hands and knees. Mr. Smith: Do I understand you to say that the workmen were represented when it was decided to seal up the pit? Witness: Mr. Hanlon was there. If Mr. Hanlon denies it what then? We have someone to prove it. Mr. Hanlon denies it? — All right. Witness was then examined at some length by Mr. Pope as to the duties and responsibilities of the overmen — that they were required to inspect and report on the conditions of the workings before each shift went down and during the work of the shifts. Witness said he did not consider that the conditions referred to under rule seven did not have reference to different conditions from those referred to under rule four. He thought the report made was quite sufficient, though a special book might be better. So far as the carrying on of work is concerned the presence of a cap not exceeding a certain amount would not prevent the deputy allowing the men to work. Say half an inch of cap would be safe. Mr. Redmayne: May I ask in all seriousness if you always have a cap? — Yes, it is always present at the face. Mr. Atkinson: At the highest point? — Yes. Mr. Pope: I want to get the exact practice from you. The overman's duty is to go in and inspect the working places and the management are compelled to reply upon his discretion and care as to the admission of the men into the working places? — Yes. The whole safety of the pit, not only as regards property but as regards the men is resting upon the shoulders of the deputies and overmen, who have a charge of the daily inspections? — That is right, yes. And they have to keep the management informed? — Yes. And their information has daily to be recorded at once? — Yes. Now then the practice is that the men work although the atmosphere may show gas? — Yes, in the face, but if you go into the return you will not find gas. Will the fact that the ventilation does not keep the places clear and the men work there throw additional responsibility on the deputies, especially in inspection during the shift more than it would have been if the rule of the pit was not to work where there is any show of gas? — Yes. In reply to further questions, witness said if a place became badly foul it would be the first duty of the deputy to withdraw the men and they would withdraw themselves if the deputy was not there. If men were so withdrawn that would be regarded as an incident so serious as to require special report in the report required by rule 7 in cases of dangerous conditions. Referring to certain reports that had been made witness said he thought the words "all right" in such and such levels might have been extended a little. As it stood there was nothing to show whether there was a slight show or any show of "gas" or a half inch cap in any particular working place. Mr. Richards: Do you suggest that at any time workmen are permitted to continue working in a place where the deputy can see a half inch cap of gas? — At any time right up against the face they have half an inch of gas. What percentage of gas would be present when you have a half inch cap? — About 4½ per cent. What is the explosive mixture? — About seven per cent. Seven? — About six and two-thirds per cent, if you want it exactly. Isn't it six? — No, it is not. Mr. Redmayne interposed that it was taken to be 6.1. Witness: I am quoting Professor Galloway's figures (Laughter) After a few further questions as to working on the edge of the goaf chiefly referred to Mr. Steele, Mr. Blair examination was closed. The Coroner said he would like to express his opinion that every praise was due to Mr. Blair for his untiring efforts and bravery on the night of the 11th May and for many hours on the 12th, at the risk of his own life, and here was a remarkable coincidence that he had been prevented by accident from going down with the night sift on the 11th. THOMAS HALL, deposed that he was a fan man working at Wellington Pit, and he had worked in the colliery for 40 years. He had been at Wellington Pit about three years and two out of the three working at the fan. He was working 11 hours on the day shift and 13 hours on the night shift. He was working on the night shift on the 11th May last, and went to work at five o'clock. He had another man with him named Graham. Witness said there was no alteration on the running of the fan on the evening of the 11th May, at the time between seven and eight when it was thought the explosion took place. DANIEL BENN deposed that he was a rope splicer, and looked after the electric signals for the Whitehaven Colliery Company, in Wellington Pit. He had been there 16 years. He was at work on the 11th May last, and went down to work about twenty minutes to eleven a.m. He came up about ten minutes to eight. The Coroner: Did you notice anything wrong as regards the working before you ascended the shaft? Witness :— Yes, sir. About what time was it? — Twenty minutes to eight. What was there? — A reversion of the air current. In reply to further questions witness said there were other men with him, fifty or sixty, going off the shifts and walking one behind the other. He was about two hundred yards from the pit bottom when it occurred. Immediately he got to the pit bottom he rang up the telephone and told the engineman to send for Mr. Henry. The engine man told him in answer to what he said to him that the hammer of the haulage signal was against the bell. What then? — I told him to ring in to the friction gear and see if he could get anyone on. Witness added that whilst he was standing about three yards from the pit bottom three men came running from the cross over points about 400 yards from the pit bottom. They said there was something wrong but they did not know what it was. The Mining Disaster The Adjourned Inquest (Continued From Page 7.) The air was still reversed, and when the other men had gone up witness went. Witness had no a watch but he considered the time would be about 38 minutes from the time they left work. That was not always the ordinary time, but they were expecting a good ride that night. He went up the pit, and when he got to the pit top they told him about dust coming up. A man called Skelton remarked it. Witness did no stop. He went right off to the fan engine-house and there he saw Mr. Henry and told him what had occurred — that the air current was reversed and there was something wrong. That might be ten minutes after witness had signalled from below. Mr. Henry was talking to the engineman. He went out and left witness who went into the fan-house. As far as he and the engineman could see all was right there. Witness came out from there and still having his lamp he went to the pit top. Mr. Henry was standing there with his lamp and said he had sent for the air course key. Witness said he had one in his pocket, and Mr. Henry said then they would go down, and they went down about fifteen minutes from witness's coming up. When they got to the bank bend they examined the separation doors there and they were all right, and witness had previously noticed when they got to the bottom that the air was going in the right direction. It was also perfectly right in the return airway when they examined that. Witness continued to answer that he went down with Mr. Henry. When they got to the separation doors at Benk's Turn they had a telephone message from John Lupton, who was outside the pit, that he had heard word from John Douglas that he could not see for dust. They went on and they met Douglas at the right side of Saltom, who had a lad named Ferryman with him. Mr. Henry asked Douglas what was wrong in there; and Douglas said he did not know, but there were two men lying dead at Benk's Turn. Douglas appeared to be all right. Mr. Henry requested that Douglas go back, but Douglas said he could not go back as he was done out. Mr. Henry then gave him instructions to send word to Mr. Steele and his son, Willy Henry, to bring some men. Witness did not hear all that was said. They went on from that point to the separation doors at pike scuttle, and they went in and examined the return side at that point. He smelt "styph" there, but the air was all right. Mr. Henry thought it was a bit warm. They came out again and they were found by John Willans, who had overtaken them. They went to Benk's Turn; and at the place two men were lying unconscious, Stephen Gregory and Joseph Walker. In about fifteen minutes they brought Gregory round. It must have been after-damp from which they were suffering. Willans and Lupton walked Gregory out, and Mr. Henry and he started respiration with walker. After they got him conscious they gave him a drink of water, and the linked him out, but they would be forty minutes over Walker, before they restored him to consciousness. Neither of the men made any statement as to what caused them to be unconscious. They had been about 55 minutes restoring these two men. They left the shaft at five minutes to eight, and then they had to walk in and had been 55 minutes in addition over these men. After they walked Walker out they met Dr. Harris and six or seven other men coming in. On returning they walked about 100 yards and saw lights ahead. Witness shouted "Hello," and there was a reply "Hello". Witness asked "Where are you from?" He said "No. 5." Witness asked "Where are the others." He said "In No. 5." "What are they doing there?" The friction-gear is afire," he said. The lights proved to be those of Wear and Kenmore, who had come out. By that time Mr. Henry had arrived and witness began putting up the telephone wire that was down, so that they might communicate with any point towards the shaft. On his return to the party he found that they had seen smoke a little in advance of them. That was just at the low side of the fan site. Wear went back with Mr. Henry. When witness got down to the smoke there was a bit of conversation, and then as they could not get down the front dip, a man was told to watch the smoke coming up the intake and they tried the back way. Witness did not know how far they got, but they had to call them back or else the smoke was going to get ahead at the place they went in at. They came back and went to the fan site and broke a hole to let the smoke into the return at that point. That was as far as they could get and witness broke the connections of the wire there; and they telephoned for brattice cloth, hammers, nails, and so on. These were sent down. Witness came up the shaft about two o'clock in the morning for a telephone bell, but he went down again, and it was half past one in the afternoon of the 12th before he got up again. It was the smoke and heat that prevented them going further. Could anyone have done more than was done during the time you were down? — No, sir. I question the assertion that we could have got in any sooner than we did. Why do you contradict the assertion? — Simply because we had to examine the air-way, and we had to those two men to restore, and then we had the smoke to contend with, and we could not penetrate it. Cross-examined by Mr. Atkinson: I thought at first that the reversal of the air was due to a fall of stone. Cross-examined by Mr. Richards: When you got down to the two men did you not think it was wise to telephone for help? — We had already sent word before that. But the telephone was quicker? — Well, I thought we had sent for men already, and we had walked a mile in-by after that before we got to these men. Because it is rather a long time, 55 minutes to be with those men and every minute was precious? — Well, I might have telephoned first when I landed, but we considered that having sent word that was all that was required, because we were sure they would have got word. You see every minute is precious? — Yes. And you had you already been told that two men were dead, when you met Douglas and Willans, you did not think it necessary to telephone then? — No. There was no smoke when Wear and Kenmore came through, but after they had got through the smoke was there. Asked if he had ever known open paraffin lamps used at the fan site, witness said he believed the fitters had used paraffin lamps there. Do you think that everything that possibly could be done that particular night was done, before Wear and Kenmore came through? — So far as I am concerned, as a would-be rescuer, I did not waste one moment. I am not wanting to make a personal reflection, because you were not responsible; but do you think that being satisfied something was wrong you should not have taken somebody else with you in case of emergency? — I consider we did our best. Well, I put it this way, and I would like an answer yes or no, supposing seven or eight men were with you and Mr. Henry, would not they have been of advantage to leave with these men while you proceeded forward? — I believe they would. Is it possible, is it not, that seeing that Wear and Kenmore came out, you might have got past the friction-gear. In fifty-five minutes would not it have been possible for you and Mr. Henry to have got down to the friction-gear? — We might. And probably have been able to put the fire out? — I hardly think so. And of course, if it had been possible to put the fire out 85 men would have been saved? — Yes, If we had been able to put the fire out. But assuming Mr. Henry and I could have put the fire out, what about Wear and Kenmore should they not have put it out? Well, if we are going to argue it, you must remember that Wear and Kenmore got out coming up the incline, and they would be excited? — We were excited as well. Don't say that, because we shall be told that a no responsible person should lose his head at a moment like that? — Oh no, I am not talking of losing heads; there was nothing of that. Don't you think Mr. Henry and you might have been of more use at the friction-gear than those exhausted men? — They were not exhausted when they reached us. Quite composed, were they? — Yes. Wear told me that they got through and sat down at the high side of the friction-gear, 25 yards from where the fire was, so that there could not have been much smoke then. Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: The reversal of the air was noticed when he was walking the last 200 yards to the pit shaft. A number of men came out at the same time. They noticed it, too. Those men did not offer to go back. They went up the pit and went home. We met Douglas and Ferryman when we were about two miles in, and they told us there were two men lying dead at Benk's Turn. We could not telephone that there and then. We were some distance from any point where we could telephone — 600 yards was the nearest. In the meantime two men were going out-by by whom we sent for help. By Mr. Richards: There is a caution board at the pit top that naked lights are not to go beyond that point. JOSEPH WALKER, Ribton Lane, Whitehaven, said he was a roadman in Wellington Pit, and had worked in the Whitehaven Colliery Company since before the Colliery Company took it, and nearly all that time in Wellington Pit. On the night of the 11th May witness was working at Benk's turn. Stephen Gregory was with him. They were working in different sections of the road. All went right till about twenty minutes to eight. Stephen Gregory had a watch. When the last lot of men rode out witness said to Gregory, "That will be the last ride," and Stephen looked at his watch. About a minute after that the rope started again; then, all at once the air rushed out-bye. It did not take any effect upon us at first. I put my hand out to feel the current and felt it going out, as long as I could remember. I was near the telephone, but I could not have telephoned. The wires would not knock. The out-rush of air had caused that. About ten minutes before the signal wires were all right. In about five minutes I felt as if I was going asleep. My marrow asked what it was, and I said it was an explosion. I could not have moved away if I had tried. I lost consciousness. Gregory had previously asked me what to do, and I told him to put his jacket over his head. He said he had not his jacket and I told him to put his cap over his mouth. I don't know which of us went over first. The first thing I remember after becoming conscious was seeing Mr. Henry. I was then perhaps 200 or 300 yards further out-by, and I was being taken out attended by Mr. Henry. I was linked perhaps 200 or 300 yards and then put into a tub and brought up. Gregory came up the pit with me. I had never known a reversal of the air in the same way before, and had never been similarly affected. When I got to the pit bottom Mr. Steele gave me a drink of something that revived me terribly. By Mr. Atkinson: I did not feel any heat. Before I lost consciousness; but there was buzzing and a whirling noise all the time, and the dust was very thick. Our lamps were burning as long as I can remember, but I could scarcely see, it was so thick. I saw the riding set pass me. STEPHEN GREGORY, Newhouses, roadman, said he had worked in Wellington Pit for 34 years. He gave similar evidence to that of the last witness. He did not feel any heat or smoke. JOHN WEAR, Lowther Row, Ginns, coal hewer, said he had worked at Wellington Pit for about 17 years. On the 11th May he was working there on the night shift. He went down about five o'clock and proceeded in to work in No. 5 High North with his son and William O'Pray. They started working about half past six, and the continued working till about twenty minutes or a quarter to eight. They left the place together. They all stopped in the working till they were told to come out. That would be about eight o'clock. They all came out together. His lad was coming down from working with a full tub, and he stopped to put a locking in, and he said there was a lot of air coming through the working. Hugh McAllister, the overman, went out to see what was the matter, and sent in to the men to tell them all to come out, as there was something wrong. They then all gathered at the air-splitting. There would be about 27 of them altogether. The deputy, Hugh McAllister, went out and said there was no chance of anybody getting out there, there was that much smoke between the doors, but they might try the return. He led them all by the return; but when they got so far on the return way they had to come back again. McAllister fetched them back; he said it was too hot to go any further and they all agreed with him, because there was black damp on the road; it put one or two lamps out. So they came back and went back to the air-splitting again. A few of them sat down and had their bait. A boy came up while they were sitting and said it was far cooler up there than it was on the main road. "Then," witness said, "there's bound to be something wrong." They went down, and when they got to the bottom there was his marrow, Will O'Pray and John Lucas, who went out, and witness asked them and they said it was terrible thick out there. Witness said it would be far better if somebody kept going backwards and forwards, so that they might get to know what it was. Witness said, "I'll go up if anybody will volunteer to come with me. I'd go up and try to come back again. They were then at the bottom of the air-split, all together." Kenmore said, "I'll go with you." So they came out to the door, Kenmore and I. They all stopped back. Nobody else would come. So we travelled on. Did you arrange you would go back? — No; we did not say anything about going back. We did not know whether we would get back. We got about two pillars above the friction gear. That was the end of the smoke. There was fire at the friction-gear — on the left hand side; there was none on the right. We sat down to get round for a minute or two, and then travelled up the brow. Could not you have gone back to those that you had left? — We would never have got back. Why? — Why, it was bad enough to come through it. Were you suffering as you went through it to the friction-gear? — Yes; we were done up when we got there. When we afterwards started off, Will Henry was the first man we met. Witness shouted "hello!" and he shouted "hello!" back. His father then shouted down from the top of the brow on reaching them. Witness told them who he was. He then said what is wrong on the high side? Do you know what is wrong? Witness answered and said there had been an explosion in the friction-gear. The Coroner: How far were you from the friction gear when you met Henry? — I could not just say as to the distance. Witness, continuing, said that Henry said he would go on. Witness said "We are not very strong, but if you think we can do any good we will go back." They went back and found smoke coming from the friction gear right up to where they are putting the new fan in. Witness remained with them and then Kenmore and he walked from the friction gear back to he shaft. It was a long distance, and it would be about twelve o'clock when they got up. The first time he noticed anything wrong was when his son had said there was something wrong. He looked at his watch to get a chew of bacco, and it was then a quarter or twenty minutes to eight. By Mr. Redmayne: When they came out into the intake it was full of smoke. They could not form any opinion as to where it had come from. When they got to the friction gear they could not see where the fire was, but it was making sufficient smoke to account for the smoke they had met in coming out of the intake in the fifth north. When he left the men and travelled to the friction gear the nearer they got to the friction gear the worse it got. When he left the men he did not mention going back. He went to see if he could get assistance; they did not know how far they were going to get. No arrangement was come to at all. They did no say they would wait until witness came back. When he got to the friction gear the props were on fire. He did not notice any oil or grease barrels in coming up. He did not know whether he stepped over any bodies. He could not put out the fire, as he had nothing to do it with but his hands, and it was right up to the roof. By Mr. Atkinson: He could not say what time he landed at the friction gear coming in-by. It might be six o'clock. He took part of his clothes off, and his lamp was examined by the joiner — he thought it was Mat Wilson. Benjy Cowie was not there. Witness was in the first set that went in-by. McAllister, their deputy, came in after them. He saw the deputy of the previous shift in the fifth north. He thought he was Wilson. He would not like to say whether he saw him at the friction gear. They generally saw a deputy at the friction gear, who told them whether the place was all right or not. They saw one on the 11th May. They had filled eight-tubs before they felt the explosion. He felt no waft of air. He told the boy to stand there and they filled an empty tub. They did not know what had happened. Going out into the return they went on the level. Two lamps went out there. His lamp was burning dim. McAllister was leading them. Then they all turned back. In going up this friction gear they found a lot of disturbance, steps blown out. The disturbance increased as they got near the friction gear — tubs were on top of each other. They could not see into third north as the fire was on that side. The fire and smoke was coming right down. It was, he thought only wood that was burning at the time. He knew there had been an explosion as he was coming up, but he did not know where it had begun. When he got to the friction gear he said to Kenmore that was where the explosion had come from — No. 3. As they came up they saw a little light, like a cinder, burning close to the friction gear, on the right side. There was a bigger fire on the left of the third north. As to the first fire he did not know what was burning — it might be rope. There were no flames. Anyone might have put that out, but the other one was more serious. There was a message in-by on a door of No. 5 North, written by O'Pray and Lucas. The accident happened at 7.40; he filled a tub after that and the men collected at the Split about eight o'clock. They stopped a little until Hugh McAllister donned his clothes and set off at 8.5 p.m. By the time they travelled along the return as far as they went and back again it would be 9.10 p.m. Kenmore and he waited until about 9.35 and then they started to come out. They landed at the friction gear at ten minutes past ten. He had a watch and looked. They met the men coming in-by at 10.30 p.m. When they left the fifth north junction they did not see any sixth north men, only two from the junction. If the sixth north men had come out directly the explosion happened at 7.40 p.m. they would have been out of the pit before the witness started. Witness said to Kenmore "if only we could put this fire out we could save the men's lives below." Kenmore replied "You can't; you have nothing to do it with." After passing the friction gear he found his own coat, which he had left. It was singed. By Mr. Pope: He had worked in the pit 17 years in all the districts from the third to the sixth north. He had been troubled in his working places with gas many times. He had had most trouble in the third north level where the explosion came from. He knew how to test for gas, and had done it may a time, but would not do it every day as a matter of practice. He had never been supplied with a copy of the special rules, and had never seen them. Mr. Pope read the rule which specified that each workman must satisfy himself of the safety of his own working place before commencing and while at work. Witness did not do that every day. Mr. Pope said that a deputy had to visit the working at least not more than two hours before work was commenced, so that some little time might elapse between his visit and the time the workmen went in, so that it was meant that the men might satisfy themselves that everything was right before they began. Mr. Pope: When you have found gas what are the size of the caps? — Maybe an inch. What are your instructions on these occasions? — On, just work away. (Sensation.) Mr. Redmayne: Has the deputy ever withdrawn you from your working for gas? No, they never withdraw. Mr. Pope: On the occasions he had drawn the deputy's attention to it he had never seen them do anything, but the men said that they stopped their "marrows" coming in. Mr. Pope: They let you finish your shift, but stop others. If you are stopped out of your place you don't get so much wages, and so long as it is safe you prefer to work? — Not if they will find us another place. Mr. Pope read the special rule which laid it down that anyone observing at any time a diminution of the ordinary quantity of air, or any inflammable gas, or dangerous symptoms in the roof or sides, or an unusual quantity of water or other source of water, shall at once cease work and report the same to his immediate superior. In reply to Mr. Pope as to his experience of the presence of gas on former occasions, witness mentioned one occasion which owing to the presence of gas the light was lost and the men were told to go on and do the best they could, and stone stops would be put in on the level to try to get them air. There was a loud demonstration of approval from the back of the court on this statement of the witness. Witness continuing, said that was some years ago under another manager. When he had found gas in his working place he had found it up against the roof. He had found a good lot of gas. The total height of his working place would be about ten feet and the corbench four or five feet. In many places standing on the top of that he could touch the roof with his head. What depth of gas have you found? Would it go down a foot? — Yes. I have seen it go lower than that. You can catch the gas before you get within two feet of the roof. When that has happened have you still gone on working? — No, we have reported it, and finished out shift. In reply to further questions, witness said there was gas in the far brake, which was brought down by falls and that drove them out of the far brake. The last time he was working there was seven or eight months before the explosion. They were driven out, deputy, joiners, and every one. This place had never been started again; they were standing yet. In reply to Mr. Smith, witness said one of the messages was written on the door before he came away, one with the two names. In witness's opinion the message on the sleeper was last written. The 35 men witness, along with Mr. Smith saw found, he left a little further in-bye. There was a little bit of smoke coming into the place where they found the men. Witness had his light when he came out. It had not gone out. It was the general practice of the pit to put the lamps on the floor. He had never been told by a deputy or manager that he should not put his lamp on the floor. He had been told to come out of a place by a deputy because it was not safe. That was in March last. Neither he nor anybody else felt comfortable when there was a cap of an inch on his lamp. In reply to the Coroner, the witness said he had no dispute nor quarrel with the Colliery Company, and for anything he knew was still in their employ. The inquiry was at this point adjourned to 10.30 a.m. to-day.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||