Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

19th August 1910, Page: 3, Column: 4

Winding Accident

Bowk Disaster At Ogmore Vale

Men Overturned Into Pit

Fall Among Explosives

One Man Killed; Four Injured

Heroic Rescue

A serious accident occurred at the pit which is being sunk by the Lewis Merthyr Company at Ogmore Vale on Monday morning, resulting in one man being killed and four others being more or less seriously injured. By 9 o'clock in the morning about 20 holes had been charged in preparation for firing, and the accident occurred when the last batch of the shift were being raised, consisting of Harry Lewis, foreman sinker ; William Davies, second chargeman ; William Richards, Daniel John, John Nolan, John Williams, and Edward Lewis, sinkers. Everything went well until they reached the landing, when the engineman found it impossible to shut off steam, and they were carried to the sheaf. The engineman promptly reversed his engine, and the bowk came down rapidly. The assistant banksman, William Woods, who was in charge at the time, tried to prevent an accident by pushing the trolley out to catch the bowk, but unhappily he had only got it partly across when the bowk reached the runner and was tipped towards the pit. It was a case of each man for his life, and they clutched at anything they could to prevent falling. Harry Lewis, chargeman of the shift, was dragged out by his son, Richard Lewis, who ran to the pit mouth on seeing the accident, having come up by the previous shift, and John Williams (Doctor) jumped to a place of safety, both being uninjured. Richards and John were precipitated to the bottom, a distance of about 40 yards, and the other three sustained injuries through being knocked about by the swaying bowk before they could be rescued from their perilous position.

Twenty Shots Explode.

In the meantime the twenty shots exploded, and what must have happened at the pit bottom cannot be imagined, much less described. After some little delay, Daniel John was rescued from amongst the rubbish at the bottom. He was severely injured, and they brought him up to the top, where he was seen by Dr. Anderson, Dr. R. A. Williams, and the latter's locum tenens, and afterwards taken to the Corbett Arms. It was impossible at the time to find William Richards, who had evidently been covered with debris. Subsequently another descent was made, and Richards's dead body was found covered with large stones and rubbish. The dead man is said to be a native of Ferndale, and is better known as Richard Williams. He had a large wound on the forehead, and the whole of his left side was crushed, his ribs being fractured.

Mr. Thomas Davies, manager of the pit, was present at the time, and did his utmost to render assistance. P.S. Rees Davies and P.C.'s Mendus and Mead, who were quickly on the spot, also rendered assistance to the injured men, and the Ogmore Vale Ambulance Corps were in attendance. There were plenty of willing men amongst the sinkers to render aid.

Edward Lewis was taken to the Corbett Arms, where he was recently lodging, in addition to John, and Nolan and Davies were taken to their lodgings. The latter was unconscious when rescued, and did not recover consciousness until after he had been placed in bed. His memory was a complete blank from the time the bowk descended.

Killed and Injured.

The following are the names of the men killed or injured:—

Killed.

William Richards, sinker, aged about 52, married man with five children, lodging at 9 Cemetery-road ; wound on forehead and left side crushed.

Injured.

Daniel John (38), single, Cymmer R.S.O., lodging at 17 Bridge-street, Ogmore Vale ; fractured skull and internal injuries ; very severe.

John Nolan, No. 2 Victoria-terrace, Llansamlet ; lodging at 29 Walters-road ; half hand off; married, five children.

William Davies ("Curly") (42), of 100 John-street, formerly of Maesteg, married, no children ; injured badly on head and thigh.

Edward Lewis (35), married, one child, now at Corbett Arms, but residing at 4 Naylor-street, Thomastown, Tonyrefail ; injuries to the back.

Perilous Shaft Descent.

Great pluck was shown by Simon Uran, one of the sinkers, in connection with the rescue of Daniel John. Uran was let down, hand over hand, by a rope into the pit after the shots had exploded, taking with him a naked light. He found John on the side, and sent for the bowk, which was lowered, and John was secured and raised.

Interviewed by our representative, Uran related his experiences. He is a native of Cornwall, but for the last twelve months has resided at 16 Maesteg-road, Cwmfelin. He told his story modestly, and referred appreciatively to the pluck of the rescued man, Daniel John.

"The fumes from the light and the powder smoke coming up," he said, "made me feel queer. I reached the bottom almost sick. When I got down I shouted to those above that I had landed on dry earth. I then shouted out to Daniel John, and he answered, 'Here I am, mate.' Going in the direction whence his voice came, I found him leaning against the side of the pit. He was terribly injured, and I was afraid to leave him lest he should go off."

"Did you know whether all the shots had gone off?"

"No. I only heard three while I was at the top, but at the time I did not think of them ; I wanted to get Dan John out of it, and to find William Richards (the dead man) if I could."

"How was John got to the surface?"

"I shouted for the bowk to be sent down, because I was afraid if I put the rope round him it would crush his life out, and he did not look as if he could stand any exertion, but he was bearing up pluckily. Presently the bowk came down, but I sent it back for a hook so that I could pull it over to where John was. The pit was filling with water, but the sides were dry where all the muck had been thrown. Four or five men — I want to give them all credit, but I don't know their names — came down with the bowk and the hook was handed to me. John was suffering from the smoke and flying dust, but I got the bowk over and Henry Davies, the chargeman, jumped out, caught John up like he would a baby and put him in the bowk. We could not find Will Richards anywhere, but he was in the sump somewhere under the debris. When he was found he was dead."

Agent's Statement.

Mr. Hutchinson, agent to the company, made the following statement to our reporter:

The engineman was bringing the bowk up with seven sinkers, and he found, when it got above the landing, he could not shut off steam properly. He could shut it off partly but not fully. The engine practically took the men to the sheaf, and he then reversed his engine, his intention being, no doubt, to run the men up and down until he could stop the steam. The banksman, when he saw the bowk coming down, tried to run the trolley across the top to receive the bowk in its usual resting place, but he only got it partly across. The result was that only a part of the bowk struck the runner of the trolley, and it capsized towards the opening.

Had it tipped the other side the men would have been shot into the trolley, but unfortunately the lesser half was towards the trolley and the greater half towards the tip. Two of the men lost their hold and went down to the bottom, which was, roughly speaking, 40 yards. I don't think Richards was killed by the fall, as there was a lot of water in the bottom. The shots all went off while the men were there, and it would be like hell, nothing less. The other man got to the side, and is still alive but suffering from a fractured skull and other severe injuries. It is a wonder they were not peppered and blown to pieces altogether.

The cause of the engineman being unable to shut off steam was that a piece of metal came from the pipes somewhere, and got under the steam throttle valve. Where it came from we don't know, as all the pipes are steel with the exception of one bend, which is cast-iron. Probably it was an internal blister which had worked itself off, as it was not big enough to be a nut, a screw or a bolt-head.

Tragic Story Related At The Inquest

Dramatic Scene

Witness Rushes From The Room

The story of the accident was told in all its tragic detail at the inquest conducted by the Deputy Coroner, Mr. W. A. Williams, at the Corbett Arms, Ogmore Vale, on Wednesday. Mr. W. N. Atkinson, superintendent inspector of mines, was in attendance, with Mr. J. W. Hutchinson, manager and agent of the Lewis-Merthyr Colliery Company.

Joseph Jones, 10 Howard-terrace, Clydach Vale, identified the body of the deceased man as that of his brother-in-law. He was 44 years of age, and married.

Henry Lewis, lodging at Bridge-street, Ogmore Vale, when called, sat down beside the Coroner, and appeared not to understand the proceedings.

The Coroner: Tell us what you know of it.

Witness bent his head upon his hands, and resting his elbow on his knees said, "I can't remember, sir."

"Can't you tell us anything," asked the Coroner. "Don't you remember coming to the top?" — Yes, sir.

What did you do that morning ? — I went down as usual, and charged the holes and fired them.

Were there any others besides yours? — No. sir.

"Can't Remember Anything."

After you charged them, what did you do? — We — seven of us — went up. Deceased was with us, and I can't remember anything more except that I held on to the deceased as long as I could. I thought something had happened when I got to the top.

Mr. Atkinson? — Can you remember anything else? — No, indeed, sir, I can't remember anything.

Did you know that the bowk went higher than it ought to have gone? — No, I know nothing about it.

Where did you find yourself when you went out? — On the landing.

At this stage, witness, who appeared to little understand the questions put to him, got up and made a rush for the door. There was a little excitement.

The Coroner: I am afraid he can't give us much information ; he seems quite dazed.

Police-Sergt. Rees Davies brought the man back, and he again took a seat near the Coroner, looking questioningly around him.

Mr. Hutchinson: Do you remember, when the bowk came down again, if it struck the trolley? — Yes, sir.

Do you remember it tipping over? — Yes, sir ; the other six men were on top of me.

Did you see Richards and Daniel John fall down the pit? — I saw Richards ; I never saw Dan John.

Do you remember whether you were thrown out or pulled out? — Pulled out by my son, I suppose.

Engineman's Story.

Thomas Richards, St. John-street, Ogmore Vale, the fireman, who was in charge of the engine at the time the accident happened, said between 9 and 9.30 he received the signal from the banksman that he was ready to fire. He asked witness if he was ready to bring the men up, and after examining the engine and steam gauge, and finding all was correct, he answered, "All is ready." The banksman then signalled to the bottom, and they charged the holes.

The Coroner: Do you mean that they fired them? — Yes.

Witness continued that he then received the signal that the men were ready to ascend, and he immediately started the bowk from the bottom. He found nothing wrong until the bowk got to the landing stage, and he proceeded to close his steam valve. Finding it impossible to do so, he applied the brake at once, and reversed the lever so as to return the bowk to the pit.

The Coroner: To prevent it going over the sheaves? — Yes, sir, and as the bowk was descending again it came into contact with the trolley.

The Coroner: That is a contrivance at the landing stage to put under the bowk? — Yes.

The bowk tipped over then, did it ? — Yes, I had not much time to see, but it went over towards the trolley, and I eased it over towards the runners.

Did you see any of the men fall out ? — I just had a glimpse of one of them going down

How long have you been an engine-driver ? — Just over three months in charge of a winding engine.

You are accustomed to machinery? — Yes; I have been working with it since I was twelve years of age all sorts of machinery, and I am 26 years of age.

You have had some little experience of this engine? — Yes, sir.

When did you start your shift that morning? — Seven o'clock.

Had the engine been working continuously from that time up to the time of the accident? — Yes, sir.

Did you find it working as well as usual? — Everything all right, sir.

I suppose you have an idea as to the reason you could not shut off the steam valve? — Something had got under it.

Pieces Of Cast-Iron In Valve.

Witness continued that the engine was afterwards examined by the chief mechanic in his presence, and three small pieces of cast-iron (produced) were under the seat of the valve. (These were no bigger than peas.)

The Coroner: Would they be sufficient to stop the valve from working? — Yes, sir.

Have you any idea how they got there ? — No. sir ; none whatever.

No theory at all? — No. sir: I have no explanation whatever.

Did you examine that particular portion of the valve that morning? — Yes, I had been cleaning it, and found nothing wrong with it.

I understand you to say that you put the brake on ; did that act? — It did act, but the distance was too short.

Did the bowk go back slowly or fast to the landing stage? — Fast.

Do I understand you to say that it is your duty to see the engine is all right? — Yes.

And you examined it carefully, and it worked for two solid hours? — Yes, sir.

Mr. Atkinson: What brakes have you on the engine? — There are brakes on both sides of the drum.

Brakes In Order.

Were they in proper order? — Yes, sir.

And you say the distance was too short for the brakes to take full effect? — Yes.

After the bowk struck the rails of the trolley did you lift it ? — Yes, I saw it tipping and eased it.

And then you lowered it again? — Yes, I slacked it.

Had the trolley been put under by that time? — Yes, the trolley had come further in, as far as I could see.

Do you think the brakes were efficient? — Yes, sir; if they had had time to operate.

There is no steam brake? — No. sir.

No controller on the engine, to prevent it over-winding ? — No, sir.

Do you think that a controller might have prevented this accident? — I could not say. I have only seen one in operation.

I suppose a steam brake might have held the bowk immediately it was applied? — I don't know, sir: it might have been worse. It would have acted with a suddenness that would have tipped them all over.

I put it to you, it might have stopped the bowk before it struck the rails of the trolley? — It might have done so.

The Coroner: What would have happened if the trolley had not been put under? — I would have had a chance to work the bowk up and down the tip till I had got control ; that was my intention.

Mr. Hutchinson: I would like to call the mechanic, or give evidence myself, because I am responsible.

The Coroner: Are you prepared to give evidence? — Yes, certainly, if it is necessary. I want to get evidence upon the efficiency of the brakes.

Mechanic's Evidence.

Thomas Davies, the mechanic, was called, and stated that he lived at 119 St. John-street. He had known the engine seven years, and it was in thoroughly good working order. It worked another pit without a mishap. Sometimes he examined the valve weekly, sometimes once a fortnight. The last time he examined it was a fortnight before the accident, and it was then all right. When examined after the accident, he found three small pieces of cast-iron under the valve stopping it from working. They were imbedded in the seating. These would make it impossible for the valve to act properly.

In reply to the Coroner, he said the brakes were efficient and in good working order. He tried them the day after the accident with full steam on, and the brakes stopped the engine.

The Coroner: Have you any idea how these little pieces of metal got there? — No, sir: I have seen honeycombs in pipes, and bits like these might come out at times, but I can't tell you where they came from ; it is a thing I have never seen before.

Mr. Atkinson: The last time you opened the valve were any repairs done? — No, sir: none whatever. It was practically a new valve.

What was the object of opening it once a week or fortnight ? — We are very careful to see that the valve is in good working order.

Is it necessary to do this once a fortnight? — I think once a month is sufficient.

Nothing was done so that these chips could have got in ? — No, sir.

Of course you are acquainted with a safety hook and controller? — I am not acquainted with the controller. I have not seen one on any engine where I have been in South Wales.

Is there any reason for not having them on a sinking pit as well as an ordinary pit? — Well, the distance in a sinking pit is so short, for one thing.

Have you seen a controller and a safety hook in a sinking pit ? — I have not seen them in this part of South Wales.

In reply to the Coroner, witness said he did not see the accident ; they fired sooner than he thought they would. The engine driver had had good experience and he thought he was a competent man.

Steel Pipes.

Mr. Hutchinson: These pipes were all steel except one cast-iron bend? — Yes.

Did you blow through steam? — Certainly.

The Coroner: I take it the idea of doing that is to clear away all grit? — Yes, sir

With these pieces of iron the valve would be partly shut and there would not be full pressure of steam on? — Oh, dear, no, sir.

Mr. Hutchinson: You tested the engine the next day in the presence of the engineman. Do you know what would be the approximate weight of the bowk with the seven men and the rubbish? — About 1,700 lbs. — five cwt.

Did you fill the bowk up when testing? — Yes, sir. I filled it with stones, and the weight was 26 cwt. to 30 cwt.

Did you come up the pit with full steam on? Yes, sir.

Did you put the brake on without shutting off steam? — Yes, sir.

What happened? It stopped it within ten feet.

Would it be safe to stop a bowk coming up a pit either with a steam brake or a foot brake in any shorter time than that? — No. sir. There would be danger attached to it. Applying a steam brake too suddenly would be enough to throw any man out of the bowk.

The distance from the top of the chain to the sheaves is 17ft., and Richards (the engine driver) would have had very little time to think of anything? — That is so.

Did you try the bowk as it was going down, with full power? — Yes, sir; I stopped it without the steam.

The Coroner: What would you have done in similar circumstances to Richards? — I have had experience of the same thing — only two large nuts got in the valve. Twenty men were down a pit, and there was ten feet of water. I pushed my lever to the centre, and held her there until the bowk stopped. Twenty-four men were saved altogether.

Banksman's Graphic Story.

Williams Woods, the second banksman, who was in charge at the time, residing at Commercial-street, Ogmore Vale, said he had the signal from the man in charge to "make ready" and gave the signal to the engine-driver, who signalled back that all was ready. He transmitted it to the men at the bottom. He could see from the top that they had lighted the fuse, had got into the bowk, and had given the signal to be raised. As soon as the bowk came up above the runners he (witness) told the men with him to push the runners on so that the bowk on coming down would rest on them. They were doing this when the bowk came back before they could properly get the runners under. The result was that the bowk tilted one side, and before the driver could ease it up it had slipped down. They were unable to get the runners back before the bowk came up again, caught under the runners, and lifted them off the rails. When it got free it came above, and the men succeeded in getting the runners in position.

The Coroner: What happened to the men? — As the bowk came down from the sheaves the first man pitched down the pit. The second man went out after the bowk got free of the runners.

What happened with the shots when these poor men were thrown out? — The shots went off after they fell.

Must Have Been Terrible.

Mr. Hutchinson : It must have been terrible.

Mr. Atkinson: How did the men get up? — Simon Uran first went down with a rope round him, and Edward Gander and John Lloyd followed.

Do you knew the depth of the shaft ? — About 80ft.

The Coroner: How long was it before the men were brought up? — The men went down immediately after the accident, and the engine was in working order again twenty minutes after. The bowk was sent down for them. They brought Dan John up with them.

Mr. Hutchinson : This man would have been drowned had they not gone down to fetch him.

The Coroner: When was the dead man brought up? — Sergt. Rees Davies: About one o'clock, sir.

Thomas Davies, re-called, said when the bowk went down to fetch the other men up there was about two feet of water in the sump. The sides were clear. Deceased was in the sump. They found him about twelve o'clock, but had to be careful in removing the stones which were on him.

A Brave Sinker.

Simon Uran, the heroic rescuer, said he was lodging at 29 Walters-street. He was in the cabin having food on the morning of the accident, and heard a shout. Dropping his food he ran to the top of the pit. He saw the bowk under the runners with a man jambed between. Ultimately the bowk stopped, and freed itself. William Richards then fell into the pit, and the next thing witness said he remembered was that the shots fired. He did not notice more than three go off. Dan John, after the explosion, shouted for the bowk and a man named Hooper asked how long it would be. Getting no answer, witness called for a rope, and attaching it under his armpits, took a "comet" (a naked light) in one hand and went down the pit, men on the top serving the rope out hand over hand. When he reached the bottom he shouted out that he was on dry ground, and then called for John. The man replied, "Here I am, mate," and witness, going over in the direction his voice came, found him leaning against the side of the pit terribly injured, but holding out as well as witness had seen anybody. He (witness) listened for a sound of the other man, and Dan John asked him if there were any others down beside him. Witness did not like to tell him there was, because he wanted him to bear up, but he said he believed another one was down. He searched for Richards, but could not find him.

Mr. Atkinson : What was the state of the air down there? — The air was tidy, but there was a lot of smoke.

Had the fumes any effect upon you? — The fumes from the comet had more effect on me than the powder fumes.

Had you a headache afterwards? — No, sir.

Then you are a pretty tough 'un. You might have been suffocated? — Witness: I did not think of that. I would have gone down forty times if I could have saved anybody.

Noah Coles, St. John-street, Ogmore Vale, fitter, also gave evidence.

Crushed By Stone.

Dr. A. W. Anderson said deceased had a lacerated wound on the scalp extending to the bone. There were several abrasions about the mouth, and six ribs on the left side were driven into the lungs and heart. Death was due to the injury to the chest.

The Coroner: Cowld the injury be caused by the fall down the pit? — No: it would more probably have been caused by a heavy stone falling upon him after the fall, because the whole side had been driven in.

Thomas Davies, re-called, said a big stone, as much as two men could lift, was on the man.

The Coroner, in summing up, said the engineman was placed under terrible responsibility at very short notice. He might have lost his head, but personally he did not think the man was at all to blame, and probably did the best thing under the circumstances by putting the brake on and reversing the lever. Uran very pluckily risked his life — much to his credit — in going down to the men at the end of a rope. In his (the Coroner's) opinion the thing was an accident pure and simple.

Driver Exonerated.

The Jury returned a verdict of Accidental Death, and attached no blame to the driver.

Mr. Hutchinson, on behalf of the Colliery Company, extended sympathy to the bereaved relatives. The company regretted very much that the accident had occurred.

The Coroner sincerely hoped the other man, Daniel John, would recover, and he was pleased to hear he was rapidly progressing.

Mr. Hutchinson: He deserves to live after what he has gone through. (Hear, hear.)


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anderson, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Atkinson, William Nicholas    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Coles, Noah    Fitter  
Davies, Rees    Police Seargent  
Davies, Thomas    Colliery Manager  
Davies, Thomas    Mechanic  
Davies, William   42 Second Chargeman  Injured, Individual Page
Gander, Edward    Miner  
Hooper, —    Miner  
Hutchinson, J. W.    Colliery Agent  
John, Daniel   38 Sinker  Injured, Individual Page
Jones, Joseph      
Lewis, Edward   35 Sinker  Injured, Individual Page
Lewis, Harry    Foreman Sinker  
Lewis, Richard    Miner  
Lloyd, John    Miner  
Mead, —    Police Constable  
Mendus, —    Police Constable  
Nolan, John    Sinker  Injured, Individual Page
Richards, Thomas    Fireman  
Richards, William   44 Sinker  Deceased, Individual Page
Uran, Simon    Sinker  
Williams, John    Sinker  
Williams, R. A., Dr.    Doctor  
Williams, Richard      
Williams, W. A.    Deputy Coroner  
Woods, William    Assistant Banksman  


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print