Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th October 1910

The Royal Commission In Cumberland

Working Conditions Of Metalliferous Mines

Some Advocated And Suggested Improvements

The Royal Commission appointed by the Government commenced their sitting at the Town Hall, Egremont, on Thursday morning, for the purpose of inquiry, and taking evidence with regard to the conditions and working arrangements in the Metalliferous Mines and Quarries of the district.

The Commission present was constituted of Sir Henry Conynghame, K.C.B. (chairman), Messrs. J. S. Ainsworth, M.P., R. A. S. Redmayne, R. M. Greaves, T. Arthur Thomas (Wales), W. Lewney (Furness District), P. Lovett, general secretary of the National Union of Quarrymen, T. Jones, general secretary of the North Wales Slate Quarrymen's Union, and Dr. Haldane, with Mr. T. R. Bettany (secretary).

Other notable personages present were: Mr. W. Burnyeat, (Whitehaven), Mr. W. J. D. Burnyeat (Whitehaven), Mr. B. T. Helder (Seascale), Mr. W. Dixon (Cleator Moor), Mr. W. Casson (St. Bees), Mr. W. Leck (Inspector of Mines), Mr. W. R. Walker (Woodend), Mr. G. Scoular (St. Bees), Mr. Myles Richardson (Egremont), Mr. J. Adair (Beckermet), Mr. T. Gavan Duffy (Moor Row), and others.

The first witness called was Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, general secretary of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miner's and Kindred Trades Association, who stated in reply to the Chairman's questions that the membership of the Association was 2,500, which was about one-third of the total of the working miners employed in the district. He had been secretary of the Association for three years, but he did not come before them as a professional miner. He had been a journalist and author, which was his profession. For a short time he had been a clothing designer. He had only been underground in a mine once, as there was no excess or liberty given to him to go underground. He estimated the total number of pits in the district at 30 or 39, and there were 25 iron ore pits. Their Association had the membership of the men in the majority of the pits, with the exception of three small pits, and these they did not intend to cater for.

Mr. Duffy here handed Sir Henry a tabulated number of replies to letter.

Witness, continuing, said he had submitted the whole of the suggestion's (produced) to the Council or governing body of the Association. They had not been put before the working miners at a meeting, and they had not been published in any form.

Sir Henry pointed out that he wished to take the local questions first, as it was what he came there for. The object he had in their coming there was to see principally the local conditions of the place, and principally to deal with questions that legally affect the trade and industry, and there was the double shaft question for instance which was an important one. He should like to hear first of all what he had to say on the double shafts.

Mr. Duffy replied that he was sure and certain that a second shaft ought to he put on every mine for emergency of exit, so that a man could get out of the pit in case of the winding arrangements of the cage going wrong.

The Chairman said they thought that vital, but did not involve a double shaft.

Witness: It would be for ventilation and for the safety of the men that a double shaft would be necessary. They should not do that before minerals were found, but when the pit was improved and a large number of men were in the mine, then the Secretary of State would be advised who ought to have power to compel the sinking of a double shaft. The cost of sinking a double shaft in the mine varied according to the ground the Company had to go through, but it was not a question of money, but for the safety and saving of the lives of men.

The Chairman: You don't consider any coalmine any more reason to have a double shaft than a Metalliferous mine? There is exceptions as there are mines adjacent to each other, and it is possible to get exit without a second shaft.

Witness further stated there were liabilities of falls and floods, and floods were more frequent in an iron ore mine than in a coalmine. A ladder being the means of exit was a system rather antiquated, when they considered getting say 200 men up a ladder. He wished to strongly emphasise the fact, and it was the wish of the whole of the miners of the district that there should be prominence given to a double shaft as certainly a second means of exit. He did not know whether a double shaft would affect the trade and industry, that he was of the opinion that saving life was the great human asset.

Dealing on the question of changing houses for miners.

Mr. Duffy said if proper accommodation was not provided, they should compel them to have proper facilities for changing.

The Chairman: You would go so far as to have them before the magistrate, if they had not proper changing facilities? — I would go that far.

Continuing, witness said his view on the matter represented 90 per cent of the miners that there ought to be a changing house sufficiently large enough to provide accommodation for all the men in the employ, and that the house should be in two departments, one for washing, and the other for changing in, and that there should be a continual supply of hot and cold water. In some of the cases accommodation was good but insufficient. In others it was a beasture. How many cubic feet they would require would depend upon how many men were employed, and the size of the mine, and what shifts they worked in the pit? Consequently he thought it would be reasonable to ask the employer's to provide accommodation of one tub for every three men.

The Chairman said he might say that that matter had been discussed by the Commission, as he (Mr. Duffy) knew.

Mr. Duffy: Yes, but I think the owners ought to provide that accommodation without a subscription on the men. There is a charge made at some pits of sixpence a fortnight, so that the change-house provided for the men was a very profitable thing for the Company. (Laughter). Witness went on to say that the ventilation of the district was not good generally at the pits. In the case of men firing shots it was common knowledge that the oxygen destroyed for the time being, and there was a certain amount of gas produced. The breathing air of the men was bad. Witness gave an instance of the bad air of the pit in quoting the case of a man named Butler, who worked at Winder Gill Pit, Frizington, and who dropped down in the mine. That was not many months ago, and two men had also died in the pit. In both cases the men had suffered from bad air. The man Butler collapsed in the mine through bad air. He fell down and was only discovered in the working by accident.

Mr. Lewney: Was not that due to fumes of oil from the engine in the shaft? — And bad air.

Witness added that if the air had been good it would have carried the fumes away. The man himself complained of the bad air, but even if the air had been good it would have carried the bad air away. Butler was under the doctor for many weeks. Several other cases had occurred through bad air at this particular mine. They had complained once or twice about it, and the inspector had carried out some arrangements. He could not say, however, whether or not it was right now. Sometimes the air was bad enough to extinguish a lighted candle. They had in connection with their Association a sick club, and although the men paid sixpence a week into it there were no less than £720 paid out in sick money, and they found on an average practically a third of the members lost ten or eleven days a year through illness brought about by bad air. Compressed air was said by the men to be almost as bad as fumes themselves. The air from a pump was deleterious. They were of the opinion that the double shaft would solve the matter.

Speaking on the question of the rock drill witness said the men considered it dangerous on account of the dust, which produced phthisis. Hematite dust would not have the same effect on the men as the rock drill dust. There had been no complaints up to the present. Where the spray was used it had reduced it, but there was a difficulty of getting men who were earning good wages to use the spray, which interfered with their liberty in getting the wages.

The Chairman: Do you suggest that they should be compelled to wear the respirator? — Yes. I think it is necessary.

Could you produce us a man who would undertake to work six hours hard work with a respirator on? — They do in the Potteries.

I dare say, but they do not work as hard as they do here — not physically as hard.

Mr. Duffy: Yes, physically hard.

I have seen them both, and think they don't work as physically hard. It is common muscles.

It is often doubled where air that is not of siliceous quality could give you phthisis. Dust of any kind produces phthisis to an extent if a man is predisposed to it.

Mr. Duffy, in further reply; said he had handled 37 death notices as their Association had a death levy fund, and 29 of those deaths were due to phthisis. Some mines in the district were very badly managed, which was often due to lack of mining education. Witness dealt at length with the question of investigation of accidents by special inquiry; and coroners and accident places.

The Chairman said if a single case was brought to the notice of the Home Office the matter would be attended to. At the present, formal inquiries were held, for instance, there was one to take place at Whitehaven.

Mr. Duffy: That is under the Coal Mining Act.

The Chairman said they could have a formal investigation if they had applied for it.

Witness said he had never yet been refused, but he had never applied for a formal investigation. Dealing with workmen inspectors witness said they suggested that power should be given to the Miners' Association to appoint an inspector and pay that inspector to inquire into any complaints that might be made by the miners, and that access should be given to the inspector. It might be conceivable that the Secretary of State might draw up rules preventing that man to interfere with a mine or to inquire into any complaints that might be made. His point was that the Association should appoint one or more inspectors.

The Chairman: To keep Mr. Leck in check. I suppose? — No, no.

If workmen inspectors were appointed in this district it would be quite useless. That is your point? — Yes.

Mr. Thomas: You mean workmen following his ordinary occupation?

Mr. Duffy: Yes. He went on to say that they did not want the coal mining system of inspection introduced in their district. In his opinion the coalminers were not content with it, and they (the Association members) were not content with it either. They did not want it here. Witness said in cases where accidents happened the place was evaporated before Mr. Leck had arrived. On one occasion when a man was taken away to the hospital, instructions were given to the other men to blow the place up. So there was a whole place evaporated there.

On the question of overhauling, Mr. Duffy said he did no know much about the Furness district, but he thought there was only three or four places in this district where riding men against men in cages was carried out. Parkhouse, for example, on one occasion, had ten men riding against ten men. If an accident happened it meant twenty men's lives were involved. Their Association was strongly against the system of men riding against men.

Replying to questions of the labour of women and girls, witness said he represented the feeling of the district when he said he was in favour of the prohibition of women and girls being allowed to work in or about the mines. As a matter of fact no women or girls should be employed at all at the mines, for it was not suitable work for them. That ought to be included in the Act as it might take place in the district.

The Chairman: You don't know what ladies are doing at this time.

Mr. Duffy: You don't know. When husbands are driven to earn small wages they don't know what they will do. He went on to say that they were no boys employed in the mines under the age of 14. They advocated that no boy under 16 years of age would be allowed to go down a mine. He added that perhaps before that new Act was passed they would have solved that question themselves, but it was for the coming generations that they wanted that putting down. Parents should not be allowed to exploit the use of children. The parents ought to get enough wages to keep their children. However, a boy under 16 was likely to play "larks" and that kind of thing, and consequently there was an element of danger in them.

For the timbering of the workings and roadways, witness said they should have a man responsible to carry out this particular work. At the present time the rule was that men were told to do the timbering, and they received no pay for it. There was not a single mine in the district where the men were paid for that work.

Some discussion took place on witness's suggestion that enginemen should go in for certificates.

On the question of sanitation of the mines witness said in the whole of the mines there was not one single case where there was a W.C. He had received four replies from employees that the men go nowhere, another the workmen use the gutter, and two mines they use the sump, another two use a paper case, and at one Woodend mine they used an old bogie as a W.C. To allow the men to use old workings or go anywhere was not respectable and was detrimental to human health.

He suggested that in a mine where a stream run into a pump that should be provided as a W.C. for over 25 men.

The Chairman: To let the sewage run into the stump would that not be rather dangerous and bad?

Mr. Duffy agreed that they were not ideal arrangements, but said something ought to be done. There should be also conveniences provided for the enginemen.

The Chairman thought that it being brought out of the mine with the stone would be just the same as the earth closet.

Mr. Duffy said the earth closets were neither healthy nor practicable. It would have to come up the mine, and it would be just the same as that old bogie that was being used at one of the mines.

The Chairman said personally he certainly agreed that something should be done in regard to this matter to make mines healthy.

Mr. Duffy also dealt at length as to over head staging being provided for men in sinking pits, and also a new method of signalling from the pit bottom to the top.

Witness was subjected to questioning by the respective Commissioners.

Evidence in some respects bearing out Mr. Duffy's statements were given by Jon Dixon, who is employed at Stirling's Mine; Noble Dawson, of Lord Leconfield's Pit, Bigrigg; John Tinnion, Parkhouse Mine, Frizington; John McClusker, Lord Leconfield's Croft Pit; and George Bewsher, engaged at Postlethwaite's Mine, at Moor Row.

The Commission adjourned the sitting until Friday morning.

Fridays Proceedings

The Commission re-commenced the sitting at Egremont, on Friday morning.

The Chairman said before commencing that the hearing of the evidence they (the Commission) had just talked over the question of possible unwillingness of witnesses to give evidence. He was particularly desired to say that, of course, it was their duty, they were earnestly desirous to hear everything. They wanted the greatest freedom of expression of opinion to prevail, and to hear everything that possibly could be said. With regard to the question of people being afraid to give evidence they (the Commissioners) could not guarantee anything. They had no power to give a guarantee one way or the other. However, if a man was in a position that he was afraid to give evidence in public, the only way was to hear him in private, and this, of course, he would point out, would not be considered as valuable as if it was given before the general public and before the Press, as in private it could not be contradicted.

Mr. Duffy said he raised this point yesterday by request, and had now an assurance from Mr. Burnyeat that the men would not be interfered with in any way whatever. Consequently his Association did not desire any of their witnesses to be heard in private.

The Chairman: I am very glad to hear that indeed.

Mr. Burnyeat said, speaking from one of the largest groups of mines and quarries he repeated what he had said the previous day, when he said "Most certainly". There was no intention or idea of anything of the sort, of intimidation or terrorism. He added most of the men knew the masters and owners perfectly well, and most of them knew him, and there was nothing in their minds.

The Chairman said he was sure of it, and he was very please to hear Mr. Burnyeat's remarks.

Mr. L. T. Helder said as representing the mine owners as a body he endorsed everything Mr. Burnyeat had said. There was no intention of preventing a man from giving straightforward account of what they knew about this matter.

The Chairman remarked that that seemed very satisfactory.

The hearing of evidence was proceeded with, and the Chairman in opening, said he had been impressed with the intelligence, and altogether the fine physique of the men in Cumberland.

John Dixon, miner, of 7 Dyke-street, Frizington, who is engaged at Lonsdale Pit, stated that he was of opinion that a double shaft should be put down in a mine.

Replying to other questions of the Chairman, witness agreed that there should be a galley running into the shaft so as to give men an opportunity of getting out of the mine in case of emergency. He was in favour of having a suitable change-house, and thought all mines should use it compulsory to the extent that men neglecting to use it would be liable to prosecution. The miners had no power to dismiss the man who looked after the changing-house, but they could complain to the management if things were not going on satisfactory. He had used explosives for about 28 years as a miner and had never had a mishap. He was of the opinion that a little more could be done with regard to improving the ventilation in mines. If men had to do timbering more than two fathoms back from the working place, witness thought they should be paid for the work.

By Mr. Redmayne: Although they had two shafts at he pit where he worked he was subject to headaches. He would certainly advocate a mine of 12ft. and 14ft. wide. As a rule, he had seen very high places. When the deputy examined the workings they knew he had been there, as he left a chalk mark on one of the tools to show the men that he had been there. If at any time there was anything wrong he would communicate with the men.

By Mr. Thomas: He agreed that the workmen themselves ought to examine the places to see that everything was right. There might be great difficulty in an emergency exit from a pit by means of a ladder erected up the shaft.

George Atkinson, Kirkland, and Joseph Braithwaite, Winder, bore out Dixon's statement.

Braithwaite said he was employed by the Cleator Iron Ore Co., and had worn a respirator in the mine. He didn't breathe so freely, but it saved a lot of dust being inhaled. Rock drills were not very healthy. Witness and his mate when down the pit could not, after a shot had been fired, see each other for dust.

By Mr. Thomas: The drill machine he spoke of was held by the hands.

Mark Daniels, Egremont, in the employ of the Combine at Woodend Mine, said he agreed with the evidence of Dixon.

By Prof. Redmayne: He believed the workmen contributed sixpence a fortnight for the change house. He didn't know whether it was a voluntary payment. A man cleaned out the change-house, and that was the subscription they gave him. Perhaps fifty changed at the place where he was employed. He would not.

By Mr. Lewney: He considered a twelve foot working wasn't a bad working. (Laughter.) He should call it a very good working. (Laughter.)

Mr. Lewney pointed out to witness that some witnesses thought the workings should be limited to one of 10ft. high and 12ft. wide.

Witness said he should consider that a fairly good high working. He should not favour compulsion in the size of a working, as a man might get a little white and convict himself. (Laughter.) He would consider it safer to work in a 12ft. working than in an 18ft. working. He was in favour of a double shaft.

James Matthews, 23, King-street, Wath Brow, employed at the Combine's Parkhouse Mine, Frizington, agreed with the evidence of previous witness.

Charles Quayle, 66, Montreal-street, Cleator Moor, employed at the Montreal Mine, said he was not in favour of compelling men to wash at the pit. He preferred going home to the "Old lass and getting a sup of water to wash me."

Isaac Watson, East-road, Egremont, employed at Pallaflat Mine, Bigrigg, James Nelson, East-road, Egremont, employed at Longlands Mine, Egremont; and John Gilpin, 56, Mill-street, Frizington, employed at Winder Ghyll Mine were also called.

Watson said every manager, shiftsman, and gaffer, should hold a certificate which he had gained, and which proved that he was qualified for the position. He was of the opinion that many men holding responsible positions were not qualified for the position. He thought men should first work in a mine and afterwards be examined as a practical man if he desired to take over a responsible position. He thought some men in this district had never had experience in mining. There might possibly be danger arise in this way by using that remark, but he would take the consequences. The men paid 3d a week for the changing-house, and the sum was taken out of their wages at the office. He thought the charge was agreed to by the workmen before he went to work at the pit. There was a man engaged to look after the change-house, and witness thought the man received the money.

Nelson said he considered that wage should be paid on the weight of ore produced at 20 cwt., to the ton.

The Chairman said that matter was not within their province as it was a question of money. They were dealing with questions of health and safety of the men.

Answering Mr. Lovett, witness said men ought to be employed in a mine five years before they were allowed to sit for certificates.

Mossop Rothery, 39, North Road, Egremont, employed at Ullcoats Mine, Jas. Smith, 54, Queen Street, Cleator Moor, employed at St. John Walsh Mine, also gave expressions of their opinion.

Charles Edmonds, labourer, Dalzell Street, Moor Row, said the changing houses should be put under the supervision of the sanitary inspector for the district, and their use made compulsory. Jack-rollers (windlasses) ought to have brakes on both sides, as some slight accidents had occurred from them. All men, he thought, should not serve less than five years, before becoming a full miner. Witness had not attended courses in mining or technical education, but he believed in lectures on mining being given for the benefit of the men.

The Chairman said he would like to know what the County Council were doing in the matter of education for mining courses.

Other sections get their share in the way of education, and it was only right that the miners should get their share.

Mr. L. T. Helder remarked that there was present a member (Mr. Scoular) of the Technical Education Committee if the Chairman would like to hear him.

The Chairman: I am sure we will.

Mr. Scoular said the County Council were most anxious to establish classes in every district, but the difficulty was in getting persons to attend, those classes.

Edmond's evidence was supported by two other labourers.

The Commission adjourned for lunch.

Proceeding after lunch the Commission called David Tidyman, Main-street, Cleator Moor, and Alex Cramond, Queen-street, Cleator Moor, miners.

Tidyman said there was one thing he had to mention and that was regard to the ladder suggested to be put down the side, as it had not been said whether or not the ladders would be above one another.

The Chairman said they could not expect to erect a ladder from the bottom to the top of a great shaft. He meant to say there would be places for the men climbing to rest.

Professor Redmayne produced rule 15, in which specified the erection of intervals in the climbing of the ladder at distances not more than 20 yards. Witness was in favour of making it compulsory that men should wash at the change-house on condition that the change-houses should be provided free.

George McWilliams, Ennerdale-road, Cleator Moor, said he had been employed at Stirling's Mine for fifty years. He was in favour of providing detachable hooks for the cages. At the pit he was working at they had been using King's patent hook for many years, and he liked it very well, and he had never seen it miss. Witness worked with paten clutch cage with springs and cylinders filled with elastic. When the weight was up the springs and clutches open, and when the weight was on the cage they could close. Witness would like universal signalling, because when a man left one employment he would have no occasion to learn the method of signalling at a new pit. Witness thought some convenience should be provided in the vicinity of the engine-house. He was in favour of a method of communication from the pit bottom to the top of the shaft. The ring of a telephone would not distract the enginemen. He was in favour of engine men sitting for examination. He (witness's) experience would not doubt enable him to obtain a certificate.

The Chairman: I don't know about that. (Laughter.)

Replying to a question witness said he would just as soon have the hammer going as the electric bell; as electricity was likely to go wrong if anything fell on the wires.

The Chairman said he had some knowledge of electricity and he should be inclined to agree with witness's views. If they got a bad contact it would be awful in the mistake which would follow as a result of the contact having gone.

Witness further stated that he advocated a daily inspection of all driving gear by an engineer if one was arranged at the mine.

Joseph Ennor, 41, East-road, Egremont, engineman at Woodend, supported the last witness's views and said he thought head gear approaches should be made easier and access made easier, to the sheave wheels. He supported the evidence that men should obtain certificates of examination of their qualification.

By Professor Redmayne: He had had a case of over winding, which on that occasion was probably due to the engineman taking his mind off his work to something else.

Replying to Mr. Lewney, witness said by means of the clutch on the cage if a mishap occurred and the cage was stopped with the aid of the clutch in the middle of the shaft, which would undoubtedly save the lives of some men. Persons under 22 years of age should not be allowed to draw men.

In answer to Mr. Greaves, he said if telephones were provided for enginemen in case of a call the driver would have to stop the cage to answer the call.

Luke Cowan, 30, South-street, Egremont, a pit sinker, in the course of his evidence which was chiefly in regard to sinking shafts, said after a charge had been fired in the shaft, it should be the duty of the chargeman to examine the shaft and see that there was no stone might be lodged in the wood after the shot. He thought the kibble should be filled to within four of five inches from the top, because in case of overfilling he had known cases where stone had fallen from kibble and killed a man. He had no complaints to make with regards to timbering.

The Chairmen: The desirability of some covering being admitted for the men who are sinking? — Witness: That would be done in a new shaft.

That would be three or four feet above their head? — Witness: and folding door at the top of the shaft was all that was necessary in his opinion.

By Mr. Thomas: He meant that the top door would be sufficient to give adequate protection for the men from any falling stones from the top.

You don't see any necessity of having some suspended covering about feet above the miners heads?

I should keep everything out of the shaft.

Mr. Thomas: I am inclined to think you are quite right.

Replying to the Chairman, witness said a stiff leather hat for men in the shaft was very good, but in this country they only had oilskin hats, and they might just as well have bare heads, except that the oilskin kept the water off. (Laughter.) As regards the shafts he preferred to have it quite clear of material. Great satisfaction was given to the men when working in having the shaft kept clear, as they would not have to keep looking about them wondering whether something was coming down.

By Mr. Redmayne: It was very desirable after heavy charges that an interval should elapse before men went down the shaft, in order that lames might be cleared away.

The Chairman pointed out that there was an Act which provided that terrorism exercised on a witness who had given evidence before a Royal Commission was punishable, but it was quite unnecessary to cite the Act. Before the men knew of the Act the employers in a very proper spirit stepped forward and said they had no thought of doing such a thing. He also wanted it to go forward to those present that there was an Act to the effect.

John Briggs, said he came from the Furness district, and was an iron ore miner. The ventilation in the pits there was generally sufficient. His candle had been extinguished many a time, and on these occasions he used to have to go and get it lighted where the air was better. He had seen various things tried to improve ventilation. One method was to draw the water up the shaft and drop it again. Whether the expense was too much or too little it was asking too much to provide a second shaft. He would be satisfied to have the question of providing a second shaft left to the Government Inspector.

By Mr. Lewney: He did not think it would be much use us having inspections by two workmen. In fact it would be very little use if they had powers of appointing such inspectors. He was in favour of a universal code of signalling. Witness nearly had an accident through changing from one code of signalling to another, and it made a great impression upon him at the time.

James Hall, another Furness miner, urged an automatic appliance for throwing a winding engine out of gear as a prevention in a case of mistake or error by the engineman. They disinfected the shaft bottom and walls and sides on the main road, and this was very effective. With regard to ventilation they suffered a little in summer. Some men were hardly able to wash. It affected them differently.

John T. Cottier, who had had 40 years experience in Metalliferous mines, being 37 years in Furness district, and three years at Isle-of-Man lead mines, concluded the evidence to be given at Egremont.

Sittings At Seascale

Saturday's Evidence

The Royal Commission sat at the Scawfell hotel, Seascale, on Saturday, for the purpose of taking further evidence on the present working conditions of the Metalliferous mines and quarries in the county. Amongst the interested persons present were: Messers. T. H. Brockbank (St. Bees), C. Booth (Yeorton), G. Scoular (St. Bees), L. T. Helder (Seascale), W. R. Walker (Woodend), W. Watkyn-Thomas (Egremont), W. Dixon (Cleator Moor), W. Casson (St. Bees), J. B. Kitchin (Woodend), J. Adair (Beckermet), H. Adair (Egremont), G. H. Turner (Ponsonby Hall), Myles Richardson (Egremont), and others.

Mr. J. W. Noon, said he was employed at Threkeld granite quarry, and was deputed to come and give evidence by the Cumberland Branch of the National Union of Quarrymen. In the Newcastle district the inspectors of quarries were inadequate. There were in the Newcastle district 365 quarries which employed four or five thousand men. Mr. Leck or one man could not possibly efficiently inspect the whole of the quarries. Some of these quarries were of a very substantial kind. They wanted an inspector who would come into contact with the workmen employed, and such a man need not be of high scientific attainments, but rather a workman. He thought the irregularity of blasting was a danger to the men. Witness said it might be of value if they had the power of appointing men, but there was the question of its expense. The quarries in their district were profitable. In their locality they had a fairly good reputation for safety of workmen, but in many cases they find they came out fortunate in a number of minor accidents, some very fortunate, and there were miraculous escapes. Speaking generally, witness said that the safety of workmen was a long way from what it should be.

The Chairman pointed out that the number of accidents in the Newcastle district was not large, and was favourable compared with other places.

Witness advocated that each quarry manager should go through an examination to test his practicability. He said it would certainly horrify any member of this Commission if they were put in the mess room that was provided for the men.

The Chairman: What do you see?

Witness: Filth generally on the floor. He went on to say that the shelves provided for the men were of corrugated iron, and there was accommodation for only twenty to cope with the requirements of seventy men. There was no system adopted for keeping the mess room clean. He certainly admitted they should have proper accommodation as regards the mess room.

The Chairman said that was a point they would consider.

Witness continuing his replies, said men (quarrymen) sometimes suffered from small cuts through the work, but in the majority of cases these cuts did not fester, as the stone they worked was not so poisonous. If a workman had sustained a fractured leg they would have to convey him to the hospital, which was four or five miles away, and the nearest doctor lived a similar distance away. They wanted ambulance arrangements adopted, whereby a man could be treated on the spot, and afterwards taken away as conveniently as possible. The shelter for blasting in many cases was inadequate, but there was not sufficient shelter for special blasting of large holes. The escape from being injured by flying stone depended on the men's activity (laughter) in dodging the stones.

The Chairman said all the points raised by witness were embodied in the model code of regulations, but they were not in operation at witness's quarry. These regulations really met all the witness's points.

By Mr. Lovett: When speaking of the inadequate number of inspectors, he did not, in mentioning the fact, reflect anything on the present inspector, but they wanted more inspectors. The present regulations could be remedied with certain modifications. The Quarry Act should be self made, and as simple as possible. He thought it best to have a self-contained Quarry Act as they were in the face of the rock, and the Act should enforce a more stringent adherence of the regulations. He was not in favour of the rough stone wall being erected at the top of the face of a quarry, for a sheep had been known to jump on the wall, and by doing so, knocked a stone down the face of the quarry where the men were working. He suggested the erection of a stone wall to keep the stone intact.

By Mr. J. S. Ainsworth: The Act which specified that twenty-five men should be employed in a working, before arrangements could be adopted, should in witness's opinion be altered to five men only.

By Mr. Greaves: He was not certain whether accidents occurring in the quarries were reported or not.

By Mr. Lewney: He thought all managers representing the owners should hold a certificate showing his competency. He was, however, satisfied with the way the manager's at present carried out their duties, and was perfectly satisfied with the class of men they had as foremen. The managing director should carry a certificate of qualifications. Overmen and managing directors should go through a practical examination.

Mr. Lewney: That would be a new experience for managing directors? — Yes, it would.

By Mr. Thomas: Putting it in broad lines what the (witness) meant was that the general manager, who was at the head of affairs, should take a certificate. He did not press the matter of the foremen, so long as they had a general practical man drawn from the ranks of the workers.

Mr. Marshall Jordan, also a quarryman at Threkeld, agreed with the evidence of the last witness in general.

The Chairman said there may be two reasons for advocating the general manager to look to who was really responsible. One was of having somebody to look to who was really responsible. Then there was another reason that he should pass certain exercises. He asked which of these reasons were most pressing on his mind?

Witness replied the first one. Continuing, Jordan, said he thought it was the duty of the foreman, after he had fired holes to go back and examine the holes to see that every shot had fired. Witness agreed that the wire fence was ample for the protection of the top of the quarry. He preferred a wire fence in almost every case to a stone wall. The ambulance arrangements were insufficient at their quarry, and on occasions there were scarcely any bandages to be found in case of accidents. They had three quarries one was over two miles away from the office, and they (quarrymen) required ambulance baskets at each quarry, instead of being kept at the office.

By Mr. Thomas: He believed the employers had been made aware of the scarcity of ambulance requisites.

Mr. W. M. Cowen, Secretary to the Cumberland Quarrymen's Limestone Association, which was constituted of 300 men, said they were better in some respects as regards the accommodation of other places. He wished to emphasis the point of the over-burden of the rudd. He was of the opinion that if they kept the rudd at the top of the quarry, a certain distance from the face of the rock, it would tend to reduce the few men killed by a fall of the rudd. Dealing with the question as to rules, witness said he did not want many rules himself. The rules set out in the model code were in operation, but that was not sufficient, as they should have a certain distance stated where the rudd (soil or earth) should be stopped for safety of the workers. With regard to mess rooms, he said there were some provided well, but others were not, and he thought these should be improved for the health and safety of the workers. He was not in favour of the rule regarding 25 men to be employed before ambulance requisites could be supplied. He thought whenever a number of men were employed one to two, and they were liable to accidents, ambulance provisions should be provided for the alleviation of suffering and pain of the men.

Mr. James Flynn, Cleator Moor, stated that he was General Secretary to the National Iron Ore Miners' Association. Originally he was Secretary to the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' and Quarrymen's Association for years. That split into a Quarry Union, and two sections of ore miners. He had been secretary between 14 and 15 years. He had attended five Miner's International Conferences of Great Britain, and thirteen Trade Union Congresses. He had in general attended to mining and quarry accidents. He had attended to a number of workmen's compensation cases, but the principal part of his duties was confined to trying to get miners more wages, because he always thought that was more essential. Since he mooted a scheme some 13 years ago, great improvements had been carried out in their mines and had been done generally between themselves and the owners. There was at the present day a difference in the mines to what they were 13 years ago. Whenever there had been an accident, and they could prove any remedy, they were met always by the mineowners, who eventually made the improvements. The mineowners always met them as far as Cumberland, and they had had no trouble in regard to remedy. Ten years ago when the Workmen's Compensation Act came in force, he began to take note of all accidents. They (the Commission) would see his reports of 1893 and 1899, which was the first time that he had taken note of compensation cases. At that time they were working under the heading of the West Cumberland Workmen's Association.

The Chairman: I suppose therefore the fact that the Workmen's Compensation Act coming in and you taking notes of the accidents and the causes apparent of the increase in accidents? As far as we were concerned we get every actual accident that did take place.

To a certain extent the increase may be due, if not entirely, to the greater points taken of accidents? — That is so. The Workmen's Compensation Act was especially due to the greater number of accidents in every way. Before that, came in vogue, they would have a man who would not attempt to work if he got compensation.

I suppose you would be of opinion that it would be desirable that there should be alternative ways of getting out of a mine in some form, whether by having two shafts, in case of emergency? — In some of our mines here, we have got two shafts. In our sallow mines I don't. I don't think it would be much better to have two shafts out, as long as they had plenty of ways into the workings, where the men were.

Answering further questions, witness said he thought himself that the owners would be quite agreeable, whenever it would be possible to make a way out.

The Chairman: The whole case would be very difficult, and in case of difference, it should be referred to a tribunal to decide? — That would satisfy me.

Witness, proceeding, said he would make it compulsory for everybody to change at the mine, and if they refused, to be punished for it. They desired sufficient room, and a sufficient supply of water. The ventilation in some places was very good. As far as he could ascertain, they had very little complaint about the ventilation from the miners. The miners usually, wrote to him if they had a complaint to make, and he wrote to the Government Inspector, who would make an inspection. He did not think in all his experience he had half a dozen complaints or letters from miners, complaining of ventilation. He agreed to a certain extent to certificated managers. He had found in iron ore mines a practical manager far better than a theoretical manager. He was in entire favour of managers holding certificates.

Mr. Greaves: would you say they were an unhealthy or hale body of men?

Mr. Flynn: You have a specimen before you. (Laughter).

The Chairman: I agree with Mr. Flynn, but one swallow does not make a summer.

Continuing his replies, witness said he found the occupation of iron ore mining very healthy, in fact they would find an the old age pension list, in this district, he was on the committee, and they would find the ripe age of the miners. They live to 70 and 80 years of age, and there was one who was 100, and he was not-likely to die yet. (Laughter). He went on to say that there were not many cases of phthisis in iron ore mines. Witness was in favour having two different sets of inspectors for the iron ore mines, and the coal mines. Dealing with the question of Coroners' Courts and investigation of accidents, Mr. Flynn said he had attended 131 inquests since he had been chairman in connection with iron ore miners. His experience was that the coroners gave them every facility and every privilege and desire they had to investigate the case. They were pleased with the coroners on giving then every facility to question witnesses, and he had never yet been pulled up by the coroner when questioning. More than that the owners had opened their pit to them to go and examine it. He thoroughly agreed that the place where an accident had happened should not be interfered with unless necessary until the place had been inspected. He thought it would be desirable to have a rule to that effect. Witness agreed with the system generally carried on of men riding against men in cages, as he said the engine drivers were really very careful, and were a trained body of respectable men, and had never found an accident having occurred through men riding against men up and down the shaft. He himself had ridden against the men from time to time. Miners were often anxious to get down when on contract, and there were no accidents. He had never found men unwilling to ride in that manner. He did not see why there could be any objection to it. Witness said he thoroughly agreed that a man in the working should timber his own road because a practical miner did not want to work under another man's timbering, and if he (witness) was a workman he would like to work under his own timbered placed. He, as a practical miner, would like to timber his own working.

By Mr. Lewney: The mines had special men for this work of timbering, but if they asked a workman to timber his working place, he would not object so long as he was paid for it.

Answering the Chairman, witness said he considered that the men should have a little to say in regard to explosives as they bought them. He was of the opinion if the appointed a man to examine the explosives they would get over the difficulty of being provided with poor explosives.

By Mr. Greaves: Workmen should have power to examine the explosives in the magazine.

The Chairman remarked that there was a great amount of rubbish in explosives brought in from foreign places, masqueraded as good explosives.

Dealing with the point of employment of boys in the mine Mr. Flynn said he did not think boys were employed too young in Cumberland mines. He thought Cumberland boys were of very little value until they are robust and growing, and can do men's work.

The Chairman asked if there was any feeling in the district with regard to the employment of boys?

Witness replied that the "Boys" were ready for marrying before they get employment in the mines. (Laughter). They were very big when young in Cumberland. Regarding ambulance provision witness said they were favoured as regarded that matter. They had a splendid system of ambulance work in the district, and as far, as he was concerned he had never received any complaint as to provisions. They might male provision for an ambulance van, and that was the only thing that they could improve upon in the ambulance line so far as the miners were concerned. It would enable them to convey injured persons more quickly to the infirmary. The district would require three ambulance vans in all, one each for Cleator Moor, Frizington, and Egremont. They had at present to get the van from Whitehaven, which constituted much delay.

Mr. Lewney observed that it would be a very good thing for the Urban Councils to get one . They had them at Dalton.

Mr. Flynn: The matter would come before the Councils, but sometimes they had those little "sky" property owners objecting to the high costs. (Laughter). He would suggest the provision of a motor ambulance van.

The Chairman said in his mind some roads in this district wanted improving. He did not know how they would be able to get a motor van over the roads in their present condition.

Mr. Flynn: The main roads are good. He added that their general rules that were drawn up fifty years ago were ahead of the Act on Metalliferous mines. He had an idea that more good could be derived by having general meetings than by Acts of Parliament. (Laughter). He did not hold faith in Acts of Parliament, and as Daniel O'Connell said "You could drive a carriage and pair through any of them."(Referred Laughter). On the question of the sanitation of mines, witness said they had a good supply of water, which was much better that the last dry mines. He would certainly suggest that chloride be sprinkled in the pits, and that, the mineowners should supply the people with it.

The Chairman said they had had a witness of Mr. Lewney's before them, who told them that a good method was to scatter quicklime on the bottom.

Mr. Flynn said this was a very good thing, and he did not know anything better.

Further evidence of Mr. Flynn's was deferred until after the hearing of Messers. Robert Irving, Timothy Harris, John Plummer, and Joseph Philips, and the general opinion of the four Hodbarrow miners was that he mines in that district were satisfactory as far as the workmen were concerned. They did no think anything could be improved.

Irving said the ventilation was all that could be desired. The pits were aired naturally and if this was not giving sufficient air, then the employers helped from out with compressed air.

The Chairmen said he had heard that compressed air became unhealthy.

Plummer and they have must all admit that compressed air was not as good as natural air, because compressed air was warm.

Irving said they could work, better with compressed air as it cooled the atmosphere in the mine.

This witness after further statements were dismissed and Mr. Flynn was re-called.

Mr. Lewney: I am not sure Mr. Flynn whether I understand you correctly with regards to the outlets to single shaft? Did I understand you to say one outlet was sufficient.

Mr. Flynn: No I don't think you understood me to say that I don't consider one outlet sufficient. It bears on the circumstances of the shaft and the place. If one outlet was all they could possibly get, then it unnecessary two shafts.

Mr. Lewney: Two means of exit? Yes they had mines where they had that.

You will agree in case when only one shaft was possible, that shaft should be protected with a sufficient ladder road to enable men to get out in case of anything going wrong with the winding gear? — Where only one shaft was I think they should provide two outlets.

You also agree in many case, probably it would reflect on the workmen, if employers were compelled to put down another shaft? — It would probably affect one half of the men in Cumberland.

Replying to further questions of the Commission witness said they had good accommodation in change houses, and he much preferred it to home. It was not necessary that the general manager or engineer should hold a certificate. They might have a very illiterate man in the iron ore pit, and almost practical man underneath a miner. He thought it a great hardship if men could not qualify and gain a certificate. They might have a man 23, who would sit and who had never been in a mine in his life.

Mr. Lewney: In your experience you have met very capable miners who would hardly from nervous temperament be likely to pass an examination before a Board? — That is so. I think one of the best miners was my father, but he could not pass an examination. I don't think a miner should have a certificate in that sense.

Mr. Lewney: With regard to inspecting of places after accidents, he thought he heard him (witness) that the owners were very agreeable and invited him to inspect the places where an accident occurred. But would he (Mr. Flynn), agree that it should be a recommendation to the Government to put a condition or clause of that kind in the Act to give them that as a right without privilege.

Witness said that was a very broad question in some cases. He would either restrict the inspection to the miners' agent or restrict the representative workmen in that particular mine. Because it they allowed any person to go through, that person may go simply because he had something against the managers. He (Mr. Flynn) would make it compulsory that one man working in that particular mine ought to inspect or the miners' representatives. They should certainly have practical men for the position. Witness went on to say that he would not advocate men purchasing explosives outside the mines.

By Mr. Greaves: Not all times would men who got a bad fuse report or object to it.

Mr. Greaves: if men won't complain that fuses are bad it will be difficult for the owners to find out that they are being supplied with bad stuff.

Mr. Flynn agreed with him.

Witness continuing said there was no pay made for the use of the change-house, except a voluntary sum was given to an old miner or pensioner who looked after the place. It was not a compulsory payment.

The Chairman: It is taken out of their pay at the office occasionally?

Witness: I don't think so.

The Chairman: Occasionally?

Mr. Flynn remarked that he sometimes pitied the man that depended upon the voluntary amounts. (Laughter).

Witness advocated, in reply to Mr. Ainsworth, the separation of inspectors from Metalliferous mines and coal mines.

Evidence was also given by Thomas Hogg, Jas. Dobie, William Eldon, and Michael Burns, all of Cleator Moor, and James Armstrong, Moor Row, who was deputed to attend in the interests of the National Amalgamation of enginemen, firemen, and electricians.

The Commission was adjourned until Monday.

Monday's Proceedings

The Commission renewed the sitting at Seascale on Monday.

Dr. Calderwood, medical officer of health for the Egremont district stated that he thought the general health of the iron ore miners was very good, better in fact than the general health of ht population. The statistics showed that clearly. He had the annual report of the medical officers of health of both Whitehaven and Cockermouth as well as his own, which he thought were suitable districts to take for a comparison. In Whitehaven district there were 20 deaths from phthisis, equal to an annual death rate of 10.3 per thousand in Cockermouth district, there were six deaths from that disease, giving a rate of .95. Only two of those deaths were of miners, and gave a rate of .31 per thousand.

The Chairman asked the doctor to what cause he attributed the improved health of the miners in the district,

Witness replied that the general health of the county was improved owing to increased sanitation.

The Chairman observed that Egremont curiously enough stood three times better in health, as far as these deaths go to Whitehaven and Cockermouth.

Witness: if you take the deaths of miners alone.

The Chairman: Yes, if you take the general death rate it is rather better.

Witness continuing said that taking bronchitis in Whitehaven there were 49 deaths, equal to a rate of 2.5. Cockermouth, which was the nearest to their own district, and being a county district and an old town, there were no iron ore pits, or mines, so that made a very good comparison. Cockermouth had five deaths from bronchitis, giving an annual rate of .92, while Egremont had five also, but that town had rather a larger population. The rate worked out at .79. There was no death amongst miners in Egremont from bronchitis last year, and as far as pneumonia was concerned there were 27 deaths in the year, giving a rate of .14. In Cockermouth there were seven, giving a rate of 1.2, and in Egremont there were also seven, which was equivalent to a rate of 1.1. Of these seven deaths two were of miners, giving a rate of .31. He considered the miners were the healthiest part of the population in Egremont. The worst district as far as phthisis was concerned was Moor Row, as far as he knew. But that was chiefly accounted for by the fact that it was a great place for miners coming home from South Africa with miners' phthisis. They went to South Africa from that district, and they stayed for variable periods of five, ten, and fifteen years, and then came home again having contracted miners' phthisis from the grit of the rock drills. The figures he had quoted included men who had returned from abroad. There was a good many resident working miners at Moor Row.

The Chairman asked witness how the figures he had given to them compared with the general rate of the country?

Witness said that the general death rate for phthisis in England and Wales about the present time was 1.5 or 1.6. The Egremont district, as would be seen from the figures given, was evidently below that. The general death rate of the Egremont district for the last ten years had been 14.3.

The Chairman commented on the striking healthiness of the district, which he had said appeared to be about forty per cent better than the average. He asked witness what he attributed that too.

The doctor answered that it was a healthy district, and the miners' occupation was quite a healthy one. There was nothing a miner contracted on account of his occupation. There was only their liability to accidents.

The Chairman: There is no real grounds for the apprehension that these miners suffered abnormally from phthisis and bronchitis, but on the contrary? — Yes.

If he (the Chairman) suggested that the doctors of Cumberland are afraid to support you in this, and are rather afraid to say what they think — that there is a bad state of things? — I don't think so. There is no reason why that should be said.

The next witness Dr. Clark, who said he was a medical officer for Cleator Moor, Arlecdon and Frizington districts. In the Cleator Moor district the number of deaths from phthisis and other tuberculosis diseases in the past year were nine, a rate of 1.1 per thousand, as against 1.7 for England and Wales. There were only six cases of phthisis, giving a rate of about .75.

The Chairman observed that this was remarkably small for phthisis, compared with the average of the country.

Witness proceeding, said they had 20 cases of bronchitis and six of pneumonia, which was equal to a percentage of .3. The figures for England and Wales of bronchitis were 2.5, and 1.75 for deaths through pneumonia. There would be no grounds for anybody saying that the health of the district was bad. Witness attributed the healthy status of the community to the healthy county, the mountain air, and the ventilation. He did not think the mines were badly ventilated or else there would be very much more bronchitis.

By Mr. Ainsworth: Five out of the six cases of men suffering from phthisis were of persons who had come home from South Africa.

By Mr. Thomas: it was not compulsory for him to report to the Councils the cases of phthisis. There were not so many persons coming home lately, but there were a great many a year or two ago.

Mr. George Scoular, mining engineer, resident at St. Bees, stated in reply to the Chairman, that he had the management of the Parkside for over forty years. He was there representing the whole of the mineowners of the district. On the whole the present working of the mines was in advance of the Metalliferous Act of 1872. Therefore there was no objection from the owner's point of view to have the Act made up. He quite agreed that it should be amended. Witness approved of the present system of inspections, and had no objection to working men inspectors, providing they were thoroughly practical men. He quite agreed there should be two shafts if desirable, and two exits if possible to a mine. He did not think it should be compulsory to have a second, for compulsion would be detrimental to the iron ore industry of the district. He knew from his own experience that a double shaft would cost £80,000 to be sunk 150 fathoms. There were many mines in the district it would stop altogether; if they made compulsory to sink a second shaft. They did not agree with ladders for the men to travel regularly, except in cases of emergency, and then the mineowners would agree to it. Witness said the £80,000 shaft would be driven through rock in deep mines, and it was too expensive a process to expend that amount on a shaft, and they would have to contend with a great amount of water. As the mine went on, and it developed and proved a good deal of ore, it would then pay the owners to lay a second shaft. No man should be alarmed at going down a thoroughly made shaft, with good outlets. In the whole witness's forty years experience they had never had an accident.

The Chairman: There may be people afraid to travel on railways in case of accidents. You would term that unreasonable? — Yes.

Mr. Scoular said there was no reason at all why a man should be afraid of going down a mine with one shaft. The only reason of alarm would be of the boilers blowing off or something more serious. But such had never happened. It was totally different in ore mines than in coal pits. It was quite different and they were agreeable to have two shafts in coal mines. Witness agreed with the medical evidence, which he considered had been given fairly and well. Dealing with the question of certificated managers, witness agreed with this method. He said as regards the present managers, they could not have a better set of men in the whole body, for they were really excellent men. He was in favour of managers holding certificates both for theoretical and practical knowledge. He was also in favour of the regulations of the mines, and he considered that it was to everybody's interest that they should have good plans of the pits for fear of water in abandoned mines. The ventilation was exceedingly good in iron mines, and was good throughout the district. He'd thought it must be very rare that the candles were blown out in the pits. Witness had never had a case of this description. He thought the standard advocated that there should not be less than 19 per cent oxygen, and not more than 1½ of carbolic acid, was very high to insist upon having it in every place.

The Chairman observed that it was much more than would poison a man. He thought they should keep the standard up. He asked witness if he would be surprised to hear Dr. Haldane on investigation found that the standard in every place was three times as much as the specified standard. If that was so he did not think 1.25 would not be too much. It was a new proposal and he drew it to his (Mr. Scoular) attention as it required some consideration. Perhaps he could give some consideration to the matter.

Mr. Scoular promised to do this.

Witness dealing with explosives, said the present Act was behind the times in that respect, and a new Act should be brought in the present practice. Witness thought that each man should see their own holes were fired because every man knew where he had put his explosives and what to expect from others. He thought half an hour was quite ample an interval in case of misfire. He was in favour of the Home Office issuing a report as to whether fuses were bad or not for that would be very useful indeed. In all their mines they procured the best explosives they could possibly get, and there was no stint on the part of the owners in that respect. In case of misfire he thought the place should be charged again and fired. Mr. Scoular thought it would be unfair to put in an Act anything limiting the height of a working.

The Chairman said they had divided opinions on that matter. Some were very confident that ten or twelve feet were sufficient, and others said it would not at all be sufficient. He thought the different opinions could be accounted for by the difference of mines at which the witness worked.

Witness said some of the mines could be limited in soft ore, but not in pits were the ore was hard. He went on to say that he had no objection to the power of inspection of workmen in the mine, and owners were quite willing to allow the men to carry it out. He thought an examination every day of the mine would be quite good, by an official and not a workman. He advocated an examination of the machinery daily.

Dealing with the point of erecting the ladder in the shaft he agreed that ladders in shafts in cases of emergency were a good thing. He thought, however, that it would be a great hardship upon the miners if they adopted long ladders if they had to get out of the mine by this means. He agreed with the statement of Mr. Duffy in that respect that it was rather antiquated.

The Chairman said that they thought it would be that, but what was suggested was that when sinking a new shaft in future they should make provision in that shaft in case of emergency, of a ladder in addition. Witness said he quite approved of that. He thought it would be a hardship in small shallow mines if ladders were not allowed at first as the only means of exit. It might be used in mines of 20 or 30 fathoms. Regarding the change-houses witness said the owners had an objection to the specified size as suggested by the Commission.

The Chairman said that they thought it would be reasonable, and they suggested it in this way. If two shifts of 100 were engaged they thought they would get the cubic feet required for each suit by multiplying 200 by 150.

Witness said he thought a universal payment was made by men using the change-houses for the payment of the person who cleaned the house out. The money did not except on very rare occasions go through the companies books. None of the owners reaped any benefit from the payments made in respect to the change-houses. What they (the owners) thought the best thing the men could do was to form a committee between themselves and endeavour to keep their companies right and keep the houses clean, and make a general supervision of the place and do more in that respect than they had done in the past, instead of leaving it entirely to the attendant. He did not think the owners would object in any way to paying one man to attend to the change-house. Of course it brought the mineowners into a responsibility in case of any little that that might occur.

The Chairman said he did not think the company would be responsible, not if all the company did was to supply a man to keep the place clean.

Mr. Scoular, speaking on ambulances, said he thought every mine provided ambulance appliances and a stretcher.

The Chairman: It was rather hard if a man seriously injured is to be removed on men's shoulders.

Witness said it was cruel. He added that every mining company in the district contributed in same way towards ambulance work.

The Chairman referring to a balance-sheet said the mineowners contributed in accordance with their output.

On the question of technical education in the district, witness said the County Council had an elaborate system of dealing with the technical classes in the district. In any village or town where a class could be organised they were organised. He went on to say that the statement made to the effect that they were always looking out for Mr. Leck was not correct. Whenever Mr. Leck (the inspector) visited the mines he gave them no notice of his coming. They were always glad to see him and to point out any mistakes. They did not try to mislead the inspector in any way, and it was not correct. The witness referred to a statement that the owners tried to hide up, and cover a place where there had been an accident for the purpose of covering the true scope of what had really happened. They did not dare to do that, and it was a mistake entirely. He did not know how the gentlemen could go there and say such a thing. He (witness) would also like to speak about the general health of the district, as it had been stated by witness that the general health was bad, and men were dying off like rotten sheep. He produced statistics issued to the County Council by the medical officer of health who showed the small number of cases of phthisis and other diseases. The witness, Mr. Scoular, had also said that there were no old men employed in the mines. He (witness) had a list before him, which showed the miners who ages ranged from 63 to 72 who were at present engaged in the mines. He only mentioned these facts as he did not think the district should be slandered in that way. Those figures, he contended, were altogether against the other witness's facts. Witness was in favour of the universal code of signalling, and also of the adoption of detaching hooks for cages. Dealing with the question of men riding against men in the cages, witness never thought there was any danger at all in that.

By Mr. Lovett: He was in favour of the Metalliferous Act, self contained, and have nothing to do with any other Act. He was of the opinion that the inspector carried out his work of inspection properly, but he could not inspect the mines every week or month and everything was kept up to the mark with the present system of inspection. If the inspector had too much to do then he should have assistance, but as far as the condition and inspection of mines were concerned witness did not think any assistance would make any difference.

By Mr. Ainsworth: He did not object and did not think his colleagues would object if additional inspectors were appointed. He thought when a candle went out in a mine through foul air it was time that the men should go out.

Mr. Lewney: And long before that.

Answering further questions put to him by Mr. Ainsworth, witness said it was in the interests of the managers to keep as good a ventilation as they possibly could. He had never known of any effect to the men through supplying compressed air.

By Mr. Greaves: It was not a correct statement that the owners put charges on the men for the use of the change-houses. It was not done at one single pit in the district.

By Mr. Thomas: He approved that explosives should be examined and passed by the Home Office.

The evidence was corroborated by Mr. Wm. Dixon, mining engineer, Cleator Moor; Mr. W. E. Walker, mining engineer, Woodend; and Mr. Jos. B. Adair, mining engineer, Beckermet.

The first named witness added that at Margaret Pit, Frizington, separate windings were provided for the ore and for the men. At Bigrigg No. 2 four compartments divided the workings, and it was proposed also to have separate windings for the metal and for the men.

Evidence was also given by Mr. W. W. Casson, mining engineer, St. Bees, who manages the Townhead, Jacktrees, and Salter Mines, and Salter Quarry, and was connected with the Boonwood Mining Company, Ltd., which was an exploration company at present.

Statements were also made by David Wilson, manager at Workington Iron and Steel Company's quarry, Isaac Walker, under-ground manager at Parkhouse Pit, Frizington; H. Mellon, mining surveyor; Professor W. Galloway, chairman and director of Messrs. Harrison, Ainslie, and Co., Lindal-in-Furness; and C. E. Ray, Messrs. Harrison, Ainslie, and Co.'s manager.

Evidence was also given by Messrs. J. Flynn and T. Gavan Duffy.

The sitting was adjourned until Tuesday morning.

Concluding Sitting

The sittings of the Commission terminated on Tuesday, when two witnesses were called namely Dr. Byers, of Cleator Moor, and Mr. D. Gill, mining engineer, the first named at the request of Mr. Gavan Duffy.

Dr. Byers, in reply to the Chairman, said as regards the whole district he considered the health comparatively favourable with any other district with which he had been acquainted. The iron ore miners were singularly free from what he might call respiratory diseases, and with regard to miners phthisis he could not say he had ever come across a case, which he could distinctly put down to iron ore mining. Undoubtedly there had been a large number of cases in the district, but they have been imported from South Africa due, no doubt to the use of the diamond boring drill. They had a fair number of cases of bronchitis, but in his opinion these cases were due rather to men sitting in draughts when perspiring rather than to any actual cause arising from their work. He must admit of course, there had been cases which he had put down to the inhalation of deleterious gas, such as explosive gas and so forth. With regard to the deaths from bronchitis he had looked through his death certificates and discovered that all the cases were those of aged men or men over sixty and in those cases it had been of a chronic form. Pneumonia was, he believed, as did every doctor, an infective disease, and he could not consider it was caused by any mining work. Of course a predisposing cause might be catching a chill.

The Chairman: On the whole, your evidence seems to me if I rightly interpreted is shortly to confirm the evidence of Dr. Morrison (County Medical Officer). The Chairman summarised Dr. Morrison's annual report, a copy of which he handed to witness.

Dr. Byers said that nine cases out of ten amongst the elder folk who died from phthisis would be those "dusted" in South Africa. Asked if he had any opinion to express with regard to changing-houses, witness said they were undoubtedly beneficial both from the point of view of comfort and health. They did a good deal to remove a tendency or liability to pulmonary disease. He had known men come home with their clothes practically frozen on them. This was where there was no hanging-house. He was very much in favour of changing-houses, but would not make their use compulsory. He thought a man should have a certain amount of say in what he did and didn't do.

By Mr. Ainsworth: As a rule Cumberland miners lived as long, and had as good a chance as anyone else to attain old age. There were a great many men working in the district of sixty and upwards.

By Mr. Lovett: A very large number of cases of phthisis were reported from South Africa. He could not say he had found any he could put down as due the iron ore. These cases of dust as it was called, sometimes didn't develop for months, or even years. Young came home from Africa perfectly well, and perhaps two or three years after developed symptoms of phthisis.

Mr. Gill, engineer at the Bigrigg Mining Company' Mine, said that with reference to the pay bill put in on Monday by Mr. Duffy in respect of changing houses charges, he would put in the books showing the number of men that were paying for the fortnight covered by the pay bill in question.

It was for the fortnight ended September 19th 1908. There were seventeen companies of men, ranging from two to six, each paying sixpence per fortnight. These were in all fifty-nine men who so contributed, and the total cost was £1 9s 6d. They (the Company) paid the men in charge £1 10s, which was all the rate of 15s per week. There was one man to add to the total number, who didn't appear in the book.

The Chairman: I think the disposes of that case.

Mr. Duffy: They have not got all the companies there.

Mr. Gill: Excuse me, that is our book.

Mr. Duffy: Number 16. I don't think you called that out.

The Chairman: Oh yes. Company 16, five men, 2s 6d.

Mr. Duffy: that is right. I didn't hear the Company called out.

The Chairman: Well, then seems to satisfy the point. — Mr. Duffy: Not quite, Sir Henry. What I pointed out was that the men in charge of the changing house received 17s a week, and there are more.

The Chairman: You brought forward a specific case, and here is the evidence. There is nothing in it. That case has gone hasn't it? Are you satisfied about this case of 1908? — Mr. Duffy said he picked the case at random as an illustration of what was taking place.

The Chairman: Have you got other figures?

Mr. Duffy: I said the man at the present moment was getting 17s a week and the men were paying that in.

The Chairman: But do they pay more? — Mr. Duffy: I won't go so far as to say they pay more.

The Chairman said the only point was that if they paid out what they received there was an end to it. — Mr. Duffy: Well, it does not satisfy us.

The Chairman: Oh, very likely; that is a totally different point, but there is a total end to the allegation that they companies are making a profit on this business. There's an end to it. I have taken the case brought forward by yourself. I challenged it once it was brought to my notice, and desired to see their books, and here is the evidence so far as that is concerned.

Mr. Gill said at the present time the Company were paying 17s a week to the changing-house man. There fifty seven men only were changed, so that they were paying 3s 6d a week more than they were receiving. Mr. Gill added that they were prepared to show their books to anyone who wished to see them.

The Chairman: At all events there is an end to the question of making profit in that case. (To Mr. Duffy) Have you any other case of making a profit? The case falls to the ground. The only question now is the wide question as regards changing-houses. Have you anything more to say? — Mr. Duffy said he had been asked by witness attending the Commission to offer the Chairman their very sincere thanks for the full liberty he had given them, and the uniform courtesy with which he treated everyone of them,. They asked him to express on their behalf, there warmest thanks, and he did so most gladly.

The Chairman said he thought the other gentlemen on the Commission should be included. They had been only too anxious to try to bring forth everything they could. They all appreciated that very much, and desired to give them every possible chance.

The inquiry then closed, after a five day sitting.

Before the Commission rose the Chairman on behalf of the Commissioners and himself thanked Mr. Leck, the Mines Inspector, for the very valuable assistance he had given them during their sittings in Cumberland.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adair, H.      
Adair, J.      
Adair, Joseph B.    Mining Engineer  
Ainsworth, J. S.    M.P.  
Armstrong, James    Miner  
Atkinson, George    Miner  
Bettany, T. R.      
Booth, C.      
Braithwaite, Joseph    Miner  
Briggs, John    Miner  
Brockbank, T. H.      
Burns, Michael    Miner  
Burnyeat, W.      
Burnyeat, W. J. D.      
Byers, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Calderwood, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Casson, W.      
Casson, W. W.    Mining Engineer  
Clark, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Conynghame, Henry, Sir    Chairman  
Cottier, John T.    Miner  
Cowan, Luke    Sinker  
Cowen, W. M.    Secretary  
Cramond, Alex    Miner  
Daniels, Mark    Miner  
Dixon, John    Miner  
Dixon, William    Mining Engineer  
Dobie, James    Miner  
Edmonds, Charles    Labourer  
Eldon, William    Miner  
Ennor, Joseph    Engineman  
Flynn, James    Secretary  
Galloway, W., Professor      
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas      Whos Who Page
Gill, D.    Mining Engineer  
Gilpin, John    Miner  
Greaves, R. M.      
Haldane, —, Dr.      
Hall, James    Miner  
Harris, Timothy    Miner  
Helder, L. T.      
Hogg, Thomas    Miner  
Irving, Robert    Miner  
Jones, T.      
Jordan, Marshall    Quarryman  
Kitchin, J. B.      
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lewney, W.      
Lovett, P.      
Matthews, James    Miner  
Mcwilliams, George    Miner  
Mellon, H.    Surveyor  
Morrison, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Nelson, James    Miner  
Noon, J. W.    Quarryman  
Philips, Joseph    Miner  
Plummer, John    Miner  
Quayle, Charles    Miner  
Ray, C. E.    Manager  
Redmayne, R. A. S.      
Richardson, Myles      
Rothery, Mossop    Miner  
Scoular, George    Mining Engineer  
Smith, James    Miner  
Thomas, T. Arthur      
Tidyman, David    Miner  
Turner, G. H.      
Walker, Isaac    Undermanager  Whos Who Page
Walker, W. E.    Mining Engineer  
Walker, W. R.      
Watkyn-Thomas, W.      
Watson, Isaac    Miner  
Wilson, David    Manager  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Cleator (Iron Ore)  Cleator (Iron Ore)
Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)
Jacktrees (Iron ore)  Jacktrees (Iron ore)
Longlands (Iron Ore)  Longlands (Iron Ore)
Lonsdale (Iron Ore)  Lonsdale (Iron Ore)
Montreal (Iron Ore)  Montreal (Iron Ore)
Park House (Iron Ore)  Park House (Iron Ore)
Salter (Iron Ore)  Salter (Iron Ore)
Salter Hall Quarry  Salter Hall Quarry
Sir John Walsh (Iron Ore)  Sir John Walsh (Iron Ore)
Threlkeld Quarry (Granite)  Threlkeld Quarry (Granite)
Townhead (Iron Ore)  Townhead (Iron Ore)
Ullcoats (Iron Ore)  Ullcoats (Iron Ore)
Winder Gill (Iron Ore)  Winder Gill (Iron Ore)
Woodend (Iron Ore)  Woodend (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print